Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Traffic Rules and Act and the provisions of Motor Vehicles Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Traffic Rules and Act and the provisions of Motor Vehicles Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The claimant, a 40-year-old employee in the Telephone Department at Namakkal District earning Rs.6,275 per month, was injured on 31.07.2000 at about 10:45 a.m. He was travelling as a pillion rider on a TVS Suzuki motorcycle (Regn. No. TN-28-H-1488) together with a friend named Babu. While approaching Thanneer-mathipatti Branch Road (Gemmedu to Cholakadu Main Road), a lorry (Regn. No. TN-28-C-2040) allegedly driven in a rash and negligent manner collided with the motorcycle. The claimant and Babu were thrown from the vehicle and sustained injuries; the claimant was taken to Mohan Kumaralingam Government Medical College Hospital, Salem. The Claim Petition sought Rs.2,00,000 as compensation, alleging fault on the part of the lorry driver.

The insurer (appellant) filed a counter-claiming that three persons had travelled on the motorcycle, which violated policy conditions, the Traffic Rules and the Motor Vehicles Act, and that the presence of three persons caused imbalance leading to the accident. The insurer further argued that one Babu contributed to the accident, that the motorcycle rider lacked control and licence, and that the motorcycle's insurer/owner should have been impleaded as parties. An additional counter expanded on the imbalance theory and asserted that the accident occurred due to the motorcycle rider's negligence rather than the lorry driver's conduct.

The learned Tribunal Judge held the lorry driver liable and awarded compensation to the claimant. The insurance company appealed the Tribunal's award. The appellate court reviewed the evidence and relevant precedents and ultimately confirmed the Tribunal's award.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether travelling of three persons on a motorcycle (contrary to statute, Rules and policy conditions) establishes contributory negligence so as to absolve the lorry owner/insurer from liability.
  2. Whether the Insurance Company discharged the burden of proving that the presence of three persons on the motorcycle was the sole and proximate cause of the accident.
  3. Whether the quantum of compensation assessed by the Tribunal (including disability percentage and heads of damages) was regular and sustainable.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant / Insurance Company's Arguments

  • The First Information Report stated that three persons were travelling on the motorcycle, which violated policy conditions and statutory traffic rules; this breach should preclude indemnity under the policy.
  • The accident resulted from the rash and negligent riding of the motorcycle (including imbalance due to three persons), and therefore liability should rest with the motorcycle rider/owner and their insurer rather than the lorry driver or the appellant.
  • The motorcycle rider lacked a valid driving licence and the claimant had no proper grip; these facts contributed to the accident and defeat the claim against the lorry's insurer.
  • The insurer contended that the motorcycle rider should have taken precaution before entering the main road and that the accident occurred in the middle of the main road due to the motorcycle's maneuvering, not due to the lorry driver's conduct.
  • Counsel for the appellant relied on a Division Bench decision (Tamil Nadu State Transport Corporation v. Abdul Salam) to argue that travelling three persons on a two-seater motorcycle constitutes contributory negligence contrary to the statute and that such conduct should attract contributory negligence liability.

Claimant / Respondent's Position (as reflected in record)

