Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Workmen's Compensation Act by substitution of S. 53 of Employees' State Insurance Act,
  • EMPLOYEES STATE INSURANCE ACT 1948
  • SECTION 46 EMPLOYEES STATE INSURANCE ACT
  • SECTION 61 EMPLOYEES STATE INSURANCE ACT
  • SECTION 53 EMPLOYEES STATE INSURANCE ACT
  • provisions of S. 22(2) of the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923,
  • provisions of S. 53 of the Employees' State Insurance Act.
  • S. 53 of the Employees' State Insurance Act No. 44 of 1966,
  • Employees State Insurance (Central) Rules, 1950. Rule 54
  • provisions of S. 53 of Employees' State Insurance Act,
  • Motor Vehicles Act or Workmen's Compensation Act
  • SECTION 38 EMPLOYEES STATE INSURANCE ACT
  • provisions of the Workmen's Compensation Act
  • provisions of Workmen's Compensation Act.13.
  • S. 53 of the Employees' State Insurance Act
  • S. 51 of the Employees' State Insurance Act
  • S. 96 of the Employees' State Insurance Act,
  • provisions of Workmen's Compensation Act
  • S. 30 of the Workmen's Compensation Act.
  • S. 2(8) of Employees' State Insurance Act.
  • S. 53 of Employees' State Insurance Act.
  • S. 30 of Workmen's Compensation Act.
  • Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923,
  • provisions of Chap. II. Section 4
  • Workmen's Compensation Act
  • MOTOR VEHICLES ACT
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Workmen's Compensation Act by substitution of S. 53 of Employees' State Insurance Act,
  • EMPLOYEES STATE INSURANCE ACT 1948
  • SECTION 46 EMPLOYEES STATE INSURANCE ACT
  • SECTION 61 EMPLOYEES STATE INSURANCE ACT
  • SECTION 53 EMPLOYEES STATE INSURANCE ACT
  • provisions of S. 22(2) of the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923,
  • provisions of S. 53 of the Employees' State Insurance Act.
  • S. 53 of the Employees' State Insurance Act No. 44 of 1966,
  • Employees State Insurance (Central) Rules, 1950. Rule 54
  • provisions of S. 53 of Employees' State Insurance Act,
  • Motor Vehicles Act or Workmen's Compensation Act
  • SECTION 38 EMPLOYEES STATE INSURANCE ACT
  • provisions of the Workmen's Compensation Act
  • provisions of Workmen's Compensation Act.13.
  • S. 53 of the Employees' State Insurance Act
  • S. 51 of the Employees' State Insurance Act
  • S. 96 of the Employees' State Insurance Act,
  • provisions of Workmen's Compensation Act
  • S. 30 of the Workmen's Compensation Act.
  • S. 2(8) of Employees' State Insurance Act.
  • S. 53 of Employees' State Insurance Act.
  • S. 30 of Workmen's Compensation Act.
  • Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923,
  • provisions of Chap. II. Section 4
  • Workmen's Compensation Act
  • MOTOR VEHICLES ACT
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Associated Electrical Agencies, a partnership engaged in electronic goods, employed Respondent 2 as a television repair worker on a monthly salary of Rs. 1,000. On 17 July 1987, Respondent 2 sustained a severe injury to his left eye caused by a bursting component during repair work, resulting in loss of vision in that eye. Respondent 2, aged 27 at the time, was covered under the Employees' State Insurance Act (ESI Act). He received monthly disablement benefits from the Employees' State Insurance Corporation as per the Act.

Respondent 2 subsequently served notice on the appellant claiming compensation of Rs. 7 lakhs under the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923 (WCA), asserting the injury arose in the course of employment. An application was filed before the Workmen's Compensation Commissioner for compensation and penalties. The appellant challenged the maintainability of this application based on Section 53 of the ESI Act, which bars claims for compensation under other laws if benefits are received under the ESI Act.

The Commissioner overruled the objection relying on a Kerala High Court Full Bench decision and allowed the application to proceed. The appellant filed a writ petition which was summarily dismissed by a Single Judge on the ground of availability of an alternate remedy by way of appeal under the WCA. The present appeal challenges these orders and raises important questions regarding the scope and constitutionality of Section 53 of the ESI Act.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Section 53 of the Employees' State Insurance Act bars an insured employee from claiming compensation or damages under the Workmen's Compensation Act or any other law in respect of employment injury.
  2. Whether the Parliament had legislative competence to enact Section 53 of the Employees' State Insurance Act.
  3. Whether Section 53 violates the fundamental rights guaranteed under Article 14 of the Constitution of India by creating discrimination among employees.
  4. The maintainability of an application for compensation under the Workmen's Compensation Act when benefits are already received under the Employees' State Insurance Act.

