Loading..
Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Summary of Opinion: High Court of Himachal Pradesh, Shimla (RFA Nos. 98 to 109 of 2009)

Factual and Procedural Background

Court: High Court of Himachal Pradesh, Shimla. Coram: The Hon'ble Mr. Justice Rajiv Sharma. The appeals were reserved on 04.01.2016 and the opinion includes a header indicating they were decided on 06.01.2016. The judgment document also contains a signature line dated January 06, 2015.

These consolidated regular first appeals arise from a common judgment dated 17.01.2009 of the Presiding Officer, Fast Track Court, Mandi, in a series of reference petitions challenging awards made under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894. The notification under Section 4 of the Act for the acquisition (Kol Dam project) was issued on 07.12.2000 and published in the Rajpatra (12.12.2000) and in newspapers on 14-15.12.2000. Public notice was issued on 08.01.2001; notifications under Sections 6 & 7 were issued on 23.04.2001 and published on 12.05.2001 with further newspaper publication on 02.05.2001. Notices under Section 9 were issued on 12.07.2001. The Land Acquisition Collector awarded a flat rate of Rs. 3,25,528.37 per bigha by award dated 12.10.2001.

The claimants filed reference petitions challenging the Collector's award as inadequate. They contended higher market values (some claimed Rs. 25,00,000 per bigha) and relied on factors such as irrigation, proximity to roads and industry, mineral richness, and comparable sale transactions. The Reference Court framed issues (18.06.2004) and ultimately enhanced the compensation to Rs. 5,00,000 per bigha with statutory benefits by its award dated 17.01.2009. NTPC Ltd. (appellant) appealed against that enhancement in these consolidated RFAs (Nos. 98–109 of 2009). The High Court heard the consolidated appeals and dismissed them.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Reference Court erred in enhancing the compensation awarded by the Collector and in its assessment of the market value of the acquired land.
  2. Whether the Reference Court correctly relied upon particular sale deeds (Ext. P-1 to Ext. P-14, Ext. PW-5/A, Ext. RA to Ext. RD) and Award No. 2 of 2002 (Ext. P-15) as comparables for determining market value.
  3. Whether the Collector's original flat rate (Rs. 3,25,528.37 per bigha) was just, adequate and in accordance with relevant market evidence available at or about the date of publication of the Section 4 notification.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments (NTPC Ltd., through Mr. Neeraj Gupta)

  • The Reference Court wrongly relied upon certain sale deeds identified as Ext. P-1 to Ext. P-9, Ext. PA, Ext. P-10 to Ext. P-14 and Ext. PW-5/A while determining market value.
  • Transactions from contiguous Mohals (Kyan and Dhawal) should have been taken into consideration by the Reference Court in a different manner (i.e., appellant contends the Reference Court erred in its selection/weighting of comparables).
  • The Collector's award was correct, adequate and just; the Collector had taken into account relevant aspects and surrounding circumstances in arriving at the flat rate.
  • The appellant relied on sale deeds placed on record by RW-1 (Ext. RA to Ext. RD) to support the Collector's award and to challenge the comparables used by the Reference Court.

Respondents' Arguments (Claimants, through Mr. N.K. Sood, Sr. Advocate)

  • The Reference Court correctly relied on sale deeds Ext. P-1 and Ext. PW-5/A which showed that HP PWD purchased land in Mohal Ropa for Rs. 4,62,000 per bigha (sale deeds dated 25.10.2002), demonstrating substantially increased market value in the relevant area.
  • The Reference Court properly had regard to Award No. 2 of 2002 (Ext. P-15) pertaining to Mohal Kyan where compensation was awarded at Rs. 4,35,447.26 per bigha; Mohal Kyan adjoins Mohal Ropa and is of lesser quality (Ropa being irrigated and superior), supporting the Reference Court's upward revision.
  • The sale transactions and award cited by the Reference Court were in close proximity to the acquired land and therefore were appropriate comparables; the Reference Court's assessment was correct and should be upheld.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded by examining the documentary and oral evidence concerning valuation and comparable transactions, and by assessing the appropriateness of the comparables relied upon by the Reference Court.

