Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts

    Alagirisami Pillai v. Akkulu Naidu

    Krishnan, J. — I am unable to agree with the District Judge that when a mortgage is redeemed the lease created by the redeemed mortgagee is still sub-sisting and that by virtue of Sect. 74 of the Transfer of Property Act when it is a 2nd mortgagee that redeems the prior mortgage the redeeming mortgagee gets the landlord's rights as against the tenants of the latter.

    I consider when a mortgage is redeemed subsidiary rights created on the mortgaged property such as lease rights come to an end ipso facto and any former tenant continuning on the land must be treated as a trespasser thereafter unless of course from the conduct of parties or otherwise a fresh tenancy can be held to have been created or an implied tenancy arises. See Govindasami Pillai v. Pethaperumal Chetty Adjoodhya Singh v. Girdharee and Ram Chand v. Raj Hans. Our attention was called to the ruling in Chinnappa Thevan v. Pazhaniappa Pillai where it was held that the possession of the tenants who were in occupation of the land under the mortgagee was not adverse to the mortgagor who had redeemed the mortgagee under whom they were originally holding. So far as that case is taken to decide the question as a matter of law, I am not prepared to follow it. The (Seshamma Shethati v. Chickaye Hegade(5)) case cited therein left the question entirely open and the Allahabad case cited. (The The Collector Of Basti v. Sarnam Gharak*(6) was the Judgment of a single Judge and with all respect to the learned Judge it is difficult to see how the tenancy created by the mortgagee continues after redemption when the learned Judge himself has held that it is not binding on the redeeming mortgagor.

    In Chinnappan Thevan v. Pazhaniappa Pillai however there was a document, Ex. G, which was construed as transferring the mortgagee's rights to the mortgagor. In that case the mortgagor as assignee will have the rights of his assignor, the mortgagee, and the ruling may be supported on that ground.

    As regards Sect. 74 of the Transfer of Property Act, the District Judge has omitted to notice that the section gives the redeeming 2nd mortgagee only the rights and powers of the redeemed mortgagee as such. It does not pass any rights of his as landlord.

    It follows from the above that in the present case the defendants were really trespassers as they refused to accept plaintiff as their landlord and repudiated his attempt to treat them as his tenants. The suit should have been valued for Court fees as a suit for possession of property under Sect. 7, Cl. (5) Court Fees Act.

    The respondent's vakil asks us to be allowed an opportunity to pay the right Court fees and to amend his plaint. Though it is true he did not take advantage of the offer by the 1st Court. I am inclined to grant him this indulgence provided he pays the Court fees in one month's time from this day in the first Court and amends his plaint as advised. In default the decree dismissing the suit with costs will stand. Plaintiff will pay the defendant's costs in this and the Lower Appellate Court. The costs in the 1st Court will be disposed of by that Court.

    Per Odgers, J.—I agree. The lease has come to an end on redemption by 2nd mortgagee. It is quite clear that this was the position in English law up to very shortly before the time when the Transfer of Property Act came into force here. The power of leasing was given to a mortgagee under certain conditions by Sect. 18 of the Conveyancing Act, 1881. That power was not incorporated in the Indian enactment, I cannot see any difference in principle (and we were referred to no authority on the point) which differentiates the case of redemption by a mortgagor from redemption by a sub-sequent mortgagee with reference to leases created by the redeemed mortgagee. The statement of the law in Govindasami Pillai v. Pethaperumal Chetty is in my opinion correct and the case in Chinnappa Thevan v. Pazhaniappa Pillai, cannot be treated as an authority on the point as it dealt with the special provisions (not reported) of Ex. G. The point is expressly left open by the judgment in Seshamma Shettati v. Chickaya Hegade. The case in The The Collector Of Basti v. Sarnam Gharak*, is that of a single Judge and is unreported in the authorised reports. I am not prepared to follow it. There can further be no question of holding over once it is conceded that the tenancy has come to an end on redemption, A new tenancy can of course be begun but the defendant's conduct here in repudiating the relationship of landlord and tenant when the mortgagee served him with notice to quit 4 days after he had redeemed clearly puts an end to any such contention. The defendants here are therefore in the position of a trespasser. I am unable to see how a tenancy created by a mortgagee does not come to an end in this country on redemption and I think the case where this has been held to take place in the case of redemption by a mortgagor must be held equally applicable to the case of redemption by a subsequent mortgagee.

    Sect. 74 of the Transfer of Property. Act only gives the redeeming mortgagee the rights and powers of the mortgagee as such. This does not extend to a case such as this. I agree in the order proposed by my learned brother.

    d,
    S. S.Decree modifie.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Alagirisami Pillai v. Akkulu Naidu
    (Aug 17, 1921)