Arguments of the Parties

Respondent 2's Arguments

  • The right to claim compensation under the Workmen's Compensation Act arises independently of contractual liability and cannot be barred by Section 53 of the ESI Act.
  • The claim for compensation or damages flows from common law tort principles and is distinct from benefits under the ESI Act.
  • The substitution of Section 53 unjustly deprives employees of their right to claim compensation under the Workmen's Compensation Act.
  • The bar under Section 53 is unreasonable and violates Article 14 of the Constitution by discriminating against employees earning wages up to Rs. 3,000 per month.

Appellant's Arguments

  • Once an establishment is covered by the ESI Act and contributions are compulsorily made, neither employer nor employee can claim compensation or damages under the Workmen's Compensation Act or any other law.
  • The bar under Section 53 is absolute and covers every obligation to pay compensation or damages under any law.
  • The benefits under the ESI Act are substantial and provide better social security, including medical assistance and periodical payments, compared to the lump sum compensation under the Workmen's Compensation Act.
  • The Parliament had legislative competence to enact Section 53 to prevent double benefits and streamline social security benefits for employees.
  • The classification based on wage limits under the ESI Act is reasonable and does not violate Article 14, as employees earning above Rs. 3,000 are not covered under the ESI Act and form a distinct class.
  • The application before the Workmen's Compensation Commissioner was not maintainable due to the bar under Section 53.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Regional Director, Employees' State Insurance Corporation v. Francis De Costa [1993 — I L.L.N 6] Consideration of whether injury while proceeding to work is an employment injury under Section 2(8) of ESI Act. Court noted that the observations were in a different context and did not directly address the bar under Section 53 of ESI Act; hence reliance on this precedent was limited.
Mangalamma v. Express Newspapers Ltd. [A.I.R 1982 Mad. 223] Section 53 bars claims under Motor Vehicles Act or Workmen's Compensation Act once ESI benefits are received. Supported the view that Section 53 creates an absolute bar on claims outside ESI Act.
K.S Vasantha v. Karnataka State Road Transport Corporation [1982 (60) F.J.R 118] Application of Section 53 bar on claims under other statutes. Reinforced that claims under Workmen's Compensation Act are barred when ESI benefits are received.
Lakshmi Oil Mills, Ambala City v. Thakur Dass [1971 (41) F.J.R 667] Interpretation of Section 53 barring claims outside ESI Act. Affirmed the absolute nature of the bar under Section 53.
Smt. Annapurna v. General Manager, Karnataka State Road Transport Corporation, Bangalore [1984 L.&I.C 1355] Effect of Section 53 on claims under Workmen's Compensation Act and other laws. Confirmed that Section 53 bars claims under other laws once ESI benefits are claimed.
Kerala High Court Full Bench in P. Ashokan v. Western India Plywoods Ltd. [1987 — I L.L.N 333] Held that Section 53 does not bar claims under Workmen's Compensation Act. Court disagreed with this view, finding it inconsistent with the clear and unambiguous language of Section 53.
Kerala High Court Division Bench in Abad Fisheries v. Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation [1985 — I L.L.N 358] Interpretation of Section 53 and its effect on Workmen's Compensation claims. Referenced in discussion of Full Bench decisions; ultimately the court rejected the reasoning that Section 53 does not bar claims.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by examining the plain language of Section 53 of the Employees' State Insurance Act, which unequivocally bars an insured person or their dependants from claiming compensation or damages under the Workmen's Compensation Act or any other law in respect of an employment injury. The Court found that the bar is absolute and not limited to contractual obligations but extends to all claims under any law.

The Court rejected Respondent 2's contention that claims under the Workmen's Compensation Act arise independently and are not covered by the ESI Act. It emphasized the express legislative intent to avoid double benefits by employees who are insured under the ESI Act, as reflected in the use of the phrase "any other law for the time being in force or otherwise."

