Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Sub Rule (1) of Rule 5 of the Central Civil Services (Temporary Service) Rules, 1965 (hereinafter referred to as 'the said Rules').
  • ARTICLE 311 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Sub Rule (1) of Rule 5 of the said Rules,
  • Sub Rule (1) Rule 5 of the said Rules
  • provisions of Article 311.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Sub Rule (1) of Rule 5 of the Central Civil Services (Temporary Service) Rules, 1965 (hereinafter referred to as 'the said Rules').
  • ARTICLE 311 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Sub Rule (1) of Rule 5 of the said Rules,
  • Sub Rule (1) Rule 5 of the said Rules
  • provisions of Article 311.
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (I.A. Ansari, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

By an order dated 4.8.1990, respondent No. 2 (Chief Engineer, IFC and PHE Wing, Public Works Department, Agartala) temporarily appointed 101 persons to the post of Junior Operator (Pump) for one year from joining. The name "Sanjoy Deb Barma" appeared at Sl. No. 76 of that appointment order. The petitioner joined the post of Junior Operator (Pump) under the Executive Engineer, Public Health Engineering Division No. III, Udaipur, South Tripura.

On 15.12.1995 respondent No. 3 issued an order terminating the petitioner's appointment, invoking the proviso to Sub Rule (1) of Rule 5 of the Central Civil Services (Temporary Service) Rules, 1965. The petitioner challenged this termination, alleging that the termination was based on an unfounded accusation that he was not the person in whose favour the 4.8.1990 appointment was issued.

The respondents resisted the writ petition, stating that a complaint alleged the petitioner had joined the post by falsely representing himself to be Sanjoy Deb Barma; an inquiry into the complaint found substance and the original appointee had never availed the appointment or joined the post.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether an order of termination of a temporary Government servant's services, passed under the proviso to Sub Rule (1) of Rule 5 of the Central Civil Services (Temporary Service) Rules, 1965, can be sustained when the termination is, in substance, punitive or stigmatic and was effected without giving the employee any opportunity of being heard.
  2. Whether the impugned order dated 15.12.1995, terminating the petitioner on the basis of allegations of misrepresentation as to identity, is a termination simpliciter (permissible under the proviso) or is punitive/stigmatic so as to attract the protection of Article 311(2) of the Constitution of India.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The impugned order dated 15.12.1995 is illegal and incorrect.
  • The order of termination is not merely an order of termination simpliciter but is based on an unfounded accusation that the petitioner was not the person in whose favour the appointment dated 4.8.1990 was issued.

Respondents' Arguments

  • A complaint was received that the petitioner had joined the post by representing himself as Sanjoy Deb Barma though he was not that person; an inquiry by the authorities found substance in the complaint.
  • The person in whose favour the appointment was actually issued never availed the appointment or joined the post, justifying termination of the petitioner.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State of Punjab v. Sukh Raj Bahadur, AIR 1968 SC 1089 Sets out tests to determine when termination of a temporary/ probationary servant attracts Article 311(2) — including that termination simpliciter does not attract Article 311, but where circumstances attendant on termination leave a stigma or visit the servant with evil consequences, Article 311 applies; the motive is immaterial; a full departmental enquiry envisaged by Article 311 will attract its protection. The court applied the Sukh Raj Bahadur tests to examine whether the impugned termination was punitive/stigmatic and therefore required safeguards of Article 311(2). The opinion reproduces and relies on these tests as the governing analytical framework.
State of Bihar v. Shiva Bhikshuk Misra, AIR 1971 SC 1011 Consideration of Sukh Raj Bahadur and the proposition that if termination is by way of punishment, it must be set aside for non-compliance with Article 311. Cited as authority where, on finding an order of termination punitive, the Supreme Court interfered and set the order aside; used to reinforce the principle that punitive/stigmatic terminations require Article 311 protections.
State of U.P. v. Sughar Singh, AIR 1974 SC 423 Supports the proposition that orders of termination that have punitive or stigmatic effect attract Article 311 protections. Referred to as a supporting precedent indicating the same legal proposition applied by the court in the present matter.
Jarnail Singh and Ors. v. State of Punjab and Ors., AIR 1986 SC 626 Indicates a similar proposition of law concerning the need for inquiry and safeguards when termination has punitive/stigmatic consequences. Cited as an additional authority consistent with the view that a termination which is punitive/stigmatic cannot be sustained without the procedural protections envisaged by Article 311(2).

