AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Docket Number
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Docket Number
Judges
To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

Dr. Naim Dahdah, MD v. Virgin Islands Department of Human Services, Gary Smith and Carla Huggins

!"#$%#&&&!'% (  )* +$ $,$ -* )./.$ +/+ )./0  *  1*.1$1 /+0/2 1 )./+$ $,$ -*  )..1$1 2* 3,./%*+/ .. 1 * 4567897:;67<=6>?6>@A=BC4567897:DE7F6GHIJK5797L689MN89>OPQRL>5S878OTOOUFF78VO9>O78VOW97Q8Q:>7F56TFR79@>O>6FFRX<79O?Q8O>R8?PO?68?F7YFOW6P69O:7578LFM � Z>OFO78V5R?OXQ9>K[G\H]K68?8Q8̂K[G\H]K 7X79F@6 OPP68?Q<:7578LFMN86??797Q89Q9>OPOXO78L O:7578LF9>O O9SWOVQ89O OPR5OFQ:V7_75WPQVO?RPOMN:4567897:XO57O_OF9>69XS78R8?6978L9>O?QVUO9>O7FXQ5F9OP78L>7F_6P7QRFV6RFOFQ:6V97Q8@>O7F<7F96UO8M̀AQPOQ_OP@8Q96X5S6XFO89:PQ<9>OQ8F56RL>9Q::7578LF7FWPQQ:9>694567897:>6FFOP_O?9>OFR< O9>POO=O:O8?689FMf79>QR9FRV>WPQQ:@9>7FcQRP9>6F8QWOPFQ865gRP7F?7V97Q8Q_OPF67?=O:O8?689FMZ>RF@:QP9>OPO6FQ8F9>69:Q5QT@9>O<6gQP79SQ:4567897:hF 4567897:� jO:OPO8VO7F<6?O9Q9>OcQRP9hF?QVUO96FQ:kOW9O O:QRPK[G\H]K 69>O>6FCFRX<79O?6PQXRF9POVQP?Q:>6P 7X79F@68? <6?O9Q4567897:hF OPO784567897:F969OFB699>O97 69>O>6FC8QT:75O?Q_OPil?QVR 7FV6FOMDs Z>7FtP?OP?QOF8Q96??POFF4567897:hF <786PS78gR8V97Q8abcdpe@abcdmue@68?abcdule@8QP>7F O6P78LQ8F6

1

!"#$%&$ '(#)" * +         , �-�.�/ 0123456

7849 :

; <

= >

8�9?

>         <

:

; @ + 8A92

=

@ 2 > 8    B< C9DEF GG1  F

H01234G

1234G4.5 / >

I

8B+;C9 1;6

J

6+;86  + ;

9

- K, 4/�.�/+    0123L5 M      0123I5 N  O +    OPQRSTUP N 0123445  M

O

O    01234�5 K, 4V�.�/ 2

J

< WPP01234/ 4-5 L N 2

J / X

Y 4.8 9

3Y2+4.8 9Z[PP\][UŜ_̀abcdeSfghcaia�..jXkALI---A481<+K �-�..j9I WPP01234G�501234GA501234GL501234GI501234GV501234G4.5WPPSl[_01234.5- + Y /�89 3

Y 2 +

O

m

F

+;; O +   O

O

O

WPP3Y2+/�8 9+ m

Y /�O

+;;

nopqrsrtuvwxvyyytzv{|}v~|€w‚ƒq„…†r‡‡sˆ‰Šq‹ryŒyttuŽoqttt

2

      !!"#  $% &'!&  & !&'&(  ) *"+,� -*"+,��-. &   ' &&(      !!&/ 0&( &!&&1' '!& !&' ''&''  2*"+,� - 3 .  '  &     !!&/ 0&( &1' &    ' &'!'  &&2*"+,��-

