AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant (decree-holder), Mt. Bilas Devi, instituted a partition suit claiming rights in several joint family immovable and movable properties against multiple defendants, including defendant 5, Bansidhar Sahu (the respondent), who was the nephew of her husband. The parties reached terms of compromise before this Court (recorded in the judgment), which were incorporated into a decree in the partition suit. The compromise included (inter alia) maintenance at Rs. 125 per month payable on the 7th of each English month, a Rs. 5,000 payment in instalments from defendant 5, Rs. 1,400 for ornaments in instalments, exclusive occupation of a house by the lady, and a clause (5) referring to interest at six percent from date of default.

Defendant 5 failed to pay the agreed amounts. Execution proceedings were initiated by the decree-holder as Execution Case No. 4 of 1948, claiming Rs. 11,079/6/- (principal amounts, interest and arrears of maintenance for 34 months with interest). The judgment-debtor objected under Section 47 CPC, arguing inter alia that the decree was "quite illegal & invalid & inexecutable" (including a contention based on Order 23 Rule 3 CPC), and that the decree-holder could not realise the sums by execution without a separate suit; also contended no interest was due on the specified sums.

The learned Subordinate Judge partly sustained the judgment-debtor's objections: execution in respect of Rs. 5,000 and Rs. 1,400 (with interest) was allowed to proceed, but the court held that, because the suit had been allowed to be withdrawn, no executable decree could have been passed in respect of maintenance arrears. The appellant appealed solely against the aspect of the order disallowing execution for arrears of maintenance; there was no cross-objection from the judgment-debtor regarding the Rs. 5,000 and Rs. 1,400.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the arrears of maintenance and future maintenance stated in the compromise decree were executable by execution proceedings, or whether the decree-holder must resort to a separate suit to enforce those items.
  2. Whether interest is payable on arrears of maintenance and on maintenance accruing after the compromise (i.e., whether the clause in the compromise providing interest applies to those sums).
  3. Whether the decree was inexecutable as a whole (including reference to contention based on Order 23 Rule 3 CPC and the effect of any withdrawal of the suit).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellant argued that the Subordinate Judge's view that the suit stood withdrawn (and therefore maintenance could not be executed) was not open to the respondent for several reasons, including that no appeal had been filed by the judgment-debtor against the portion of the order allowing execution of the Rs. 5,000 and Rs. 1,400 (with interest), and that no appeal had been preferred from the decree itself which had been drawn up on the terms of the compromise recorded in this Court.
  • Reliance was placed on precedent (Anath Nath v. Dwarka Nath and Hardi Ram v. Kali Prasad) to support that the decree was enforceable and that the court could and did properly record and draw up the compromise as a decree.
  • The appellant relied on Ashutosh Banerjee v. Lakhimoni Debya (leading case) for the proposition that a decree declaring future maintenance and making it payable at intervals is executable and that it is unnecessary to institute a fresh suit each time there is a default.
  • Further reliance was placed upon Sabitri Thakurain v. Mrs. F.A. Savi (which followed the Calcutta decision) and other supportive authorities to show that maintenance decrees in such form are executable by execution proceedings.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The respondent contended that on a proper construction of the decree only the two sums of Rs. 5,000 and Rs. 1,400 were explicitly made payable and realisable by execution; the portions relating to arrears of maintenance and future maintenance did not contain an explicit direction for execution and therefore only declared rights, leaving the decree-holder to seek remedies by a regular suit against all persons who could be liable.
  • It was urged that, whereas clauses (2) and (3) specifically named defendant 5 as liable for payments, clauses (1) (future maintenance) and (6) (arrears of maintenance) did not name any person specifically, and that omission supported the view these items were not made executable by the decree.
  • The respondent relied on Charu Chandra v. Sambhu Nath (a decision of a single bench of this Court) for the proposition that when a compromise includes matters extraneous to the suit those terms may be recorded but the drawn decree should incorporate only the terms which relate directly to matters in controversy; the respondent argued this supported the view that maintenance provisions were not properly incorporated as enforceable terms.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Anath Nath v. Dwarka Nath, 43 CWN 529 : AIR (26) 1939 PC 86 Authority relied upon by the appellant to support the enforcement of compromise/decree and relevant judicial observations. The court noted reliance on this Judicial Committee of the Privy Council decision as supporting the appellant's contention that the compromise/decree was enforceable.
Hardi Ram v. Kali Prasad, 29 PLT 499 : AIR (36) 1949 Pat 79 Decision of a Division Bench of this Court relied upon by the appellant to support enforceability of the compromise/decree. The court recorded that reliance was placed on this decision to bolster the view that the compromise terms could be executed without a fresh suit.
Ashutosh Banerjee v. Lakhimoni Debya, 19 Cal 139 (FB) Holding that a decree declaring future maintenance and making it payable at intervals is executable and that a fresh suit is unnecessary for each default. The court accepted this as the leading case supporting the principle that decrees for future maintenance payable at intervals are executable.
Sabitri Thakurain v. Mrs. F.A. Savi, 12 Pat 359 at p. 555 : AIR (20) 1933 Pat 306 Followed the Calcutta Full Bench decision that maintenance decrees payable periodically are executable. The court noted that this Division Bench decision followed the Calcutta Full Bench decision and supported the appellant's position.
Ekradeshwar Singh v. Mt. Janeshwari, 42 Cal 582 : AIR (1) 1914 PC 76 Privy Council decision referenced in earlier case law relating to maintenance decrees (as cited in Sabitri Thakurain). The court noted the reference in prior authorities (Sabitri Thakurain) to this Privy Council decision as part of the chain of authority supporting executability.
Charu Chandra v. Sambhu Nath, 3 Pat LJ 255 at p. 267 : AIR (5) 1918 Pat 507 (FB) Direction that when a compromise embraces matters extraneous to the suit, the agreement may be recorded but the decree should incorporate only those terms directly relating to the controversy. The respondent relied on this authority; the court concluded that, rather than supporting the respondent, the authority lent some support to the appellant because the full recording of terms in the decree evidenced an intention that the parties intended enforceability by execution.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the compromise terms, the decree drawn on their basis, the execution petition, and the objection under Section 47 CPC. It considered both parties' arguments and the authorities relied upon.

