Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Docket Number
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Docket Number
To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

Boyden v. Salmonsen

" "! f

Sji a k- - •M

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF MONTANA

OP 26-0755

HOV 1 0 2026 ROBERT ALLEN BOYDEN,

Oreenwood

Court Eiovwen

oierk of Supreme

^ £ata of Montana Petitioner,

V.

ORDER

JIM SALMONSEN, Warden, Montana State Prison, Respondent.

Robert Allen Boyden represents himself and has returned tothisCourtwitha Petition for Writ of Habeas Corpus. Boyden claims that he has a facially invalid sentence because he has already served it. He also raises a

claimforcreditfortimeserved while incarcerated in Idaho from 2019 to 2022. He states

that he was on parole during that time as well. Boyden includes attachments. Boyden believes that he is entitled to habeas corpus relief, arguing that the Records Bureau at the Montana State Prison has improperly and incorrectly calculated his sentence. Upon review, this Court does not reach that conclusion.

Boydenhasavalid sentence. This Court is familiar with Boyden's history. Boyden hashadfiveoriginal proceedings with this Court since 2007. See Boyden v. Mahoney^ No. OP 07-0318, Order dismissing his petition for a writ of habeas corpus

(Mont.Jul.11,2007) {Boyden/); Boyden v. State, No. OP 08-0440, Order denying his writofmandamus (Mont.Oct.1, 2008) {Boyden 77); Boyden v. Linder, No. OP 25-0048,

Order denyinghispetitionfor habeas corpus relief (Mont. May 13, 2025) {Boyden 777); andBoydenv.Salmonsen,No. OP 26-0345, Order denying his petition for a writ of habeas corpus (Mont. Jun. 9, 2026) {Boyden IV). This Petition is his second this year.

We provide his history, as previously detailed.

11/10/2026

Case Number: OP 26-0755

1

Beginning thirty years ago, on June 8, 1995, Boyden entered guilty pleas to misdemeanor theft, felony theft, and felony escape in the Custer County District Court. The District Court deferred imposition ofsentenceoftwo, concurrent, three-year terms for the felony convictions

(CauseNo.DC-1995- 3701) (first sentence). On February 27, 1997, the Yellowstone County District

Court accepted Boyden's guilty plea to accountability for

attempt (deliberate homicide) and sentenced him to the Montana State Prison

(MSP)fora sixty-year term, awarding credit for time served of 487days(CauseNo. DC 95-654) (sixty-year sentence). The Yellowstone County

District Court did not mention Boyden's first sentence. In less than two months, the Custer County District

Courthelda dispositional hearing on the State's Petition to Revoke thedeferred imposition of sentence for Boyden. In its written April 24,1997Orderof Final Sentence, the Custer County District Court revoked

the'sentenceand sentenced Boyden to MSP for a ten-year term for felony

thefttorun consecutively to his sixty-year sentence (first sentence upon revocation). In a May 2, 2012 Order Granting Withdrawal of Guilty Pleatoand Dismissing Count 3; Escape, the Custer County District

Court entertained Boyden's request for relief where the State responded thatBoyden's deferred imposition of sentence for felony escape (Count 3) hadsince expired.The District Court dismissed the conviction.

On December 21, 2016, the Yellowstone County District

Court committed Boyden to the Department of Corrections (DOC) forconcurrent terms-of ten years with five suspended for two counts offelony robbery (Cause No. DC-14-0954). The District Court awarded 725daysofcreditfor jail time served and ran the sentence consecutively tohissixty-year sentence. Boyden returned to the Custer County District Court forhabeas corpus relief in June 2020. Boyden argued that he received anillegal sentence upon revocation of his deferred sentence because oftheeffecton his parole eligibility due to the consecutive nature ofhisfirst sentenceupon revocation and the sixty-year sentence. The court explained:

"[Boyden] contends that although the two sentences run consecutively, hebegan serving the ten-year sentence [first sentence upon revocation] in2010,oncehe became parole eligible under the sixty-year sentence (byhaving served one-quarter of the sentence, or 15 years)." (Footnote

omitted.) Citingto § 46-18-40 l(l)(a), MCA (1995), the District Court

denied Boyden's petition for habeas corpus relief On March 5, 2025, the Custer County District Court

entertained Boyden's renewed Motion for Time Served and Correction andCompletion of Sentence. The District Court determined that Boyden had fully served his first sentence upon revocation after application of

Statev.Wolfblack,2024 MT 166, H 13, 417 Mont. 376, 553 P.3d 9.

2

Boyden III, at 1-2. We determined that due to the Custer

County District Court's recent Order, Boyden had received relief. Boyden now argues that he has discharged his 2016 sentence forthetworobbery convictions (Cause No. DC-14-0954). We conclude that he has not. He has only discharged his older, first sentence upon revocation. According to the attached sentence calculation which we also reviewed in Boyden III, Boyden began serving his sixty-year sentence on October 29, 1995, and earned good time credit. He discharged the sentence on October 21, 2025. He then began serving his consecutive sentence for the two robbery convictions on that day. With his credit for time served of almost two years, Boyden discharges his prison term on October 19, 2028. Boyden thenhasasuspended, five-year term to serve.

Boyden is not entitled to time in Idaho as credit for timeservedwhenhewasa parolee and placed there pursuant to the Interstate Compact. He cannot have credit applied retroactively from one sentence to another. The Yellowstone

County District Court explained that rationale in its February 9, 2026 Order Denying Boyden's Motion to Vacate or Expunge. Boyden argued that credit for a sentencing

error should apply retroactivelyto his sixty-year sentence. The District Court determined thatBoydenhadraisedtheissue previously, and the court had denied it in a November 3,2025Order. Boyden has not demonstrated an illegal sentence. He doesnothaveafacially invalid sentence. In Boyden IV, we cautioned Boyden

about seeking further reliefinthis Court for his sentences. "We caution Boyden in seeking

further reliefwithcollateral attacks upon any of his current sentences in this Court." Boyden IV, at 4. Accordingly,

IT IS ORDERED that:

1. Boyden's Motion for Writ of Habeas Corpus, deemed aPetitionforWritof Habeas Corpus, is DENIED and DISMISSED;

2. henceforth, prior to filing any original proceeding withthisCourt, Boydenis directed to submit a motion for leave to file the pleading. Themotionmustbe sworn under oath before a notary public, not exceed

three pagesinlength,and make a preliminary showing that the motion has merit andmeetsthecriteriato

3

state a prima facie case under M. R. App. P. 14(5). Only when this Court has reviewed the motion and issued an order granting leave to file may the Clerk of Court file the petition. The Clerk shall reject any other original petition that Boyden seeks to file and shall inform Boyden accordingly; and

3. this matter is CLOSED as of this Order's date. The Clerk is also directed to provide a copy of this

Ordertocounselofrecordand to Robert Allen Boyden personally.

DATED this iT') ^day of November, 2026. / hief Justice

Justices

4

Use AI to get other relevant cases.

Comments

Boyden v. Salmonsen
(Nov 10, 2026)