The Court analyzed the legislative purpose behind the amendment substituting Section 53, noting that the Parliament aimed to simplify administration, extend coverage, and provide better social security benefits including periodical payments and medical assistance, which are absent under the Workmen's Compensation Act.

The Court also addressed the constitutional challenge under Article 14, rejecting the argument that the wage-based classification under the ESI Act is discriminatory. It held that employees earning above Rs. 3,000 per month form a distinct class not covered by the ESI Act, and the classification is reasonable to provide insurance coverage to employees most in need.

Regarding the procedural issue, the Court found that the Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation lacked jurisdiction to entertain the application for compensation as it was barred by Section 53. The Single Judge's dismissal of the writ petition for want of alternate remedy was incorrect because the question was about jurisdiction, not merely the merits of an appeal.

The Court disapproved the Kerala High Court Full Bench decision that took a liberal interpretation of Section 53 to allow claims under the Workmen's Compensation Act, stating that the clear and unambiguous statutory language must prevail over considerations of benevolent legislation.

Holding and Implications

The Court held that Section 53 of the Employees' State Insurance Act bars an insured employee from claiming compensation or damages under the Workmen's Compensation Act or any other law once benefits under the ESI Act have been received.

The Court further held that the Parliament had legislative competence to enact Section 53 and that the provision does not violate Article 14 of the Constitution. The application filed by Respondent 2 before the Workmen's Compensation Commissioner was not maintainable and is liable to be dismissed.

Accordingly, the appeal was allowed, the orders of the Single Judge and the Commissioner were set aside, and Respondent 2's compensation application was dismissed. No costs were awarded.

This decision clarifies the exclusivity of benefits under the ESI Act for insured employees and confirms that claims under the Workmen's Compensation Act are barred in such cases. It reinforces the legislative scheme aimed at providing a consolidated social security framework and prevents double recovery by employees.

    Associated Electrical Agencies, Bombay v. (1) Commissioner For Workmen'S Compensation And Judge, Third Labour Court, Bombay

    Pendse, J.:— Associated Electrical Agencies is a partnership concern carrying on business in electronic goods. Respondent 2 was employed for carrying out repairs of television sets on a monthly salary of Rs. 1,000. On 17 July, 1987, while carrying out repairs of a television set, a component of the set burst resulting into injury to the face of respondent 2. Respondent 2 lost vision of the left eye. Respondent 2, at the time of the incident, was 27 years old.

    2. The Legislature enacted the Employees' State Insurance Act, 1948 (for short the Employees' State Insurance Act) to provide for certain benefits to employees in case of sickness, maternity in case of female employees, employment injury and to make provision for certain other matters in relation thereto. The Employees' State Insurance Act came into force on 19 April, 1948. The provisions of the Act apply to all the factories other than seasonal factories and the State Government, with the approval of the Central Government, is authorised to make the provisions of the Act applicable to any other establishment or class of establishments. Section 38 of the Employees' State Insurance Act provides that all employees in factories or establishments to which the Act applies shall be insured in the manner provided by the Act. Section 39 provides that the contribution payable in respect of an employee shall comprise contribution payable by the employer and contribution payable by the employee and it shall be paid to the corporation created under the Act. The employers are required to pay contribution at the rate of 4 per cent of the total wages and the employees are required to pay at the rate of 1.5 per cent of the total monthly wages. Failure to pay contribution leads to levy of damages and prosecution and once the establishment is covered by the provisions of the Employees' State Insurance Act, then there is no option either to the employer or to the employee to claim exemption from contribution. Chapter. V of the Act deals with the benefits available to the insured persons or their dependents, as the case may be. Section 46(1)(c) of the Act provides for benefit of periodical payments to an insured person suffering from disablement as a result of an employment injury sustained. The expression “employment injury” is defined under S. 2(8) and means:

    “a personal injury to an employee caused by accident or an occupational disease arising out of and in the course of his employment, being an insurable employment, whether the accident occur or the occupational disease is contracted within or outside the territorial limits of India.”

    The expression “insured person” is defined under S. 2(14) and means:

    “a person who is or was an employee in respect of whom contributions are or were payable under the Act.”

    Section 51 of the Act, inter alia, sets out that a person who sustains permanent disablement, whether total or partial, shall be entitled to periodical payment at such rate and for such period and subject to such conditions as may be prescribed by the Central Government.

