Court Filter
FEDERAL COURTS
STATE COURTS
Apply Filter
Judge Filter
Filter by Judge Name (Beta)
Motion Filter
Filter by Motion (Beta)
*Please select motion
Other Filters
2010 Onwards2069
From 2000 To 20101124
From 1990 To 2000478
From 1980 To 1990212
From 1970 To 198033
From 1960 To 19702
From 1950 To 19600
Before 19500

Cases cited for the legal proposition you have searched for.

Loading..

Showing 100 of 1305 results

...reasons should be given preclusive effect in this action. We agree. The doctrine of issue preclusion prevents relitigation of issues actually litigated and necessarily decided..., 895 F.2d 1267, 1271 (9th Cir. 1990). Nonetheless, Shaw asserts she should not be bound by Judge Wilson's ruling. The doctrine of issue preclusion, of course, cannot be...objection to a peremptory challenge against the venireperson. The doctrine of issue preclusion bars litigation only of issues actually litigated and necessarily decided in a prior proceeding. However, under...

...Queens County District Attorney. Identity of parties, an essential element for application of the doctrine of issue preclusion or collateral estoppel, was lacking here so that the determination made...

.... I. In general, the doctrine of issue preclusion prevents parties to a pr...). Traditionally, the presence of three prerequisites was required before the doctrine of issue preclusion could properly be applied in any given case: (1) identity of issues raised in the.... 2, 1975) (footnote added). Mindful of the foregoing, we conclude that offensive application of the doctrine of issue preclusion should not invariably be precluded where...

...doctrine of issue preclusion and that, as to all but two defendants, genuine issues of material fact appear in the record, we affirm in part and vacate in part the district court's entry of judgment in favor..., concluded that Colon's claim of retaliation was barred by the doctrine of issue preclusion, or collateral estoppel, which bars a party from relitigating an issue that has been resolved in a prior..., the doctrine of issue preclusion only applies if (1) the issue in question was actually and necessarily decided in a prior proceeding, and (2) the party ...

...support of that claim. It should go without saying that the identical reasons in support of ineffectiveness cannot be litigated twice. That is prevented by the doctrine of issue preclusion. ...

...his claim, as well as his wife's derivative claim for loss of consortium. We affirm. This action was dismissed by the trial court by use of the doctrine of issue preclusion, a...applies only to parties to the earlier action. The doctrine of issue preclusion, which may be used either "offensively" or "defensively," allows the use of the earlier judgment by one not party to the...proper use of summary judgments, directed verdicts, or other forms of disposition prior to submission to a jury are violative of § 7. We find the application of the doctrine of issue preclusion to be...

...ultimate disposition turns on the application of an "unmixed questions of law" exception to the doctrine of issue preclusion. The case arises from a shipment of furnace equipment by Tongil Co., Ltd. from...the timeliness issue is an interesting and important one, this appeal turns not on that issue but on the doctrine of issue preclusion, for Hyundai's principal argument on appeal is that, in holding the...argument and refused to apply the doctrine of issue preclusion to the issue resolved in Atlantic Mutual, relying on an exception for "unmixed questions of law," the scope of which is a question...

...we conclude that the district court properly determined that the doctrine of issue preclusion prevents appellant from relitigating its claims under the Tariff and Lanham Acts and that appellant has no...I Appellees moved to dismiss the complaint, arguing that the doctrine of issue preclusion prevented Yamaha-America from relitigating claims under the Tariff and Lanham Acts it...different conclusion on the merits under the law of this Circuit is irrelevant, for the doctrine of issue preclusion prevents reaching the merits, even where a different view would prevail. Id. at...

...based on a 1986 order and decision of the Civil Court, New York County (Roger Bryant Hunting, J.). The doctrine of issue preclusion applies only to arguments that could have been raised in prior...

...obtaining interlocutory review of a motion to disqualify is so remote, it is not sufficient to invoke the doctrine of issue preclusion. The fact that the parties to the Union Products case entered into a.... 3. Issue preclusion. The doctrine of issue preclusion provides that when an issue has been "actually...Union Products case was not subject to review in any meaningful sense. The doctrine of issue preclusion cannot apply where there is no "avenue for review of the prior ruling on...

...doctrine of issue preclusion did not apply because there was no identity of issues between the modification-of-visitation proceeding in district court and the request to correct the abuse report before...., 709 N.W.2d 114, 117 (Iowa 2006) (reviewing decision as to applicability of doctrine of issue preclusion for correction of errors at law); Mrozek v...the child abuse assessment was presented — did the incident occur as described by Bo? Accordingly, the identity of the factual issues supports application of the doctrine of issue preclusion under...

