ORDER OF THREE-MONTH SUSPENSION
[¶1] This matter came before the Court upon a Report and Recommendation for Three- Month Suspension, filed herein March 5, 2026, by the Board of Professional Responsibility for the Wyoming State Bar. The Report and Recommendation was filed pursuant to Rule 12 of the Wyoming Rules of Disciplinary Procedure, which governs stipulated discipline. The Court, after a careful review of the Board of Professional Responsibility's Report and Recommendation and the file, finds that the Report and Recommendation should be approved, confirmed and adopted by the Court, and that Respondent Kent C. Cobb should be suspended from the practice of law for three months. It is, therefore,
[¶2] ADJUDGED AND ORDERED that the Board of Professional Responsibility's Report and Recommendation for Three-Month Suspension, which is attached hereto and incorporated herein, shall be, and the same hereby is, approved, confirmed, and adopted by this Court; and it is further
[¶3] ADJUDGED AND ORDERED that, as a result of the conduct set forth in the Report and Recommendation for Three-Month Suspension, Kent C. Cobb shall be suspended from the practice of law for three months, with the period of suspension to begin April 8, 2026; and it is further;
1
[¶4] ADJUDGED AND ORDERED that, during the period of suspension, Respondent shall comply with the requirements of the Wyoming Rules of Disciplinary Procedure, particularly Rule 21 of those rules. That rule governs the duties of disbarred and suspended attorneys; and it is further
[¶5] ORDERED that, pursuant to Rule 25 of the Wyoming Rules of Disciplinary Procedure, Mr. Cobb shall reimburse the Wyoming State Bar the amount of $50.00, representing the costs incurred in handling this matter, as well as pay the administrative fee of $750.00. Mr. Cobb shall pay the total amount of $800.00 to the Wyoming State Bar on or before April 17, 2026. If Mr. Cobb fails to make payment in the time allotted, execution may issue on the award; and it is further
[¶6] ORDERED that the Wyoming State Bar may issue the agreed press release contained in the Report and Recommendation for Three-Month Suspension; and it is further
[¶7] ORDERED that the Clerk of this Court shall docket this Order of Three-Month Suspension, along with the incorporated Report and Recommendation for Three-Month Suspension, as a matter coming regularly before this Court as a public record; and it is further
[¶8] ORDERED that, pursuant to Rule 9(b) of the Wyoming Rules of Disciplinary Procedure, this Order of Three-Month Suspension, along with the incorporated Report and Recommendation for Three-Month Suspension, shall be published in the Wyoming Reporter and the Pacific Reporter; and it is further
[¶9] ORDERED that the Clerk of this Court cause a copy of this Order of Three-Month Suspension to be served upon Respondent Kent C. Cobb.
[¶10] DATED this 8thday of April, 2026.
BY THE COURT:
/s/
LYNNE BOOMGAARDEN
Chief Justice
2
IN
THE
SUPREME COURT
STATE OF WYOMING
BEFORE THE SUPREME
COURT
FILED
STATE
OFWYOMING MAR5 2026
In the matter
of SHAWNA GO KENT
C.
COBB,
WSB #8-6998, BPRNo.2025-074
)
Respondent.
)
:
:
»CL
K
D-26-0001
REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONFOR
THREE-MONTH
SUSPENSION
THIS MATTERcamebeforeaReview PaneloftheBoardof
Professional Responsibility of the Wyoming State Bar ("BPR'') on February 19, 2026,forahearingviaZoom
teleconference pursuant to Rule 12,
W.R.Disc.P.
Review Panel members John
C.
Brooks (chair), Joelle Hadley- Day andTandy Dockerywereinattendance.The
Wyoming StateBarwas
representedbyBar Counsel, Mark W. Gifford. Respondent Kent C.Cobb("Respondent")aswellashis
counsel, Anna
Reeves-Olson, were
present. Based upon the parties'
Stipulation
for Three-Month
SuspensionandRespondent's Affi- davit of Conditional Admission, the Review
Panel
unanimously FINDS, CONCLUDESand RECOMMENDS as follows:
Findings of Fact
1. Respondent has been licensed to practice law in Wyoming since February
1,
2023, but was admitted to practice law in
1993.
As setforthin
detail below,
Respondent condi- tionally admits that he violated Rules 1.1,1.3,1.4and8.4(c) of theRules of
Professional Con- duct in his representation of Jennifer Randall inadebtcollection lawsuit.
3
2. On November 26, 2024, Discover Bank filed
suit against Jennifer
Randall in the Circuit Court for the Third Judicial District, Uinta
County, Wyoming,
seeking collection of $2,595.85.
3. Ms. Randall was
served with the summons
and complaint
on December 11, 2024. Under the Rules ofCivil ProcedureforCircuit
Courts,heranswertothecomplaintwas
required to be filed onor before December 31, 2024.
4. On December17,2024, Ms. RandallsentRespondentanemail with her case in- formation, including a copy ofthesummonsandcomplaint.Onthatday,Respondent
forwarded Ms. Randall's
emailandattachmentstohislegal assistant, Rachel McDaniel,withaforwarding note, "This is a LegalEASE case; sounds pretty simple. Wyoming. We
justneedtofileare- sponse within
about a week." Thus, itisclearthatanattorney-client
relationship was
formed with Ms. Randall on that date.
5. On
December 18, 2024, Ms. McDaniel responded to Respondent with an email stating, "Okay Iwill callthecounty clerktoseeifwe canemailtheanswer tomorrow."
Later the same day she sent Respondent anemail stating, "Just got off the phone withtheclerk
regard- ing this case. The
answercan
be mailedto:Ccevs@courts.state.wy.us. A
check
representinga$1 per page must be mailed tothecourt house."
6. On January 9; 2025, Ms. Randall sent Respondent an email stating, "This
is J en- nifer
Randall. Just making sure a responsewasfiled? Andwhatthenextsteps are?"
7. On January 10, 2025,
Respondent forwarded Ms. Randall's
email to Ms. McDan- iel with a transmittal note asking, "Didwe everdothis? The clientis
super superniceandis checking." That day, Ms. McDaniel e-filed a pro se answer for
Ms.
Randall.
8. On January 16, 2025, the court issued
an order setting a scheduling
conference in the case for February 24, 2025.
2
9. On January 27, 2025, Ms. Randall sent Respondent an email withacopy of the notice of setting, stating, "I received this in the mail today. Notsurewhatit means, orif I'm sup- posed to go to this
or if the lawyers just deal with it. Please let me know it mademereally
nerv- ous. Thanks so much."
10. On
February 7, 2025, Respondent sent Ms. Randall an email
stating, "Hey
Jen- nifer.
We
are trying to settle this, but you need to make sureandgotothishearing ifwedonot. Simply ask for a continuance because we are tryingtosettle this."
11. On February 21, 2025, RespondentsentMs. Randall an email
stating, "Jennifer - Remember to go to this hearing on Monday. Just askfora continuance,
becauseyour
settlement attorney is
negotiating."
Ms. Randall responded, "Perfect.Ihave is [sic] scheduled outtomake sure I'm there. Thank
you."
12. After the scheduling
conference, on the afternoon of
February 24, 2025, Ms. Ran- dall sent the following email to Respondent and Ms. McDonald:
"Attachedarepictures of what they gavemetoday. Theysetanew notice of
settingfor3/24/2025at2:00p.m.They told meto make sure that I get you to submit anentry of appearancetothecourtassoonaspossible before then. I'm not sure what that
is
but I told them I would. Attached is
the new notice of setting pa- per and the sticky note the judge had the court lady write. Thank
you." Attachedtotheemail were
copies of the new notice of setting as well asayellow stickynotewiththefollowing
hand- written note: "We need an Entry of Appearance filed by himtothecourt,next
hearing 3/24/252:00 p.m."
