Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff instituted a suit on a mortgage (Ex. P-1) dated 6 June 1909. The trial Court decreed the suit, but the lower appellate Court dismissed it; the plaintiff has preferred this second appeal. The sole point argued before the Court was whether the suit was barred by limitation. The suit was instituted on 27 July 1944 to enforce the mortgage. The mortgage bond bears two endorsements of payments: Ex. P-1(a) dated 30 July 1920 and Ex. P-1(b) dated 29 July 1932. It is common ground that Ex. P-1(a) constitutes a valid acknowledgement of liability and restarts limitation. Ex. P-1(b) records: “The amount of Rs. 100 paid and endorsed (sellu vaithadu) by us five parsons,” followed by the names and signatures of the debtors.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the endorsement Ex. P-1(b) can be construed as an acknowledgment of liability under Section 19 of the Limitation Act (i.e., whether its language implies that a further sum remained due).
  2. Whether Act XVI of 1942 (the amendment to Section 20 of the Limitation Act, effective 30 March 1942) applies so as to save the suit from the bar of limitation — specifically, whether the amended provision can be applied retrospectively to revive a remedy already barred under the pre-1942 law.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The Tamil expression “(sellu vaithadu)” in Ex. P-1(b) should be interpreted to imply that an outstanding balance remained due; therefore Ex. P-1(b) operates as an acknowledgment of liability under Section 19 of the Limitation Act (citing Ramayya v. Anjayya).
  • Even if Ex. P-1(b) were treated as an "open payment" (and thus inoperative under the pre-1942 Section 20), the amendment by Act XVI of 1942 to Section 20 should govern because limitation is procedural and the law in force at the time of institution (30 March 1942 in force; suit instituted 27 July 1944) should apply. Consequently, the endorsement would save the suit under the amended Section 20. The appellant relied on Division Bench decisions of the Patna High Court (Baleswar v. Latafat; Sarab Devaprasad v. Dwarka Prasad; Jagadish Prasad v. Saligram) holding in favour of that view.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The respondents relied upon single-judge decisions of this Court (Avud nammal v. Amhasankar and S. Venkatapayya v. Y. Venkatapayya) concluding that the amendment could not revive a claim which had already become barred before the amendment took effect.
  • Implicitly, the respondents' position is that a law amending limitation provisions cannot be invoked to resurrect a right already extinguished under the previous law unless the amending statute expressly provides for such revival.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ramayya v. Anjayya, I.L.R (1942) Mad. 405 : A.I.R (29) 1942 Mad. 146 Authority relied on by appellant for the proposition that an endorsement may be read as an acknowledgement under Section 19. The Court considered the decision but held Ex. P-1(b) did not carry language sufficient to imply further liability; it rejected the appellant's reliance on this case for Ex. P-1(b).
Bamshah v. Lalohand (Ramshah v. Lalchand), 21 Lah. 470 : A.I.R (27) 1940 P.C. 63 Privy Council authority that "open payments" were ineffective to save limitation under Section 20 (pre-amendment). The Court acknowledged that under the unamended Section 20 the endorsement would be insufficient; this decision formed part of the background for assessing the effect of the 1942 amendment.
Baleswar v. Latafat, 24 Pat. 249 : A.I.R (32) 1945 Pat. 368 Patna Division Bench decision relied on by appellant to support that the amending Act should be applied and could affect previously-made payments/endorsements. The Court expressly refused to follow this decision and the other Patna decisions that adopted the same view.
Sarab Devaprasad v. Dwarka Prasad, A.I.R (33) 1946 Pat. 59 : 219 I.C. 169 Another Patna Division Bench decision in the same line as Baleswar v. Latafat. The Court declined to follow this decision.
Jagadish Prasad v. Saligram, A.I.R (33) 1946 Pat. 60 : 24 Pat. 391 Third Patna Division Bench decision relied on by appellant. The Court declined to follow this decision.
Kunhilal v. Gobina Krishna, 33 All. 356 : 38 I.A. 87 P.C. Authority cited for the principle that an amending Act cannot resurrect claims already extinguished unless it expressly provides for revival. The Court relied on this principle to hold that the 1942 amendment cannot revive a claim already barred before its coming into force.
Sachindranath Boy v. Maharaj Bahadur Singh, 49 Cal. 203 : A.I.R (9) 1922 P.C. 187 Supporting authority for the same principle regarding non-revival by subsequent amendment without express provision. Applied by the Court in support of the conclusion that the amending Act could not resurrect a previously barred remedy.
Rammayya v. Lakshmayya, I.L.R (1943) Mad. 1 : A.I.R (29) 1942 P.C. 54 Authority cited as relevant to the question of revival/retrospective application of limitation statutes. Relied upon by the Court to support the proposition that an amending Act does not revive a remedy already barred unless expressly stated.
Vaidhyalinga Mudahar v. Srirangathanni, 48 Mad. 883 : A.I.R (12) 1925 P.C. 249 Another authority supporting the Court's view on the effect of amendments on previously barred remedies. Used by the Court to reinforce its conclusion that the 1942 amendment cannot revive extinguished rights absent express provision.
Soniram v. Kanhaiyalal, 35 All. 227 : 40 I.A. 74 (Privy Council) Privy Council decision discussing which law of limitation applies when a new Limitation Act comes into force. The Court examined this case and distinguished it on its facts: in Soniram the right had not already become barred under the prior Act, so it did not support the Patna decisions' broader conclusion.
Mohesh Lal v. Busumt Kumaree, 6 Cal. 340 : 7 C.L.R 121 Old case cited as holding that a new mode of interrupting limitation might revive debts barred before the new Act. The Court noted such older authorities exist but rejected their applicability as a correct general rule for the present case.
Vaha Thamburatt v. Veera Rayan, 1 Mad. 228 Another old case of similar purport (revival under new law). Not accepted as controlling; the Court held the correct view is that revival does not occur absent express provision.
Teagaraya Mudali v. Mariappa Pillai, 1 Mad. 264 Case cited by appellant's counsel but where the remedy had not become barred when the later Act came into force. The Court treated this case as distinguishable on its facts and not supporting appellant's position.
Avud nammal v. Amhasankar, 1944-1 M.L.J 347 : A.I.R (31) 1944 Mad. 398 Single-judge decision of this Court relied on by respondents concluding that amendment could not revive a long-barred claim. The Court preferred and followed this decision in reaching its conclusion.
S. Venkatapayya v. Y. Venkatapayya, 1945-2 M.L.J 405 : A.I.R (33) 1946 Mad. 72 Another single-judge decision of this Court with the same result as Avud nammal. The Court preferred and followed this decision in preference to the Patna Division Bench decisions.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded in two main analytical steps.