Key factual findings recorded by the High Court:

  • Notifications and statutory steps for acquisition were dated and published (Section 4 notification on 07.12.2000; publications and subsequent Section 6 & 7 notifications in 2001; Section 9 notices on 12.07.2001).
  • The Collector's award was a flat rate of Rs. 3,25,528.37 per bigha (12.10.2001).
  • No sale transaction in Mohal Ropa occurred at or about the date of publication of Section 4 notification; however, subsequent private sale deeds (Ext. P-1 and Ext. PW-5/A, dated 25.10.2002) established that HP PWD purchased land in Mohal Ropa at Rs. 4,62,000 per bigha.
  • Award No. 2 of 2002 (Ext. P-15) pertained to acquisition in Mohal Kyan (adjoining Ropa) and awarded Rs. 4,35,447.26 per bigha, demonstrating higher values in adjoining areas.
  • Evidence (witnesses PW-1 to PW-7) supported that Mohal Ropa land was irrigated and of better quality than Mohal Kyan, with local information and sales suggesting market prices substantially higher than the Collector's rate.
  • RW-1 (Partap Singh, Tehsildar) produced sale deeds Ext. RA to Ext. RD but admitted lack of knowledge about the Collector's basis for assessing market value; the Court therefore treated those documents and the witness's contribution with caution.

Application of legal principles to facts (as reflected in the judgment):

  • The Reference Court's reliance on contemporaneous and proximate transactions (Ext. P-1, Ext. PW-5/A and Ext. P-15) was appropriate because they showed a genuine increase in market value in the vicinity of the acquired land and were sufficiently proximate in time and location to be relevant comparables.
  • Because the land in Mohal Ropa was shown to be superior (irrigated) to Mohal Kyan, the Court found it reasonable for the Reference Court to treat those higher comparables as indicative of the market value of the acquired land.
  • Sale deeds relied upon by the appellant (Ext. RA to Ext. RD) were not shown to provide a better basis for valuation; the producing witness conceded lack of knowledge about the Collector's valuation methodology, reducing the probative value of those documents as a basis to displace the Reference Court's assessment.
  • On the totality of evidence, including the HP PWD purchases and Award No. 2 of 2002 for adjoining Mohal Kyan, the Reference Court correctly concluded that the Collector's flat rate undervalued the land and justifiably enhanced compensation to Rs. 5,00,000 per bigha.

The High Court therefore declined to interfere with the Reference Court's reasoned valuation exercise, concluding there was no legal or factual basis to set aside or modify that award.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The High Court affirmed the Reference Court's award and dismissed the appeals. The court's disposition is summarized in the opinion as:

Appeals dismissed.

Direct implications:

  • The enhancement of compensation by the Reference Court to Rs. 5,00,000 per bigha (with statutory benefits) stands confirmed by the High Court.
  • Pending applications, if any, were directed to stand disposed of. The judgment states "No costs."

Broader implications: The opinion does not announce or discuss any novel legal principle or new binding precedent beyond applying established principles for assessing market value on the basis of relevant and proximate comparables; accordingly, no new precedent is set by this decision beyond its application to the facts before the Court.

Judgment dated by: Justice Rajiv Sharma. Result recorded in the opinion: dismissal of RFA Nos. 98 to 109 of 2009.

    NTPC v. SHER SINGH

    H

    ig h Co ur t o f H

    .P

    .

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA.

    RFA No. 98 of 2009

    with

    RFA Nos. 99 to 109 of 2009.

    Reserved on: 04.01.2016.

    Decided on: 06.01.2016.

    1. RFA No. 98 of 2009 NTPC Ltd. ……Appellant. Versus

    Kirpa and others …….Respondents.

    2. RFA No. 99 of 2009 NTPC Ltd. ……Appellant. Versus

    Raghu & ors. ….Respondents.

    3. RFA No. 100 of 2009 NTPC Ltd. ……Appellant. Versus

    Sher Singh & ors. ….Respondents.