13. Ms. McDaniel responded to Ms. Randall's email with, "I will handle this today and send
you a copy. It hasto
be mailedtothe clerk." Ms. McDaniel
apparently failed to under- stand that Respondent's entry of appearance couldbee-filed.
3
14. Late in the afternoon
on February 24, 2025,
Respondent
chimed
into the email string, "I will havetoseeif they
charge for
that. Ifso,you
would
havetopay
for it.We
justneed to settle this. That's
the main thing. Because ifwe
don't settle it, you aregoing
to get a judgment against you."
15. Ms.
Randall
responded to Respondent's
emai! with, "I was told it's
justaformal declaration tothecourt thatyouarerepresentingmeasmy
attorney. WhichIassume was
already done since Iwas matched with
you in
DecemberandDiscover had been notified you are.But the court is asking for
it,soI'm
not sure. I'msureif
extra billing is
required you'd needtoreach out to legalEASE. Or I can if
you'd
prefer? I hope we can negotiate it
before then
as well,
that's just what the judge asked metoask you."
16. No
entry of
appearance was filed
on February
24, 2025. A
telephone calltothe clerk of
court's office
would have
confirmedthatthereisnofeeforfiling anentry of
appearance.
17. On March
24, 2025,
Respondent's
entry of
appearance was filed.
18. The March
24 scheduling
conference was
reset for April14,2025. On the after- noon ofApril14,2025, Respondentsent anemailtoMs. Randall
stating, "I'm
abouttogotothis hearing. What are you offeringtosettle this?" Ms. Randall
respondedafew
minutes
later, "I have noidea, whendoIneedtoknow by? If
it's today. Why amIjust being
asked? My
husband lost his job onthe 12",Ineedmore information onwhattheoptions are."
19. There was apparentlyatechnical glitch with the April14scheduling
conference. That
afternoon, Respondent sentanemailtoAmanda Lee,
counselforDiscover
Bank,
withthe subject line, "Sorry forthetechnical
issues: "I
was actuallyonthehearing ontime,but noone ever let me. The
client, Ms. Randall, would like tooffer
$80/month for24monthstosettle this."
20. Ms. Lee
respondedtoRespondent's
emailafew
minutes later, stating, "It sounds like they willbereachingouttoustorescheduletheCMC [case
management conference]in
4
about 30 days. If you have anoffertosendover, you
can forward the offer,
total monthly in- come, total monthly expenses, anda description of your client's
hardship informationtoof- fers@jrllawoffice.com. Youcanccme ontheemail ifyou
would like, butroutingit
directlyto this
department
is themost efficient because it goes directlytomy
legal assistants thatactually send the offers on to the client."
21. Later intheafternoon of
April14,2025,
Respondent sentanemailtoMs. Lee with the subject
line, "Offerfor
Jennifer Randall": "Yes,thatis theoffer.
$80/monthfor24 months. Client is disabled and
has nogarnishable income orassets."
22. Ms. Lee
respondedtoRespondent's
email two days
later,onApril 16,2025, ask- ing,
"Is
she able to do payments of $87.00for 24monthsforatotal settlement of
$2,088.00?"
Ms. Lee's email
promptedaflurry of emails
between Respondent, Ms. Lee andMs. Randall,as detailed below.
23. Respondent forwarded Ms. Lee's
emailtoMs. Randall
with the note, "See note below. Do you
accepttheoffer?"
respondedtoRespondent's email five
minutes
later, stating, "Yeah that works forme, did they rejectthelump sum offer?"
25. A few
minutes after Respondent received
Ms. Randall's
email,
Respondent
re- sponded to Ms. Lee's
email with, "Theyarealso offerings [sic] $1500
lump sumtosettle it." It is apparent from these last two emails thatMs. Randallhadauthorized Respondenttomakealump sum offer of $1,500.00 which Respondent failedtoconvey
promptly.
26. Ms. Lee
respondedtoRespondent's
email six minutes
later, stating, "I already have approval forthe $2,088 in24months,so Iwould
prefertogetyour client's
acceptance or rejection of that offer before submittinganewlump sumoffertomy client. Iunderstandthat your client's income may likelybeallexemptfrom
garnishment,butIwould still needtothe
5
amount ofmonthly income and monthly expenses and hardship information
in ordertosubmit your
client's
lump sum offer.
Please let me know if your
client would like to accept the settle- ment over 24 months, and if so what date she would like her payments due soIcansendovera proposed agreement for her signature,
or
alternatively if she would
prefer to provide the income, expense, and hardship information I need to submit her lump sum offer to Discover."
27. Respondent responded to Ms. Lee twelve minutes later with, "Let's dothe24 months."
28. One minute later, Respondent sent the following email to Ms. Randall: "Appar- ently they rejected that. You can always pay this offer. But it gets you
24
months ofno interest. Let's accept
this offer and then she can still go back and try to talk her client into accepting the lump sum." Respondent apparently neglected to inform Ms. Randall at this time what infor- mation Discover Bank would need in
order to consider a lump
sum
offer.
29. Ms. Lee then responded to Respondent's email, stating, "What date shouldIlist for the payments to be due? Typically they would want to see the first
payment of this month yet, but if that's
not possible for your
client,
I
would
need to have payments
start by May
15"at
the very latest. Ifwe go out as far as
May 15™
for the first payment, please stress to your client the importance ofus receiving that first payment on time because I must have the first payment in- house
by
that date."
30. Next, Respondent sent an email to Ms. Randall, asking, "Will you makethefirst payment by April
30?" Ms. Randall responded a few minutes
later, stating, "Yeah. I'd have to know how and where. But
yeah."
Thus ends the email communication between Respondent,Ms. Randall and Ms. Lee on April 14,
2025.
6
31. More
than two weeks later,onApril 29, 2025, Ms. RandallsentRespondentan email asking, "T still need to know how tomakethefirst payment if it's duetomorrow?"
Re- spondent responded with, "Thenotebelow hastheir
address."
32. Clearly
confused,
Ms. Randall responded, "The only waytopayisthroughthe mail to a law firm? I guess IcanorderacheckbookbutIhavenoway togetareceiptthatway.Is there a settlement document somewhere?"
33. Approximatelyonehour later,at8:03p.m.Central Time, Respondent
responded to Ms. Randall, "For atleast the first one, until you
can work it
out with them, just go getacash- iers check from my [sic] convenience
store. Takeapicture of
it."
34. Ms. Randall
replied five minutes
later, asking, "Okay,
canIgetthesettlement documents? Don'tIneedtosign something?" Respondent
respondedafew
minutes
later, "No, you don'tneedtosignanything. In this
case,theemailfromtheopposing counselis allwe need."
35. On May6,2025, Ms. Lee
filedamotion for summary judgmentonDiscover Bank's
behalf. Undertherules of civil procedureforcircuit courts,Ms.Randall's
responsetothe motion was due onorbefore June4,2025. There is noevidence thatRespondent informed Ms. Randall thatthe motionhadbeenfiled,itspotential
consequencesorherduty torespond.
36. At 9:23 p.m. Central
Time onMay15,2025, Respondent sentMs. Randallan email stating, "Did you make thatfirst payment? I just
wanttomake sureyou have everything worked out.Otherwise, you're
goingtohavetogotothishearing."Itisunclearwhat"hearing"
Respondent was referring to, as therewerenoupcoming hearingsinthecase.