  1. Interpretation of Ex. P-1(b): The Court examined the endorsement language, including the Tamil phrase “(sellu vaithadu).” It held that a mere written endorsement of a payment cannot be read as an acknowledgment of liability under Section 19 of the Limitation Act unless the endorsement, without straining its language, implies not only that a payment was made but also an implied admission that a further sum remained due. The Court found nothing in Ex. P-1(b) to suggest that any further sum was due. The phrase means “paid and endorsed” (i.e., an open receipt), not “paid towards” a debt. Accordingly, Ex. P-1(b) cannot be construed as an acknowledgment of liability.
  2. Effect of Act XVI of 1942 (amendment to Section 20): The Court acknowledged that the amending Act introduced a new mode of interrupting the running of time and that, as amended, the endorsement in question would have sufficed to save limitation. It then addressed whether the amended provision could be applied to revive a remedy already barred under the pre-1942 law. The Court rejected the appellant's contention that all procedural amendments are automatically retrospective so long as the amended law is in force at the time of institution. The Court held that the general rule that a suit is governed by the Limitation Act in force when it is instituted is subject to the condition that the substantive right sought to be enforced had not already been extinguished under the previous law. Where a right of action had already become barred under the Limitation Act of 1908 (as it stood before 1942), the amending Act cannot be invoked to resurrect the time-barred claim unless the Amending Act expressly provides for such revival.

In reaching this conclusion the Court critically examined and distinguished the Patna Division Bench decisions relied upon by the appellant (which held otherwise), noting that those decisions purported to rely on Soniram v. Kanhaiyalal but that the facts of Soniram were different (the right there had not become barred under the earlier Act). The Court also noted and considered older authorities that reportedly held the contrary view, but concluded that the correct principle is that revival by amendment does not occur absent express statutory provision. The Court referenced earlier Privy Council and High Court authorities in support of this principle and emphasised Section 3 of the Limitation Act as mandatory in requiring dismissal of suits on barred claims.

Holding and Implications

Holding: APPEAL DISMISSED.

Immediate consequences:

  • The Court dismissed the appellant's second appeal with costs.
  • No leave to appeal was granted.

Broader legal implication as stated by the Court:

  • The Court held that an endorsement which merely records payment (an "open payment") and does not, by its language, imply that further sums are due cannot be treated as an acknowledgement of liability under Section 19.
  • The Court held that an amendment to the Limitation Act introducing a new mode of interrupting the running of time will not serve to revive debts which, under the old law, had already become barred before the date of the amendment — unless the amending statute expressly provides for revival. The Court followed previous single-judge decisions of this Court on that point and declined to follow the Patna Division Bench decisions to the contrary.