4

!&!&01'2'*"+,�5-6789:;6 &!&  < & &=&0&   2   0'&&' '   &&   2*"+,� -  =  +&/ '=    &   ''  &&     & & . &      '!*"+,�>-  ' &    & & '  ' &  ' 4 ' !&!& =1''*"+,�-0 &   '<& !   2) 4 &  & # '    6789:;6.  <6789:;6    '& &(  & !'         *"+, 3 &  3-&&/ 0 !!"# ) 2 '   !!&  '&0& !!&   '! '&' &2?66*"+, 3-�%!!&    "# ) !!  "# )*"+,

-''! / '! &/ !&&1'  &&0 !!"# +2 >  ?66*"+,

-"#  @ & % &

!!&/ !&&1'   "#  $%!&! !&'&(    '  *"+,�  & ��-4"# "*"+,5A-         "# B*"+,5-3 C  &'&&'  !&&1'     = 0'!& !&'''&''  2 % !!&  ' &(   ! & +&

+!&*"+,

->A  *"+,�>-5

4   #   &#!&      ' *"+,5 5

- =+&'&  ' &

DEFGHIHJKLMNLOOOJPLQRSLTRUVWMXYGZ[\H]]Î_̀GaHObcOJcJKdEeGIWfJJ

3

!

"   �#!$% &'()*+&   ,-#.    /

"

01!-2. /

3

/   04!-0. //

/      �2!-�.    56 7 8 $ 3    �0! #0 -9.

"

9! -:. /

"

"

:!$; <  < = ��! >       <  ?

/  "

$  �1!#@ �A!#$B = "202 29 /

"

"

"

$8 /&'()*+& /

"

9#!

"

92!    /

"

"

90!$ #� 8 $;   9:!/ /

/

$%

,-#.

>

C

"

91!-2.

"       9A! -0.

C

/ 94!$#0 ;

"

"

$D&&EF #9$#$# < = ?G&& �4! 9�!  99!      /

3

/ $ 9 !$ HIJKLMLNOPQRPSSSNTPUVWPXVYZ[Q\]K̂_̀LaaMbcdKeLSfgSNgNOhIiKj[kNN

4

! ! "# !!$  %&$  '(   ) *+&,-. / 0 , "#%    (    +&,-.1/"%! !2   !    (3      ! ! "#41 2   " !+&,-.�/     "$ +&,-../ 5 2  2 !! +&,-.6/ %! 7 ! !! (+&,-.8/ '    9 !+&,-. / 2!! +&,-.5/ 1� 5  �   !!&$   & :  2 !! ! $   ;<<+&,-6 / +&,-61/ +&,-6 / = 2 !    2   <>?@AB<  )  !+&,-65/+&,-65C1/  !  22! 2!+&,-6 / 1. 3    2        +&,-6�/ !  2  ! 2+&,-

./+&,-�5/ )   41   !!  # +&,-6./   ! 2+&,-

/   !2 ! +&,-66/   ! 2+&,-56/+&,-�1/ 5   #  ! +&,-68/   ! 2+&,-

/+&,-� / )      ! 241   $!   +&,-6D/   ! 2+&,-8/    1� +&,-.5/ 5  �+&,-.D/ ! "  1. +&,-65/+&,-65C1/  +&,-

5/  +&,-6

/  +&,-

/

EFGHIJIKLMNOMPPPKQMRSTMUSVWXNYZH[\]Î̂ J_̀aHbIPcdPKdKLeFfHLXgKK

5

!

"  #$  % % & ' (  ))* + )  ,

( (

( %- .   ( +

$

// (

//

0

,

( (

(

(

(   ! $

1

$# (      & ' ( � ))* + *

!