37. Ms. Randall respondedat9:42 p.m., "Isentittotheaddress intheemail, thelaw firm (it's theonly address there was),Ididn'tsendit
certified mailsoIhavenoideaiftheygot it or
how
to even tell?"
7
38. Respondent repliedat11:06p.m., "Go
aheadandemail
themorcallthemand see if they
gotit."
39. Ms. Randall respondedafew minutes
later, "I will,
thank you
again."
40. On May19,2025, Respondent sentthefollowing
emailtoMs. Randall: "Jennifer, I went to this hearing today. They tried to get a summary judgment because you had not sent your payment? Did you mailitintotheopposing
counsel? When we talkedafew daysago, Iun- derstood that's
what you were goingtodo.Igot this
continued until June23at2o'clock. Ihave not seen any agreement thattheysentme,
but theyaregoingtosend me one,andyou
also
need to mail in the payment to them."
41, Ms. Randall
responded, "Okay, Iwill
callthenumber inthatemail whenIcan, unfortunately I'm
chaperoningatTeton
science
for mysonandthey don't allow
electronicstobe turned onduring certain hourssoit's
been hardtocheck
emails. I'1lalso check uspstoseeif it got sent back while I've beengone.Ican send
another check Friday
whenIgetback. Ireally don't want to send another$80withoutanyclue iftheyregettingit,how tocheck my
balance etc. If you could send me anagreement that would help me feel more comfortable with all this. Also awaytopayonline iftheyhaveit
because I'll justbehonestI'mnotgoingtorememberto get a cashiers check
every monthandsnail mail it."
42. The same
afternoon,
Ms. Lee sentRespondent thefollowing email: "I think the confusion this
afternoonwasover theterms of theagreement never
getting finalized. We were supposed to getanexactduedateforthepayments in
ordertodraft anagreementandIwas
sup- posed to have the first
payment
by May
15"atthelatest. The
email string below is
where my records indicate things
dropped off. I
can trytoget re-approval forthesettlement
terms, butthe payments would reallyneedtostart in May.Isthatstill
possible? Ifso,whatdatecanyour client make payments by eachmonth?"
Ms. Lee's
referencetothe"email string below" istotheemail
8
communication between RespondentandMs. LeeonApril16,2025(seeitem28above). There is no evidence that Respondent
ever respondedtoMs. Lee's
earlier email. 43, Then Respondent simply handedtheproblem overtoMs. Randall.
Respondent forwarded Ms. Lee's email to Ms. Randall, stating, "Jennifer,Iamhaving you
respondtothe email questions below. I don't needtobe inthemiddle of that, andIneedyouto setthepayment date and arrange payments with the opposing counsel."
44. Ms. Randall's
initial responsetoRespondent's
email reiteratedherearlier re- quests for a signed
settlement agreement:
Hi Kent,
Thank you for forwardingthemessages. Before Iproceed withany
additional payments, I'd liketorequestaformal, signed
agreement that outlinestheterms, payment
structure,andobligationsfor both parties. While I understandthatemails candocument discussions, I'mnot comfortable moving forward
based solelyonforwarded
correspondence - espe- cially
given that this involvesanofficial court case. Additionally, I noticed the paymentisbeing
directedtothelaw firmrather than Discover.
Withoutaformal
agreement clearly stating thattheyaretheproper en- tity to receive
payment, I'm hesitanttoproceed.Iwanttoensure everythingis handled properly,
transparently,andwiththeappropriate documentation. I'm happy to accept the termsonceIreceiveaformal
documentthatclearly out- lines how topay,whotoaddressthepaymentto,andwho will
legally ownthe settled debt. Please let me know whenI canexpect thefinalized
agreement,and I'll review it promptly.
45. On the evening ofMay 19, 2025, havinghadtheopportunitytoreview thecon- tents of Respondent's April 16, 2025,
email communication with Ms. Lee, Ms. Randall sentRe- spondent the following email:
Hi Kent,
After reviewing the email correspondence betweenyouandopposing
counsel,I notice
something deeply troubling. InAmanda Lee's
email dated April16,she made it clear thata lump sumhardship offer
could stillbesubmitted ifIprovided
9
information about my income, expenses,
and overall financial situation. She spe- cifically asked
for this in order to proceed with that option. However, you told me that the lump sum offer had already been rejected,andat no point did
you
mention I could still pursue a hardship settlement by
submitting this information. Given that my husband had just lost his job, and I've
undergone several back surgeries in the last few years leaving me unable to returntoworkas of yet, I
believe
I have absolutely qualified for this option had you
presenteditto me when she asked.
I
also wrote about my hardships in my first email to you with the initial document served to me Dec 17". I have since undergone additional hardship with household
job loss before that email
was
sent to you.
I
need to understand why this was never communicated to me. The
failure to in- form me of this option -
on that could have drastically reduced my
financialand emotional
burden -
feels like a serious oversight, ifnot outright negligence. This entire
process
has caused me significant anxiety, and I trusted you toinform me of all my options. Please provide a clear
explanation ofwhy this
hardship
op- tion was not discussed or pursued when it was clearly offered
by
opposing
coun- sel.
46. Respondent responded to Ms. Randall's
email thesameevening:
I did communicate that to you. We communicated that to you in the first email communication, and then in subsequent communications. That's always anop- tion. But you said you had nothing lump sum to offer. You can
always get
the best
offers in a lump
sum, including right now. We always
make the known in the very first communication we everhavewith you, and
we did. Look at the
email. It's still an
option. We even prefer it because we can get the best deal.Butyou said
you didn't have
any lump sum
to offer.
47. Several minutes
later,
Respondent added: ""'P.S. Your very low
lumpsumoffer was rejected. Then you
could not raise it, you
said."
48. Ms. Randall replied, Hi Kent,
I
reviewed our recent correspondence and want to point
some thing out for clarification.
10
You statedthatthelump sumhardship offerwas
rejectedandthatIhadsaid I had nothing to offer. However, in your own
emailtoopposing
counsel dated April 16 at 10:04 AM,you
wrote: "Theyarealsooffering $1500lump sumto settle it." This confirms thatthelumpsumwas
not rejected -
it was
presentedas an active
option. Moreover, Amanda Lee's
follow-up message madeit
clearthat shewaswaiting on financialandhardship information from metoproceed with thatoffer. That request was
never shared withme.If it
had been, Iwould have gladly provided that information, asIstated in my emailandearlier
communication. At this point,Ineedtounderstandthefollowing:
11
A few
minutes later, Respondent added:
P.S. Ihavenoincentivetowithholdanyinformation fromyouornotgetthelow- est possible
settlement.
It actually helps me if you get
metheinformation more quickly. When
theseget
drawnout,and aclient tellsmetheyhave
nothing else more theycanoffer,andthenwill provide
detailed
hardship information ...
it does nothelp anyone. Again, like I say, nothinghas beenfinalized. If youhavehardship infor- mation, and they are feeling
generous, it
wouldbeawesome if you can come up with a lump sumI canoffer them. But youhavenever told mewhat that is, and wecan't play
games with them.
50. Ms. Randall replied:
Hi Kent,
Attached is the screenshot of your
messagefromApril16,where youtold methe lump sumoffer was
"apparently rejected."
This
directly
contradicts Amanda Lee's message senttoyoujust18minutes prior, which clearly
statedthatahard- ship sum could still be
considered if
financial
information was provided. Nowhere did you explain thatIcould still pursuethatoption by
submitting
documentation. Your current claim - thatyou"beggedme"forthatinformation andI've been the one delaying -
does not matchthewritten record. Atnopoint did you
explain what was
needed for thehardship offer orindicate
itwasstillonthetable. In- stead, you said it was
already rejected andimmediately shifted me towardthe monthly plan.