  • The F.I.R. (Ex.A.1) and the claimant's evidence (P.W.1) state that the lorry driver drove in a rash and negligent manner and dashed into the motorcycle without sounding the horn; the claimant attributes the cause to the lorry driver's negligence.
  • In cross-examination, the claimant denied that the accident was due to loss of control caused by three persons travelling on the motorcycle.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Tamil Nadu State Transport Corporation v. Abdul Salam & Others, 2003 (1) M.L.J 489; 2003 (2) L.W 75; 2004 (2) TN MAC 59 (DB) Observed that when three persons travel on a motorcycle meant for two, the conduct of those persons is liable for contributory negligence, especially when contrary to statute. The appellant relied on this decision to argue contributory negligence. The court considered it but noted that that decision did not contain specific findings linking three-person travel as the direct cause of the accident in that case; hence its application is fact-specific.
Kattabomman Transport Corpn. Ltd. v. Vellai Duraichi, 2004 (1) TN MAC 180 (DB): 2004 (1) CTC 677 Affirms that there must be evidence showing that travelling three persons on a motorcycle was responsible for the accident before applying contributory negligence mechanically despite statutory violation. The court relied on this authority to state the correct principle: mere violation of Act/Rules or policy conditions does not automatically result in contributory negligence unless the insurer proves causation.
M. Anandavalli Amma v. Arvind Eye Hospital, 2002 (5) CTC 70 : 2002 (3) L.W 710 Holds that merely carrying extra passengers is not necessarily a fundamental breach of the insurance contract; insurer must prove that the extra passengers caused the accident. The court applied this principle and followed it: unless the insurer established that taking more passengers caused the accident, the insurer/owner remains liable to pay compensation.
Canadian Pacific Railway Co. v. Leonard Lochart, AIR 1943 PC 63 Cited in M. Anandavalli Amma as an authority relied upon in relation to the principles governing breach and causation in liability/insurance contexts. Referenced as one of the authorities followed in M. Anandavalli Amma; the appellate court treated it as part of the chain of authorities supporting the proposition that causation must be shown.
K.R. Sivagami v. Mahaboob Nisa Bi & others, 1981 ACJ 399 Cited in M. Anandavalli Amma and relied upon for principles concerning breach, causation and indemnity under insurance law. Identified as one of the decisions followed by the Division Bench in M. Anandavalli Amma; used as supporting authority for requiring proof of causation by insurer.
B.V. Nagaraju v. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd., Divisional Officer, Hassan, 1996 (4) SCC 647 Cited in M. Anandavalli Amma as an authority relevant to the issue of insurer liability and conditions of policy. Noted as one of the earlier authorities relied upon in M. Anandavalli Amma; treated as supporting the principle that insurer must show the breach caused the accident to deny indemnity.
Skandia Insurance Company Ltd. v. Kokilaben Chandravadan, 1987 (2) SCC 654 Cited in M. Anandavalli Amma; relevant to insurance-law principles on breach and indemnity. Included among authorities followed in M. Anandavalli Amma and relied upon by the court for the stated legal proposition about causation and breach.
Shivraj Vasant Bhagwat v. Shevanta Dattaram Indulkar, AIR 1997 Bom 242 Cited in M. Anandavalli Amma as part of the body of case law on insurance breach and causation. Listed as one of the cases followed in M. Anandavalli Amma; the appellate court treated it as supporting authority for its rule on proof of causation.
Branch Manager, National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Murugesh, 1998 (1) L.W 59 Cited in M. Anandavalli Amma; relates to the principle that insurer must show the breach caused the accident to avoid indemnity. Noted as an authority followed in M. Anandavalli Amma and relied upon to support the proposition applied by the court in the present case.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded in stages, closely following the evidence on record and the settled jurisprudence of the Court:

  1. Factual findings and admissions: It was a conceded fact that three persons had travelled on the motorcycle. The F.I.R. (Ex.A.1) and P.W.1 (the claimant) attributed the cause of the accident to rash and negligent driving by the lorry driver, including the allegation that the lorry driver did not sound the horn. In cross-examination, the claimant denied that the accident occurred because the rider lost control due to carrying three persons.
  2. Appellant's legal contention: The insurer placed reliance on the Division Bench decision in Tamil Nadu State Transport Corporation v. Abdul Salam to assert that riding with three persons (contrary to statute) attracts contributory negligence and should relieve the lorry's insurer of liability.
  3. Review of authorities: The court reviewed a subsequent Division Bench decision (Kattabomman Transport Corpn. Ltd. v. Vellai Duraichi) and the Division Bench decision in M. Anandavalli Amma, which had clarified the scope of Abdul Salam. The court noted the settled principle appearing in those decisions: violation of rules/policy conditions alone does not automatically result in contributory negligence or denial of indemnity. Rather, the owner/insurer must prove that the specific breach (here, carrying more passengers) was the proximate and sole cause of the accident.
  4. Application to the case at hand: The court found that the Insurance Company had not discharged the legal burden of proving that travelling three persons on the motorcycle alone caused the accident. There was no contra-evidence to the F.I.R. and the oral evidence (P.W.1) that implicated the lorry driver. The insurer produced no evidence to show that the additional passenger caused the accused event.
  5. On quantum: The court examined the medical records (Ex.A.4 wound certificate; Ex.A.5 discharge summary) showing the claimant was inpatient from 31.07.2000 to 15.08.2000 and that he suffered a fracture of the left ankle malleolus and multiple lacerations requiring operations. P.W.2 (an orthopaedician) opined restricted ankle movement and a 25% permanent disablement. The Tribunal, however, assessed disability at 15%, used a notional income of Rs.70 per day (Rs.2,100 per month), calculated annual loss at Rs.25,200 and applied multiplier 15 to reach Rs.3,78,000 as a base before taking 15% of that figure (Rs.56,700) as the loss-of-income component. The Tribunal awarded a total of Rs.68,700 across various heads.
  6. Conclusion on both liability and quantum: Given the insurer's failure to prove causation linked solely to the policy breach and given no demonstrable irregularity in the Tribunal's quantification of damages, the court held the insurer liable and found no legal infirmity in the Tribunal's award.