...principle of issue preclusion. Under Wisconsin law, we must also consider several factors to determine whether application of the doctrine of issue preclusion would comport with...initial action. He chose instead to withdraw and then to sit on those allegations in state court. He has attempted to bite this apple not just twice but three times. The doctrine of issue preclusion bars him from d...

...Massachusetts state court, it is precluded from relitigation under the doctrine of issue preclusion. Second, even if the issue were not precluded, we find that Keystone and NEP have a legally..., was the result compelled by the merits. This appeal ensued. Standard of Review We review de novo the district court's application of the doctrine of issue preclusion be...the preclusion question in this case. However, we have previously recognized that Massachusetts courts "apply the doctrine of issue preclusion in a traditional manner." Willhauck...

...denial of workers' compensation benefits and negligent medical care. Hartford filed a motion for summary judgment arguing Gardner's claim for bad faith denial of benefits was barred by the doctrine of issue ...the district court's application of the doctrine of issue preclusion and the court's determination she failed to exhaust her administrative remedies. The court confirmed its earlier determination...Merits On appeal Gardner argues the court erred in granting summary judgment based upon its finding her bad faith tort claim was barred by the doctrine of issue ...

..., Trial Judge. The trial court applied the doctrine of issue preclusion/collateral estoppel to a criminal conviction which was pending on appeal. We find that if an appeal is...impeachment, judgments against persons other than the accused. The pendency of an appeal may be shown but does not affect admissibility;". The doctrine of issue preclusion is...doctrine of issue preclusion/collateral estoppel is inapt. The conviction may either be admissible for "what it is worth", or it may have no effect at all. The comments state that the rule adopts the...

...Pleas in Pennsylvania State College v. County of Centre, (No. 2 Equity November Term 1937, filed August 24, 1939), precluded the present action based on the doctrine of issue preclusion. The trial..., 562 A.2d 279, 280 (1989). At issue in this appeal is the applicability of the doctrine of issue preclusion, based on the...doctrine of issue preclusion. In Pennsylvania State College, the Centre County Court of Common Pleas was called upon to determine whether certain property belonging to...

...barred by the doctrine of issue preclusion. We reverse. II. Standard of Review Our standard of review in this equity action is de novo. Iowa R. App. P. 4. We give...current child support for Lisa. IV. Discussion of Law — General Principles The doctrine of issue preclusion, or collateral estoppel, serves a dual purpose.... Hunter v. City of Des Moines, 300 N.W.2d 121, 123 (Iowa 1981). Formerly, the doctrine of issue preclusion was available only...

...dismissal in this case was mandated by the doctrine of issue preclusion. We affirm the dismissal in part, reverse in part, and remand for further proceedings...the doctrine of issue preclusion does not control, and that the present complaint's statements of those claims come within the required particularity of Rule 9(b...action between the same parties is foreclosed by the doctrine of issue preclusion. See Allen v. McCurry, 449 U.S. 90, 94...

...application of the doctrine of issue preclusion might engender. Opinion...doctrine of issue preclusion should not apply to that claim as well. Otherwise, a small claims judgment in favor of or against the plaintiff might later be used by or against her in her personal injury.... In any event, unless the doctrine of issue preclusion were not applied to such a small claims judgment, there would be an incentive on the part of the...

....: In this appeal, appellant Emil Frei, III, challenges the district court's refusal to apply the doctrine of issue preclusion and its application of the parol evidence rule in.... Frei asserted, and maintains on appeal, that the doctrine of issue preclusion prevented Goodsell from denying the existence of an attorney-client relationship with Frei in the legal malpractice...that under the doctrine of issue preclusion, Goodsell could not deny the existence of an attorney-client relationship in light of the district court's order disqualifying Goodsell from the trust...

...disclose required information. Accordingly, the district court found the doctrine of issue preclusion prohibited relitigation of the issue. Additionally, the district court found DMMHA was not required to...district court judge. However, the district court did apply the doctrine of issue preclusion to preclude relitigation of the factual findings made in the administrative proceedings that Hunter failed to...found the doctrine of issue preclusion precluded the district court in this action from deciding that the notice to cure was not required to...

...the proceedings. The defendants in the present case are seeking summary judgment under the doctrine of issue preclusion, also known as collateral estoppel...appealed. The Iowa Supreme Court noted, "In general, the doctrine of issue preclusion prevents parties to a prior action in which judgment has been entered from relitigating in a.... The court found the three prerequisites to application of the doctrine of issue preclusion set out in Goolsby had evolved under Iowa case law into four prerequisites...