    4. RFA No. 101 of 2009 NTPC Ltd. ……Appellant. Versus

    Sarvan Kumar & ors. ….Respondents.

    5. RFA No. 102 of 2009 NTPC Ltd. ……Appellant. Versus

    Sita Ram & ors. ….Respondents.

    6. RFA No. 103 of 2009 NTPC Ltd. ……Appellant. Versus

    Kanshi Ram & ors. ….Respondents.

    7. RFA No. 104 of 2009 NTPC Ltd. ……Appellant. Versus

    Parwati & ors . ….Respondents.

    8. RFA No. 105 of 2009 NTPC Ltd. ……Appellant. Versus

    Prabha Devi & ors. ….Respondents.

    9. RFA No. 106 of 2009 NTPC Ltd. ……Appellant. Versus

    1

    2

    Parma Nand & ors. ….Respondents.

    10. RFA No. 107 of 2009 NTPC Ltd. ……Appellant. Versus

    Sunder Ram & ors. ….Respondents.

    11. RFA No. 108 of 2009 NTPC Ltd. ……Appellant. Versus

    Sant Ram & ors. ….Respondents.

    12. RFA No. 109 of 2009 NTPC Ltd. ……Appellant. Versus

    Prem Lal & ors. ….Respondents. Coram

    The Hon'ble Mr. Justice Rajiv Sharma, Judge. Whether approved for reporting? Yes.

    For the appellant(s): Mr. Neeraj Gupta, Advocate.

    For the respondents: Mr. N.K. Sood, Sr. Advocate with Mr. Aman Sood and Mr. Varun Rana, Advocates for respondents No. 1 to 3.

    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

    Justice Rajiv Sharma, J.

    Since common questions of law and facts are involved in these regular first appeals, the same were taken up together for hearing and are being disposed of by a common judgment.

    2. These regular first appeals are directed against the common judgment of the learned Presiding Officer, Fast Track Court, Mandi, Distt. Mandi, H.P., dated 17.1.2009 in Ref. Petition Nos. 78 of 2002, 74 of 2005, 82 of 2002, 76 of 2005, 79 of 2002, 75 of 2005, 83 of 2002, 77 of 2005, 81 of 2002, 132 of 2005, 80 of 2002, 133 of 2005, 89 of 2002, 134 of 2005, 88 of 2002, 135 of 2005, 87 of 2002, 137 of 2005, 84 of 2002, 136 of 2005, 85 of 2002, 138 of 2005, 86 of 2002, 139 of 2005.

    3

    3. "Key facts" necessary for the adjudication of these regular first appeals are that the notification under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (hereinafter referred to as the Act) was issued on 7.12.2000. It was published in the Rajpatra on 12.12.2000. It was also published in the Newspapers "Amar Ujala" and "The Tribune" on 14.12.2000 and 15.12.2000, respectively. Public notice was issued on 8.1.2001. Consequently, notification under Sections 6 & 7 of the Act were issued on 23.4.2001 and published in Rajpatra on 12.5.2001. It was also published in two newspapers i.e. "Divya Himachal" and "Indian Express" on 2.5.2001. Notices under Section 9 of the Act were issued to the interested holders on 12.7.2001. The Land Acquisition Collector awarded a flat rate of Rs. 3,25, 528.37/- per bigha to the respondents claimants on 12.10.2001.

    4. The claimants, feeling aggrieved by the award dated 12.10.2001, filed reference petitions before the learned Presiding Officer, Fast Track Court, Mandi, Distt. Mandi, H.P. According to them, they were given inadequate compensation by the learned Collector. The value of their land was Rs. 25,00,000/- per bigha. The land acquired from the claimants would be submerged in the water by Kol Dam. The land adjacent to Sundernagar Tatapani road is rich in minerals. The sale transactions of Mohal Dhawal, which land is not similar to the acquired land was wrongly considered to work out the market value of the land by the Collector. The sale transaction of Mohal Kyan which land is same vis-a-vis land of Mohal Ropa and higher in value were wrongly ignored by the Collector while assessing the market value of the land.