The opinion therefore resolved the case by rejecting the appellant's textual construction of Ex. P-1(b) and by holding that Act XVI of 1942 does not revive a remedy already barred under the pre-1942 Limitation Act in the absence of express statutory revival.

    Mangapathi Naidu v. M.K Krishnaswami Naidu And Others .

    1. The plaintiff whose suit on a mortgage (Ex. P. 1) dated 6th June 1909, was decreed by the trial Court and dismissed by the lower appellate Court has preferred this second appeal. The only point argued before me is whether the suit is barred by limitation. The suit was instituted on 27th July 1944 to enforce the mortgage (Ex. P-1). There are two endorsements of payments on the mortgage bond, Ex. P-1(a) dated 30th July 1920 and Ex. P-1(b) dated 29th July 1932. It is common ground that Ex. P-1(a) is a valid acknowledgment of liability under Ex. P-1 and is a fresh starting point of limitation. Exhibit P. 1(b) is in these terms: “The amount of Rs. 100 paid and endorsed (sellu vaithadu) by us five parsons.”

    Then follow the names and signatures of the debtors. The appellant contends that the Tamil expression “(sellu vaithadu)” implies that there is an outstanding balance still due under the mortgage and that the endorsement, Ex. P-1(b), therefore, operates as an acknowledgment of liability under Section 19 of the Limitation Act as held in Ramayya v. Anjayya, I.L.R (1942) Mad. 405 : (A.I.R (29) 1942 Mad. 146) even if it be held to be an open payment and, therefore, inoperative to save limitation under Section 20 of the Limitation Act (before its amendment in 1942) as held by the Privy Council in Bamshah v. Lalohand, 21 Lah. 470 : (A.I.R (27) 1940 P.C 63). A mere endorsement in writing of a payment cannot serve as an acknowledgment of liability under Section 19 of the Limitation Act unless the Court is able, without overstraining the language, to read into the endorsement not only the fact of a payment but also an implied admission that a further sum is still due. I consider that the lower appellate Court was right in holding that Ex. P. 1(b) cannot be construed as an acknowledgment of liability, there being nothing in the endorsement suggesting that any further sum was due. The expression “(sellu vaithadu)” means “paid and endorsed” and not paid ‘towards’ a debt.

    2. The appellant next relies upon Act XVI[16] of 1942 which came into force on 30th March 1942 and which amended Section 20 of the Limitation Act. As is well known the object of the amendment was to supersede the decision of the Judicial Committee in Ramshah v. Lalchand, 21 Lah. 470 : (A.I.R (27) 1940 P.C 63), as regards the ineffectiveness of what were termed “open payments” to save limitation under Section 20 of the Limitation Act of 1908. It is true that the endorsement evidencing the payment Ex. P. 1(b) would be sufficient to save limitation under Section 20 of the Limitation Act as amended in 1942 but not under the unamended section. The contention of the learned advocate for the appellant is that the law of limitation is part of the processual law of the country, that amendments to the Limitation Act are retrospective in their effect and that the law of limitation applicable to the suit is the law in force at the time it is instituted. According to him, Act XVI [16] of 1942 would, therefore, apply to the present case and the effect of Ex. P-1 has to be decided only on the language of Section 20 of the Limitation Act as amended in 1942. To support the last contention three decisions of Division Benches of the Patna High Court in Baleswar v. Latafat, 24 Pat 249 : (AIR (32) 1945 Pat 368), Sarab Devaprasad v. Dwarka Prasad, A.I.R (33) 1946 Pat. 59 : (219 I.C 169) and Jagadish Prasad v. Saligram, A.I.R (33) 1946 Pat. 60 : (24 Pat. 391) are cited. The first of these cases has been followed in the other two decisions and they are all in favour of the appellant. I am, however, with all respect, unable to follow them. It is true that a suit is governed by the provisions of the Limitation Act in force when it is instituted, but this rule has not the sweeping effect attributed to it by the learned Judges of the Patna High Court. It is subject to the condition that the right sought to be enforced had not already been extinguished under the law as it previously stood. Where, as in this case, the right of action on the mortgage had already become barred under the Limitation Act of 1908, as it stood before 1942, the amending Act cannot be invoked far resurrecting and reviving the time barred claim, unless in the Amending Act it is expressly so stated. See Kunhilal v. Gobina Krishna, 33 All. 356 : (38 I.A 87 P.C), Sachindranath Boy v. Maharaj Bahadur Singh, 49 cal. 203:(A.I.R (9) 1922 P.C 187), Rammayya v. Lakshmayya, I.L.R (1943) Mad. 1 : (A.I.R (29) 1942 P.C 54) and Vaidhyalinga Mudahar v. Srirangathanni, 48 Mad. 883 : (A.I.R (12) 1925 P.C 249). The learned Judges of the Patna High Court purported to rely on the decision of the Privy Council in Soniram v. Kanhaiyalal, 35 All. 227 : (40 I.A 74) in aid of their conclusion. But it will be found on an examination of the facts of that case that when the Limitation Act of 1877 came into force, the right of the mortgagor's representatives to redeem the mortgage of 1842 had not become barred under the Limitation Act of 1859 and, therefore, it was held that the Act of 1877 applied to the enforcement of rights that were existing and alive when that Act came into force. Their Lordships held that the right of redemption was barred under the Act of 1877. In so holding the Privy Council approved of the High Court's observation that the law of limitation applicable to a suit or proceeding was the law in force at the date of the institution of the suit or proceeding unless there was a distinct provision to the contrary in the Act. This decision, in my opinion, affords no basis for the conclusion reached by the learned Judges of the Patna High Court that a claim barred before the Limitation Act was amended Could be enforced after the amendment of the Act taking advantage of the provisions in the Amending Act when the latter does not expressly provide for such revival. The observation in the first of the three Patna cases above cited that it is only in the case of title to property that there is an extinguishment of the right by lapse of time under Section 28 of the Limitation Act and that this principle of extinctive prescription does not apply to debts may be true-It is on this basis that the debtor who pays a time barred debt or executes a fresh document promising to pay a time barred debt cannot thereafter recall the payment or repudiate the promise on the ground of want of consideration, see Section 25 of the Contract Act. Sections 60 and 61. Contract Act allow the appropriation of payments, under certain circumstances, to the discharge of time barred debts. It is also true that a Hindu father can renew time barred debts so as to bind the interests of his sons in joint family properties. At the same time it must be remembered that a right in respect of which the remedy is lost is not a right that is enforceable by our Courts and Section 3 of the Limitation Act is mandatory and compels the Court to dismiss a suit on a barred claim.