  1. Construction of the compromise and decree: The court emphasised that the compromise had been agreed before the Court, recorded, and reduced into a decree in the partition suit. It observed that clauses (2) and (3) expressly named defendant 5 as liable for the specified lump-sum payments and provided for execution in case of non-payment; clause (1) declared entitlement to maintenance at Rs. 125 per month; clause (6) declared entitlement to arrears from 7-4-1945; clause (5) mentioned interest at six percent from date of default.
  2. Application of precedent: The court accepted the appellant's reliance on authorities (including the Calcutta Full Bench decision in Ashutosh Banerjee v. Lakhimoni Debya and subsequent decisions following it) establishing that a decree declaring future maintenance payable at intervals is executable and does not require a fresh suit for each default. The court treated these precedents as supporting enforcement of maintenance provisions embedded in a decree.
  3. Analysis of Charu Chandra: The court considered the respondent's reliance on Charu Chandra (which directed that only terms directly relating to the controversy should be incorporated in the drawn decree when compromises include extraneous matters). The court concluded that because the whole compromise was incorporated in the decree here, Charu Chandra, rather than supporting the respondent, lent some support to the appellant's contention that the parties intended maintenance and arrears to be payable by execution.
  4. Policy and practical considerations: The court reasoned that it is consonant with reason and public policy to construe compromises so as to avoid multiplying litigation. For dependent persons (such as the appellant, a dependent member of a joint Hindu family) the court preferred enforcement by execution rather than forcing them into fresh litigation with additional costs. The court stated that courts favor constructions that shorten litigation and resist constructions that multiply litigation.
  5. Interest issue: The court separately analysed clause (5) (the interest clause) and concluded that on true construction clause (5) referred only to interest on the instalments mentioned in clauses (2) and (3) (the Rs. 5,000 and Rs. 1,400 items). It reasoned that clause (5) could not refer to clauses (1) and (6) (future and arrears of maintenance) because those clauses made no mention of interest; thus either by mistake or deliberate omission the parties did not agree to interest on maintenance arrears or future maintenance. The result, the court found, was unfortunate for the lady but binding because she entered into the compromise knowingly.
  6. Conclusion from analysis: Given the construction of the compromise and the supporting authorities, the court held that the maintenance and arrears provisions were intended by the parties to be enforceable by execution and that recourse to fresh suits was not necessary. However, the court limited the award by excluding interest on arrears/future maintenance.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL ALLOWED.