    3. In exercise of powers conferred under S. 96 of the Employees' State Insurance Act, the Government has framed rules known as the Employees State Insurance (Central) Rules, 1950. Rule 54 classifies the employees into 11 categories depending upon the quantum of daily wages drawn by the employees. The workers covered by these categories are provided standard benefiting in terms of rupees set out in the rules. Second Schedule to the Act sets out description of various kinds of injuries and the percentages of loss or of incapacity. Item (31) in the Second Schedule refers to loss of one eye, without complications, the other being normal, and the percentage of loss of earning capacity is prescribed at 40 per cent.

    4. The establishment of the appellant is covered by the provisions of the Employees' State Insurance Act. Respondent 2, who is an insured person, approached the Corporation for receipt of benefits on account of injury suffered on 17 July, 1987. It is not in dispute that the Corporation granted the benefit as claimed by respondent 2 and the respondent 2 is paid a sum of Rs. 289.90 per month.

    5. On 4 September, 1991, respondent 2 served notice upon the appellant claiming that the injury was caused during the course of employment and respondent 2 is entitled to claim compensation for the loss of vision of one eye. Respondent 2 demanded a sum of Rs. 7 lakhs and threatened to adopt appropriate proceedings in case the amount so demanded was not paid within seven days of the receipt of the notice. The notice was followed by Application No. 108.C-18 of 1992 before the Workmen' Compensation Commissioner at Bombay. The application was filed in accordance with provisions of S. 22(2) of the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923, and the sum demanded was Rs. 1,06,785 with penalty, penal interest and costs.

    6. On 27 November, 1992, the appellant-company appeared before the Commissioner and filed an application, inter alia, claiming that the application filed by respondent 2 was not maintainable in view of provisions of S. 53 of the Employees' State Insurance Act. The Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation, by order, dated 29 April, 1993 passed below Exhibit C5, overruled the objection about maintainability of the application filed by respondent 2 by holding that the Workmen's Compensation Act is a beneficial and social piece of legislation and placing reliance upon a Full Bench decision of Kerala High Court. The appellant, thereupon, approached this Court by filing Writ Petition No. 1406 of 1993 under Art. 226 of the Constitution of India, but the learned Single Judge, by order, dated 2 August, 1993, summarily dismissed the writ petition by observing that there is an alternate remedy by way of first appeal as provided under S. 30 of the Workmen's Compensation Act. The summary rejection of the petition has given rise to the present appeal.

    7. This appeal was set down for hearing along with a group of other appeals where validity of S. 53 of the Employees' State Insurance Act was challenged. In some of the appeals, notice was issued to the Attorney-General as vires of a Central Legislation was under challenge. As the question required to be determined in this appeal is of considerable importance, the learned Advocate-General was requested to assist the Court. We must express our appreciation for the assistance rendered by the learned Advocate-General.

    8. Section 53 of Employees' State Insurance Act, prior to its amendment, inter alia, read as follows:

    “53. Disablement and dependent's benefits.— When an insured person is or his dependants are entitled to receive or recover, whether from the employer of the insured person or from any other person, any compensation or damages under the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923, or otherwise, in respect of an employment injury sustained by the insured person as an employee under this Act, then the following provisions shall apply, namely:

    (1) The insured person shall, in lieu of such compensation or damages, receive the disablement benefit provided by this Act, (but subject otherwise to the conditions specified in the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923) from the Corporation and not from any employer or other person.

    (ii)…………………..

    (iii)…………………….

    (iv) ……………………..

    (v) Save as modified by this Act the obligations and liabilities imposed on an employer by the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923, shall continue to apply to him.”

    The Parliament substituted S. 53 of the Employees' State Insurance Act No. 44 of 1966, with effect from 28 January, 1968 and the substituted section reads as follows:

    “53. An insured person or his dependants shall not be entitled to receive or recover, whether from the employer of the insured person or from any other person, any compensation or damages under the. Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923, or any other law for the time being in force or otherwise, in respect of an employment injury sustained by the insured person as an employee under this Act.”

    Section 61 of the Act reads as follows:

    “61. When a person is entitled to any of the benefits provided by this Act, he shall not be entitled to receive any similar benefit admissible under the provisions of any other enactment.”

