Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • the amendments made thereto by the High Court of Punjab and Haryana
  • Section 5 of the Limitation Act
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Order 22 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (for short “CPC”) and amendments made thereto by the High Court of Punjab and Haryana
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • the amendments made thereto by the High Court of Punjab and Haryana
  • Section 5 of the Limitation Act
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Order 22 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (for short “CPC”) and amendments made thereto by the High Court of Punjab and Haryana
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner in Special Leave Petition (SLP) No. 7735 of 2010 discovered that Respondent 1 had died on 9-6-2009, i.e. before the SLP was instituted. Consequently, the petitioner filed several interlocutory applications:

  • IA No. 2 of 2011 – for substitution of Respondent 1 by his legal representatives.
  • IA No. 3 of 2011 – for condonation of the delay (9-6-2009 to 5-9-2011) in seeking such substitution.
  • IA Nos. 4 and 5 – for exemption from filing an official translation and from filing the death certificate.
  • IA No. 6 – for deletion of pro forma Respondent 2 (attorney of Respondent 1).

The Court’s task was to decide whether the procedural route chosen—an application for substitution when the respondent was already deceased at the time of filing—was maintainable and, if not, what corrective mechanism should be employed.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether an application for substitution of a respondent who had already died before the SLP was filed is maintainable under the Supreme Court Rules or the Code of Civil Procedure.
  2. If such substitution is not procedurally maintainable, what is the appropriate remedy for the petitioner once the prior death of the respondent comes to light?

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • Invoked Order 22 CPC and the amendments made by the Punjab & Haryana High Court to contend that legal heirs of a respondent who was already deceased can be substituted even after filing.
  • Relied on a series of precedents—including Bank of Commerce Ltd. v. Protab Chandra Ghose (AIR 1946 FC 13) and Karuppaswamy v. C. Ramamurthy (1993) 4 SCC 41—to support the view that substitution is permissible and delay can be condoned.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Bank of Commerce Ltd. v. Protab Chandra Ghose, AIR 1946 FC 13 An application to substitute legal representatives when the respondent had died before the appeal amounts to filing a fresh appeal; delay may be excused under §5 Limitation Act. Accepted as supporting authority that substitution in such circumstances is not the correct procedure; an amended appeal and condonation of delay are required.
Adusumilli Gopalakrishnayya v. Adivi Lakshmana Rao, AIR 1925 Mad 1210 (FB) The court may amend the appeal memorandum under §153 CPC to bring on record the heirs of a respondent who had died before filing; delay must be condoned. Relied upon to demonstrate the proper course of action—amendment rather than substitution.
Govinda Kaviraj Purohita v. Gauranga Saw, AIR 1924 Mad 56 Earlier contrary view that an appeal against a dead person must be dismissed. Cited only to note it was overruled by the Full Bench in Adusumilli.
Darbar Shri Khachar Alabhai Vajsurbhai v. Khachar Bhura Bhaya, AIR 1937 Bom 401 Referenced for principles on substitution/amendment. No specific analysis provided in the opinion.
Sachindra Chandra Chakravarti v. Jnanendra Narayan Singh Roy, AIR 1963 Cal 417 Referenced for principles on substitution/amendment. No specific analysis provided in the opinion.
State of W.B. v. Manisha Maity, AIR 1965 Cal 459 Order 22 Rule 4 CPC does not apply where appeal filed against a person already dead; remedy is to file fresh appeal against heirs with an application under §5 Limitation Act. Quoted approvingly; forms part of the ratio for requiring amendment plus condonation.
Angadi Veettil Sreedharan v. Cheruvalli Illath Sreedharan Embrandiri Mannoor, AIR 1968 Ker 196 Referenced for substitution principles. No specific analysis provided in the opinion.
Vantaku Appalanaidu v. Peddinti Demudamma, AIR 1982 AP 281 Referenced for substitution principles. No specific analysis provided in the opinion.
Karuppaswamy v. C. Ramamurthy, (1993) 4 SCC 41; AIR 1993 SC 2324 Referenced for substitution principles. No specific analysis provided in the opinion.
Ram Kala v. Director of Consolidation, (1997) 7 SCC 498 Referenced for substitution principles. No specific analysis provided in the opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court undertook a two-stage analysis:

  1. Examination of authoritative precedents. Decisions of the Federal Court, Madras High Court (Full Bench), Calcutta High Court and others consistently hold that when a respondent is already deceased at the time of filing, the correct procedure is to treat any move to bring the heirs on record as filing a fresh appeal against them. The remedy therefore lies in amending the appeal memorandum coupled with an application for condonation of delay under Section 5 of the Limitation Act.
  2. Interpretation of Supreme Court Rules, 1966. Order 16 Rules 8 and 9 govern substitution only when the respondent dies after the SLP is filed. They do not cure the defect where the initial filing itself was against a dead person. Consequently, the Court held that these rules are inapplicable to the present situation.