(

( & ' ( )* ))* + $

2    ( '

(

(

3

4

(

(    +

(

5

(

6 3) ! #$//#$' (7// 3 (%%% ' #$( #$

+8 %

+

5

(   9 : 6 3 & "$% ))* + #$; %%)

5

$ 2 6 %- '

1

5 6 0 $ <= %* % % >?? 3/%  3*/%  3�/%  %/%  %3/% %%/%

@ABCDEDFGHIJHKKKFLHMNOHPNQRSITUCVWXDYYEZ[\C]DK̂_KF_FG̀AaCLSbFF

6

!"!#$#%$!&'(%#)"!!*"()+#(,-*!%.)")-,!$! $*,-'!)(/0123$-)- ")4567689:01;<=6>560?<6@A _3<9&̀aaE4F*FFF&FFHIF*J-#4GCKKLIbcQ!(.$- )-(")($-.!#$V'(")#%!/0123$-)- ")S+$!*-" -O!$!).$-Q!*4dL4e!))Q!#!#!$-P-))()Q-+#('!*%#$U$!W-.-$-)V&"*/0123$-)- ")P%).-*!.V)Q!P!#%$!)Q)++$V)($()Q!#$-)- ")45676&�CDE4F*)GDaY23367215Bf3?789g&GCGamyKDFKK̀�&)zFI'-)-" ƒ?„„30„6<89g

7

!!"  " # ""$%"  " # &# " "   # !! '#%"#  ("�)  #(" *&+# "#,-./001234,567  89) : ; <=>??"   @<    @A,B1C23-CD  89E)

; <=>??  @FGHIJKLMINOHPQQNRSTRUVNQWXTLRY Z[ ## "# '\#  # ]"#   &#  # "##%"#  #&  "  "$̂_̀ 6/-a3b6016cd0C323efCghgi-3cd0C3  � jk:

) <):

@l # # m#   m" m " '" #  m #" m#m"  #&  "  ##%"bCn$ "# " " #&  "#& &"]"#   "$]  # "#]"#   &# #   #'#&bC<  ///aa/ofpqr-1a323f1a.1  Ejk �  s <): E@ n#" &# " #&  #("   #(" *&+# "#j##" #&  "   "$   m: '     (*&+ < @k " $#&m #   "#!!    #  m#    !! "   m " #]"   # ###& $ m   bCl# $'    # # #' "   #t # "# (*&+ <@<$@u  #t""   # $ #& "  #&m: s' #  (*&+ < @k   ' (" < @ # &  mv wxyz{|{}~€‚‚‚}ƒ„…†‡…ˆ‰Š€‹ŒzŽ{|‘’“z”{‚•–‚}–}~—x˜z™Šš}}

8

!" # !$ %!$

#

!

$#

&    !$ $   "'$(    #

" ! !   ) *+,-./0"! $  1"  $     ! " "      !$ 2+,34. /5/0/5678 ,966/8:;!$ #<=>  "

" ?

$  !"  $  " ! ! $" !!

"  % #!$

#

@  !

#  ! !

*1?  A B � C     *1?  A B � D  E > $!

#  $

$$

&

"?

F  $GH IJ// ,K-:L >*M* NO * (2M��>P F Q R F  *D>*M*     >  >'$(& $" $ #     !$

"EG H"! $  1"  $     ! "I $ &

; S4T ' A

R (* %!!  #   E     ?

F  $GH

#

&

$!

!

$

&

>

&

&#

#

#

$!  I ;

&U.V48W; 5X00/45K87Y;90;;ZX [/\:.W; ZX 4/\U8K8 ]/7;X>�DT ' Q 1 > *̂ �12

"

! !  '$( &$">

!$

#

!

$#

&    !$ $   "'$(     #

" ! !   ) ; '$( >  > _!

?  F  $

!$

$$

&

5T ' A

R (*>4 4/J// ,>*M* NO * (2M�� P* ? # _!

>

"# 8\/06X684   ̀ T ' A

R (* %  _! abcdefeghijkilllgminopiqorstjuvdwxyezzf{|}d~el€lg€ghb‚dtƒgg

9

!     "##$%&'()*+,(&-./010�  2� 3 4 5 6 �7 �1 8 9

::

!  :: 9! ;

<  8

!9=

!

;

>    9   = ?    9 9> @    9      A !

!

> B    9        C!9   !9 D  B E   �   F

9

9

9   ; =  "(G(#',H'IG%J')#,KL#K(*?

9

M     C !;

!