...dismissed Clinton and Norma Buckingham's suit against the Federal Land Bank Association (FLB) after determining the claim was barred by the doctrine of issue preclusion. We transferred the case to the...doctrine of issue preclusion clearly is applicable to this case. As a general rule, issue preclusion bars relitigating in a subsequent action issues raised and fully litigated in a prior action...to explore whether it would immunize this action from application of the doctrine of issue preclusion. We have noted that after final judgment in Clinton's first action, but before his appeal could be...

...a claim upon which relief can be granted due to the exclusivity provision of section 85.20 must fail. The Court now turns to Defendants' argument for dismissal pursuant to the doctrine of issue preclusion. ... Gardner, 659 N.W.2d at 207 (applying the doctrine of issue preclusion to employer's defens...determinations defensively in this action. Nor are there any other factors present that would deter this Court from applying the doctrine of issue preclusion. All of Plaintiff's...

...notice under rule 56 would have been harmless. Ibid. 2. Issue preclusion. In order for the moving party to successfully invoke the doctrine of issue preclusion, the...the level of finality sufficient to apply the doctrine of issue preclusion, in particular the absence of an appealable order or judgment. For purposes of issue preclusion, "final judgment" includes...of Appeals of Stoughton, 402 Mass. at 149. It is settled that the doctrine of issue preclusion may not be invoked unless there is available...

...principles guide our analysis of this issue. The doctrine of issue preclusion strives to protect litigants from the "vexation of relitigating identical issues with identical parties or those persons...

...required when the district court enters a deferred judgment after the Alford plea. Accordingly, we hold the victim of a crime (or the victim's subrogated insurer) may invoke the doctrine of issue preclusion ...doctrine of issue preclusion based on Van Haaften's Alford plea accepted by the district court. EMCC, however, failed to show it is entitled to summary judgment in excess of...

...to overcome paternity was dismissed. On appeal, Stacy contends the district court erred in relying on the doctrine of issue preclusion, because no party raised the doctrine.... The doctrine of issue preclusion “prevents parties to a prior action in which judgment has been entered from relitigating in a subsequent action issues raised and resolved in the previous...encompass the doctrine of issue preclusion and doctrine was not tried by consent). We reverse the district court...

...answer and, shortly thereafter, a motion for summary judgment. He raised the doctrine of issue preclusion, arguing the favorable judgment in the Armstrong litigation barred West from proceeding with...and she needed to pursue additional discovery to determine whether issue preclusion should apply, (B) the district court erred in applying the doctrine of issue preclusion under the circumstances of...this case, and (C) it was unfair and inequitable to apply the doctrine of issue preclusion. A. Incomplete Discovery West argues Kirby's motion...

...district court erred in finding the doctrine of issue preclusion barred his claim. Allan contends the issue in the current action is not identical to the issues in his previous action and, therefore, the...claim was barred under the doctrine of issue preclusion because Allan's prior claims for intentional interference with contractual/business relations decided the issue of David's intent in purchasing his...doctrine of issue preclusion prevents parties to a prior action in which judgment has been entered from relitigating in a subsequent action issues raised and resolved in the previous action...

...., 617 N.W.2d 909, 911 (Iowa 2000). Generally, rulings on the application of the doctrine of issue preclusion are reviewed for an abuse of discretion...that the doctrine of issue preclusion is inapplicable in this context. Even if the doctrine applies, Roland argues the department erred both procedurally and substantively in its application...administrative proceedings. The supreme court has, however, at least by implication held that the doctrine of issue preclusion may apply in this context...

...obtained against its insured, Tim Allie, did not bar this action under the doctrine of issue preclusion. American also asserts the district court erred by concluding American did not meet the burden on...permission to use the vehicle. The court therefore determined there was no coverage under the policy. Before the doctrine of issue preclusion may be applied in any given case, four.... SCHULTZ, Justice (dissenting). I believe that it is improper to apply the doctrine of issue ...

.... Sturgell, 553 U.S. 880, 892 (2008) (discussing doctrine of issue preclusion). Plaintiff ...). The fact that Judge Gordon dismissed the previous case without prejudice does not render the doctrine of issue preclusion inapplicable: "It ...

...registration requirements. On further review, Barker invokes the doctrine of issue preclusion and argues the DPS...he was misled about the duration of his registration requirement and trial counsel was ineffective in advising him about the consequences of his plea. Barker also claimed that the doctrine of issue preclusion appli... on whether the doctrine of issue preclusion applies. See, e.g., State v...

.... III. The trial court also based its holding on the doctrine of issue preclusion. Issue preclusion serves a dual purpose. First it p...