This is not a matter of miscommunication -
it's aclear failuretorelayacritical financial option thatopposing counsel explicitly
offered.Iamprovidingthis asa documented example ofmy
concernandwill be including it in my
formal
com- plaint. PS reply: Final ClarificationonHardship OptionandCommunication Breakdown I understand your
position, but the record is
clear. You told me
the lump sum of- fer was
rejected full stop. You never explained thatahardship-basedlumpsum was still available
pendingthesubmission of
financial
documentation,even though Amanda Lee
outlinedthatexact option inherApril16emailtoyou. You didn't
forwardthatemailtomeuntiloveramonth later, andonly
afterI asked for verification ofthesettlement terms. Atnopoint did you give me in- structions to submit
hardship information pastwhat you asked metoinclude in my very first
email -
whichIdid - nordidyouclarify thatthe$1,500 lump sum was conditional orimprovable based ondocumentation.
12
This
isn't about incentives - thisis
about informed representation.Iwasnever given thechance tomakeaninformed choice.Ididn't evenknowitwasn't re- jected until you
askedmetodoyour
job
for you by
forwardingmetheir emails and I'm now in a worse financial and legal position because of it. Youmay
be- lieve you communicated effectively,butIhaveemails showingyou toldmethis option
was off the table when it was not. **
Screenshot of you telling me it was "apparently rejected" and first email
out- lining hardship like you requestedinourconsultation. If youhaveanydocumen- tation that you asked meabout hardship outside oftheemails I've scoured, I'd love to see them?
51. Having been called out on his
misstatements, Respondent changed tack:
P.P.S.
Nothing has beensettled orfinalized,sotherehasbeennoeffect onyour finances or other
elements. I looked back through some of the correspondence, and I see what you
are saying. I talk to opposing counsel on the phone,
and there was
something that she said that made me think they
were goingtoaccept it regardless. I
may
have
gotten mixed up on it myself. Fortunately,
it has not had any financialor[sic] impact onyou,because if they would accept it, based onwhat you provide, they still will. So here's what
we need youtodo,for sure: Provide yourbesthardship situation. And then what you can
offerinterms
of lumpsum. I definitely want to help
vou.
and it's
possible I may have mixed up communica- tion, but I definitely
would never tryto.Fortunately, ithashadnoimpact. These cases take forever.
52. Ms. Randall's
response:
Kent,
Thank you foryourfollow-up.
I
appreciate you acknowledging that there may have been amiscommunication or mix-up regarding the lump sumhardship
settlement. That said,thedirect
state- ment thatit had been "rejected" was
presentedtomeasfinal, which
understanda- bly influencedmydecisions andcaused agreatdealof stress.
I
was never told that the hardship information could stillbesubmitted before to- day's correspondence, norwasIaskedforitafterthatApril16exchange. Iwould have absolutely provided it, andIfind it
deeply concerningthatsuchanimportant
13
option
was
not communicated clearly -
especially whenthewritten email from opposing counsel made thepathforward very
clear. Regardless of whether the matteristechnically "finalized,"thisdelayandlack of communication had a significant emotionalandprocedural impactonme,which could havebeenavoided with
clearer guidance.Ialsowanttherecordtoreflect that I
did not feel properly informed
throughouttheprocess.
53. In response, Respondent
stated:
Believe me, I try my best to communicateasbestas Ipossiblycan.Youhave been going through financial stress for many years
beforeIever even
met you, and I
didn't have anythingtodowith
any of that.Ifeel bad for you and your
fam- ily but I did not have any impactonthat. If you would like tofindsomeoneelsetoreachandfinalize theagreementwith them, that's fine. You
still have never told me what you could offerthemin terms of the 2" lump sum offer which, as Iunderstandit,isgoingtobeneeded. Again, everything existsjustasitalways has.Nothinghaschanged. You haveto still provide all of the information,andtheyhave notpromisedtoaccept anything in particular.
Just let me know ASAP. Ican'tkeepspendingtimeonthis. I'm
losing money on this big time.Icanwithdraw
tomorrow if you would like.
54. Ms. Randall had clearly had enough. She wrote:
Dear Kent,
This
message servesasformal
noticethatIamterminatingyourlegal
representa- tion, effective
immediately.Inolongerfeelthatmy
legal interests have been ade- quately represented, and Ihave documented multiple instances of serious mis- communication, lack of
diligence,andprofessional misconduct
throughoutthe course of your handling ofmy case. My reasons for terminatingthisrelationship includebut arenotlimitedtothefol- lowing:
¢
Failure to timely file with
the court
after I first contacted you on December 17, 2024, resulting in my
appearing unrepresentedatinitial hearings. *
Failure to file a formal Notice of Appearance with the court formonths,
despite repeated notices and my
own effortstoaddress
the issue. *
Repeated delegation of legal duties to me, including
instructing me to attend court hearings alone and communicate with opposing
counsel directly. *
Misrepresentation of
settlement options, including
telling me a lump sum offer was "rejected," when opposing
counselhadin
fact requested financial
14
documentation to pursue it further. This
cause unnecessary stress anddeprived me of aninformed decision. «
Requesting that I send payment to the law firm
rather
than Discover
without providing a signed
settlement agreement clearly
outliningtheterms,evenafter opposing counsel requested formal
documentation. This
leftmefully
unpro- tected and legally vulnerable. *
Dismissive,
contradictory, and gaslighting responses when I questioned your handling ofmy case.
Mischaracterizing a court-related letter -
clearly
addressedtoyourlawoffice as having been "accidentally mailed to you instead of me,"
which
further de- layed my
understanding
of thecaseandmisledmeregardingitslegal signifi- canice.
This
experiencehashadasignificantandlastingtollonme.As
someonewith panic disorder, ADHD,anddegenerative disc
disease,Isought legal
representa- tion in hopes of
reducing my anxiety andprotecting my
stability.
Instead,Iwas repeatedly putin
confusingandhigh-pressure situations thatworsened my
mental health and left
me feeling
abandoned during analready vulnerable
time. WhatI needed was guidance andclarity. WhatIreceived
was dismissalandblame. I am requesting that you send me a complete digital copy ofmy
file,
including all communications with Discover's
counsel, all filings,andany
documents related to proposed settlements. Please send this
no later than May
24, 2025.
Additionally, Iwillbefilingaformal complaintwiththeWyoming
StateBar, Veritas Legal Plan, andLegalEASE regarding yourconduct andtheharmcaused by yourrepresentation. Iwillbesubmitting
supporting documentation including email correspondence, screenshots, andrecorded phone conversations. If you
be- lieve there is anything materialthatshouldbe
considered beforeIproceed,you may
reply. I will also be informing
opposing
counsel that I am now
self-represented moving forward, to ensure all future communications andcasematters arehandled di- rectly.
Finally, your lastmessagetome -
implyingthatmy
financial
hardshipoverthe past two years from a severe condition somehow
excuses orjustifiestheconfu- sion and stress your
representationhascause - was notonly
unprofessional, but deeply manipulative. Suggesting thatyou
have "lost
money"
by
representing me and that I am "wasting
your time" is
both cruel and inappropriate, especially given the repeated failurestoproperly inform,
support,oradvocateforme throughout this
process. The language youusedwas dismissive,
emotionally in- validating, and servedonlytoshift blame anddiminish my very realconcerns.