    The controversy in this appeal is whether S. 53 of the Employees' State Insurance Act deprives an employee from seeking compensation or damages under the Workmen's Compensation Act and, if so, whether the Parliament had legislative competency to enact S. 53 of Employees' State Insurance Act. It is also claimed that even if the Parliament had legislative competence, still this section should be struck down as being violative of fundamental rights guarenteed under Art. 14 of the Constitution of India. The gravamen of the complaint made on behalf of respondent 2 is that the right conferred upon the workman to seek compensation under the Workmen's Compensation Act cannot be taken away by the subsequent legislation enacted as a measure of social security. It was claimed that the right to seek compensation or damages flows from common law for the tortious wrong done to the employee and the liability flowing from such wrong does not amount to any of the benefits provided by the Employees' State Insurance Act. The contention of the appellant, on the other hand, is that once the establishment is covered by the provisions of the Employees' State Insurance Act, then there is no option either to the employer or to the employee to decline to make contribution and once the establishment is covered, then the employee is not entitled to receive, whether from the employer or from any other person, any compensation or damages under the Workmen's Compensation Act or any other law for the time being in force or otherwise. In view of these rival contentions, the first question, which requires determination, is the true ambit and scope of S. 53 of the Employees' State Insurance Act.

    9. A plain reading of S. 53 makes it clear that the right to seek compensation or damages by an insured person in respect of an employment injury under any law including Workmen's Compensation Act is taken away. The bar created under S. 53 is absolute. It is not in dispute that respondent 2 is an insured person and has secured disablement benefit under S. 51 of the Employees' State Insurance Act in respect of the employment injury. The appellant claims that the application filed by respondent 2 to seek compensation under the Workmen's Compensation Act is clearly barred in view of S. 53 of the Employees' State Insurance Act. The contention was controverted on behalf of respondent 2 by claiming that the claim for compensation made by respondent 2 under Workmen's Compensation Act is de hors the contractual liability and such claim cannot be defeated by reference to the bar under S. 53 of the Employees' State Insurance Act. The submission cannot be accepted, because the bar created under S. 53 is not limited only to contractual obligation but covers every obligation to pay compensation or damages under any law including Workmen's Compensation Act. The use of the expression “any other law for the time being in force or otherwise” clearly sets out the intention of the Parliament that the insured person is not entitled to any claim in respect of an employment injury beyond what is provided under Employees' State Insurance Act. A reference was made to some of the observations in the decision of the Supreme Court reported in Regional Director, Employees' State Insurance Corporation v. Francis De Costa [1993 — I L.L.N 6], though it was very fairly stated that the observations were in different context. Indeed, the case before the Supreme Court was heard by Bench of two Judges and the Judges differed and the matter was directed to be placed before a larger Bench. The observations in Para. 46, at page 22 of the judgment of Justice Sri K. Ramaswamy are to the following effect:

    “….. The general law of tort or special law in Motor Vehicles Act or Workmen's Compensation Act may provide a remedy for damages. The coverage of insurance under the Act in an insured employment is in addition to but not in substitution of the above remedies and cannot on that account be denied to the employee. In K. Bharati Devi v. G.I.C.I [A.I.R 1988 A.P 361], the contention that the deceased contracted life insurance and, due to death in air accident, the appellant received compensation and the same should be set off and no double advantage of damages under the carriage by Air Act be given, was negatived.”

    The question before the Supreme Court was whether the injury caused by an accident on a public road while an employee was on his way to join duty can be held as arising out of or in the course of his employment within the meaning of S. 2(8) of Employees' State Insurance Act. The reliance on the observations in the decision of the Supreme Court is not accurate. The Supreme Court was not examining the bar under S. 53 of Employees' State Insurance Act and the observations were made in the context as to whether the injury received while proceeding towards the place of employment can be treated as an employment injury.