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by acknowledging the textual correctness that under the proviso to Sub Rule (1) of Rule 5 of the said Rules a temporary Government servant's service can be terminated forthwith without assigning reasons or giving an opportunity to show cause. However, the court emphasized that the form of an order does not conclusively determine its nature.

Relying principally on the tests laid down in State of Punjab v. Sukh Raj Bahadur, the court set out the analytical framework: termination simpliciter does not attract Article 311; the circumstances antecedent to the order must be examined; if the order casts an aspersion on character or integrity or visits the servant with evil consequences, it is punitive/stigmatic and Article 311 protections are triggered; full departmental inquiry procedures will attract Article 311.

Applying these principles to the facts before it, the court observed that although the impugned order of 15.12.1995 was couched in language that would normally permit summary termination under the proviso, the factual backdrop (respondents' own case that the petitioner allegedly misrepresented himself as Sanjoy Deb Barma and thereby fraudulently joined) revealed that the termination was imposed because of alleged dishonest conduct. The court concluded that the termination was therefore punitive and stigmatic in nature.

Because the impugned termination was, in substance, punitive and stigmatic, Article 311(2) required that the petitioner be given a reasonable opportunity of being heard and, where appropriate, a departmental inquiry. No such opportunity had been afforded before the impugned order was passed. Hence the court found the termination unsustainable.

The court therefore quashed the impugned order, reinstated the petitioner, but allowed the authorities to proceed in accordance with law by conducting any inquiry or disciplinary proceeding — subject to a specific temporal direction that such proceedings be commenced within two months from receipt of the order by respondent No. 2.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court SET ASIDE AND QUASHED the impugned order dated 15.12.1995 terminating the petitioner's appointment.

Immediate consequences and directions:

  • The petitioner is reinstated in service.
  • The question of back wages is left open and is explicitly made subject to the outcome of any inquiry or disciplinary proceeding that the respondents may hold in accordance with law.
  • The respondents are permitted to institute inquiry or disciplinary proceedings, provided such proceedings are commenced within two months from the date respondent No. 2 receives a copy of this order.
  • The order does not preclude lawful termination thereafter if the respondents comply with the requirements of Article 311(2) and relevant procedure.
  • The writ petition is disposed of; no order as to costs.

Broader implications: The opinion applies established Supreme Court jurisprudence on when Article 311(2) is attracted to terminations of temporary servants and does not purport to lay down a new precedent. The direct effect is the reinstatement of the petitioner and the requirement that any subsequent adverse action comply with Article 311(2) procedures.

    Sanjoy Debbarma v. State Of Tripura

    I.A. ANSARI, J.

    (1.) I have heard Mr. K. N. Bhattacharjee, learned Senior counsel, for the petitioner and Mr. A. Ghosh, learned Government Advocate, appearing on behalf of the respondents.

    (2.) By an order, dated 4.8.1990, issued by the respondent No. 2, namely, Chief Engineer, IFC and PHE Wing of the Public Works Department, Agartala, as many as 101 persons were temporarily appointed in the post of Junior Operator (Pump) under the Irrigation, Flood Control and Public Health Engineering Wingh of Public Works Department, Tripura, for a period of one year with effect from the date of joining. The name of one Sanjoy Deb Barma, son of Hira Lal Deb Barma, Village and Post Office Kalkalia, Tripura, appeared at SI. No. 76 of said order of appointment. Following this order of appointment, the petitioner herein joined the post of Junior Operator (Purnp) under the Executive Engineer, Public Health Engineering Division No. III, Udaipur, South Tripura. While the petitioner was serving in the post of Junior Operator (Pump), an order was issued, on 15.12.1995, by the respondent No. 3, terminating the petitioner's appointment in exercise of powers under proviso to Sub Rule (1) of Rule 5 of the Central Civil Services (Temporary Service) Rules, 1965 (hereinafter referred to as 'the said Rules'). The petitioner has challenged the legality and correctness of the order, dated 15.12.1995, aforementioned on the ground, inter alia, that the impugned order, dated 15.12.1995, is not an order simpliciter of termination of his appointment, for, this order is based on unfounded accusation that the petitioner is not the person in whose favour the order of appointment, dated 4.8.1990, aforementioned was actually issued.