55. Twenty minutes
later, Respondent replied:
Jennifer,
15
I do not have any digital copies of anything you have
not seen,andI will not be providing youwithanything further. I have spent an extra extraordinary [sic] amount of time on your relatively
small case. And now you are complaining. Everything that was available is still availa- ble to you, but
yet you complain. You haveeverythingthat
is
there exceptforphone communicationswith
oppos- ing counsel, which were important. Phone communicationswith
opposing
counsel affected what I told you and I told you everythingI
had inthebestpossible way. I will be more than eager to explain the major work my paralegal and I did on this case -
to the Wyoming Bar Association, LegalEASE, Veritas oranyone
else. A while back, my paralegal asked me why I was spending somuchtimeontis
case. My work has done nothing but benefit you.Thatiseasytoprove. As youyourselfmentionedatdifferent points,youhave beenunder stressfrom your own family personal
situations that have nothing to dowithme. For a relatively small case, I have been to multiple
hearingsandspent anextraor- dinary amount of time going back-and-forth between you andthecreditors [sic] representative. You may not care at all whetherIhave lost moneyonthiscase, but that is not considerate of you.
Regardless, you can complain aboutmeallyouwant,butitdoesnotaffect that fact that I did a good job for you. My
paralegal and opposing
counsel knowit. At yourrequest, I
will be withdrawingfromthiscasetomorrow.
56. Respondent ended the May 19, 2019, email
conversation with Ms. Randall on the following note:
See below -
I stated to you that they had rejected your $1,500
offer, which they did, without other financialandhardship info. And youhadnotprovided any hardship info that I hadnot
told them
already. I didn't want you to get a judgment, soyouand Iboth
agreedthatyouwould accept their 24 pay offer and then try to get the opposing
counseltotalk
their client into accepting the $1,500lumpsum,whichtheyearlier
rejected. Weare still atthat
stagenow,but atyourrequestIamwithdrawing.
57. Two days later, on May 21, 2025,
Respondent sent the following
email to Ms. Randall:
16
I am
withdrawing
today. As you know,
your case is settled with the interest-free payments, at a
20%
reduction,over2years. Unless you
purposely
sabotage that, and we are not responsible for that. Second, once you madethefirst
payment, weweregoingtostart pressingthemto do a lump sum settlement and specifically
said thattoyou
in writing. We
simply were going to have to have
other information from you
(thoughIhadtoldthem you had no garnishable incomeandonlyoneincome)andthenwe weregoingto press for a lump sum offer.
58. A few minutes
later, Respondent added, "TI
also let the Opposing Counsel know I am withdrawing
today."
59. Ms. Randall replied:
Dear Mr. Cobb,
As I previously statedinmyformal termination letter,Iamnolongeryourclient and respectfully request no further contact unless it directly pertains toproviding my complete case file.
Please ensure that all
documents, including
communications with opposing
coun- sel and any
filings
related to my caseincluding
your withdrawal withthecourts, are sent to me by May 25" 2025,asoriginally requested. Any further communication
unrelatedtothis
request willbeconsidered unwel- come.
60. A few minutes later Respondentsent anemailtoMs. Randall from Ms. McDan- iel's
email addressthatstated:
Hello Ms. Randall, We understandthatyouarefeeling
frustratedandupset aboutthecurrent state of your case, and we want totakeamomenttoaddress your
concerns withthecare and attention they deserve. First, we
want to reaffirm thatyourcaseiscurrentlysetupwithaninterest-free payment plan, which includesa
20%
reduction overatwo-year period. It's
im- portant tonote that this
arrangement will
remain in effect unless
therearedeliber- ate actions that could jeopardize it. We
are committed to ensuring
that you are not held responsible for any
unforeseen issues thatmay arise. Once opposing
counsel received
your initial payment, ourintention was toac- tively pursue a lump-sum
settlementonyourbehalf.This plan
communicatedto
17
you in writing, highlightingthatwe would
require additional information from you to proceed effectively. We wanttoreassure you thatitwas
conveyedtoop- posing
counselthatyou havenogarnishable income andrely solely ononesource of income.
We wantto clarifythatatnopointdidwe
misrepresentthesettlement offers. For several months, you
expressedadesire forastructured monthly
payment plan, and that is precisely
what
we
pursued with opposing
counsel. On April14,prior to your hearing, we
reachedouttoyoutodiscuss potential of- fers for settlingthecase. We
understand thatyou were feeling uncertain, particu- larly
giventherecent joblossyourhusband experienced. We
providedyouwitha general outline of possible offers,andwe entered the hearing with
yourbestinter- ests in mind. Following
our discussions,aproposed offer of $80
per month for
24
months was
made, which reflects roughlya
25%
reduction. Two days later, on April 16,wereceivedacounteroffer fromtheopposing coun- sel for payments of $87 per month over the same 24-month
period. We
promptly communicated this toyouandinquired whether you would accept theoffer. Your response indicated that
it was acceptable, andyou asked
aboutthestatus ofthe lump-sum offer. We noted thatherphrasing
suggestedsomeflexibility,assheex- pressed a preference while also indicatingawillingness todiscuss
further options. Throughout this process,
therehasbeenconsiderable back andforth among multi- ple parties, andwe focused onmaintainingapositive rapport with
opposing coun- sel to facilitate
future negotiations
regardingthelump sum.My
earlier remark about "apparently they rejected
that"
was in referencetothe opposing counsel's reluctance to submit a lump-sum offer
until
we
reachedasettlementonthe monthly payments. Given your
preferenceforthispayment method, especially considering your husband's
recent job loss, we believed
it prudenttoacceptthe current
offer. This strategy would allowustokeep
the lines of
communication open with the opposing counsel, potentially leading
hertoadvocate
foralump- sum acceptance later. We want to emphasize thatitwasspecifically statedthatpursuingalumpsum was still a possibility,
includingthelumpsumthattheopposing counsel was hesi- tant to submit until
we
reachedanagreement on the payment plan. Our intention has always beentowork towards thatlump
sum for you,andwe believed
this was communicated clearly. We understand thatitcanbeeasytonitpick details within
multiple emailex- changes, especially giventherapid back andforth among
threeorfour parties. We wantto assureyouthattherewasabsolutely nointentiononmyparttowith- hold a lump sumoffer from you. WhileImaynotalways
express myself perfectly in every word or paraphrase, my focushasbeenonconveyingthestrategy that would ultimately benefit you. We recognize thatImissedthecontradiction inthe
18
opposing counsel's language, butmy commitment
remainedtopursue thebest possible outcome without any
intentiontomisrepresentthesituation. In fact, the current arrangement provides you withtheflexibilitytomanage your payments
interest-free for two years, whichisespecially
important given your husband's job situation. Regarding your concerns
about timely filingsandrepresentation,wewanttoclar- ify a few key points:
We did not fail to timelyfilewiththecourts. Asapresumed
referral,wedonot have prior knowledge of
potential cases until theyarereferredtous.We arenot required to do any work on our law
partner referralsthatarenotcovered
underthe member benefits. This is
sometimesatimely process toverify
what servicesare covered. Furthermore, our commitment is to assessthefacts
before making any decisions. Inmany instances, including yours, we provide
guidance without
for- mal representation. In your case, wehaveprovided legal
representation for over five months, paying out of
pocketforfiling fees,andattending hearingswithno compensation to date.