...Corp. of Am. v. United States, 961 F.2d 245, 254 (D.C. Cir. 1992) ("The objective of the doctrine of issue preclusion . . . is judicial finality; it fulfills 'the purpose for which civil...doctrine of issue preclusion counsels us against reaching the merits in this case, however, regardless of whether we would reject or accept our sister circuit's position...not be unfair to the plaintiff and, therefore, her Second and Third COAs are dismissed under the doctrine of issue preclusion. ...

...decided in the earlier December 2002 decision, and that under the doctrine of issue preclusion the State was precluded from raising those issues again. The juvenile court denied the motion to dismiss... On appeal Bridget claims the district court erred by denying her motion to dismiss the termination petition. She asserts the petition should be barred by the doctrine of issue ...under principles of due process. The doctrine of issue preclusion provides parties may not relitigate issues already decided in a previous action...

...doctrine of issue preclusion applies when: 1. The issue concluded is identical; 2. The issue was raised and litigated in the...App. 1985). The doctrine of issue preclusion may be utilized in either a defensive or an affirmative manner. The phrase "defensive use" of...doctrine of issue preclusion should not invariably be precluded where mutuality of parties is lacking." Id. at 125. The supreme court in Hunter adopted as their own the position taken by...

...Ninth Circuit's decision rests upon a precedent that this circuit has not adopted is just another way of saying that the Ninth Circuit's decision is wrong. The doctrine of issue preclusion counsel us...

...the doctrine of issue preclusion and the doctrine of claim preclusion. Migra v. Warren City School Dist. Bd. of Educ., 465 U.S. 75, 77 n...determined by the court for, the Eastern District of Virginia, the doctrine of issue preclusion, not claim preclusion, pertains. "[O]nce an issue is actually and necessarily determined by a court of...was time-barred. (See Mem. Op. at 9.) Third, no unfairness will accrue to plaintiff by applying the doctrine of issue preclusion here. To the contrary, the doctrine of issue ...

...beneficiaries under a will against the remaining beneficiaries under a will, (4) concluding the interference with inheritance claim was barred by the doctrine of issue preclusion, (5) concluding the...an inheritance, we need not reach this issue, as we determine that the doctrine of issue preclusion is dispositive of this appeal. The doctrine of issue ...741. There are four prerequisites to the application of the doctrine of issue preclusion, as follows: the issue concluded must be identical; the issue must have...

...." Hunter v. City of Des Moines, 300 N.W.2d 121, 123 n. 3 (Iowa 1981). The doctrine of issue preclusion can be used both offensi...

...happened was negligently done while under the influence of alcohol. Dolan urges State Farm participated in the defense of the Olson trial and that the doctrine of issue preclusion prevents...

...that (1) the issue decided in the prior action is identical to the issue in the later litigation; (2) there was a final judgment on the merits; (3) the party against whom the doctrine of issue preclusion is...asserted was a party to the prior action or in privity with a party thereto; (4) the party against whom the doctrine of issue preclusion is asserted had a full and fair opportunity to litigate...

...them are barred by issue preclusion. The Iowa Supreme Court recently offered this explanation of issue preclusion: [T]he doctrine of issue ...

...Court's affirmance of that determination. The District Court then concluded that the doctrine of issue preclusion bound the court to that determination, and dismissed the case for lack of subject...doctrine of issue preclusion as a basis for concluding she was a Pennsylvania resident was legal error. She argues that the District Court's...doctrine of issue preclusion. Coulter's related factual challenge essentially argues that the facts determining her domicile changed between the filing of her action against the Paulisicks on July 20...

...of the holding below, plaintiff Bertran relies entirely on the doctrine of issue preclusion, claiming trial court's finding in the prior case of Bertran v. Chantland and Richey that the...entirely on the doctrine of issue preclusion. We believe, therefore, the case should be reversed and remanded for a new trial. VI. Recognizing the likelihood that the prior.... McDonald, 212 N.W.2d 505, 507 (Iowa 1973). The foundation theory on which the doctrine of issue preclusion rests is that the parties ought not to be permitted to litigate...

...doctrine of issue preclusion. Cruise filed a resistance to the motion for summary judgment, asserting that the issues in the two cases were not identical, that the issue of fault was not litigated by Cruise...in the Linn County litigation, and that the lack of identity of the parties in the two litigations made the doctrine of issue preclusion inapplicable. The district court entered...resisting the motion for summary judgment. Cruise contends the district court erred in applying the law of issue preclusion to the present case. The purpose of the doctrine of issue preclusion,...

...consider several factors to determine whether application of the doctrine of issue preclusion would comport with "fundamental fairness" before closing the book on Virnich's section 134.01 claim. See.... The doctrine of issue preclusion bars him from doing so. AFFIRMED. ...

...F.2d 190, 194 (D.C. Cir. 1990) ("The doctrine of issue preclusion counsels us against reaching the merits in this case, . . . regardless of whether we would reject or accept our sister circuit's...