Applying these principles, the Court held that IA No. 2 should be treated as an application to amend the SLP rather than for substitution. Because IA No. 3 adequately explained the delay in seeking such amendment, the delay could be condoned in the interests of justice.

Holding and Implications

IA Nos. 2 and 3 ALLOWED; delay condoned. IA Nos. 4, 5 and 6 also ALLOWED; all interlocutory applications stand disposed of.

Immediate Effect: The SLP’s cause title will be amended to substitute the legal representatives of deceased Respondent 1; pro forma Respondent 2 is deleted at the petitioner’s risk. Broader Implications: The decision reiterates that where an appeal or SLP is inadvertently filed against a deceased party, the correct procedural course is amendment plus condonation, not direct substitution under Order 16 of the Supreme Court Rules; however, no new substantive precedent is created beyond reaffirming existing authority.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Gurcharan Singh v. Surjit Singh And Another

    Order

    1. These interlocutory applications have been filed by the petitioner in Special Leave Petition No. 7735 of 2010. IA No. 2 of 2011 is an application for substitution of legal representatives of deceased Respondent 1. As Respondent 1 died on 9-6-2009 and the application for substitution has been filed on 5-9-2011, IA No. 3 of 2011 has been filed for condonation of delay in filing the application for substitution of legal representatives of the deceased Respondent 1. The question which I have to decide is whether an application for substitution of a respondent who was dead when the special leave petition was filed was maintainable, and if not, the remedy of the petitioner when he comes to learn that the respondent was actually dead when he filed the special leave petition.

    2. The learned counsel for the petitioner relied on the provisions of Order 22 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (for short “CPC”) as well as the amendments made thereto by the High Court of Punjab and Haryana and submitted that even where the respondent was dead when the special leave petition was filed, his legal heirs can be substituted under these provisions of CPC. He also relied on the decisions in Bank of Commerce Ltd. v. Protab Chandra Ghose AIR 1946 FC 13, Gopalakrishnayya v. Adivi Lakshmana Rao AIR 1925 Mad 1210, H.H Darbar Alabhai Vajsurbhai v. Bhura Bhaya AIR 1937 Bom 401, Sachindra Chandra Chakravarti v. Jnanendra Narayan Singh Roy AIR 1963 Cal 417, State of W.B v. Manisha Maity AIR 1965 Cal 459, Angadi Veettil Sreedharan v. Cheruvalli Illath Sreedharan Embrandiri Mannoor AIR 1968 Ker 196, Vantaku Appalanaidu v. Peddinti Demudamma AIR 1982 AP 281, Karuppaswamy v. C. Ramamurthy (1993) 4 SCC 41, AIR 1993 SC 2324 and Ram Kala v. Director of Consolidation (1997) 7 SCC 498.

    3. I have perused the aforesaid decisions cited by the learned counsel for the petitioner and I find that in Bank of Commerce Ltd. v. Protab Chandra Ghose AIR 1946 FC 13, the Federal Court took the view that where an appeal has to be preferred for the first time against the legal heir of a person in whose favour the lower court had passed a decree, the mere fact that an appeal had already been preferred as against other persons will not justify the application being treated merely as one to add a party because it is in substance an appeal preferred against him for the first time. After taking this view, the Federal Court held that an application for substitution of legal representatives of a respondent, who was dead before the filing of the appeal, must be treated as if appeal is filed for the first time against legal representatives of the deceased respondent and the delay in making the application is only to be excused under Section 5 of the Limitation Act if the delay is satisfactorily explained.