    (3.) Resisting the writ petition, the respondents have submitted to the effect, inter alia, that an inquiry was made by the respondents/authorities concerned into a complaint received by the respondents/ authorities concerned that the present petitioner had joined the post of Junior Operator (Pump), though he is not Sanjoy Deb Barma, son of Hira Lal Deb Barma, Village and Post Office Kalkalia, in whose favour the order of appointment, dated 4.8.1990, was actually issued and on finding substance in the complaint, so received, the respondents/authorities concerned had no option, but to terminate the appointment of the petitioner. It is also the case of the respondents that the person, in whose favour the order of appointment was actually issued, never made use of the said appointment and never joined the post of Junior Operator (Pump) under the respondent No. 3.

    (4.) While considering the present writ petition, what is important to note is that it is not merely the form in which an order of termination is made, which is determinative of the nature of termination. It is, no doubt, true that under the proviso to Sub Rule (1) of Rule 5 of the said Rules, the service of a temporary Government servant can be terminated forthwith and no reason need be assigned for such termination and no opportunity of showing cause need be given to such a temporary Government servant before his service is terminated. At the same time, it is also true that an order of termination simpliciter cannot be passed under the proviso to Sub Rule (1) of Rule 5 of the said Rules if the order of termination leaves stigma on the temporary Government servant concerned or when the order is apparently innocuous, but, in reality, a punitive one. The reason behind this principle is that a Government servaint, temporary or permanent, cannot be removed from service without giving him any opportunity of having his say in tie matter if the termination of his service is stigmatic in nature or is by way of punishment, for, Article 311 (2) of the Constitution of India does not permit removal of a Government servant, temporary or permanent, without holding an inquiry on the accusations made against him and without giving him reasonable opportunity of bieing heard in respect of the accusation made against him if the order of termination of the service of the Government servant concerned leaves stigma on the Government servant or if such an order is passed as a measure of punishment. In State of Punjab Vs. Sukh Raj Bahadur, (AIR 1968 SC 1089), the Apex Court has culled out the tests, which may be applied for determining if the termination of service of a temporary Government servant attracts Article 311 (2), the tests are :

    1. "The services of a temporary servant or a probationer can be terminated under the rules of his employment and such termination without anything more would not attract the operation of Article 311 of the Constitution.

    2. The circumstances proceeding or attendant on the order of termination have to be examined in each case the motive behind it being immaterial.

    3. If the order visits the public servant with any evil consequences or casts an aspersion against his character or integrity, it must be considered to be one by way of punishment, no matter whether he was a mere probationer or a temporary servant.

    4. An order of termination of service in unexceptionable form preceded by an enquiry launched by the superior authorities only to ascertain whether the public servant should be retained in service does not attract the operation of Article 311 of the Constitution.

    5.. If there be a full-scale departmental enquiry envisaged by Art. 311, i.e., an Enquiry Officer is appointed, a chargesheet submitted, explanation called for an considered, any order of termination of service made thereafter will attract the operation of the said article."

    (5.) The decision in Sukh Raj Bahadur (supra) was considered in the case of State of Bihar Vs. Shiva Bhikshuk Misra (AIR 1971 SC 1011) and on finding that the order of termination was by way of punishment, the order was interfered with and set aside. Similar proposition of law has been indicated in State of U.P. Vs. Sughar Singh (AIR 1974 SC 423) and Jarnail Singh and Ors., etc. Vs. State of Punjab and Ors. (AIR 1986 SCI 626).