..., 631 N.E.2d 1021, 1024 (1994). Alternately, the doctrine of issue preclusion prevents "reliti...the State Court, and the doctrine of issue preclusion prevents the Debtor from raising it again in this Court. Furthermore, even were issue preclusion not to apply, this Court's...

...has offered this explanation of issue preclusion: [T]he doctrine of issue preclusion prevents parties to a prior action in which judgment has been entered from...

...detainer suit and find he was entitled to possession of the entire seventy acres for the 1993-94 crop year. The doctrine of issue preclusion prevents parties to a prior action in...at 123. Traditionally, the presence of three prerequisites was required before the doctrine of issue preclusion could properly be applied in any given case: (1) identity of issues raised in the...

...as a matter of law under the doctrine of issue preclusion when the industrial commissioner awarded penalty benefits as a part of its decision to award workers' compensation benefits.... The district court denied McIlravy's motion for a partial summary judgment and granted summary judgment for North River. It found that the doctrine of issue preclusion was inapplicable to th...the element of the bad faith tort requiring him to establish the absence of a reasonable basis for denying benefits was established as a matter of law under the doctrine of issue preclusion when the...

...abused his children. In September 2000, an administrative law judge granted the motion based on the doctrine of issue preclusion. Swanger filed a petition for judicial review, which the district court...hearing under section 235A.19(2), and that the doctrine of issue preclusion does not apply. We note at the outset that whether issue preclusion operates to deny a hearing under section 235A.19(2) is...an issue of first impression. "The doctrine of issue preclusion prevents a party to a prior action in which a judgment has been rendered from relitigating in a subsequent action...

...of the doctrine of issue preclusion. Defensive use has been defined to mean that a stranger to the judgment, ordinarily the defendant in the second action, relies upon a former judgment as...issue of defendant's negligence has been litigated and adjudicated. We therefore hold that plaintiff David Bryan's lawsuit is barred by the doctrine of issue preclusion on the...

... The doctrine of issue preclusion, also referred to as collateral estoppel, bars the relitigation of issues determined in prior..., 112 L.Ed.2d 755 (1991) ). If the party against whom the doctrine of issue preclusion is sought “had a full and fair opportunity to litigate certain issues, whe...). Issue preclusion “can apply [even] where the subsequent proceeding involves a cause of action different from the first.” Id. (citation omitted). The doctrine of issue preclusion applies in...

...the doctrine of issue preclusion (or collateral estoppel), once a court has decided an issue of fact or law necessary to its judgment, the same parties or their privies may not relitigate the issue in...(Okla. 1984). However, the doctrine of issue preclusion bars an attack on a judgment only when the issue in question has been "`fully and fairly' litigated" in the prior proceeding. Veiser...."). In the instant case, there are two reasons why the doctrine of issue preclusion is inapplicable. First, the minute entry on which Dillard relies is not signed by the municipal...

...the doctrine of issue preclusion in Fellmer, the dispositive principle governing the decision was one of claim preclusion. The status of Fellmer as the father of the child...

...adjudicated as lost. The doctrine of issue preclusion "prevents parties to a prior action in which judgment has been entered from relitigating in a subsequent action issues raised and resolved in the...attempt to relitigate issues of personal jurisdiction is barred by the doctrine of issue preclusion. The trial court was correct in so holding. II. Robert F. Wilson's simultaneous...

...doctrine of issue preclusion ... is judicial finality; it fulfills ‘the purpose for which civil courts have been established, the conclusive resolution of disputes within their jurisdiction...Laborers' Int'l Union of N. Am. v. Am. Postal Workers Union, 907 F.2d 190, 194 (D.C.Cir.1990) (“The doctrine of issue preclusion counsels us against reaching the merits in this case, however...

...TO DISMISS COUNTERCLAIM This motion presents the question of whether the doctrine of issue preclusion bars the defendants' counterclaim. I conclude that it.... Second, the trustee argues that the doctrine of issue preclusion bars the reformation claim. I agree...(Second) of Judgments § 27 cmt. c (1982). "The doctrine of [issue preclusion] applies only when the issues presented in each matter are identical. The doctrine is inapplicable if the issues are merely...

...); see also Yamaha Corp. of Am. v. United States, 961 F.2d 245, 254 (D.C.Cir.1992) (“The objective of the doctrine of issue preclusion ... is....1990) (“The doctrine of issue preclusion counsels us against reaching the merits in this case, however, regardless of whether we would reject or accept our sister circuit's position..., preclusion would not be unfair to the plaintiff and, therefore, her Second and Third COAs are dismissed under the doctrine of issue preclusion....