    10. It was urged on behalf of respondent 2 that the statement of objects and reasons for substituting S. 53 of Employees' State Insurance Act is silent as to the reason which prompted the Parliament to deprive the employees of the benefit under Workmen's Compensation Act. The counsel wondered why the right, which was available prior to of S. 53, was withdrawn when the object of Employees' State Insurance Act was to provide benefits to the employees in case of employment injury. The Advocate-General urged that assumption that such right was available prior to amendment is not accurate but even otherwise introduction of bar cannot be faulted. The reason for creating a bar under S. 53 of Employees' State Insurance Act is not difficult to find. The statement of objects and reasons, inter alia, sets out that the experience of the administration of the Act had disclosed certain difficulties in its working and the object of the amendment was to remove such difficulties and to make the administration of the Act simpler. The Amending Act provided for raising the wage limit for coverage of employees and widening the existing definition of the term “employee” to bring in administrative staff engaged in sale, distribution and other allied functions. The category of dependents was also widened and provision was made for grant of funeral benefit and the maternity benefits were enlarged. The counsel appearing on behalf of the Attorney-General tendered affidavit sworn by Deputy Regional Director, Employees' state Insurance Corporation, and the affidavit sets out that the present limit of coverage of the employees under Employees' State Insurance Act is of those employees whose wages per month are not more than Rs. 3,000. The affidavit further sets out that an employee who is drawing Rs. 1,000 as wages per month will be entitled to a permanent total disablement benefit in the sum of Rs. 840 per month whereas the employees drawing Rs. 2,000 per month and Rs. 3,000 per month would be entitled to Rs. 1,512 and Rs. 2,226 per month respectively. In addition, the employee, during the period from the date of sustaining injury and rejoining the employment, would be entitled to 50 per cent of the wages. An insured employee under the Act is also entitled to the medical assistance free of charge. The medical benefit is available even after the employee ceases to be in service on payment of sum of Rs. 10 per month. The object of the Parliament in enacting Employees' State Insurance Act was to provide insurance cover to the employees of the establishments registered under the Act. The Act demands contribution both from the employer and the employee and contribution is not optional but compulsory. Once the establishment is covered by the provisions of the Act, then the employer is liable to contribute both the employer's contribution and the employee's contribution by deduction from the wages payable. The object of the Parliament was to provide social security to an employee who suffers employment injury. The experience and the collective wisdom of the Legislature may have indicated that the benefits available under the Employees' State Insurance Act, are equal, if not better, than those available under Workmen's Compensation Act or any other law. It is true that the compensation or damages payable under the Workmen's Compensation Act is paid in a lump sum, but such a payment may not give long term benefits to the employee or to the dependents. The employee is also required to file application before the Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation and often that leads to considerable litigation requiring substantial expenses and which litigation is also time consuming. The Parliament, while creating bar under S. 53 of Employees' State Insurance Act, was entitled and justified in taking into consideration all these facets. The counsel for respondent 2 could not deny that the benefits available under Employees' State Insurance Act are substantial, but urged that the benefit of receiving compensation under Workmen's Compensation Act should be in addition to the benefit under the Employees' State Insurance Act. The Parliament, by substituting S. 53 of Employees' State Insurance Act, was obviously preventing the employee from seeking double benefit; one under Employees' State Insurance Act and the other under Workmen's Compensation Act. Once insurance cover is available to an employee and when the insurance premium is contributed substantially by the employer and partly by the employee, then the Legislature was justified in creating a bar for employees seeking benefit outside the benefits available under the Employees' State Insurance Act. Section 61 of Employees' State Insurance Act, therefore, specifically provides that when a person is entitled to any of the benefits provided by the Act, then he shall not be entitled to receive any similar benefits admissible under the provisions of any other enactment.

    11. The Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923, was enacted to provide for the payment by certain classes of employers to the workmen towards compensation for injury caused by accident. The Act came into force on 5 March, 1923 and S. 3 provides that when a personal injury is caused to a workman by accident arising out of or in the course of his employment, the employer shall be liable to pay compensation in accordance with the provisions of Chap. II. Section 4 sets out the amount of compensation payable and in respect of permanent total disablement resulting from the injury the amount payable is equal to 50 per cent of the monthly wages of the injured workman multiplied by the relevant factor, or an amount of Rs. 24,000, whichever is more. The explanation further provides that where the monthly wages of a workman exceed Rs. 1,000, then the monthly wages for determining the amount payable shall be deemed to be Rs. 1,000 only. In other words, the amount of compensation payable is to be calculated on the basis that the monthly wages are only Rs. 1,000. The compensation is payable in a lump sum and is available to the dependents only in the case of fatal accident. The Workmen's Compensation Act did not provide for any insurance coverage or periodical payments or medical benefits and which are obviously the additional and better features prescribed by the subsequent legislation, i.e, the Employees' State Insurance Act. The Parliament was fully conscious of the limited benefit available under the Workmen's Compensation Act and, consequently, Employees' State Insurance Act was enacted with a view to provide better social security to the employees and the dependents. Bearing this factor in mind, it is obvious that the Parliament had sound reasons for creating a bar for the employees to seek benefits under Workmen's Compensation Act or any other law other than Employees' State Insurance Act Section 46 of the Employees' State Insurance Act provides for payments to an insured person in case of sickness, to a female employee in case of confinement or miscarriage or sickness arising out of pregnancy and periodical payments to the dependents of an insured person in addition too the medical treatment. These benefits available under the insurance cover are enjoyed by an employee and, consequently, withdrawal of the advantage of seeking compensation under the Workmen's Compensation Act can, by no stretch of imagination, be said to be unreasonable or due to non-application of mind.