    4

    5. The appellants contended that the market value worked out by the Collector was correct, adequate and just. The Collector while working out the market value of the land of this Mohal has taken into consideration all aspects and surrounding circumstances.

    6. The issues were framed by the learned Reference Court on 18.6.2004. The learned Reference Court enhanced the compensation from Rs. 3,25,528.37/- per bigha to Rs. 5,00,000/- per bigha, with statutory benefits. Hence, these regular first appeals.

    7. Mr. Neeraj Gupta, Advocate, has vehemently argued that the Reference Court has wrongly relied upon sale deeds Ext. P-1 to Ext. P-9, Ext. PA, Ext. P-10 to Ext. P-14 and Ext. PW-5/A, while determining the market value of the acquired land. According to him, the transactions pertaining to contiguous Mohals Kyan and Dhawal were required to be taken into consideration by the learned Reference Court. He has supported the award made by the Collector. On the other hand, Mr. N.K.Sood, Sr. Advocate, has supported the award dated 17.1.2009.

    8. I have heard learned Advocates for the parties and gone through the award and records of the case(s) carefully.

    9. PW-1 Khazana Ram deposed that their land was acquired by the Kol Dam Project. It was situated in Mohal Ropa. The possession of the land was taken about 4-5 years back i.e. in December, 2000. The land was irrigated. There is BBMB Power House, Slapper and ACC Cement Plant at Barmana, in close vicinity of the acquired land. The price of the land was 10- 11 lacs per bigha. They have been awarded compensation of the land at the rate of Rs. 3.20 lacs per bigha. Kyan Mohal is adjacent to their Mohal, having

    5

    common boundary and having land of lesser quality than their land and for Mohal Kyan compensation has been awarded at the rate of Rs. 6 lac per bigha. In his cross-examination, he admitted that Kol Dam authorities started visiting their area about 10-11 years back. He denied the suggestion that in the year 2000, the land prices in their Mohal was not more than Rs. 15-20,000/- per bigha. The ACC Cement Plant, Barmana is at a distance of about 2 ½ - 3 kms from their Mohal.

    10. PW-2 Ganpat Ram deposed that they were having four gharats (water mill) in village Ropa belonging to Kirpa Ram, Raghu Ram, Sher Singh and Sarvan Kumar etc. They have not been paid any compensation for loss of income and only price of structures has been paid. Paddy, ginger and vegetables etc. are sown in the area. Their land is near to ACC Barmana, Dehar Power Plant. The price of land in their area is Rs. 10-12 lacs per bigha. In the adjoining Mohal, compensation was awarded at the rate of Rs. 5 lacs per bigha. They should be paid compensation on the value of land of Kyan.

    11. PW-3 Lekh Ram deposed that he has purchased land in village Kyan vide sale deed Ext. PA for sale consideration of Rs. 1,20,000/-. He had enquired about the land price at village Ropa and was told that the value of the land was Rs. 8 lacs per bigha and then he went to village Kyan and found the rate of Rs. 40,000/- per biswa. He, therefore, purchased 3 biswas of land for Rs. 1,20,000/-.

    12. PW-4 Sarvan deposed that in village Ropa, Government purchased land from him. 15 families sold land to the Government at the rate of Rs. 4,62,000/- per bigha for the construction of the road. The

    6

    agreement was executed in December, 2002 and the same was made in 2003. They were demanding price at the rate of Rs. 10,00,000/- per bigha but for want of budget, Government insisted at the rate of Rs. 4,62,000/-. The Government purchased 8-10 bighas of land.

    13. PW-5 Sant Ram deposed that he remained Pradhan w.e.f. 1985 to 22.1.2006. According to him, the acquired land falls in his Panchayat. In the year 1998-99, there was an agreement between HP PWD and the villagers for selling the land to HP PWD and they were demanding Rs. 10 lacs per bigha in Mohal Ropa. Their land in Mohal Ropa is irrigated one and they have been growing vegetables etc and finally in the year 1999, the land was agreed to be sold for Rs. 4,62,000/- per bigha. He proved sale deed vide Ext. PW-5/A.