    (6.) In short while it is permissible by the Government to terminate the service of temporary Government servant by taking recourse to the proviso to Sub Rule (1) of Rule 5 of the said Rules without holding any inquiry or without giving any notice to the Government servant concerned, the fact remains that when such an order is challenged on the ground that the order of termination is aimed at avoiding the holding of an inquiry in terms of the guarantee available to even a temporary Government servant under Article 311 (2) of the Constitution of India, it becomes the duty of the Court to determine if the termination, under challenge, is a termination simpliciter or it is, in substance and in fact, an order of termination of service by way of punishment or does the order of termination leave stigma on the Government servant concerned. In either case, that is, when the termination is punitive or stigmatic, the order of termination made under the proviso to Sub Rule (1) Rule 5 of the said Rules will not be allowed to survive if such an order has been made without complying with the mandate of Article 311 (2).

    (7.) What crystallizes from the above discussion is that the service of a temporary Government servant or a probationer can be terminated without assigning any reason therefor and when such a termination of service takes place, the provisions of Article 311 of the Constitution of India would not be attracted. In order to determine if an order of termination, passed under the proviso to Sub Rule (1) of Rule 5 of the said Rules, requires interference, the circumstances preceding or attendant on the order of termination shall be examined. If the order of termination visits the public servant with any evil consequence or cast a stigma on his character or integrity, such an order of termination must be treated to be an order of termination passed by way of punishment and shall be interfered with by the Court for violating the provisions of Article 311. Where the form of 'the order of termination is merely a camouflage for an order of dismissal for misccmduct, the Court may go behind the order, lift the veil and ascertain if the termination is a termination simpliciter or the same is punitive and/or stigmatic.

    (8.) In the present case, though couched in the language in which it is permissible to terminate a temporary Government servant's service under the proviso to Sub Rule (1) of Rule 5 of the said Rules, the fact remains that the facts leading to the impugned termination of service clearly reveal that the termination of the petitioner's service, as a temporary Government servant, was on account of the fact that the petitioner had allegedly misrepresented himself to be Sanjoy Deb Barma and thereby, fraudulently and dishonestly, joined the post of Junior Operator (Pump). Such termination of service was not merely punitive, but was also stigmatic in nature. In such a case, termination of service was not possible without giving reasonable opportunity of hearing to the person, who was to be adversely affected in consequence of the order of termination.

    (9.) In other words, in the present case, though the order of termination is purportedly passed under the proviso to Sub Rule (1) of Rule 5 of the said Rules, yet the backdrop in which the order has been passed and the reasons, which the respondents/ authorities concerned have themselves assigned in the writ petition for terminating the service of the petitioner, make in abundantly clear that though the order is shown to have been passed by invoking the proviso to Sub Rule (1) of Rule 5 of the said Rules, the fact remains that recourse to the proviso to Sub Rule (1) of Rule 5 of the said Rules has been taken merely to give the order of termination a mask or colour of an order of termination simpliciter. In short, the impugned order of termination of service, though passed in the garb of exercise of powers under the proviso to Sub Rule (1) of Rule 5 of the said Rules, the order, in question, being in reality and in substance, punitive and stigmatic in nature attracts the mandate of Article 311 (2).

    (10.) Thus, in the case at hand, when the impugned order of termination is ex facie punitive in nature and also leaves stigma on the petitioner, the same cannot be allowed to survive, when no opportunity had been given to the petitioner to have his say in the matter before the impugned order was passed.

    (11.) Because of what have been discussed and pointed out above, the impugned order, dated 15.12.1995 is hereby set aside and quashed. This order shall not, however, debar the respondents/authorities concerned from terminating the service of the petitioner in accordance with law. The petitioner shall stand reinstated, but the question of his back wages shall be subject to the out come of any inquiry or disciplinary proceeding, which may be held by the respondents/authorities concerned in accordance with law provided that the inquiry or disciplinary proceeding is commerce within a period of two months from the date of receipt of a copy of this order by the respondent No. 2, namely, Chief [Engineer, IFC and PHE Wing of the Public Works Department, Tripura, Agartala.

    (12.) With the above observations and directions, this writ petition shall stand disposed of. No order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Sanjoy Debbarma v. State Of Tripura
    (Jun 5, 2006)