    12. Referencc was made to decisions Mangalamma v. Express Newspapers, Ltd. [A.I.R 1982 Mad. 223], K.S Vasantha v. Karnataka State Road Transport Corporation [1982 (60) F.J.R 118], Lakshmi Oil Mills, Ambala City v. Thakur Dass [1971 (41) F.J.R 667] and Smt. Annapurna v. General Manager, Karnataka State Road Transport Corporation, Bangalore [1984 L.&I.C 1355], were it was held that S. 53 bars claim made under Motor Vehicles Act or claim under the provisions of Workmen's Compensation Act.

    13. The discordant note was sounded by Full Bench decisions of Kerala High Court P. Ashokan v. Western India Plywoods, Ltd., Cannanore [1987 — I L.L.N 333]. Reference was made to the Full Bench as a Division Bench of the Kerala High Court, in a judgment reported in Abad Fisheries v. Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation [1985 — I L.L.N 358], had held that S. 53 of Employees' State Insurance Act bars claim under the Workmen's Compensation Act. In the case before the Full Bench, the employee had received benefit from the Employees' State Insurance Corporation. The employee then filed a suit for recovery of Rs. 1,50,000 and applied for leave to prosecute in forma pauperis. The application for prosecution was resisted on the ground that the employee had no cause of action and the suit was barred by virtue of S. 53 of Employees' State Insurance Act. The trial Judge rejected the contention, but refused leave on the ground that the employee had means to pay the Court fees. The employee carried an appeal before Kerala High Court and the question, which required determination, was whether the employee should be permitted to file suit in forma pauperis. ‘The Full Bench held that the employee had a cause of action. The Full Bench then observed that the legislation was undertaken in the background of expanding industrialisation and strongly emerging trade union organisation. After quoting the observations made by Dr. Ambedkar while introducing the provisions of Employees' State Insurance Act, the Full Bench observed that the Court has a positive role to play in relation to the interpretation of statutes and if a section yields two different interpretations, that which leads to an arbitrary or shockingly unreasonable result has to be eschewed. There cannot be any debate as to the accuracy of this observation. The Full Bench then observed that a restricted view of S. 53 should not be taken; otherwise the section is liable to be challenged as violative of fundamental rights. We are afraid we cannot subscribe to several observations made in the judgment and the conclusion reached. The Full Bench, with respect, has not considered various facets of the matter and proceeded to hold that the right to claim damages or compensation under the Workmen's Compensation Act is not barred, in face of clear-cut and unambiguous provisions of S. 53 of Employees' State Insurance Act, on consideration that the Act is a piece of benevolent legislation and should be construed liberally. It is undoubtedly true that the Act is a beneficial piece of legislation; but when the Parliament has enacted the provision, which is unambiguous and crystal clear and which is based on sound principle, then it is not permissible to bypass the bar created under S. 53 of Employees' State Insurance Act on considerations which are not germane to the interpretation of the section. We are, therefore, unable to share the view taken by the Full Bench of Kerala High Court.