....2d 245, 254 (D.C.Cir.1992) (“The objective of the doctrine of issue preclusion ... is judicial finality; it fulfills ‘the purpose for which civil courts have been established, the conclusive...doctrine of issue preclusion counsels us against reaching the merits in this case, however, regardless of whether we would reject or accept our sister circuit's position...and Third COAs are dismissed under the doctrine of issue preclusion. Th...

...licensed usage of the intellectual property to Axiom LLC for a period of time. Id. at 4. Axiom Inc. further contends that under the doctrine of issue preclusion, HTRD, as a...persuaded by HTRD that the doctrine of issue preclusion (also called collateral estoppel) may not apply unless the parties were adversaries in the prior proceeding, Judge McCoun concluded that the...determination that issue preclusion should not apply in this case. Specifically, Axiom Inc. argues that, HTRD's arguments to the contrary, the doctrine of issue preclusion does not require an adversarial...

...); see also Yamaha Corp. of Am. v. United States, 961 F.2d 245, 254 (D.C. Cir. 1992) ("The objective of the doctrine of issue preclusion . . . is.... Am. Postal Workers Union, 907 F.2d 190, 194 (D.C. Cir. 1990) ("The doctrine of issue preclusion counsels us against reaching the merits in this case, however, regardless of whether we would...

...). The court that entered the Contempt Order was a Massachusetts court. In Massachsuetts, "[t]he doctrine of issue preclusion provides that when an issue has been 'actually...

.... United States, 961 F.2d 245, 254 (D.C.Cir.1992) (“The objective of the doctrine of issue preclusion ... is judicial finality; it fulfills ‘the purpose for which civil courts have been.... Postal Workers Union, 907 F.2d 190, 194 (D.C.Cir.1990) (“The doctrine of issue preclusion counsels us against reaching the merits in this case, however, regardless of whether we would reject...

...respondent. HALPERN 1. Held: This Court may raise sua sponte the doctrine of issue preclusion, or collateral estoppel.... 765 F.2d 1051 (11th Cir.1985). b. The Doctrine of Issue Preclusion The ...interest issue. The equitable doctrine of issue preclusion requires that petitioners be given an opportunity to...

...collateral estoppel, also known as the doctrine of issue preclusion, Hunter v. City of Des Moines, 300 N.W.2d 121, 123 n. 2 (Iowa 1981.... Hunter, 300 N.W.2d at 123. Hall's initial argument — that the doctrine of issue preclusion may not be invoked here because the...Barrett was negligent in failing to attack it. The district court did not err in its application of the doctrine of issue preclusion. Cf. Allen v...

...Mass. App. Ct. 86, 98 (1999). The doctrine of issue preclusion "prevents relitigation of an issue determined in an earlier action where the same issue arises in a later action, based on a different...

.... 2001). The doctrine of issue preclusion is a slightly more narrow doctrine than claim preclusion. TLT Constr. Corp. v. A. Anthony Tappe and Assocs., Inc...

...Insurance Co., Jasmine's liability insurance provider. The district court ruled that Manganella was not entitled to coverage from Evanston because, under the doctrine of issue preclusion, a prior...or intentional disregard of” the Massachusetts sexual harassment law underlying Burgess's MCAD charge. Id. at 347–48. The district court thus held that the doctrine of issue preclusion barred...application of the doctrine of issue preclusion because ‘[t]he applicability vel non of preclusion principles is a question of law...

.... ANALYSIS The doctrine of issue preclusion, commonly invoked under the less precise heading of collateral estoppel, bars a party from relitigating an issue of fact or of law that was..., 78 L.Ed.2d 388 (1984), the APWU next contends that it comes within an exception to the doctrine of issue preclusion where "different courts of appeals have...circuit has not adopted is just another way of saying that the Ninth Circuit's decision is wrong. The doctrine of issue preclusion counsels us against reaching the merits in this case, however...

.... 1988) (stating that "the doctrine of issue preclusion prevents relitigation of all 'issues of fact or law that were actually litigated and necessarily decided' in a prior proceeding") (quoting...

...previously litigated his claims in another federal case, Civil Action No. 14-1425. Thus, the government contends that this case should be dismissed with prejudice pursuant to the doctrine of issue preclusion and.... Discussion The government contends that this case must be dismissed with prejudice pursuant to the doctrine of issue preclusion and/or lack of subject...satisfy a four-part test in order to apply the doctrine of issue preclusion: 1) the issue decided in the prior adjudication must be identical with the one presented in the later action...

