AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Section 26 of the Indian Electricity Act, 1910
  • parties.4. Section 26 of the Indian Electricity Act, 1910
  • Section 26 and Regulation 31.04 (supra).
  • Sub-section (4) of Section 26 entitles
  • Sub-section (3) of Section 26
  • Sub-section (7) of Section 26
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Section 26 of the Indian Electricity Act, 1910
  • parties.4. Section 26 of the Indian Electricity Act, 1910
  • Section 26 and Regulation 31.04 (supra).
  • Sub-section (4) of Section 26 entitles
  • Sub-section (3) of Section 26
  • Sub-section (7) of Section 26
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitions challenge (a) the constitutional validity of Regulation 31.04 of the Karnataka Electricity Board (Supply) Regulations, 1988 and (b) the validity of a Circular dated 22 April 1997 issued by the respondent (K.E.B.). The 22 April 1997 Circular revised the Meter Security Deposit (MSD) for L.T. Electronic Trivector Meters to Rs. 13,710/-, less amounts already deposited.

The petitioners are small-scale industrial units and L.T. consumers, associated with the Peenya Industries Association (petitioner in W.P. No. 3701/1998). They also challenge the Board's earlier decision (Circular dated 31 December 1996) to install Electronic Energy Meters in certain installations and the then-prescribed MSD rates (Rs. 1,300 for single-phase and Rs. 3,000 for three-phase L.T. installations). The earlier circular stated that the MSD could vary from time to time and that the deposit would earn interest at 10% p.a. under Regulation 31.04.

By amendment, the petitioners specifically contested the constitutional validity of Regulation 31.04 on the ground that conferring power on the Board to prescribe the MSD "from time to time" was arbitrary and violative of Article 14 of the Constitution. Hearings were held and counsel for the parties was heard.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Regulation 31.04 of the Karnataka Electricity Board (Supply) Regulations, 1988 is constitutionally valid (petitioners contending that the power to prescribe Meter Security Deposit from time to time is arbitrary and violates Article 14).
  2. Whether the Circular dated 22 April 1997 (revising the Meter Security Deposit for L.T. Electronic Trivector Meters to Rs. 13,710/- less prior deposits and prescribing payment in three equal interest-free instalments) is valid.
  3. Whether, under Section 26 of the Indian Electricity Act, 1910, the Board had the authority to replace meters already supplied to consumers with electronic trivector meters (and whether that exercise of power was arbitrary or unreasonable).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The Circular of 22 April 1997 (and the Board's decision to replace meters) was not supported by Section 26 of the Indian Electricity Act, 1910 and was therefore invalid.
  • The exercise of the Board's power to prescribe Meter Security Deposit "from time to time" under Regulation 31.04 was arbitrary and hence violative of Article 14 of the Constitution.
  • The revision of the MSD (including the amount and terms of payment) prejudiced the petitioners.

Respondent K.E.B.'s Position (as reflected in the opinion)

  • The Board decided to introduce electronic meters (and later electronic trivector meters) because they are more accurate, trouble-free and tamper-proof; these considerations were relevant to the Board's objectives.
  • Regulation 31.04 expressly empowers the Board to prescribe Meter Security Deposit at rates fixed "from time to time", and the Board legitimately exercised that power.
  • The revised MSDs take into account deposits already made by consumers and, under Regulation 31.05(e), such deposits earn interest at 10% p.a.; the cost of the trivector meter (Rs. 14,034 per the K.E.B.'s S.R. Rates for 1997–98) supports the level of the revised deposit.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded in discrete steps tied closely to statutory text and the regulation:

  1. Interpretation of Section 26, Indian Electricity Act, 1910: The court set out key subsections of Section 26 — that the amount of energy supplied must be ascertained by means of a correct meter supplied by the licensee; that the licensee may require security for the price of the meter where the meter is hired; that a consumer who owns the meter must keep it correct or face disconnection after notice; and that the licensee may inspect and test meters and recover reasonable expenses where a meter is found incorrect.
  2. Reading Section 26 together with Regulation 31.04: Regulation 31.04 empowers the Board to prescribe a Meter Security Deposit (MSD) at rates set by the Board "from time to time" (with specified exceptions). On a conjoint reading, the court concluded that the obligation to provide and maintain a correct meter carries with it the right of the licensee to change metering equipment for improved accuracy, dependability and tamper resistance. The statutory provisions do not prohibit the licensee from replacing an installed meter by a more advanced one.
  3. Arbitrary exercise and Article 14 analysis: The court acknowledged that statutory power cannot be exercised arbitrarily and that Article 14 prohibits arbitrary actions adversely affecting citizens. It then examined the Board's reasons for replacing meters (earlier circulars indicating electronic meters are more accurate, trouble-free and tamper-proof; the trivector meter being an apparent improvement). The court found these considerations relevant and legitimate, and therefore the exercise of the power was not arbitrary in the present case.
  4. Prejudice to petitioners and financial consequences: The court considered that deposits earn interest at 10% p.a. under Regulation 31.05(e) and that the revised deposit accounted for amounts already paid under earlier rates. Given those protections, the court found no significant prejudice warranting interference.
  5. Proportionality of deposit amount: The court noted the K.E.B.'s S.R. Rates for 1997–98 showing the cost of an electronic trivector meter as Rs. 14,034, and concluded that an MSD broadly equivalent to the price of the meter could not be regarded as unfair or unreasonably high.
  6. Constitutionality of Regulation 31.04: The court rejected the contention that conferring power on the Board to prescribe MSDs "from time to time" is per se arbitrary. It emphasized that the power is exercisable by a statutory Board composed of experts, and that the mere breadth of power does not render the provision unconstitutional. The court observed there was no material before it to suggest past misuse or an immediate risk of arbitrary exercise; it also left open the possibility for petitioners to challenge any specific future exercise of the power if it proved arbitrary.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The petitions challenging Regulation 31.04 and the Circular dated 22 April 1997 were dismissed. The court found no reason to interfere and dismissed the petitions without any order as to costs.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The Board's Circular revising the Meter Security Deposit for L.T. electronic trivector meters (to Rs. 13,710/- less amounts already deposited, payable in the manner prescribed) and the regulatory power under Regulation 31.04 remain operative with respect to these petitions.
  • The court treated the MSD as permissible when linked to the price of the metering equipment and protected by interest provisions and credit for earlier deposits; accordingly, the petitioners' challenge failed on the facts and law presented.
  • No broader constitutional principle or new precedent altering the law was announced beyond the court's conclusions on the specific statutory and regulatory provisions; the decision does not indicate the setting of a novel legal precedent beyond its application to the instant facts.
Petition dismissed.

    Peenya Industries Association And Others v. Karnataka Electricity Board And Others .

    1. Constitutional validity of Regulation 31.04 of Karnataka Electricity Board (Supply) Regulations, 1988 has been called in question in these petitions. Also under challenge is the validity of Circular dated 22nd of April 1997 issued by the respondent K.E.B, whereunder it has revised the Meter Security Deposit for L.T Electronic Triveclor Meters wherever installed to Rs. 13,710/- less the amount already deposited.