!9= ?    9 N > @

9

!!9

O

P

QR .   3 B S  $%&'()*+,(&- ./17TU  3 4 5 S � ; ! !9 F

S  $%&'()*+,(&-./010�  3 4 5 6 �7 ;    !

!9 F

S

VWXYZ[Z\]̂_̀ âaa\b̂cdêfdghi_jkYlmnZoo[pqrYsZatua\u\]vWwYoaix\\

10

!�"# $%# & %' #"()#()*%+$ %( , *,#($ #' ,-. %#/# .0 ,& %' #"()#(.% ('#1 ( 2) # 0/$( (% ,-.

%#.%# ,3 .%#4-#%)&"

53 .#)4 *,#($ #''.

%#/# /2).4 #, (.0 1 )121 4 (%

1/$( 6/$2.# ,-.

%#.%  ,3 .%#4-#%)  ,1, 071$

.0 1%.0 , #

$)'#14 # ,#//2).48    �  !� 1 #'&"

3 9#)(((%

1 (*

2%..0.0(%

1/$( 6/ . ,1.$%

):712 0.%(%

1649# ;  (/%(,).%2$ 4/%(,) ($1,2%..0/$( 664 ,(% %<(0

=>"# ,/ % ,#  ,% (#. , #' # ,%1.% . # 1 #4.0 ,?0## (, *

(%

1 @* (  ,.1@  (

. .02%..0 ,  ,(?0## (, 6#(%

* ,($//.#(# ,.% ' #)1./2) # A:�B #11.%#1* ,$)   C.%  ) # 0(@ , (($#1.0($//.#(* ,%(21  ., (/#1./2) # A:DEB36(# 2%..0.0(% 1  ,.$%  (2%1)$0%./7%1 ( #'2%(.#)$% ( 1 .#.

% ,?0## ( 0%#1 (/ . ,.$% F(.1@ (.0;2 /6%� G"#%

* #' ,/$) $.02) #'(   ($#1)%*, ,% ) # 0/4+$  , (($#1.0($//.#(( . , .0(%

1H A: EB �;$1,#(($/2 .#*.$)6/ ( @# %,2( ,.*

%  ) # 022%1  ( , $) 1.0 ,%)$)(.0

) %.1$%%+$ %(6. ,

) ($//.#(# ,1./2) #  .6(%

#  ( ,/#( #*, 1, ) # 0,( /2  .2%01 ($1,(%

1 ,  (0)*I, ((/( .6%0)1  #5;$22)/# )C. 1.0 )  .%4 ,,.) #'#J$) K3'#14; )#180 ) #' *,% # ) # 01.# #( , ,,(L M)*0$)4(% ,./2) # #%) .1$/# ($2.#?0## (#%)

# '.

%#/# .

%( ', # (  #1)$ #' ,& %' #"()#(?2% /# .0N$/#;%

1( ?N;  ,9;& %' #"()#(?2% /# .0O$( 1 J;' .#  ,P0 1.0 ,-.

%#.%# $ ## -.

%#.%.0 ,& %' #"()#( # ,P0 1.0 ,"#(21 .%-#%)A:GB �I,0 ) #'0$% ,%

%( , 5A1B% 0 / )(%

1.0 ,./2) # #;$22)/# ) ) #'8*(2%01 .# ,#/?0## ( (*)(5AB %1 / )(%

1 .'#14.0 1 )(#)')2% /# (8=>  QDN.*

% # ,% ,%)$)(.0

) %.1$%#.%& %' #"()#()*2%.