Holding and Implications

The appeal is dismissed; the Tribunal's award is confirmed and the Insurance Company is held liable to pay the compensation assessed by the Tribunal.

Implications:

  • The direct effect is that the insurance company must satisfy the Tribunal's award (total Rs.68,700 as apportioned by the Tribunal under various heads) and the appeal against that award is dismissed with no costs.
  • The decision reaffirms the settled principle of this Court that a statutory or policy breach (such as carrying more passengers than permitted) does not automatically absolve the owner/insurer of liability. The insurer must specifically prove that the breach was the proximate and sole cause of the accident before being relieved of indemnity obligations. In the absence of such proof, the insurer remains liable to compensate the claimant.
  • The court indicated that the Tribunal's assessment of quantum (including the choice of disability percentage and the application of multiplier-based calculation) did not suffer from legal infirmity and was therefore confirmed.

    New India Assurance Co. Ltd., Divisional Office, No.2, Paramathi Road, Namakkal v. T.K Duraiswamy 2. P. Chinnayan (Set Ex Parte Before The Lower Court) S

    1. In the Claim Petition, the following are stated:

    The claimant was working in Telephone Department in Namakkal District and was aged 40 years. He was earning Rs. 6,275/- p.m On 31.07.2000, at about 10.45 a.m while he was travelling in TVS Suzuki Motor Cycle bearing Registration No.TN-28-H-1488 as a pillion rider along with his friend one Babu who was also a pillion rider and the same was driven by one Babu. When the Motor Cycle was going near Thanneer-mathipatti Branch Road in Gemmedu to Cholakadu Main Road, Lorry bearing Registration No.TN-28-C-2040 driven by its driver in a rash and negligent manner dashed against the Motor Cycle and the claimant and his friend Babu were thrown away from the vehicle and they sustained injuries. The claimant was immediately removed to Mohan Kumaralingam Government Medical College Hospital, Salem. The Lorry driver was at fault at the time of accident. Hence, a sum of Rs. 2,00,000/- is prayed for as com-pensation.

    2. In the counter filed by the appellant/ Insurance company, it is stated that in the F.I.R, it has been clearly stated that three persons had travelled in the Motor Cycle in which the injured was sitting lastly and the travel itself is violation of Policy conditions. The claimant had no grip and the accident took place due to the rash and negligence on the part of one Babu. The Insurer and the insured of Motor Cycle should have been impleaded as parties since both the drivers are responsible for the accident. The said Babu had also contributed to the accident. He did not possess any valid driving licence and hence the Petition has to be dismissed.

    3. In the additional counter filed by the appellant/Insurance Company, it is stated that due to travelling of three persons in the TVS vehicle, the driver could not have any control over the vehicle and due to imbalance, the driver of the TVS vehicle dashed against the Lorry. The accident was not due to fault of the Lorry driver. The person who rode the Motor Vehicle should have stopped the vehicle on seeing both sides of the main road and proceeded. Without taking any caution and following the Traffic Rules, he dashed against the Lorry. The accident took place in the middle of the main road and hence, the Petition has to be dismissed.