    2. The petitioners are small scale industrial Units and L.T Consumers of electrical energy. They are also members of the Peenya Industries Association — Petitioner in W.P No. 3701/1998. They are aggrieved in these petitions of a Circular dated 22nd of April 1997, where under the respondent has revised the Meter Security Deposit earlier prescribed for H.T & L.T Installations. According to the decision now taken in the case of L.T Electronic Trivector Meters, the consumers are required to deposit Rs. 13,710/- less the amount already deposited towards the Meter Security Deposit. The decision to change the meters supplied to the consumers has its genesis in an earlier circular dated 31st of December, 1996 where under the Board had taken a decision to install Electronic Energy Meters in all high revenue yielding installations as such meters were considered to be more accurate, trouble free, and tamper proof. The Meter Security Deposit for Electronic Meters was accordingly revised to Rs. 1,300/- in the case of a single Phase connection and Rs. 3000/- in the case of a III Phase L.T Installation. The circular stipulated that the security Deposit fixed was subject to variation from time to time and that the deposit would earn interest at the rate of 10% p.a in terms of Regulation 31.04 of the Regulations from the date the installation is serviced. The impugned Circular dated 22nd of April, 1997 is an improvement on the said decision in that instead of electronic meters, the Board proposes to provide electronic Trivector Meters and has accordingly revised the meters security Deposit for such Meters, to be deposited by the consumers in three equal interest free instalments. The Circular has come under challenge primarily on the ground that the decision to replace the meters was not supported by the provisions of Section 26 of the Indian Electricity Act, 1910 and was in any case arbitrary and unreasonable. By an amendment application moved by the petitioners they have called in question the constitutional validity of Regulation 31.04 of the K.E.B Electricity (Supply) Regulations, on the ground that the power to prescribe the meters Security Deposit from time to time was arbitrary and hence violative of Article 14 of the Constitution.

    3. I have heard counsel for the parties.

    4. Section 26 of the Indian Electricity Act, 1910 provides that the amount of energy supplied to a consumer or the electrical quantity contained in the supply shall be ascertained by means of a correct meter which shall be supplied to the Consumer by the Licensee provided that the Licensee may require the consumer to give security for the price of the meter and enter into an agreement for the hire thereof unless the consumer elects to purchase a meter of his own. The provision further obliges the licensee to keep the meter correct in cases where the consumer has entered into an agreement for hire of such a meter and in default of the licensee doing so, the Consumer shall cease to be liable to pay for the hire of the meter. Sub-section (3) of Section 26 provides that where the meter is the property of the consumer, he is required to keep the same correct and in default of his doing so, the licensee-may after giving him seven days notice for so long as the default continues, cease to supply energy through the meter. Sub-section (4) of Section 26 entitles the licensee or any person authorised at any reasonable time to have access and be at liberty to inspect and test the meter and except where the meter is hired, all reasonable expenses of and incidental to such inspection and testing etc. shall if the meter is found to be otherwise than correct be recovered from the consumer. Sub-section (7) of Section 26 empowers the licensee to place on the premises of the consumer, a maximum demand indication or other apparatus as it may think fit for purposes of ascertaining or regulating the amount of energy supplied or the number of hours during which the supply is given subject to the conditions stipulated in the provisions to the same. It would therefore appear that once the consumer decides to have a meter installed by the Licensee, the obligation to keep the meter correct and to bear all expenses incidental to its inspection, testing etc., are to be borne by the licensee. The provision does not however suggest that the metering equipment which the licensee provides to the consumer if once installed cannot be replaced by another equipment more accurate trouble free and tamper proof. On the contrary, Regulation 31.04 of the K.E.B Electricity (Supply) Regulations, which deals with the furnishing of Meter Security Deposit empowers the Board to prescribe such deposit from time to time. Regulation 31.04 reads thus:

    “Meter Security Deposit (MSD).— Meter Security Deposit is payable towards the metering equipment at the rates prescribed by the Board from time to time by Consumers of all installations except,—

    (a) All consumers of non-commercial lighting;

    (b) All consumers of non-commercial combined lighting and heating;

    (c) Consumers of Commercial lighting installations whose sanctioned load is 1 KW and less.”

    On a conjoint reading of Section 26 and Regulation 31.04 (supra). I have no difficulty in rejecting the contention urged on behalf of the petitioners that the Board does not have the power to replace a meter once provided to the consumer by a more sophisticated equipment which in the opinion of the Board, is better than what was installed earlier. The obligation to provide and maintain a correct meter would in my opinion carry with it the right to change the metering equipment also, not only in situations where the earlier installed meter is found to be working unsatisfactorily but also where the Board considers it necessary so to do with a view to improving the quality of the equipment and making the same more dependable and tamper proof.