0.%(%

1

/ ) 1% 0 .%. ,%* (.% / ).# ,%).1)'. %#/# '#1 (.%).1)'. %#/# /2).4(($ # , %.0 1 )121 (H #  &"

-

# , 1,.0 ,?0## (0)* , # , (1 '.%40.%(% 12$%2.(( (%

164/ )#R.%/ )).#*.$)6 #($0 1 # 9) / )4 ,.* %   (#.  ,.$% F(2)1 .(21$)  # ) # 0 (%+$ % .2%. 2%..0.0(%

1 #11.%#1* ,$) ).0 ,%)$)(.0 ) %.1$%

STUVWXWYZ[\][̂^̂Y_[̀ab[cadef\ghVijkWllXmnoVpŴqr̂YrYZsTtVllfuYY

11

�     �   !"# $ %&! '(  ' ))*+,  --+.�///0 123

24

356728932289326 :;35<852 =23<8>2528?5>8@ 22> A>2 3B23:C

22>3

93

;3 >:85 3285BB2;><62>:

32>2

3

3  D !$$% % 'E' F) & G) &"HI�-,+J�K�.L L M N C J0 OPQRSTUTVWXYZTU[ >:

3\;5

28

N

:

35\;5 28]4:

>6

&$ ' <=;:65<>26 86>2;C= 623

2>C5

:9;

C

6; ̂.�0 _ >

35<7>2B>B> 3562;3̀ 3235=;3:62> 23.0 6>C 66;3

5<>:3

:5<:

3 >

:832 2;36

B2

66;36<6>>23

2>C5<C

a;

2>

: N

: \ ]4: �.C0 b3;5 8;3

39

3 62;327

=;:65>26

2>2B>2383

a;

:2893<

62;3 ;7

;6>26

8

62;3;995 :B

>

6

3<>823 2> Ec �.60 de=;:65<>26 :86 ;

3C

_

>

35<7>2B>B>

=;3:62>28

3562;323C

69C5

2866;3

>:3

:<:

3 >2>C<3

2322;36

B2

66;36<6>>23

2>C5<C

a;

2> fgF $%D F"�,-N

: e99h ��+.-:M3 ,0.6>_g  %g  *,JN -: /+.-:M3 �0  N3>:823 2>282393<27

;6>26

82362;32

h

36

e6;323<3

4

B28?5>8@>; 32;d=;:65f>26

3

85

6?5>8:2 >2993

6

:>62> 123

24

3C<B<28 h 95

=;C

6;

?5>8;C :

6532>4 36

3>: _

:2

>2 a; 2;C= 639 823=;:65>26 b2

62>33<L

8

>:>� di]j4 >9329

35<;

:; 2>>2>

5

>

8

64 8239;392 2862>8 33>_9 32>5=;3:62>8>2C >

34

:>62 95>6 B\;5

̀

346

289326

93242> fG &!k$Fc% &l # FFc$' " '$ *E&�-HI+J ,K.1 L ?

9 �J�-0.6>_G" %m &$k n F *(G*//N -:+,++J.-:M3 �//,00 opqrstsuvwxywzzzu{w|}~w}€‚xƒ„r…†‡sˆˆt‰Š‹rŒszŽzuŽuvprˆu‚‘uu

12

!  "#

"

$$ $$

" %&'()*+),+-.,/0123456787*9: ;<=>?@A<     "

"     BCDDCEFGEH<@IFJKJLEMNMLEFAKOL?DMLEM PPQ R SPP STUV W  �TTXY D<<?ODEZ <NM[EH?F\?]E@ÊJ_ ̀U�̀ab��̀TXP cVd W # ; S ̀U�̀Y R                    BCDDCEFGEH<@ PPQ R STU e "     "      f  !     g\ hD<<?ODEbij �j ̀ e <=>?@A<    "  kV�Y

"  "                 hV̀Y <=>?@A<    VY        l "    mE><@NMnFCA<\oC@OCF ?@A<    """#     e       "

tQSu

#   s"

v

"         "            "   <=>?@A<  Q wxyz{|{}~€‚‚‚}ƒ„…†‡…ˆ‰Š€‹ŒzŽ{|‘’“z”{‚•–‚}–}~—x˜z|Š™}}

13

!  "#$%&'"     ! ( )         *    +,-. /0  1             * * 2   *             * (     3)  45 /2     "#$%&'"    6    "#$%&'"

*   *   *        *789:;<=;>=:?@AB<=CDB;=E

P  *        *  3

P  *  *

P  *  I

K L KL KL   * -I* �JK LK�LK  L0                 *       * Q3R""S%'T"NUMV"&WXYZ'VM[\"%5ZN] �Ĵ-_ ̀� ̀aK,!