    14. PW-6 Sarvan Kumar and PW-7 Sher Singh deposed that they were earning Rs. 4,000/- to 5,000/- per month from the Gharats (water mill). The acquired land price was Rs. 10 lacs per bigha.

    15. RW-1 Partap Singh deposed that he remained Tehsildar at Sundernagar w.e.f. March, 2000 to November, 2002. He proved Notifications Ext. RW-1/A to Ext. RW-1/O, Notices under Section 9 of the Act Ext. R-1 to R-3 and sale deeds Ext. RA to RD. In his cross-examination, he deposed that he has no knowledge on what basis the market value of the acquired land was assessed by the Collector.

    16. It is admitted case of the parties that no sale transaction has taken place in Mohal Ropa at or about the time of publication of Notification under Section 4 of the Act and the Collector had awarded flat rate of Rs. 3,25,828.37 paise per bigha. It has come on record that ACC Cement plant is

    7

    at a distance of 2 ½ -3 km. from the acquired land. Power House Dehar is also situated at a distance of 2.5-3 kms from the acquired land.

    17. It is duly proved that the villagers of Ropa have sold their land to HP PWD vide sale deeds Ext. P-1 and Ext. PW-5/A dated 25.10.2002 for consideration of Rs. 4,62,000/- per bigha by private negotiations. The sale deeds were executed by HP PWD in the year 2002. It establishes that in Mohal Ropa, the market value of land has substantially increased. In this case, the notification has been issued under Section 4 of the Act on 7.12.2000. The sale deeds Ext. P-1 and Ext. PW-5/A were in close proximity of acquired land of notification issued under Section 4 of the Act.

    18. Mr. N.K.Sood, Sr. Advocate, has drawn the attention of the Court to Award No. 2 of 2002 vide Ext. P-15. Award No. 2 of 2002 pertains to the acquisition of land in village Kyan for Kol Dam Hydel Project. The compensation was awarded at the rate of Rs. 4,35,447.26 paise per bigha. The notification under Section 4 of the Act, as noticed hereinabove, by acquiring the land of Village Ropa, was also published on 11.12.2000. Mohal Kyan is adjoining to Mohal Ropa. It has also come on record that village Ropa is having better quality of land, since it is irrigated vis-à-vis Mohal Kyan. The HP PWD has already purchased land at village Ropa for a consideration of Rs. 4,62,000/- per bigha. The land of Mohal Kyan was though sold in small plots, in the year 2000, but for approximate price of Rs. 40,000/- 50,000/- per biswa. The learned Reference Court has correctly taken into consideration the sale transactions made vide sale deeds Ext. P-1 and Ext. PW-5/A and award No. 2 of 2002 Ext. P-15, while determining the market value of the acquired land of the claimants.

    8

    19. Mr. Neeraj Gupta, Advocate, has placed strong reliance upon sale deeds Ext. RA to Ext. RD. These sale deeds were placed on record by RW-1 Partap Singh. RW-1 Partap Singh, in his cross-examination, has admitted that he has no knowledge on what basis the market value of the acquired land was assessed by the Collector. Sale deed Ext. RA pertains to Mohal Kyan, Ext. RB pertains to Mohal DPF Dhawal, Ext. RC pertains to village Kyan and Ext. RD pertains to Mohal Kyan. The Court has already noticed that the land of village Ropa was superior vis-à-vis Kyan. Village Ropa and Kyan share common boundary. The land at village Ropa itself has been purchased by the State Government for consideration of Rs. 4,62,000/- vide sale deed Ext. P-15, which also pertains to village Kyan. This land was also acquired for the construction of Kol Dam. The Reference Court has correctly assessed the market value of the land. There is no occasion for this Court to interfere with the well reasoned award of the Reference Court dated

    17.1.2009.

    20. Accordingly, there is no merit in these appeals and the same are dismissed. Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of. No costs.

    January 06, 2015, ( Rajiv Sharma ),

    (karan) Judge.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    NTPC v. SHER SINGH
    (Jan 6, 2016)