    5. The question then is whether the power vested in the Board to replace the existing electronic mechanical meters by electronic trivector Meters has been exercised unfairly or arbitrarily. It was contended by the petitioners that even if the power to replace the metering equipment was vested in the Board, the same could not be arbitrarily exercised to the detriment of the consumers. There is and can be no dispute with that proposition. The mere availability of the power to do a particular act does not mean that the power can be exercised arbitrarily. The guarantee contained in Art. 14 of the Constitution strikes at any thing that is arbitrary if the same affects the citizen adversely. The question however is whether the exercise of the power is in the present case in any way arbitrary so as to fall foul of Article 14. As noticed earlier, the Board appears to have deliberated upon the proposal of using only electronic meters in all LT & HT installations and three phase electro mechanical installations in all I.P set installations to be serviced on or after 1st of January, 1997. These meters, it is apparent from Circular dated 31st of December, 1995 were considered to be more accurate, trouble free and tamper proof. The decision was thus taken by reference to considerations that were relevant and aimed al increasing the efficiency of the metering equipment at the same time reducing the chances of tampering with the same. Electronic trivector meter which is now introduced by the Board, is apparently an improvement on the metering equipment earlier installed or proposed to be installed. So long as such metering equipment is an improvement on the existing meters, and so long as the decision to install the same is actuated by considerations which are relevant for the purpose which is otherwise legitimate, the petitioners cannot possibly grudge the same. It is not possible for a consumer to insist that the existing metering equipment should continue even when better equipment is available nor can a consumer claim that a metering equipment which is less efficient or more prone to tampcring should not be replaced just because according to him, the equipment is serving the consumer well. It is common knowledge that theft of electricity is a wide spread phenomenon. If the cases instituted against the back billing demands raised on account of, theft of energy is an indication, the practice of stealing energy is more than rampant. It is therefore necessary that the K.E.B takes into account all such measures and updates its metering equipment suitably to prevent not only defective recording of the energy consumed but also any illegal drawl and theft of such energy. A decision to do so was in my opinion perfectly justified.

    6. That apart the prejudice which the petitioners claim does not really exist. That is because the Security Deposits made by the petitioners are entitled in terms of Regulation 31.05(e) to earn S.I at the rate of 10% p.a The revised Security Deposits also gives to the petitioners the benefit of the deposits already made as per the earlier rates prescribed by the Board. In the circumstances, it is difficult to see how the revision in the Security Deposit, really causes any prejudice of the kind that may warrant interference from this Court.

    7. As regards the amount of deposit the same is relatable to the price of the metering equipment. It was pointed out by Mr. Gupta, from the S.R Rates of the K.E.B for the year 1997-1998, that the cost of electronic Trivector Meter was Rs. 14,034/-. That being so, a security deposit of an equivalent amount can hardly be considered to be unfair or unreasonably high to justify any reduction or interference from this Court.

    8. That leaves me with the only other submission urged on behalf of the petitioners and relating to the unconstitutionality of Regulation 31.04 It was contended that the power to prescribe the Security Deposit from time to time was arbitrary, hence unconstitutional. I see no merit in that submission either. The power to prescribe a Security Deposit is exercisable by a Statutory Board comprising experts in the field. The fact that the power to prescribe is conferred on the Board is in itself an effective safeguard against any arbitrary or illegal use of the same. It is fairly well settled that the plentitude of the power dies not by itself render the provision conferring the same unconstitutional. It is in any such case relevant to see as to who is entitled to exercise the power. If it is exercisable not by an individual but by the Government or a Board as in the instant case, the very fact that the power is wide does not render the provision confering the same invalid. There is nothing before me to suggest that the Board has either in the instant case or previously exercised the power vested in it in an unfair or arbitrary manner to justify the apprehension that the same may be misused in future. It is indeed open to the petitioner to question the exercise of the power by the Board at any stage if it is found to have been exercised unfairly or arbitrarily.

    9. In the result I see no reason to interfere. These petitions fail and are accordingly dismissed but in the circumstances without any order as to costs.

    Petition dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Peenya Industries Association And Others v. Karnataka Electricity Board And Others .
    (Mar 11, 1998)