bb�LK  * (     Q3   )Lc4N&"dN]e"Y%f"f aga-�b̂

̀aK

b�LK(2    * I�J

6      3  **       P       2  **

h    *         **           *

2    (P    ) +,-.

ijklmnmopqrsqtttouqvwxqywz{|r}~l€m‚‚nƒ„…l†mt‡ˆtoˆop‰jŠl‚‹|Œoo

14

!"#$%&'(!)#'# *+�,+ -.- -./01

2 �**3 456

7

0

0+

8

01

8

9

:; "#';<=>?&%@A<A -��,1

. �1-01 2 +33BC!!D)@A"#@";C 1/�EF�/. �.+0�*G+5 7 9

H

9

8

4  6IJ ;A"#K@ ;&L; ./,1 -3 �-*M301

2 +3�/ N

O�� 2  PQ O 2 R +  7   8

8

S  SF   O 8T5  8

8  UV   8

2

8

5

B;#! � +

1

N     R A&!     8   W++ +3+ +G ?!!4U2,1G6X 7

7  8          2  P ?!!, O2 R+ XQ O 2 R

Y 2   Z  N

2  P8888

+G 5  R

7

?!!, O2 R�00 [\]̂_̀_abcdecfffagchijckilmndop̂ qrs_tt̀uvŵx_fyzfazab{\|̂tbn}aa

15

!  "

# !  ! $ $ % &  ' ! ( "$)* !! +$

,!%

-#.

-

! $

) /)! $   .! $ - )#" " #$ #.! "

011 �  23114561789:;97<=>;?8679)@A@@BC@A@�) @&D* #@@)@A@@! -06EF59GHI7J>=>K7681L089813)  @ )  �M0119:3N;1ON7LP?3Q6N73PN5R>=>STUPNER97613HI7J>)@A�MBC@ �@�) V�&WXW /@)@A�M-   Y"- "!%! $  ZR5N31  ! $ /  -

+#CC )

%! $  ).

.$$

! "   "- ! "

011[N?\Q158O=>07OL15)@� ,$$] �) � @A�"$

-   ! ! "

! $  $

#!"  $   $ ! -#.! "

̂  ) /  / -  ! $

-

.$ .+$

!% )

-

." #$ #.! "

,        ! "

#% - $$ ! #

&  ' !

( "$)* !)

#  " $Y" ! ,

!  _@    __    ! $

)  ! $

. C̀ �� .

!

"a b! $.  $ $     $!  !

.

!  -    $! ! $ !)  ! $

X"

.@@)@A@   $! /  % %

" ! $ . C̀ �� - "   . - /  ! $

@ c?331:=>dSeSHI7J>)@A@ABC��_@) V�&D*X" �_)@A@A2fN?73=>g38981Nhi?8N7)@A�_BC�@M@ @) V&D*'M)@A�_23119:3N;5NN<3jkJPN:?E=>gE159:Lc6L\1015=>PN5R>H@ aC !

"

$ .l/ ! ! "     - /    !% )b a! $

! " $

!.bcNE15N=>SGR>NhSNFOQ9779)@A@BC@ @__@M) V@ '�)@A@a   )  #  - l#. m"    &   !  "   "  .   % -

! $

.

!

"

bIL nopqrsrtuvwxvyyytzv{|}v~|€w‚ƒq„…†r‡‡sˆ‰Šq‹ryŒyttuŽoq‡ztt

16

!"# ! "$ %   $ ! &! '&

" ! & ! "  #   #  !()*+$ ,  !  ! ""!-   " !  #   #  ! .#". !   /'& ! 01  2,  !   ! %!  0  &!  !  "      0 "!!.  !"  "!  $ ! ! !# #!

1

0

,

""& ! &!" "! 3! "  "$ "! % !"   "& !! 456789:8;:<=;>?@A:B7A:CBDE=FA;G H  -(+ ! #  !"3 " 0   # " & % ! ! "0   "I&  % 1& 2JKLKMNOPQRMSTUPVWXTYZ[[�\]�!̂_

.