    3. By the amending Act of 1942, the Legislature introduced a new method of interrupting the running of time. The Act may operate retrospectively upon payments and endorsements made before it came into force, though such payments and endorsements were of no avail at the date when they were made, but such a mode of interrupting the running of time will not serve to revive debts, which, according to the provisions of the old law, had already become barred before the date of the amendment. There are some old cases which hold that even if the debt had already become barred before the new Act came into force the new method of interrupting the running of time would avail to revive debts barred before the new Act came into force, Mohesh Lal v. Busumt Kumaree, 6 Cal. 340 : (7 C.L.R 121), Vaha Thamburatt v. Veera Rayan, 1 Mad. 228. The learned counsel for the appellant also cited the decision in Teagaraya Mudali v. Mariappa Pillai, 1 Mad. 264, in support of the above proposition, but in that case though limitation had commenced to run under Act XIV[14] of 1859, the remedy had not become barred on the date when Act IX[9] of 1871 came into force. I am of the opinion that the correct view is that a remedy by suit barred under the old law cannot be revived by the new enactment enlarging the period of limitation or providing a new mode of interrupting the running of time unless the later enactment expressly so provides. The decisions of the Judicial Committee already cited recognise this principle. For these reasons I am unable to agree with the decisions of the Patna High Court on which reliance has been placed by the appellant.

    4. The learned advocate for the respondents cites two decisions of single Judges of this Court in Avud nammal v. Amhasankar, 1944-1 M.L.J 347 : (A.I.R (31) 1944 Mad. 398) and S. Venkatapayya v. Y. Venkatapayya, 1945-2 M.L.J 405 : (A.I.R (33) 1946 Mad. 72) as con eluding the point in his favour. The appellant, however, seeks to distinguish these cases on the ground that the amending Act of 1942 had not come into force at the time when the suit was instituted in those cases and that in the present case, the Act was in force at the time of the institution of the suit.

    5. In the latter case it was stated by Rajamannar J. (as he then was),

    “This amendment was made long after the institution of the suit and it cannot have the result of reviving what was a barred and unenforceable claim at that time.”

    From this passage, it is sought to be argued that if the suit in that case had been instituted after the Act came into force, the decision would have been different. I am unable to agree with this interpretation of the learned Judge's judgment. The real basis of the two decisions of this Court above cited was that the debt sought to be realized became unenforceable long before the amending Act came into force and that the amendment could not operate retrospectively so as to revive a barred debt.

    6. For these reasons, I would follow the two decisions of this Court in preference to those of the Patna High Court and dismiss this appeal with costs.

    7. No leave.

    C.R.K/D.B

    8. Appeal dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Mangapathi Naidu v. M.K Krishnaswami Naidu And Others .
    (Aug 19, 1949)