Holding (core ruling): The appellate court allowed the decree-holder's appeal and set aside the order of the Subordinate Judge insofar as it refused execution in respect of arrears of maintenance and future maintenance; the court held that those items were enforceable by execution under the decree entered on the terms of the compromise. However, all interest claimed in the execution petition in respect of arrears of maintenance and of maintenance accrued after the compromise was struck off the claim, because the interest clause (clause 5) applied only to the instalments provided in clauses (2) and (3).

Consequences for the parties:

  • The decree-holder may proceed to realise arrears of maintenance and future maintenance by execution (subject to the striking off of interest on those amounts).
  • Interest on the arrears of maintenance and on maintenance accruing after the compromise is disallowed.
  • The appellant is entitled to her costs in this Court; she is not entitled to costs in the Court below because she allowed the case against her to go ex parte there.

The opinion did not announce any novel legal principle beyond applying and following existing authorities; the decision primarily applies precedent and construes the compromise terms to determine executability and the scope of the interest clause.

    Mt. Bilas Devi Decree-Holder-Applt. v. Bansidhar Sahu Judgment-Debtar-Resp.

    B.P Sinha, J.:— This is a decree-holder's appeal from the decision of the learned Subordinate Judge of Arrah, dated 8-5-1948, partly allowing objections under Section 47 of the CPC raised on behalf of the resp. judgment-debtor.

    2. It appeal's that the applt. instituted a suit for partition of properties said to have been joint family properties against a number of defts., including deft. 5, Bansidhar Sahu, the resp in this case, who happens to be the nephew of her husband. The suit related to many items of immovable property as also of movables, including ornaments & pieces of furniture & clothing. The matter came up to this Ct. on appeal from an order passed by the Ct. below refusing to record a certain compromise. That case was Misc. App. No. 454 of 1945. A.D.B of this Ct. succeeded in getting the applt., who was then also the applt. & deft. 5 to agree to certain terms of compromise which are as follows:

    “1. That Mt. Bilas Devi shall be declared entitled to maintenance at the rate of Rs. 125/- (One Hundred & twenty five) a month which shall be payable to her on the 7th of each English calendar month.

    2. That the lady shall also get Rs. 5,000/- & the same shall be paid to her by deft. 5 at the rate of Rs. 2,000/- a year & the balance of Rs. 1,000/- shall be paid in the third year after the first two instalments have been paid. The first two thousand rupees is to be paid on or before 15-1-1948, the second instalment on or before 15-1-1949, & the balance on or before 30-6-1949. In the event of non-payment of any of the instalments, the lady shall be entitled to realise the whole amount then due by execution.

    3. That the lady shall also be paid Rs. 1,400/- on account of ornaments. Rs. 700/- must be paid by the deft. 5 on or before 15-7-1947, & the balance of Rs. 700/- on or before the 15-1-1948. In the event of non-payment of the first instalment on the date fixed, the lady shall be entitled to realise the whole of Rs. 1,400/- by execution.

    4. That it is also agreed that the lady shall be entitled to live in the house situated in Mahalla Abarpool in the town of Arrah. Neither the lady nor any of the parties to the suit shall be entitled to sell the house during the lifetime of the lady.

    5. That, in the event of these instalments not being paid to the lady, interest shall run at six per cent from the date of default.

    6. That the lady is entitled to arrears of maintenance at this rate from 7-4-1945. Respondents, 6, 7, 9, & 11 are minors. They are not a party to this compromise. They are not affected by this.”