Under Wyoming law, specifically Wyo. Stat. § 1-21-201(b), therules regarding small
claims do not require defendants to fileanansweroranyresponsive plead- ings inresponse to a claim. The statute explicitly statesthatinsmall claims ac- tions, the defendant is notobligatedtorespondtotheclaim unlessthecourt
orders otherwise. This provision is
designedtosimplifytheprocess for
defendantsand encourage resolution without the need for formal pleadings. Additionally, Wyo. Stat. § 1-21-201(c) further emphasizes thatsmall claims pro- ceedings are intendedtobeinformalandexpeditious, allowing partiestopresent their cases without the complexities often associated with
traditional litigation. This means that if you choose nottofileananswer, thecourt will
still proceed with the case. It
is
important to be aware of your
rightsandoptions
in these proceedings. While it is not mandatory to file ananswer,maystill choosetodosoif youwishtopre- sent your side of the case
or challenge the claims made against you.
2. When you reached out to us in December 2024, Wyoming had not yet imple- mented remote hearings. As wearenotphysically located in Wyoming, we are unable to attend the hearings youhadscheduled for January. Duringourconver- sation, you expressed that you did not want to incurtheexpense ofhiring local appearance counsel. As a result, we advised you torequestacontinuance, which you successfully did. Subsequently, Kentwasabletoattendyour
later hearings once remote hearings became available.
3. We want to clarify that you
did not have to attend the hearing "alone."
We
in- formed
you
that hiring appearance counsel wasanoption,butyou decided against
19
that. Our goal was to provide you with the best possible guidance andoptions while respecting your preferences
and financial
considerations. 4, Additionally, we would like to addressthenature of
settlement
agreements in cases like yours. It is common for the emails exchanged
between attorneysto serve as the basis of the agreement, often without a formal
settlement document being drafted. In my experience overtheyears, we estimate thatin over50%of the cases, an actual written settlement document was not
created. We had notseen any settlement document from the opposing
counsel,andwe wantedtoensure that the agreement was not withdrawnduetoany missed
paymentsonyour part. Therefore, we recommended, as we have with many other clients,thatyougo ahead andsend
the payment.
This
often helpsto"lock
in" the agreement by demonstrating your commitment withthefirst payment. Kindly find
opposing counsel contact information below, and be advisedthatthepaymentscanbemade directly on Rodenburg Law Firm's
(opposing counsel) website atthefollowing web address:
https://payrodenburg.com/payment#/payment/legalDisclaimer Opposing Counsel Co [sic]
Amanda Lee
Rodenburg Law
Firm
300 N.P. Avenue, Suite 105 P.O. Box 2427
Fargo, ND 58108-2427 aleewiebolt@rlawoffice.com We hope this clarifiesourpositionandthestepswehave
takenonyour
behalf. Your concerns are valid, andwewanttoensurethatyoufeel
supportedandin- formed every step of the way.
Under Wyoming law, specifically Wyo. Stat. §16- 22-308, a client has a righttoterminatetheattorney-client
relationshipatany
time, and an attorney must comply withtheclient's
request to withdraw
from
represen- tation. We respect your decision and will ensurethatthetransition is
handled smoothly and professionally. There is anupcoming Case Management Conference scheduleinyourcase thatis set at the following date, location and time:
"The hearing is setforthe
[sic]
6/23/2025at2:00PMattheCircuit Court ofthe Third Judicial District, Uinta County, 2259" Street Evanston, Wyoming
82930."
A copy of the above hearing notice,theentryofappearance, answer,andformal withdrawal are attached for
your records. Please feel free to reach out if you have any further questions orif you would like to discuss your options moving forward.
20
Warm regards, Kent Cobb Law, P.C. The email contains
misrepresentations,
misstatementsandinaccuracies whicharefurther detailed below.
61. On May 28, 2025. the Office of Bar Counsel (OBC)
received Ms. Randall's
com- plaint against Respondent. The OBC asked herforadditional information.
62. On June 9, 2025 -
several days afterthedeadlinetofilearesponsetoDiscover Bank's
motionforsummary judgmenthadpassed thecourt
enteredanorder granting Respond- ent's motion for leave to withdraw. There isnoevidencethatRespondent provided Ms. Randall with a copy of the motion for summary judgment,
informedherofthedeadlinetorespond or ad- vised her of the potential consequences ofnotresponding. Misrepresentations, MisstatementsandInaccuracies intheMay 21Email
63. "We did notfail to timelyfile with the
courts. a"
Respondentdidnot timely filean answer on Ms. Randall's
behalf.
Respondentdidnottimely fileanentry of appearance. Re- spondent neglected to file a response to Discover Bank's
motion
for summary judgment. The t
only thing Respondent timely filed was his
motiontowithdraw.
64. "We are not requiredtodoany workonour law partner
referralsthatare not covered
underthememberbenefits.Therecordisclear thatRéspondent formedalawyer-client relationship with Ms. Randall on December17,2024(seeitem4above). From thatdateforward, Respondent was required to abide by theRules of Professional Conduct inhis
representation of Ms. Randall, includingthedutyof
diligence (Rule 1.3)andthedutytocommunicate with thecli- ent (Rule 1.4).
65. "Under Wyoming law, specificallyWyo.Stat.
§
1-21-201(b), therules regarding small
claimsdonotrequire
defendantstofileananswerorany
responsive pleadingsinresponse
21
to
a claim. The
statute explicitly
states
that in small claims
actions,
the defendant is
not obligated to respond to the claim unless
the court orders
otherwise. This provision is designed
to
simplify the process for defendants and
encourage
resolution without the needfor formal pleadings. a" This was notasmall claims
court case.
66. "Under
Wyoming law, specifically Wyo.Stat.
§
1-21-201(b), therules regarding small claims donotrequire
defendantstofileanansweroranyresponsive pleadings inresponse to a claim.
The statute explicitly states
that
in small
claims
actions, the defendant is
not obligated to respondtothe claim
unless the court
orders
otherwise. This provision is designedto
simplify the process for
defendants and
encourage
resolution without the needforformal
pleadings. "
Be- cause this was notasmall claims
court case,theRules ofCivil
Procedure for Circuit
Courts
re- quired that a timely
answertothecomplaintbefiled.
67. "When you
reached outtousinDecember 2024, Wyoming hadnotyet
imple- mented remote hearings. Remote hearings in
all Wyoming
circuit courts were implemented by 2021 atthelatest.
68. "Additionally, wewould liketoaddressthenature
of settlement agreementsin cases like yours. Itis
common fortheemails exchanged
between attorneys toserveas thebasis of theagreement, often without aformal
settlement document being drafted.In myexperience over the years,weestimatethatinover 50%
of thecases,anactual
written
settlement document was not
created. Wehadnot seenany
settlement documentfromtheopposing
counsel, andwe wanted to ensurethattheagreement wasnotwithdrawnduetoany
missed paymentsonyour part. "
The
reason Respondenthadnotseenany
settlement documentfromMs.Leeis thatRe- spondent failedtorespondtoher email asking
whatdateMs. Randall
would like her payments due so Ms. Lee could "send overaproposed
agreement for Ms. Randall's
signature," or alterna- tively ifMs.
Randall "would
prefertoprovidetheincome,
expense, andhardship informationI
22
need to
submit
her lumpsumoffer toDiscover" (see item 29 above). Similarly, Respondent failed to
inform Ms.
Randall thatshe had theoption ofproviding
income,
expense andhardship informationthatwouldneed toaccompany any lump sumsettlement
offer.
69.
"Under
Wyoming law,
specificallyWyo.Stat.
§
16-22-308, aclient
has arightto terminate the
attorney-client relationship at anytime, andanattorneymustcomply with thecli- ent's
requesttowithdraw from representation. " When Bar
Counsel asked Respondent
about the reference to
Wyo.
