CiteTEXT
...manslaughter. He appeals from the judgment of conviction and sentence entered by the trial court on the jury's guilty verdict.
1. The trial court's giving of a charge on mutual combat is enumerated as error. ...that mutual combat and self-defense are mutually exclusive by definition, where there is evidence of both the jury, as trier of fact, must...parties are at fault and are willing to fight because of a sudden quarrel.' [Cit.] The mutual intention to fight need not be proved directly, but may be inferred by the jury from the conduct of the parties...
...this case. The jury could quite reasonably have concluded this was a mutual combat situation. If they did so, they would likely have....
CALJIC No. 5.56, as given in this case, provides, "The right of self-defense is only available to a person who engages in mutual combat if he has done all th...cautioned about the care to be taken in a situation in which a fact is proved by the testimony of a single witness. On the facts of this case, we do not believe the inclusion of CALJIC Nos. 2.71 or 2.71.7...
...incidents" was admissible to show the inadequacy of the security provided. However, "all police incidents" at the inn and lounge were not substantially similar to the mutual combat situation in which...premises is irrelevant and cannot form a basis for liability on the premises owner.
The dissent fails to distinguish a mutual combat situation from a case involving an innocent...present circumstances, because of Sailors' voluntary participation. In a case of mutual combat, the superior knowledge must always remain with the combatants, as they, by their voluntary...
.... Defendant responded with a blow that fractured her cheekbone. We are called upon to consider whether the participants were engaged in "mutual combat" for purposes of the law of self-defense. Defendant...in "mutual combat" with the alleged victim. Further, the court refused the jury's request during deliberations for a legal definition of "mutual combat," telling jurors instead to rely on the...first, on the doctrine of "mutual combat." The jury found defendant guilty of aggravated assault and aggravated battery, and sustained the great bodily injury allegation. The trial court denied a motion...
.... 7 and 35 (2d ed. 1991).
The trial court went on to charge the jury as to mutual combat, a concept arising out of OCGA § 16-3-21 (b) and the law of justification.... The charge given by the trial court as to mutual combat was virtually identical to the pattern charge found in Council of Superior Court Judges of...combat situation and then differentiated between when a homicide occurring during such a situation will be considered murder, voluntary manslaughter or justifiable homicide...
...do not believe either's behavior was reasonable or necessary, regardless of who actually fired first. This case appears to be a mutual combat situation, where both parties fought willingly upon equal...situation. Defendant's probation officer, Brad Parks, testified that defendant had requested to move to two different places.
At the party, defendant approached Harvey and attempted to...return. Defendant pleaded with Harvey to resolve the situation and repeatedly asked Harvey to "leave it alone." Harvey kept repeating, "It's not over till I say it's over."
At this...
....
1. Appellant claims that the trial court should not have instructed the jury on mutual combat since there was no evidence to support the charge. We disagree. "Mutual combat . . . generally inv...presented justified the mutual combat charge. "It is well established that an instruction is not inapplicable where there is any evidence, however slight, on which to predicate it. [Cit...) ( 49 S.E.2d 196) (1948). While it is true that mutual combat and self-defense are mutually exclusive by definition, where there is evidence of both the...
....) In refusing to give the pertinent jury instruction in this case, the trial court stated that there was no evidence of a mutual combat situation.
.... Stat. 1985, ch. 38, par. 9-2(a).
Mutual combat is recognized as serious provocation sufficient to warrant an instruction to the jury on voluntary manslaughter based on serious...evidence in this case is sufficient to conclude that the parties became suddenly heated and engaged in mutual combat on equal terms and the death resulted from the combat. (See...
...conclusion of the hearing, the juvenile court said that the incident between F.N. and P.W. started as a mutual combat situation, but then changed: "I think the force used, even if you give [F.N...fight starting as a mutual combat situation it would "give" F.N. her first swing of the bat. It then rejected F.N.'s self-defense claim based on the second, third, and fourth times she struck P.W., blows...
...allow her to press charges because this was a mutual combat situation. The applicant further asserted Ms. Wrights' position was inaccurate and untrue.