...relitigating Judge van Gestel's demand futility determination based on the doctrine of issue preclusion. To trigger the application of this doctrine, the defendants must satisfy five elements...Section II.A.2.1. That sub-section continues: "Whenever a court considers applying the doctrine of issue preclusion, there is always.... Without more, however, this consideration does not outweigh the extremely important policy underlying the doctrine of issue preclusion — that litigation of issues at some point must come to an end. To allow...

...arose in the course of his employment, were conclusively established in the first trial. The court held that under the doctrine of issue preclusion, plaintiff was not entitled to coverage as a volunteer..."volunteer" was rendered moot under the doctrine of issue preclusion. Our review convinces us that no issue of material fact exists with regard to Krueger's "status," either as to IRTT...Krueger's employment status were conclusive upon Krueger, and under the doctrine of issue preclusion, Krueger was estopped to question that adjudication in the instant case...

..., is barred by the doctrine of issue preclusion. We affirm the judgment of the district court dismissing the petition but reverse its ruling awarding Victoria attorney fees...motion to dismiss the petition, arguing it was barred by the doctrine of issue preclusion because Darren's attempt to overcome paternity of C.F. had been decided adversely to him in the prior action.... Treimer v. Lett, 587 N.W.2d 622, 624 (Iowa Ct. App. 1998). III. Discussion. A. Issue Preclusion. The ...

...claim contained in his habeas corpus petition presently on appeal is barred under the doctrine of issue preclusion. Issue preclusion, or collateral estoppel, bars relitigation of...determination on the CCC issue was certainly essential to the final judgment in Brown v. Hogsten. We are satisfied that Brown's claim in the petition on appeal is now barred by the doctrine of issue ...

...review. We initially must decide whether the trial court correctly determined that the doctrine of issue preclusion does not apply to preclude Nuckoll's from proving that Randall violated his agreement...statement, we have held that a nonparty has had an opportunity to be heard where the party against whom the doctrine of issue preclusion "is defensively invoked has a `community of interest with, and...of issue preclusion. Our review of the record reveals substantial evidence to support the district court's findings and, therefore, they are binding on appeal. See Iowa R. App. P. 14(f)(1...

...a suit based on an entirely different claim. Massachusetts applies the doctrine of issue preclusion in a traditional manner. The Massachusetts courts use...doctrine of issue preclusion applies, this Court must first determine whether the issue in question was: " 'actually litigated;' determined by a 'final judgment'; and was 'essential to the judgment...determination of the issue did not have the level of finality sufficient to apply the doctrine of issue preclusion because her appeal was dismissed for failure to post a bond. This argument fails: "[f]or...

...by the doctrine of issue preclusion. "Under New York law, the doctrine of issue preclusion only applies if (1) the issue in question was actually and necessarily decided in a pri...

...order to effectively analyze the applicability of the familiar doctrine of issue preclusion. Defendants moved for summary judgment on the issues of commercial reasonableness and tortious interference...the Tokheims failed to satisfy the requirements of the doctrine of issue preclusion under either Iowa or federal law. The court found that it could not determine from Judge Hoyt's Order and his...this court previously concluded that the Tokheims had failed to satisfy the requirements of the doctrine of issue preclusion. (Resistance to Mot. for Summ.J. ¶ 2.). The court could not determine from...

...Homes (Classic Homes). He also appeals the summary judgment for Classic Homes on his claims of constructive fraud and civil conspiracy, which judgment was based on the doctrine of issue preclusion. We...doctrine of issue preclusion. The court confirmed the arbitration award in full and granted Classic Homes summary judgment on Barnett's claims for constructive fraud and civil...conspiracy, concluding that those claims were barred under the doctrine of issue preclusion. The court later certified these orders for immediate appeal under C.R.C.P. 54(b). The court granted only partial...

...: [T]he doctrine of issue preclusion prevents parties to a prior action in which judgment has been entered from relitigating in a subsequent action issues raised and reso...(Second) of Judgments § 27 (1982)) (footnote omitted). The doctrine of issue preclusion can be used defensively or offensively...opportunity to do so. Therefore, under the doctrine of issue preclusion, SFI is precluded from relitigating Bud's authority to sign a mortgage, even though it may have a different theory for making that...

...doctrine of issue preclusion bars Plaintiff's FHAA claim based on the KCHR's decision. The Kentucky Supreme Court has established four requirements for issue preclusion...). Further, "[t]he doctrine of issue preclusion, which may be used either "offensively" or "defensively," allows the use of the earlier judgment by one not party to the original.... B. The doctrine of issue preclusion bars Plaintiff's FHAA claim based on Kentucky's Campbell County Circuit Court decision as well. The same issue preclusion rules ...