Stat. § 16-22-308, Respondent statedthe
statute "deals with the
recovery of attorney's feesin civil actions
relatedtocontractorspecific
types of
commercial claims."
Actu- ally, thereisnoWyo. Stat. § 16-22-308.
Respondentwent on toassert thattheemail
shouldin- stead have referenced "044-32 Wyo.
Code
R.Section
32-9 -
Appearances andWithdrawals. This regulation details the
specific
stepsanattorneymust takewhenfiling a
motion towithdraw from a
contested case, including providing reasonable efforts
to give
actual
notice
to the client about the
withdrawal and
its implications." In point of
fact,
044-32
Wyo.
Code R.Section
32-9 is areg- ulation
applicable to
contested
cases
before the
Wyoming
Insurance
Department. The
proper ci- tation is WY RulesandRegulations
044-0002.32 §9(325).It hasnoapplication whatsoeverto withdrawals fromcircuit
court
proceedings. Respondent's
assertions onthispoint raise signifi- cant questions
regarding his
competence aswellashis honesty.
70.
As
evidenced by
his affidavit of
conditional
admission,
Respondent concedes
that there is clear and
convincing evidence
that
he violated Rule 1.1(competence),
Rule 1.3(dili- gence),
Rule 1.4
(duty to
communicate with
client) andRule 8.4(c)
(engaging in
conduct involv- ing dishonesty, fraud, deceit ormisrepresentation) of the
Wyoming
Rules of ProfessionalCon- duct.
71.
Respondent's
Rule 1.1
violations include:
23
1. Failing to recognize and acknowledge
that he formed a lawyer-cli- ent relationship with Ms. RandallonDecember17,2024.
2. Citing anon-existent Wyoming statute in the May
21, 2025,
email to Ms. Randall. 3, Failing to recognize
that 044-32 Wyo. Code R.Section 32-9
has no application to circuit
court matters.
72. Respondent's Rule1.3violations
include:
1. Failing to timely file
court documents, as discussed
above.
2. Failing to attend the February
24, 2025,
scheduling
conference
on Ms. Randall's behalf.
3. Failing to convey Ms. Randall's
$1,500.00
lump sum settlement offer in a timely manner.
4. Failing to respond to the questions Ms. Lee posed in her April 14, 2025, email.
5. Failing to inform Ms. Randall of the information Ms. Lee would need to have in order for her clienttoconsideralump sumoffer from Ms. Ran- dall.
6. Failing to follow
through on getting a signed
settlement
agreement.
7. Forwarding his May19,2025,
email communication with
Ms. Lee to Ms. Randallanddirecting
hertoanswer Ms. Lee's
questions.
73. Respondent's Rule 1.4 violations include:
1. Failing to inform Ms. Randall of the information Ms. Lee
would need to have in
order forherclienttoconsideralumpsumoffer from Ms. Ran- dall.
2, Failing to inform Ms. RandallthatMs. Lee filedamotion
for
sum- mary judgment, the potential
consequences of suchamotionandtheneedto timely
file
a response.
3. Citing
non-existent or otherwise applicable law in the May
21,
2025, email to Ms. Randall.
74. Respondent's Rule 8.4(c)
violations
include:
1. Telling Ms. Randall that Discover Bank
"apparently" rejected
the $1,500.00 lumpsumsettlement offerwhenDiscover Bank toldmethatthey needed more informationtosupportthelump sumofferthatRespondent
con- veyed to Discover Bank onApril16,2025.
2. Telling Ms. Randall Discover Bank
would not accept the $1,500.00 lump sumsettlementwhen
Respondentdidnotrecognizeandcom- municate thatadditional informationwas
neededtosupport thelumpsum thathe had conveyed to opposing
counselonApril16,2025. Inother words, Ms. Lee was waiting on Respondenttoget thatinformationtoher. 3, Telling Ms. Randall
that remote hearings had not yet been imple- mented in
December 2024.
24
4. Misrepresenting Wyoming lawtoMs. Randall in the May 21,
2024,
email to her. Determination of the Appropriate
Sanction fortheMisconduct
75. Rule 15(b)(3)(D), W.R.Disc.P., provides, "In imposing a sanction
afterafinding ofmisconduct by the respondent, theBPR [Board of
Professional Responsibility]
shall consider the following factors, as enumerated in the ABA Standards for Imposing Lawyer
Sanctions:
1. Whether the lawyer has violated a duty owed to a client, to the public, to the legal system, or to the profession;
2. Whether the lawyer acted intentionally, knowingly, or negligently;
3. The amount of the actual or potential injury
caused
by
the lawyer's
misconduct; and
4. The existence of any aggravating or mitigating
factors."
76. Respondent's violations ofRules
1.1, 1.3, and 1.4 call into play Standard 4.4,
"Lack of Diligence,"
of the ABA
Standardsfor
Imposing Lawyer
Sanctions.
Standard4.4sets forth the following guidelines:
4.41 Disbarment is generally appropriate when:
(a) a lawyer abandonsthepracticeandcauses seriousorpotentially
seri- ous injury to aclient; or
(b) alawyer knowingly failstoperform servicesforaclientandcause se- rious orpotentially serious injurytoaclient;or
(c) a lawyer
engagesinapattern ofneglectwith
respecttoclient
matters and causes serious or potentially
serious injurytoaclient.
4.42
Suspension
is
generally
appropriate when:
(a) a lawyer knowingly failstoperform servicesforaclientandcauses in- jury or potential injurytoaclient,or
(b) alawyer engagesinapattern ofneglectwith
respecttoclient matters and causes injury or potential injurytoaclient.
4.43 Reprimand [i.e., "public
censure" under Rule 9(a)(3) oftheRules of Disci- plinary Procedure] is generally
appropriatewhenalawyerisnegligentand does not actwith reasonable diligence in representing a client,andcauses injury or potential injurytoaclient.
4.44 Admonition [i.e., "private
reprimand" under Rule 9(a)(4) oftheRules of Disciplinary Procedure] is
generally
appropriatewhenalawyerisnegli- gent and does not actwith reasonable diligence in
representingaclient, and causes little or no actual or potential injurytoaclient.
25
Respondent engaged in a pattern ofneglect in his
representation of Ms.
Randallandcaused in- jury or potential injury. The presumptive
sanction forRespondent's violations of Rules1.1,1.3 and 1.4 is a suspension.
77. Respondent's violations of Rule 8.4(c) implicate
Standard 5.1, "Failure toMain- tain Personal Integrity":
Absent
aggravatingormitigating
circumstances, uponapplication ofthefac- tors set out in Standard 3.0, thefollowing sanctions aregenerally
appropriate in cases involving commission ofacriminalactthatreflects adversely onthelaw- yer's honesty,
trustworthiness,orfitnessas alawyer inother respects, orincases with conduct involving dishonesty, fraud, deceitormisrepresentation:
5.11 Disbarment is generally
appropriate when:
(a) a lawyer engages in serious criminal conduct,anecessary
element ofwhich includes
intentional
interferencewiththeadministration of justice, false swearing,
misrepresentation, fraud, extortion,mis- appropriation, or theft; orthesaledistributionorimportation of controlled
substances;ortheintentional killing of another; oran attempt or conspiracy
or solicitation of any other commit any of these offenses;or
(b) a lawyer
engages inanyother intentional
conduct involving dis- honesty, fraud, deceit,ormisrepresentationthatseriously
adversely reflects on the lawyer's
fitnesstopractice.