{¶ 3} Ultimately...here was anything other than mutual combat or that the applicant was the victim of criminally injurious conduct.
{¶ 5} From review of the file and with full and careful...
...alleging that it was a "mutual combat" situation, the weight of the evidence supports the conclusion by a rational trier of fact that the essential elements of the crime were proven beyond a reasonable doubt..., the purported evidentiary gaps or shortcomings. Appellant simply implies that the struggle between the two men was mutual.
{¶ 10} Our function when reviewing a manifest...
...-mutual combat situation, was not required to retreat if he reasonably believed he was in imminent danger of death. The instruction which was read to the jury said that, for self-defense to be considered...fact that the trial court instructed the jury as to a defendant's responsibility when he voluntarily enters into a mutual combat...mutual combat.
Instruction No. 7 reads:
When a defendant voluntarily enters into a mutual combat...
...next examine how this concept relates to a defendant's criminal liability for the death of an innocent bystander.
D. Relevancy of Mutual-Combat Situation. In other...review for purposes of considering two allegations of trial court error: (1) the failure to give an instruction on voluntary manslaughter and (2) the submission of a "mutual combat" instruction...court did not err in instructing on the theory of mutual combat as a basis for the defendant's culpability as an aider and abettor. We vacate that portion of the court of appeals' decision addressing...
...Supp. 21–5223(a). In assessing the testimony and other evidence, the district court concluded that the facts established a “mutual combat” situation between Caton and Kelly, particularly on the front...271 Kan. 1041 (2001); Comment, Standing Your Ground in Kansas, 82 UMKC L.Rev. 847, 866 (2014) (Under Kansas law, “a determination of mutual combat cuts off the entire self-defense...applied lawful physical force to remove Kelly from the house is similarly unpersuasive given the mutual combat.
Caton also contends the district court failed to consider self-defense or...
...account the witnesses' reluctance to testify, disbelieve them and find the defendant guilty?
First of all, I disagree that this was a mutual combat situation where the defense of...his withdrawal but the other person continues the use of force. IPI Criminal 4th No. 24-25.09.
There is no right of self-defense in a mutual combat situation. Where two..., 292 Ill. App.3d at 178, 684 N.E.2d at 1058, this court addressed a situation in which the prosecutor pointlessly elicited ...
..., 244 N.E.2d 358, as support for the proposition that once evidence is presented to show a mutual-combat situation, such an instruction is required. However, there is...establish that the death of Engle was the result of serious provocation that arose during mutual combat. Alternatively, Calhoun asserts that the 30-year term of imprisonment was excessive and that it...provocation" has been defined as "conduct sufficient to excite an intense passion in a reasonable person." (Ill. Rev. Stat. 1985, ch. 38, par. 9-2(a).) If the mutual quarrel or combat which occurred between...
...fifteen-year-old innocent bystander in the mutual combat situation of voluntary gang warfare-was consistent. We find no reason in the record...reasonably perceive the situation in which he found himself to be a drive-by shooting and an imminent attack on his life. Although the stipulated-to testimony indicated that Phung had fired first, it also...)
Page 682.
that reversal in such a situation is required only where the prosecutor presents theories that are "totally inconsistent," and not "where the...
...combat situation. But the second[, ] in which Sandra and Melanie were attacking the victim, and [B.A.] had indicated to the officer that she had been involved in that is enough for the court to.... to have been a credible witness, however the court was greatly concerned with what it characterized as the “second fight.” The juvenile court stated: “I think the first fight sounded like... a mutual...
...the argument, Cummings pulled a gun with which he attempted to hit James. A crowd of onlookers formed, including Henry, a Scott brother. After Henry produced a gun, the mutual combat situation became...mitigate a shooting. The mitigating circumstances of mutual combat and self-defense already factored into the jury's verdict of the lesser offense of second degree murder. See People v.... Garibay, 366 Ill. App. 3d 1103, 1110 (2006) (defendant's plea of guilty to second degree murder apparently based on theory of mutual combat...
...denied Hoban's claim. He found that Hoban had contributed to the infliction of his injuries because he was involved in a mutual combat situation and he was under the influence of alcohol. Hoban...