Factual and Procedural Background
This judgment disposes of R.F.A 28-D of 1965 and Civil Revision No. 111-D of 1964, both filed by Bharat Singh. The appellant filed a suit against five defendants seeking a declaration that shops Nos. 32, 45, and 46 at Narela mandi, Delhi, belonged to him and his brother Kirpa Ram (defendant No. 5). The suit challenged the validity of a sale of these shops in execution of a decree dated March 18, 1950, which the appellant alleged was collusive and void, and asserted that the auction-purchasers (defendants 3 and 4) had no rights over the shops.
The appellant and Kirpa Ram were sons of Ram Narain and constituted a joint Hindu family. The decree had been passed in favor of Mst. Bhagirathi (defendant No. 2), widow of Maha Chand, another son of Ram Narain, and the firm M/s. Sheo Pershad Giani Ram (defendant No. 1). The appellant alleged the decree was collusive and sought to restrain execution against the joint family property.
Following the decree, the shops were attached and sold in auction in July 1962. The appellant had filed objections under various provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC), which were dismissed. The suit was filed shortly after the dismissal of objections to the auction sale. The trial court dismissed the suit on the ground of limitation, leading to the present appeal. Additionally, Civil Revision No. 111-D of 1964 concerns the dismissal of the appellant’s review application challenging confirmation of the auction sale.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the suit filed by the appellant challenging the sale of the shops was barred by limitation.
- Whether the dismissal of earlier objections under Order 21, rule 58 CPC, and the non-filing of a suit under Order 21, rule 63 CPC, barred the present suit by conclusiveness or res judicata.
- Whether a review petition under Order 47, rule 1 CPC could be filed by a person not party to the lis.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The decree dated March 18, 1950 was collusive and void, and did not confer rights on the auction-purchasers.
- The appellant and his brother had been in possession of the shops for over 25 years and denied ownership rights of defendants 3 and 4.
- The dismissal of objections under Order 21, rule 58 CPC in 1950 was irrelevant as the execution application was dismissed in 1953, and a fresh attachment was made in 1956, thus the suit filed after dismissal of objections in 1962 was within limitation.
Defendants' Arguments
- The suit was misconceived and barred by limitation.
- There was no collusion between Mst. Bhagirathi and defendant No. 1.
- The dismissal of objections under Order 21, rule 58 CPC in 1950 was final and conclusive since no suit under Order 21, rule 63 CPC was filed, barring challenge to attachment and sale.
- Appellant was delaying the process and harassing defendants 1 to 4.
- In the Civil Revision, the review application was incompetent as the petitioner was not a party to the lis.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent |
Rule or Principle Cited For |
Application by the Court |
| Najimunnessa Bibi v. Nacharaddin Sardar, AIR 1924 Calcutta 744 |
Interpretation of "shall be conclusive" in Order 21, rule 63 CPC and limitation of suit after attachment ceases. |
Supported the view that a suit to resist attachment is not barred by limitation if attachment ceases and is re-attached later. |
| Radhabai Gopal Joshi v. Gopal Dhondo Joshi, AIR 1944 Bombay 50 |
Reiteration of principles regarding conclusiveness of order under Order 21, rule 63 CPC. |
Reiterated the principle that conclusiveness is conditional on subsisting attachment. |
| Bibi Amar Kaur v. Shiv Karan and others, AIR 1965 Punjab 206 |
Concurrent remedies under Order 21, rule 58 and rule 63 CPC; requirement of subsisting attachment. |
Clarified that the order under rule 58 is operative only while attachment subsists; suit under rule 63 must be within one year. |
| Kumara Goundan v. Thevaraya Reddi and others, AIR 1925 Madras 1113 |
Effect of cessation of attachment on conclusiveness of order under rule 58 CPC. |
Supported that conclusiveness depends on continuance of attachment and that cessation within or beyond one year affects operativeness. |
| Mangru Mahto and others v. Thakur Taraknathji Tarkeshwar Nath and others, AIR 1967 Supreme Court 1390 |
Effect of order under Order 21, rule 58 CPC on res judicata and conclusiveness under rule 63 CPC. |
Held that order in claim proceedings is not res judicata and conclusiveness under rule 63 applies only if suit is not filed within one year. |
| Sant Lal and others v. Firm Udhi Ram Walait Ram, AIR 1938 Lahore 568 |
Effect of sale on attachment and competence of claim petition under Order 21, rule 58 CPC. |
Discussed whether claim petitions are competent after sale and the requirement of postponing sale pending claim investigation. |
| Chet Singh v. Gujar Singh and others, AIR 1931 Lahore 74 |
Conclusive effect of order under Order 21, rule 63 CPC related to attachment validity. |
Clarified that conclusiveness applies only between claimant and decree-holder in the same execution proceeding and is conditional on attachment subsisting. |
| Ramchandra Singh and others v. Mt. Bibi Khodaijatul Kubra and others, AIR 1945 Patna 369 |
Conditional conclusiveness of order under Order 21, rule 63 CPC depending on continuance of execution proceedings and attachment. |
Held that when execution proceedings end and attachment ceases, a suit beyond one year for title is not barred by limitation. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court analyzed the sequence of attachments, execution applications, and objections filed by the appellant. The trial court had erred in treating the dismissal of objections under Order 21, rule 58 CPC in 1950 as the relevant date for limitation, ignoring the dismissal of the execution application in 1953 and the subsequent attachment in 1956. The court held that the conclusiveness of an order under rule 58 and rule 63 CPC is conditional on the subsistence of the attachment. Since the execution application was dismissed in 1953 and the attachment ceased, the bar of limitation for filing a suit under rule 63 CPC after the 1950 dismissal did not apply to the present suit filed after the 1962 dismissal of objections to the second attachment and sale.
The court relied on authoritative precedents from various High Courts and the Supreme Court that consistently held that the conclusiveness of orders under Order 21, rule 58 and rule 63 CPC applies only while the attachment subsists. If the attachment ceases, the order becomes defunct, and a fresh claim or suit can be filed within the prescribed limitation period from the date of dismissal of objections to the new attachment.
Regarding the Civil Revision, the court held that a review petition under Order 47, rule 1 CPC can only be filed by a party to the lis. Since Bharat Singh was not a party to the original lis, his review petition was incompetent and rightly dismissed.
Holding and Implications
The appeal in R.F.A 28-D of 1965 is allowed, the finding of the trial court that the suit is barred by limitation is set aside, and the suit is remanded for trial in accordance with law.
This decision means the appellant's suit challenging the auction sale is not barred by limitation and may proceed on merits. No costs were ordered in the appeal.
The Civil Revision No. 111-D of 1964 is dismissed.
This dismissal confirms that review petitions under Order 47, rule 1 CPC are restricted to parties to the lis, preventing third parties from seeking review of orders affecting them indirectly. No costs were awarded for this dismissal.
Show full summary ...