,

!

1

0

,

. "! ! &!"  $00%   " ! ! #! " 0   ""    !  !$ " !!! #  "I&   " 0 ̀a

\  ! " ! !!!b    & !" "" !  "!     # ! !   ! " 0 !- 0    2 !  & ! "!  !-  &"2 -" % """!  2$  # ! !   ! " 0 NcKdefdOgWaWLORhTUPfdShWJWdcP�\]*i�*!̂�)

.

,

H ! jQMKORdWLJdKLXfcXdKORLkJWPlmmJUPnaeRLT\]!̂)

.

,

o& -p !q  &"r"!  ! ! "3   !  " 0 #&"! # "!!!! !"qI&"! "" %   ! ! 0!  &#"! "

r2NcKde�\]*i�*!̂

\! & "   !  " 0  "! !0   & #   #   '& !   &!" " ! $  s&"! 0  ! "t-�!! #   !! ! " 0 I&"!"  & $!  #   '& !  "%"  &  j!"   & " !I&"!"j !!& !%& ! !"  ! 2naeRLT\]!̂jNcKde�\]*i�*!̂

uvwxyzy{|}~}€€€{}‚ƒ„}…ƒ†‡ˆ~‰Šx‹ŒyŽŽz‘x’y€“”€{”{|•v–xŽ—ˆ˜{{

17

! "#"$%&'()('*# +$,  -./012034..1!566789:; <=>;4;/?!95667 "#""%&�@@***@$ +�,AB

"( "#""CD

E

F

G

H

F

I J ,  K0>3;>89L;1!M0>N.O7.9 "#�"%&$#@$*$ +$,PBQR "* "#�"C I  I IF

G

I

F

G

H

S

G

I

T

UJ ,  VW!1. V ;>NXY- 5J /9897?;!0W;0; WW010/?05667 "#"�%&�*'#(" +$,ABQA$ "#"�C,H  K;<;>Z0/0N;!5J /989[?; N "##)%&�$*$#(( +$,B\RA�* "##)C] I   F  S

H

F

F

I

T  UJ 9,H  K;<;>Z0/0N;! "##)%&�$*$#(( +$C ̂ I Q      G  I   F__P F̀aP]b$"c ̂aP]b$$c__ I H B   d

I E

I

F

e "), C  b e  ] Q 70 01-< "#�$%&�**(#) +"d  Q G e '

H

I

A

H

F   IG  ] ̂

H

G

be]Q$',C\ H G  ]

I

__

I

__ Gbe]Q(,C,�C,C P  I H G

I

F

B    e $' $#f G

I

H

ghijklkmnopqorrrmsotuvowuxyzp{|j}~k€€l‚ƒj„kr…†rm†mn‡hˆj€‰zŠmm

18

!"   # $%&'($%)�'( $%&&'( *  (* !( #  (  ( * (   ! #   + *   (* !

,   !

-.       /  ## ( # !

# * 012345676789:;6:7< = !"  !   >#  $% '($%)/'( $%/-'( $%?' $%&'!  ,

@>#   !     !  # #  >

(

* >ABB/CDE??  �  F #    !"

(

!"  $%��'!   # # ! #(  !"  $%�' $%)&' # #    # ! #  ##   (  !"  $% ' $%& '    #       (   !"  $% ?'($%)'( $%&)' + !=

(   !

! ! #

(

#G   > #    H!   = !"BIJKLMB  $%'! ># #     #  ! .   (  !"  $% )'($%)'( $%&/'G>#  # !     (  !"  $%?-'G>#  # !N!  #! (O   !"  $%?�'!     #  !  / @ %,

@ #   + (  !  PP# # PP

H!

