Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — Pendse, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant was employed by Forbes Forbes Campbelle & Co. Pvt. Ltd. and, while travelling to work in a bus engaged by the employer, was injured in a motor accident involving vehicle No. MRR 7601 on January 28, 1979. The appellant's employer's establishment was covered by the Employees' State Insurance Act, and the appellant had received benefits under that Act for the employment injury.

The appellant filed a claim for damages before the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal for Greater Bombay. The employer and the owner of the bus resisted the claim on the ground that it was barred by section 53 of the Employees' State Insurance Act. The 3rd Additional Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal upheld that objection by order dated January 25, 1985 and dismissed the application for damages. This First Appeal challenges the Tribunal's dismissal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a claim for damages arising from an employment injury is barred by section 53 of the Employees' State Insurance Act when the employee has received benefits under that Act.
  2. Whether the bar under section 53 applies only to claims against the employer or also extends to claims against other persons (for example, the owner of a vehicle engaged by the employer).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellant's counsel (Ms. Sarnaik) argued that the claim was not against the employer but against the owner of the bus who had contracted with the employer to convey workers; therefore, section 53, at most, could bar claims against the employer but not against other persons.
  • The counsel reiterated contentions advanced in the companion appeal (Associated Electrical Agencies v. Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation).

Respondents' Arguments

  • The employer and the bus owner resisted the claim on the ground that it was barred by section 53 of the Employees' State Insurance Act.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Associated Electrical Agencies v. Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation, 1994 ACJ 1078 (Bombay) Reasons recorded in that judgment were relied upon by the court to address the legal contentions raised in this appeal. The court applied the reasoning recorded in that companion judgment to conclude that the appellant's contentions cannot be accepted, and to hold that the appeal must fail.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court relied on the reasoning recorded in a companion judgment delivered the same day (Associated Electrical Agencies v. Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation). Applying that reasoning, the court concluded:

  • The bar under section 53 of the Employees' State Insurance Act is not confined to claims against the employer but extends to claims against any other person.
  • The claim before the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal was made in respect of an employment injury for which benefits under the Employees' State Insurance Act had been received by the appellant; accordingly, any claim for compensation or damages in respect of that employment injury is not permissible where the statutory benefits are available.
  • Given these legal conclusions, the court found no infirmity in the Tribunal's order dated January 25, 1985 dismissing the application for damages.

Holding and Implications

Appeal dismissed.

Direct consequences: The order of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal dismissing the appellant's claim is upheld. The court recorded that there will be no order as to costs. The opinion does not purport to establish a new principle beyond affirming the application of section 53 (as explained in the companion judgment) to bar claims for employment injuries where Employees' State Insurance Act benefits are available.

    Ganpat Pratap Bhogle v. H.L Roche And Others

    Pendse, J.:— This appeal is companion to Original Side Appeal No. 676 of 1993 in Associated Electrical Agencies v. Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation, 1994 ACJ 1078 (Bombay), in which today we have delivered judgment. For the reasons recorded in that judgment, this appeal must fail.

    2. The appellant in this case was employed in Forbes Forbes Campbelle & Co. Pvt. Ltd. and was proceeding to the place of work in a bus engaged by the employer. Motor vehicle bearing No. MRR 7601 met with an accident on January 28, 1979, causing injuries to the appellant.

    3. It is not in dispute that the establishment where the appellant was working is covered by the provisions of Employees' State Insurance Act. It is equally not in dispute that the appellant has received the benefits available under Employees' State Insurance Act in respect of the employment injury suffered.

    4. The appellant filed claim for damages before Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal for Greater Bombay in respect of the injury suffered. The application was resisted by the employer and the owner of the bus which met with the accident on the ground that the claim was barred under section 53 of Employees' State Insurance Act. The objection was upheld by 3rd Additional Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal by order dated January 25, 1985 and the application for damages was dismissed. The order of dismissal has given rise to this First Appeal.

    5. Ms. Sarnaik, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant, reiterated the contentions urged in the companion appeal in which today we have delivered judgment [Associated Electrical Agencies v. Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation, 1994 ACJ 1078 (Bombay)]. For the reasons recorded in that judgment, the contentions cannot be accepted. The learned counsel urged that the claim filed by the employee is not against the employer but against the owner of the bus, who had entered into a contract with the employer for carrying the workers to the place of work. It was urged that section 53, at the most, can create a bar to file a claim against the employer but not against any other person. The submission is devoid of any merit. The bar under section 53 applies not only against the employer but also against any other person. Apart from this consideration, the claim is made not against any individual but in respect of the employment injury suffered. Any claim for compensation or damages in respect of employment injury is not permissible when the benefit is available under the provisions of Employees' State Insurance Act. In our judgment, the order passed by the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal does not suffer from any infirmity and the appeal must fail.

    6. Accordingly, appeal is dismissed but there will be no order as to costs.

    7. Appeal dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ganpat Pratap Bhogle v. H.L Roche And Others
    (Aug 4, 1994)