5.12 Suspension is generally appropriate whenalawyer knowingly
engages in criminal conduct which doesnotcontaintheelements listed in
Standard
5.11 and that seriously reflects
onthelawyer's
fitnesstopractice.
5.13 Reprimand [i.e., "public
censure" under Rule 9(a)(3) of the Rules of Disci- plinary Procedure] is generally appropriatewhenalawyer knowingly en- gages in anyother conductthatinvolves
dishonesty, fraud, deceit,ormis- representation andthatadversely
reflectsonthe
lawyer's
fitnesstoprac- tice law.
5.14 Admonition [i.e., "private
reprimand" under Rule
9(a)(4) of the Rules of Disciplinary Procedure] is generally
appropriatewhenalawyer engagesin any other conductthatreflects
adverselyonthelawyer's fitnesstopractice law.
Several of Respondent's violations of Rule 8.4(c)
seriously adversely reflectonhis
fitnessto practice law. The presumptive
sanction for Respondent's violations ofRule 8.4(c)
is
disbarment.
78. The
Prefacetothe ABA
Standards includes the following
discussion
regarding mental state:
26
The
mental statesusedinthismodelaredefinedasfollows. The mostculpable mental state is
that of intent,
when the lawyeractswiththeconscious objective or purpose to accomplish a particular result. The
nextmostculpable mental
stateis that of knowledge,
whenthelawyeractswith conscious
awareness ofthe
nature or attendant circumstances ofhis orherconductbothwithout theconscious
objec- tive or purpose to accomplishaparticular result.The
least culpable
mental stateis negligence, when a lawyer failstobeaware ofasubstantial risk thatcircum- stances exist
orthataresult will follow,
which failure isadeviation ofacare that a reasonable lawyer would exercise in the situation. Respondent's violations ofRules 1.1,1.3and1.4werenegligent. However,
several ofhis viola- tions ofRule 8.4(c) were intentional. Under the ABA Standards, "injury" is definedas"harmtoaclient,thepublic, thelegal system, or the profession which resultsfromalawyer's
misconduct. The
level of injury can range from 'serious'
injuryto'littleorno'
injury;areferenceto'injury' alone indicatesanylevel of injury
greaterthan'littleorno'injury." "Potential injury"is
definedas"harmtoaclient,the public, the legal system ortheprofession that is
reasonably foreseeable atthetimeofthelaw- yer's
misconduct,andwhich, butforsomeintervening factor orevent, would
probablyhavere- sulted from the lawyer's
misconduct."
Respondent's violations of theforegoing rules
caused significant
emotional distressforMs.Ran- dall.
79. ABA Standard 9.0,
entitled "AggravationandMitigation," provides asfollows:
9.1 Generally After
misconduct hasbeenestablished, aggravatingandmitigating cir- cumstances may beconsidered in deciding
what sanctiontoimpose.
9.2 Aggravation
9.21 Definition. Aggravationoraggravating
circumstancesareany
consider- ations or factors thatmay justify anincrease inthedegree of
discipline to be imposed.
9.22 Factors which may be consideredinaggravation. Aggravating factors include:
(a)
prior disciplinary offenses; (b)
dishonestorselfish motive;
(c) a pattern ofmisconduct; (d)
multiple offenses;
(e) bad faith obstruction ofthedisciplinary
proceeding by
intentionally failing to complywithrulesororders of thedisciplinary
agency; (f)
submission of false evidence, false statements,orother deceptive practices duringthedisciplinary process;
(g)
refusaltoacknowledge wrongful nature of conduct;
(h) vulnerability of the victim;
27
(i) substantial experiencein thepracticeoflaw; (j)
indifferenceinmaking
restitution;and (k)
illegal conduct, includingthatinvolvingtheuseofcontrolled sub- stances.
9.3.
Mitigation. 9,31 Definition. Mitigationormitigating
circumstancesareany considera- tions or
factors thatmay justifyareduction inthedegree of
discipline to be imposed.
9.32
Factors
which may be considered inmitigation. Mitigating
factors in- clude:
(a) absence of a prior disciplinary record; (b)
absence ofadishonestorselfish motive; (c)
personaloremotional problems;
(d) timely good faith efforttomake
restitution ortorectify
conse- quences of misconduct;
(e) fullandfreedisclosure of
disciplinary
boardorcooperative
attitude toward proceedings;
(f) inexperienceinthepractice oflaw; (g)
characterorreputation; (h)
physical disability;
(i) mental disabilityorchemical
dependency including
alcoholism or drug abuse when:
(1)
thereismedical evidence thattherespondentisaffectedby a chemical dependencyormental disability;
(2) the chemical
dependencyormental disability caused themis- conduct;
(3) the respondent's recovery fromthechemical
dependency or mental disability is
demonstrated by ameaningfulandsus- tained period of
successful
rehabilitation;and
(4) the recovery
arrestedthemisconductandrecurrence ofthat misconduct is unlikely.
(j)
delayindisciplinary proceedings; (k)
impositionofother penaltiesorsanctions;
(1) remorse; and
(m) remoteness ofprior
offenses.
9.4 Factors
Which Are
Neither Aggravating
norMitigating. The
following factors shouldnotbeconsideredaseither aggravating nor mitigating:
(a)
forcedorcompelled restitution;
(b) agreeing totheclient's
demandforcertain improper behavior orresult; (c)
withdrawal of
complaint
againstthelawyer; (d)
resignation priortocompletion of
disciplinary
proceedings;
(e) complainant's
recommendationastosanction; and (f)
failureofinjured clienttocomplain.
28
80. Aggravating factors applicabletoRespondent's
misconduct include
dishonest or selfish motive;apattern of misconduct; vulnerability ofthevictim;andsubstantial
experience in the practice of law. The
absence ofadisciplinary
history is amitigating
factor. In addition, Re- spondent has recently paid Ms. Randall's debttoDiscover
Bankoutofhis own pocket. This is an additional mitigating
factor. Further mitigating
factors include: (1)
Mr. Cobb's
sincere
re- morse; (2) his apology
lettertoMs. Randall;
(3)
his $1,000
donationtoWyoming
Legal Aid;and
(4) his
cooperationtoresolve this
matter withoutahearing.
81. Respondent
concedes
that, in
consideration oftheforegoing
factors,asuspension is theappropriate sanction fortheconducttowhich
Respondenthasconditionally
admitted. Re- spondent agrees toathree-month
suspension.
82. Ms.
Randall was provided withacopy of this Stipulation
and the accompanying Affidavit of
Conditional Admissionandhadnoobjectionto thestipulated sanction.
83. If the Court ordersathree-month suspension in
accordance herewith, Bar
Counsel and Respondent agree to the following
press release:
The
Wyoming
Supreme Court
issuedanorder suspending attorneyKentC. Cobb fromthepractice of law foraperiod of three months. The
order of
suspension stemmed from Cobb's
representation ofaWyoming
resident inadebt collection matter. In the course of the representation, Cobb
violated his duty of
competence and diligence in
additiontofailingtocommunicate with his client. Cobb
also
made numerous unintentional misrepresentationstohis client. Cobb
agreedtothe sus- pension, which was
recommendedtotheSupreme Court by theBoard of
Profes- sional Responsibility of theWyoming State Bar. Cobb was
orderedtopay anad- ministrative feeintheamount of$750.00 andcosts of$50.00totheWyoming
State Bar. Recommendation Based upontheforegoing findingsandconclusions, theReview
Panel
recommends that the Court issue an order of
29
Dated
this) dayof February,
2026.
John C airtooks, ReviewPané Boardof
Professional Responsibility Wygming StateBar
30