    14. It was then contended on behalf of respondent 2 that the provisions of S. 53 should be struck down as the Parliament was not competent to enact the provision. It was urged that item (23) in the Concurrent List in the Seventh Schedule to the Constitution of India provides for subjects of social security and social insurance, employment and unemployment while item (24) deals with welfare of labour including conditions of work, provident funds, employers' liability, workmen's compensation, invalidity and old age pensions and maternity benefits. It was submitted that the Parliament was entitled to enact the provisions of Employees' State Insurance Act to confer social security and social insurance upon the employees, but it was not permissible for the Parliament, while doing so, to deprive the employees of a benefit available under the Workmen's Compensation Act. It was submitted that as the Parliament had withdrawn the benefit of Workmen's Compensation Act by substitution of S. 53 of Employees' State Insurance Act, the Parliament had transgressed the limits of legislative competence. It is impossible to accede to the submission. As mentioned hereinabove, the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923, provided benefits of a limited nature. The Parliament enacted Employees' State Insurance Act with the object of conferring several more benefits and while conferring those benefits, the Parliament provided that the employees, who are entitled to, the benefits under Employees' State Insurance Act, should not secure double benefit by reference to Workmen's Compensation Act. In other words, the provisions of Workmen's Compensation Act stand repealed qua the employers and the employees of the establishments which are covered by Employees' State Insurance Act. It is futile to suggest that the Parliament was not competent to repeal the provisions of the Workmen's Compensation Act in respect of the employees covered under Employees' State Insurance Act.

    15. It was then submitted that S. 53 of Employees' State Insurance Act should be struck down as violative of fundamental rights guaranteed under Art. 14 of the Constitution of India. The counsel submitted that the provisions of Employees' State Insurance Act are applicable only to those employees whose monthly wages are not in excess of Rs. 3,000 and, consequently, the employees who are drawing higher wages and working in the same establishment are entitled to take advantage of provisions of Workmen's Compensation Act and that amounts to invidious discrimination. The submission is merely required to be stated to be rejected. The employees drawing wages in excess of Rs. 3,000 per month are not covered by the provisions of Employees' State Insurance Act and, consequently, such employees form a class by themselves and are entitled to invoke Workmen's Compensation Act for claiming compensation or damages. It was urged that there is no nexus to the object to be achieved for making such discrimination. We are unable to find any merit in this contention also. It is obvious that the insurance cover is made available to the employees whose wages are below Rs. 3,000 per month and for whom insurance cover is absolutely necessary. The availability of the insurance cover to the small employees as distinct from the employees drawing higher emoluments cannot be faulted on the ground of discrimination. The object to be achieved is to provide insurance coverage to small employees in respect of employment injuries as well as maternity benefits, medical benefits and benefits to the dependents and such object is clearly subserved in respect of small employees who are in need of such cover. A faint attempt was made to urge that the employees of the establishments which are not covered by Employees's State Insurance Act are entitled to approach the authorities under the Workmen's Compensation Act for compensation and damages even though the monthly wages drawn by such employees are below Rs. 3,000. The counsel urged that discrimination is made even between employees drawing wages below Rs. 3,000 per month. The submission is devoid of merit because the employees of the establishment covered by Employees' State Insurance Act cannot be compared with employees of the establishment not so covered. The two classes of employees are different and distinct and the grievance is without any substance. In our judgment, challenge to constitutional validity of S. 53 of Employees' State Insurance Act is required to be rejected.

    16. The Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation, by order, dated 29 April, 1993, rejected the objection raised by the appellant to the maintainability of the application filed by respondent 2 in view of the bar under S. 53 of the Employees' State Insurance Act only because in view of the judgment of Full Bench of Kerala High Court and, consequently, the order of the Commissioner cannot be sustained. The learned Single Judge was not right in summarily dismissing the petition by observing that the appellant has a remedy to file an appeal under S. 30 of Workmen's Compensation Act. The appeal is provided against order awarding compensation and such appeal is of no consequence when the issue raised is about the jurisdiction of the Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation to entertain the application. The issue as to the lack of initial jurisdiction cannot be shut out by directing the appellant to submit to the jurisdiction of the Commissioner and then prefer an appeal. In our judgment, the order of the learned Single Judge declining to entertain petition under Art. 226 of the Constitution of India on the ground of availability of effacacious remedy is not correct and cannot be sustained. The application filed by respondent 2 before the authority under the Workmen's Compensation Act was not maintainable and is liable to be dismissed.

    17. Accordingly, appeal is allowed and order, dated 2 August, 1993, passed by learned Single Judge in Writ Petition No. 1406 of 1993 as well as order, dated 29 April, 1993, passed by Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation below Exhibit C. 5 in application (WCA) No. 108/6-18 of 1992 are set aside and the application for compensation filed by respondent 2 stands dismissed. In the circumstances of the case, there will be no order as to costs.

    Employees' State Insurance Act.Employees' State Insurance Act.
    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Associated Electrica... v. (1) Commissioner For...
    (Aug 4, 1994)