    4. The learned Tribunal Judge after considering the evidence of record, fastened the liability upon the Lorry driver. The learned counsel for the appellant Mr. C. Ramesh Babu would very much assail the award passed by the Tribunal by stating that the Tribunal has lost sight of the fact that travelling of three person in a motor vehicle is violative of the Traffic Rules and Act and the provisions of Motor Vehicles Act and that only due to imbalance of the Motor Cycle, the Babu dashed against the Lorry and by no stretch of imagination, the Lorry driver can be anchored with the liability of causing the accident.

    5. It is conceded fact that three persons were travelling by the Motor Cycle. In the First Information Report by Babu, Ex.A.1, he has stated that while the Motor Cycle was coming near Thanneermathipatti diversion road, the Lorry was driven by its driver in a rash and negligent manner and without sounding horn, he dashed against the Motor Cycle. P.W.1, the claimant also would state in line with the allegations in the F.I.R In the cross-examination, a suggestion was put to him that since three members were sitting and travelling by the Motor Cycle, the person who rode the same could not exercise control over it, hence the accident took place for which his answer was in the negative.

    6. In this context, the learned counsel for the appellant would place much reliance upon a Division Bench decision of this Court in Managing Director, Tamil Nadu State Transport Corporation v. Abdul Salam & Others, 2004 (2) TN MAC 59 (DB): 2003 (2) L.W 75: 2003 (1) M.L.J 489, wherein it is observed that ‘when three persons travelled in a Motor Cycle which is meant for two person, this Court is of the view, that the conduct of the persons who travelled in such a manner are liable for contributory negligence; especially when their action is contrary to the statute’.

    7. On a later occasion, another Division Bench of this Court had occasion to refer the above said decision and also various decisions of this Court, Privy Council and Supreme Court and come to a conclusion that there should be evidence on record to show that only due to the travelling of three persons in the Motor Cycle, the accident took place and if no such evidence is forthcoming, then the Insurance Company could not be absolved from its liability. The conclusive portion of the said judgment is as follows:

    Kattabomman Transport Corpn. Ltd. v. Vellai Duraichi, 2004 (1) TN MAC 180 (DB): 2004 (1) CTC 677:

    Para 8. ‘In the light of the said conclusion, we have carefully verified the factual details and the ultimate decision arrived at in the first Division Bench decision, namely, Tamil Nadu State Transport Corporation, Coim-batore Division v. Abdul Salam (citeds supra). As observed earlier, except stating that 3 persons travelled in a motor vehicle, which is prohibited, no specific finding was given to the effect that travelling of three persons in a Motor Cycle was responsible for the accident; hence we are of the view that the conclusion in 2003 (1) M.L.J 489 is to be confirmed to that case. In other words, merely because there is violation of the provisions of the Act or Rules or the Policy conditions, it is not automatic that in every case the principle of contributory negligence is to be applied mechanically. As rightly observed in the other Division Bench decision, namely, M. Anandavali Amma v. Arvind Eye Hospital, 2002 (2) L.W 710, unless there is evidence to prove that the accident took place only because of such act that is taking/travelling more persons in a Motor Cycle which resulted in an accident, the owner of the other vehicle and its insurer will be liable to pay compensation. To put it clear, if the appellant-Transport Corporation is able to prove that it is because of the addition of one more (third person in the Motor Cycle instead of two), the accident occurred, the position would be different. In other words, unless the owner of the vehicle or the Insurance Company is able to prove that the accident took place only because of such act that is taking more persons than the prescribed number, the owner/Insurance Company will be liable to make good the loss/compensation. In the case on hand the materials placed before the Tribunal show that it was the bus driver who had gone to the other side of the road, hit the Motor Cycle thereby caused the accident. There is no evidence to show that the accident occurred because of travelling of three persons in the Motor Cycle. In the light of the above said conclusion, we reject the contra argument made by the learned counsel for the appellant.’