    3. The matter did not rest there. The two parties aforesaid appeared before the Ct. where the suit was pending, & a decree was passed in the suit itself, recording the terms of the compromise aforesaid. As the judgment-debtor, deft. 5, did not pay the amounts covered by the terms of the compromise, the decree-holder was compelled to take out execution, which was numbered as Exen. Case No. 4 of 1948. She claimed a total sum of Rs. 11,079/6/- being made up of the cash amounts mentioned in the terms of the compromise as also interest accrued due thereon plus arrears of maintenance for 34 months at the rate of Rs. 125/- per mensem with interest. The judgment-debtor filed an objection petn. under S. 47 of the Code, contending, inter alia, that the decree-holder was not entitled to realise the several sums constituting her total claim as laid in the execution petn., without having recourse to a separate suit, & that the decree passed in the partition suit was “quite illegal & invalid & inexecutable”. The judgment-debtor further contended in his objection that the decree passed was against law, as laid down in O. 23 R. 3 of the CPC & as such it was unenforceable. The question was also raised that the decree-holder was not entitled to any interest either on the sums of 1,400 or 5,000 or on the amount of maintenance. The learned Subordinate Judge overruled the judgment-debtor's objection that the decree was inexecutable as a whole. But the Ct. below gave effect to the judgment-debtor's contention that, the suit having been allowed to be withdrawn, no executable decree could have been passed in respect of maintenance. In that view of the matter, the Ct. below overruled the objection in respect of the realisation of the two sums of 5,000 & 1,400 with interest but upheld the contention in respect of the arrears of maintenance.

    4. The present appeal by the decree-holder is therefore limited to the question of the arrears of maintenance claimed in the execution proceedings. There is no cross-objection or cross appeal by the judgment-debtor in respect of the principal sums of 5,000 & 1,400 plus interest, execution in respect of which has been allowed by the Ct. below to proceed.

    5. Mr. Brahmadeva Narayan, on behalf of the applt. has contended, in the first instance, that the argument which partly found favour with Ct. below that the suit stood withdrawn was not open to the resp. for several reasons, the first, that no appeal had been preferred by the judgment-debtor from that portion of the order of the Ct. below allowing the execution to proceed in respect of the two sums aforesaid, namely, 5,000 & 1,400 with interest, in as much, if this argument were well founded, no decree could have been passed as the argument about the withdrawal of the suit would apply with equal force to the entire decree, & not only to that portion of the decree which related to the arrears of maintenance & secondly, that no appeal had been preferred by the judgment-debtor from the decree itself, which was drawn up by the trial Ct. on the basis of the terms of the compromise recorded in this Ct. Reliance was placed on behalf of the applt. on the observations of their Lordships of the Judicial Committee of the P.C in the case of ‘Anath Nath v. Dwarka Nath, 43 CWN 529 : AIR (26) 1939 PC 86) & a D.B of this Ct. in ‘Hardi Ram v. Kali Prasad’, 29 PLT 499 : (AIR (36) 1949 Pat 79). It was further argued that the terms of the compromise declaring the applts' right to maintenance & making it payable on the 7th of each English Calendar month was itself executable, & reliance was placed upon the leading case — a decision of P.B of the Calcutta H.C in ‘Ashutosh Banerjee v. Lakhimoni Debya’, 19 Cal 139 (FB). In that case, their Lordships had ruled that a decree declaring the future maintenance of a person entitled to maintenance & making it payable at certain given intervals is executable & it is not necessary to institute a suit each time there has been a default. The decision of the F.B of the Calcutta H.C referred to above has been followed by a D.B of this Ct. in the case of ‘Sabitri Thakurain v. Mrs. F.A Savi’, 12 Pat 359 at p. 555 : (AIR (20) 1933 Pat 306) where their Lordships of the D.B of this Ct. have also made reference to the decision of their Lordships of the P.C in the case of ‘Ekradeshwar Singh v. Mt. Janeshwari’, 42 Cal 582 : (AIR (1) 1914 PC 76).