...). The doctrine of issue preclusion prevents relitigation of all "issues of fact or law that were actually litigated and necessarily decided" in a prior proceeding...had been entered in 1974. The other two were the two Robi cases which the district court had decided approximately seven months before it decided the Williams case. Under the doctrine of issue preclusion, "once...be achieved is to stop a second court from rendering an inconsistent judgment by applying the doctrine of issue preclusion. See Restatement (Second) of Judgments § 29 comment f (1982). The...

..., an essential element for application of the doctrine of issue preclusion or collateral estoppel, was lacking here (see, S.T. Grand, Inc. v. City of...

..., 823 F.3d at 1364-65 (where amendments in a second action render the doctrine of issue preclusion inapplicable, they must be independently examined). However, Melaleuca's new assertion...

...of a suit based on an entirely different claim. Massachusetts applies the doctrine of issue preclusion in a traditional manner...). Thus, in determining whether the doctrine of issue preclusion applies, this Court must first determine whether the issue in question was: " ‘actually litigated.... Plaintiff's primary argument appears to be that the determination of the issue did not have the level of finality sufficient to apply the doctrine of issue preclusion because her appeal was dismissed for...

...filial consortium due to the defendants' alleged negligence, and an adverse judgment for Laass in this action would impede his ability to protect this interest in state court because of the doctrine of issue ...consortium claims with wrongful death claims nor the doctrine of issue preclusion will impair McFarlin's ability to protect his interest. Although loss of consortium claims are.... McFarlin and the Dredging Defendants also argue that the doctrine of issue preclusion will prevent McFarlin from litigating his claims in state court if Laass receives...

.... III. The Merits. The doctrine of issue preclusion bars the same parties from relitigating identical issues raised and litigated in a.... Hunter v. City of Des Moines Mun. Hous. Auth., 742 N.W.2d 578, 584 (Iowa 2007). The doctrine of issue preclusion furthers goals of ...

...lawsuit. In its ruling the court reserved "the issue of whether State Farm . . . is bound by the verdict in said case." The court further stated that "[s]aid issues can be raised under the doctrine of issue ..., State Farm filed an application for adjudication of law points. State Farm asked the court to rule that (1) the doctrine of issue preclusion prevented Yenter and Brown from relitigating the Yenter v...coverage limit, which was $100,000 per person. They disputed that the doctrine of issue preclusion applied to Brown because she was neither a party nor in privity with a party in the Yenter v. Kassouf...

...are absolutely privileged. The court also found Pickens's claims were rejected in the ADA lawsuit, and thus were now barred by the doctrine of issue preclusion. Finally, the court determined section...the defensive use of the doctrine of issue preclusion. Defensive use of issue preclusion occurs when a stranger to the judgment in the former action, ordinarily the defendant in the second action...here may invoke the defensive use of issue preclusion against Pickens, who was a party to the previous action. We conclude Pickens's action is barred by the doctrine of issue preclusion and was...

...healing benefits and partial disability payments was "unreasonable." In the Motion, Etten asserts the doctrine of issue preclusion and contends the Deputy's findings in the workers' compensation case..., Heidemann v. Sweitzer, 375 N.W.2d 665, 667-68 (Iowa 1985) (stating doctrine of issue preclusion is inapplicable where "the burden has shifted...

...No. 7-2). On June 3, 2014, the Bankruptcy Court entered an Order sustaining Creditor Group's Objection and denying BB&T's claim under the doctrine of issue ...conspiracy pursuant to the doctrine of issue preclusion. The Court agrees. "Issue preclusion prevents relitigation of an issue decided in an earlier action, even though the later action...

...S.Ct. 70, 88 L.Ed.2d 58 (1985). Moreover, in general, Kentucky courts apply the doctrine of issue preclusion or collateral estoppel, "only as to matters which were...district court concluded that the doctrine of issue preclusion, as applied by the Kentucky courts, does prevent Barnes from succeeding in his section 1983 claim. The court so held because the state..., the district court erred in concluding that the doctrine of issue preclusion bars further litigation of Barnes's federal claim. The district court dismissed Barnes's action...

...States Tax Court. Filed October 23, 1997. 1. Held, this Court may raise sua sponte the doctrine of issue preclusion, or...), affd. 765 F.2d 1051 (11th Cir. 1985). b. The Doctrine of Issue Preclusion ...doctrine of issue preclusion, or collateral estoppel, provides that, once an issue of fact or law is "actually and necessarily determined by a court of competent jurisdiction...

...judicial notice can be taken. Further, a judge may take judicial notice of the court's records in a related action”). 3. Issue preclusion. “The doctrine of issue preclusion pro.... 93A claims were barred by the doctrine of issue preclusion. The plaint...

Loading..
Loading..

Please log in or register for a free trial to access these features.

s Register now

Got It