.     -. *

#

ABB$%'

QRSTUVUWXYZ[Y\\\W]Ŷ_̀ Ya_bcdZefTghiUjjVklmTnU\op\WpWXqRrTjodsWW

19

!!"# $"%"&'! (

)

* + ,-./01-2345/67869:;<=>3;?;9:?6@.-<A@.; ��BCDB�EFG� HEI(  J K EG ��BLI  M1->N?;O:P231@ QGRS K B BGI�ETLU=6V7-@.-?;W::@-X TYZ [+ EBT EBYIF \ �EGLU4--624:]:7-?;OP..6@--7<A@.; ��CD�QEQRBE HFI( ̂ _ ̀EQ ��L C a

)

)

)

b-6?-4?;]P1@-3 ��BCDBYQ�F HEI ( c J �Q ��BLI  W12-7?;M:@623 QBEZ F ERE ERTIEE\ �YLU4--624:A@7-W.M:@623 BYRS K EY EYBIERYRL _

)

d

)

A3 I  M-e:4-?;f@1>-3g>6>-4 ��BCDBYRTRR HEIEE\ Z ) Y ��BL [

+

)

)

d M-e:4- ��BCDBYRTRR HEU4--O7:V@-?;91:e6@P ��QCDTEREQ� HEI ( _ Z ) �Q ��QL  h(

d  i

)

+  jkM-e:4- ��BCDBYRTRR HEI  W67>1@l,71m:@6?;g/6V RYTZ � EFYB EFYGIEE\ ERRFLU]6m216731?;W.n121684 YFBZ � YE YFIF \ ERYGLU51.o-71@ml]-:7m-?;M:V3X- �EQCDBREQFY H�I( ̂ _ [  EG �EQL [  d +

)

M:V3X- �EQCDBREQFY H�I  ]6m216731 YFBZ � YF p \ q7:4-

rstuvwvxyz{|z}}}x~z€z‚€ƒ„…{†‡uˆ‰Šv‹‹wŒŽuv}‘}x‘xy’s“ux}…”xx

20

! " #$ %$�%  & '

((

((

) * '

+

,

- .  /0*!1234 5    '

6

,     0 4/

,

04 / 0*!1"4 �70*!1)4 270*!1�34 70*!1�)47 0*!124 8

9 !

.

' '

.

:

.

.

' ! ! '

8

! '

6

8! ;<=>'

7

?@ABCDEFGH@IJKH=C 

6

$ 5   % ) '

, / 0*!1P40*!1PO4 0*!1)34

VWXYZ[Z\]̂_̀ âaa\b̂cdêfdghi_jkYlmnZoo[pqrYsZatua\u\]vWwY\oix\\

21

!"# $$%!"# $�%!"# &�%!"# &'%!"# ()%!"# (*%!"# *&%+!"# *(%   ,  - .  -          !"# &)%!"# *)%!"# /�%+!"# //%   012 13 4  .  -           )5 !"# )*%!"# )6%!"# &5%!"# &(%!"# ($%!"# (�%!"# (6%!"# '5%!"# '$%!"# **%!"# */%+!"# /&%   .  -     789:;<7+   !"# $$%!"# $�%!"# )&%!"# )*%!"# )6%!"# &�%!"# &)%!"# &(%+!"# &'%  => .+  -         ++? , !"# 6�%+@ !"# 6&%!"# 6(%!"# 6'%!"# 6*%!"# 6/%!"# 66%!"# $55%!"# $5$%!"# $5�%!"# $5)%!"# $5&%!"# $5(%!"# $5'%!"# $5*%!"# $5/%!"# $56%!"# $$5%+!"# $$$% -,,   A"@ B -CD 1E F        "GH"IJ K+JL,  ��5�(     MNMOPQR:ST7:UV7         WFBXBGH"BWY"        YFLFCBWZLHIBH"[YKW"

)5 H  ?-+ \- ]-+ ?   ?+]-+ ? ?̂ _+ F

àbcdedfghijhkkkflhmnohpnqrsitucvwxdyyez{|c}dk~kffg€acffs‚ff

22

Use AI to get other relevant cases.

Comments

Dr. Naim Dahdah, MD v. Virgin Islands Department of Human Services, Gary Smith and Carla Huggins
(Sep 2, 2025)