    8. In the above said judgment, this Court has also referred yet another decision of Division Bench in M. Anandavalli Amma v. Arvind Eye Hospital, 2002 (5) CTC 70 : 2002 (3) L.W 710, in which it is observed that ‘Merely by lifting a person or two, it cannot be said to be such a fundamental breach that the owner should, in all events, be denied indemnification.’ The Division Bench further proceeds to observe as follows:

    “The Breach of the condition of the Policy was somewhat irregular, though, but not so fundamental in nature, so as to put an end to the contract, unless some factors existed, which, by themselves, had gone to contribute to the causing of the accident. If the Insurance Company is able to prove that it is because of the presence of the additional persons who were allowed to occupy the vehicle, the accident occurred, the position would be different. Consequently, we hold that even in cases where more passengers are taken with or without the knowledge or implied consent or even consent of the owner, unless the Insurance Company is able to prove that the accident took place only because of such act (taking more passengers) the Insurance Company will be liable to make good the loss/compensation.....”

    9. In the above said M. Anandavalli Amma's, case the Division Bench of this Court has followed the following decisions:

    (1) Canadian Pacific Railway Co. v. Leonard Lochart, AIR 1943 PC 63;

    (2) K.R Sivagami v. Mahaboob Nisa Bi and others,1981 ACJ 399;

    (3) B.V Nagaraju v. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd., Divisional Officer, Hassan., 1996 (4) SCC 647;

    (4) Skandia Insurance Company Ltd., v. Kokilaben Chandravadan, 1987 (2) SCC 654;

    (5) Shivraj Vasant Bhagwat v. Shevanta Dattaram Indulkar, AIR 1997 Bom 242;

    (6) Branch Manager, National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Murugesh, 1998 (1) L.W 59.

    10. Thus, it is the consistent view of this Court and settled position on this issue that it is incumbent upon the vehicle owner and the Insurance Company to establish the fact that travelling by three persons in a Motor Cycle alone was the main reason for the accident and if such evidence is lacking in a case, then the Insurance Company shall be required to make good the loss to the claimants.

    11. Following the above said principle in this case, it is to be held that since the Insurance Company has not discharged its burden as required by law in showing that travel by three persons in a Motor Cycle was alone the cause of accident, it is to be held that the Insurance Company is liable to pay compensation. It is to be noticed that in order to controvert the allegations in the F.I.R and oral evidence of P.W.1, there is no contra evidence on behalf of the Insurance Company. In the above circumstances, this Court is of the definite view that the Insurance Company has to be held liable for paying compensation and in this regard, this Court does not find any legal infirmity in the award passed by the Tribunal, even though it has not elaborately dealt with circumstances leading to fasten the liability to pay the compensation upon the Insurance Company.

    12. As far as the quantum of compen-sation as fixed by the Tribunal is concerned, Ex.A.4 is the Wound Certificate issued by the Government Hospital, Salem while Ex.A.5 is Discharge Summary issued by the same hospital in which it is stated that he was inpatient from 31.07.2000 to 15. 08. 2000. It is learnt from the above said records that the claimant had suffered a fracture in his left ankle malvelous, besides five other lacerations and operations on various parts of the body.

    13. The doctor P.W.2, an Orthopaedician in Government Medical College Hospital would say that the movements in the ankle were restricted that the fractured bone malunited that he could not work utilising his left leg, that he is not able to squat on the floor that it is impossible for him to walk to long distance and that he is suffering from permanent disablement to an extent of 25%. However the Tribunal has restricted the disability at 15% and proceeded to assess the compensation as Loss of Income by applying multiplier method on a notional income of Rs. 70/- per day and Rs. 2,100/- per month and calculated Rs. 25,200/- as annual Loss of Income. Applying the multiplier 15, it has reached Rs. 3,78,000/- in which 15% is equal to Rs. 56,700/-. The following are the compensation under various heads fixed by the Tribunal.

    (1) Loss of Income (Permanent Disability) : Rs. 56,700 (2) Pain and Suffering : Rs. 5,000 (3) Extra-Nourishment : Rs. 5,000 (4) Transport Expenses : Rs. 1,000 (5) Damage to Clothes : Rs. 500 (6) Medical Expenses : Rs. 500 Total : Rs. 68,700

    14. This Court does not find any irregularity in assessing the above said quantum of compensation. In all aspects, the award passed by the Tribunal does not suffer from any infirmity and the same is confirmed. The Appeal has to face dismissal and the same is dismissed. No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    New India Assurance ... v. T.K Duraiswamy 2. P....
    (Jul 21, 2009)