    4. In Gopalakrishnayya v. Adivi Lakshmana Rao AIR 1925 Mad 1210 the facts were that an appeal had been presented by the appellant against a person who was dead at the time of presentation and the Full Bench of the Madras High Court took the view that although such an appeal may be incompetent owing to the wrong person being named as respondent, the court which deals with it has full power under Section 153 CPC to direct an amendment of the appeal memorandum and if the appeal is out of time against the legal representatives, the court will have to excuse the delay in presentation of the appeal before it in exercise of its discretion. The Full Bench overruled the contrary view of a Division Bench of the Madras High Court in Govinda Kaviraj Purohita v. Gauranga Saw AIR 1924 Mad 56 that an appeal filed against a dead person has to be dismissed. The Full Bench of the Madras High Court further held that Order 15 Rule 6 of the Federal Court Rules, 1942, which dealt with substitution of the representative of one who is a party to an appeal and for addition of party did not apply to a party who was dead at the time of filing of the appeal.

    5. The Calcutta High Court has taken a similar view in State of W.B v. Manisha Maity AIR 1965 Cal 459 that Order 22 Rule 4 CPC providing for the procedure for substitution of the heirs and legal representatives of the deceased defendants has no application when the appeal itself was preferred against a dead person. The Division Bench of the Calcutta High Court, however, has suggested that in such a case: (AIR p. 462, para 11)

    “11. The remedy of an appellant, who has unknowingly filed an appeal against a dead person, is to file an application for presentation of the appeal against the heirs of the dead person afresh. If the time for filing the appeal was in the meantime over, he is to present an application, under Section 5 of the Limitation Act, therein explaining the delay in presenting the appeal afresh against the heirs of the dead person. If he can make out sufficient cause for making the belated prayer, the Court may allow the same, amend the cause title of the memorandum of appeal by incorporation of the names of the heirs and legal representatives of the dead person and treat the appeal as a freshly presented appeal against the heirs.”

    6. Thus, the aforesaid authorities are clear that where a party has been impleaded as respondent in an appeal but such respondent was dead before filing of the appeal, the remedy of the appellant is not to file an application for substitution of legal representatives of such respondent, but to file an application for an amendment of the appeal memorandum and in a case where such application for amendment is filed beyond the limitation prescribed for filing the appeal, the appellant must also file an application under Section 5 of the Limitation Act for condonation of delay in filing the application for amendment and if the court is satisfied with the explanation given by the appellant for the delay, the court can condone the delay and allow the amendment of the appeal memorandum.

    7. Order 16 of the Supreme Court Rules, 1966 is titled “Appeals by special leave”. Rules 8 and 9 of Order 16 which provide for substitution and addition of parties are extracted hereinbelow:

    “8. Where any person is sought to be impleaded in the petition as the legal representative of any party to the proceedings in the court below, the petition shall contain a prayer for bringing on record such person as the legal representative and shall be supported by an affidavit setting out the facts showing him to be the proper person to be entered on the record as such legal representative.
    9. Where at any time between the filing of the petition for special leave to appeal and the hearing thereof the record becomes defective by reason of the death or change of status of a party to the appeal or for any other reason, an application shall be made to the court stating who is the proper person to be substituted or entered on the record in place of or in addition to the party on record. Provisions contained in Rule 33 of Order 15 shall apply to the hearing of such applications.”

    8. Considering the authorities discussed above, the aforesaid provisions of Order 16 Rules 8 and 9 will apply where at the time of filing of the special leave petition, the respondent was alive and after the filing of the special leave petition his legal representatives are sought to be substituted, but will not apply where the respondent was dead when the special leave petition was filed. Where the respondent was dead when the special leave petition was filed, the court can, in the interest of justice, allow an application for amendment of the special leave petition and condone the delay in filing such an application for amendment if the delay is satisfactorily explained.

    9. IA No. 2 of 2011 is, therefore, treated as an application for amendment of the special leave petition and as the delay in filing the application for amendment of the special leave petition has been satisfactorily explained in IA No. 3 of 2011, the delay is condoned and in the interests of justice, IAs Nos. 2 and 3 of 2011 are allowed. The prayers in IAs Nos. 4 and 5 are for exemption from filing official translation and from filing death certificate of the deceased and are allowed. IA No. 6 of 2011 is for deletion of pro forma Respondent 2, Ajaib Singh, who appears to be the attorney of the contesting Respondent 1, and is allowed at the risk of the petitioner. The IAs stand disposed of.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Gurcharan Singh v. Surjit Singh And Another
    (Nov 2, 2012)