    6. To these arguments on behalf of the applt., the answer sought to be given by Mr. Banerji, on behalf of the resp is that, on a proper construction of the decree itself, it should be held that, whereas the two sums of 5,000 & 1,400 were made payable & realisable by execution, no such explicit direction is made in the other portions of the decree relating to arrears of maintenance or future maintenance. The contention therefore is that, in respect of the latter, namely, the arrears of maintenance & future maintenance, only the rights of the pltf. were declared, & she was left to her remedies by a regular suit instituted against all those persons who could have been made liable for the payment of arrears of maintenance & future maintenance. It was also urged that, whereas in the second & third clauses, the deft. 5 is specifically named as the person liable to make the payment, no person is specifically named as liable for payment of the future maintenance mentioned in Cl. (1) or the arrears of maintenance mentioned in Cl. (6). In this connection it is necessary to bear in mind the fact that the compromise was only between the pltf. & her husband's nephew, deft. 5, apparently because he had come by the whole estate, including the interest of the pltf.'s deceased husband. Naturally, therefore it was he alone who would be liable to pay the maintenance. Hence, the omission of the name of the person liable to pay the maintenance or the arrears of maintenance was not a deliberate one but is a case of mere accidental omission.

    7. Reliance was also placed on behalf of the resp upon the decision of a P.B of this Ct. in the case of ‘Charu Chandra v. Sambhu Nath’, 3 Pat LJ 255 at p. 267 : (AIR (5) 1918 Pat 507 FB), where their Lordships have given directions as to what is to be done in a case where the compromise effected between the parties embraces matters not only directly arising on the pleadings of the parties but also matters extraneous to the suit. Their Lordships have directed that the entire agreement may be recorded as the terms of compromise between the parties; but the decree to be drawn up by the Ct. should incorporate only those terms which relate directly to the matters in controversy between the parties. Applying the test laid down there to the present case, it would appear that all the terms of the compromise were incorporated in the decree passed by the Ct. below. Hence, in my opinion, the decision to which our attention was drawn by the learned Advocate for the resp., far from being in support of his contention, lends some support to the contention raised on behalf of the applt. that the intention of the parties was that future maintenance as also arrears of maintenance should be payable by executing the decree, & not by recourse to a separate suit. On general principles also, it is in my opinion, more consistent with reason & public policy that a compromise of the nature entered into by the parties in this case should be enforced by execution instead of compelling the decree-holder to take recourse to a separate suit, because a person in the position of the applt., who is a dependent member in a joint Hindu family, should not be compelled to incur further costs upon fresh litigation. The Ct. is always in favour of construing a compromise in a manner which tends to shorten litigation & the Ct. will always resist any attempt on the part of any of the parties to construe the decree in such a way as to multiply litigation. On a proper construction of the entire terms of the compromise between the parties in this case, in my opinion, it should be held that the parties contemplated that recourse to a fresh suit each time a default is made in the payment of maintenance or in the payment of arrears of maintenance was not necessary. Rather the parties must be deemed to have intended that they were putting an end to the litigation between them. Hence in my opinion, for the reasons given above, the contentions raised on behalf of the applt. are sound.

    8. But there is one small point raised on behalf of the resp. It relates to the question of interest which has been calculated on the arrears of maintenance & future maintenance after it has accrued. The compromise does make reference to interest in Cl. (5) but that clause must, on its true construction, refer to interest on instalments mentioned in Cls. (2) & (3) of the terms of the compromise. It cannot refer to clauses (1) & (6), for the simple reason that, if it was so intended, arrears of maintenance had already accrued & still interest was not mentioned as being payable. It must therefore be inferred that either by mistake or after due deliberation, the parties did not agree to pay or receive interest on arrears of maintenance or of future maintenance when it fell due. Whatever may be the reason for this omission, the result is rather unfortunate for the lady. But it cannot be helped. She has entered into the terms of the compromise with her eyes open, &, if she did not contemplate a contingency of a default by the judgment-debtor & a consequent liability for payment of interest, she must bear her losses without any complaint at this stage.

    9. For the reasons given above, the appeal is allowed, & the order passed by the Ct. below, in so far as it was against the applt. set aside, with this reservation that all interest claimed in the execution petn. in respect of arrears of maintenance & of maintenance accrued after the compromise will be struck off from the claim.

    10. The applt. is entitled to her costs in this Ct. As the decree-holder allowed the case against her to go ‘ex parte’, she is not entitled to costs in the Ct. below.

    11. C.P Sinha, J.:— I agree.

    V.B.B

    12. Appeal allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Mt. Bilas Devi Decree-Holder-Applt. v. Bansidhar Sahu Judgment-Debtar-Resp.
    (Dec 13, 1950)