Filed 12/1/25 In re L.M. CA2/4
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION FOUR
In re L.M. et al., Persons Coming Under the Juvenile Court Law.
B342086
(Los Angeles County Super. Ct. Nos.
22LJP00125,
22LJP00125A,
22LJP00125B)
LOS ANGELES COUNTY
DEPARTMENT OF
CHILDREN AND FAMILY
SERVICES,
Plaintiff and Respondent. v.
W.M.,
Appellant. APPEAL from orders of the Superior Court of Los Angeles County, Debra L. Gonzales, Commissioner. Affirmed.
Jack A. Love, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for Appellant Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy, Assistant County Counsel, Jessica Bucklew, Deputy County Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
1
Father W.M. appeals from the juvenile court's order terminating his parental rights over his two young children following a hearing pursuant to Welfare and Institutions Code section 366.26.1He argues that he met his burden to show that reinstating his reunification services was in the children's best interests and therefore the court erred in denying his petition under section 388. He also contends that the court erred by failing to apply the parental benefit exception to termination of his parental rights. We find no error in the trial court's orders and therefore affirm.
BACKGROUND
I. Referral and Petition
Father and mother, A.M., are parents to twins L. and S., born in November 2021. The family came to the attention of the Los Angeles County Department of Children and Family Services (DCFS) from a referral in February 2022 stating that mother had engaged in domestic violence against father in the presence of the infant twins.
Both mother and father denied any domestic violence between them. However, DCFS reported that there had been 10 law enforcement calls for domestic violence and yelling by the parents between June 2020 and February 2022.
On March 28, 2022, DCFS filed a dependency petition under section 300, subdivisions (a) and (b)(1). Allegations a-1 and b-2 alleged that mother and father had a history of engaging in violent physical altercations in the presence of the twins, including striking each other and breaking objects, necessitating law enforcement involvement and placing the twins at risk of physical harm. Allegation b-1 alleged that mother had a history of substance abuse, was currently an abuser of marijuana, and that father knew of mother's substance abuse and failed to protect the children. Allegation b-3 alleged that mother had mental and emotional problems rendering her incapable of caring for the children.
2
The juvenile court ordered the twins detained, and DCFS placed them with a maternal aunt. The court ordered monitored visitation for both parents.
II. Jurisdiction and Disposition
In the April 2022 jurisdiction/disposition report, DCFS reported that father was arrested in 2020 for driving under the influence of alcohol and drugs. In an interview with a DCFS children's social worker (CSW), father denied any violence between him and mother, denied that he or mother used drugs, and stated that he had no concerns about the children in mother's care.
The court sustained the petition as alleged, finding the twins to be persons described by section 300, subdivisions (a) and (b). The court also found by clear and convincing evidence that returning the twins to the parents' home would pose a substantial danger to the children's health, safety, and well-being. The court ordered reunification services and monitored visitation for both parents. Father's case plan included a domestic violence program, drug testing, parenting classes, individual counseling, and conjoint counseling if he and mother planned to reconcile. Mother and father appealed the jurisdiction and disposition orders. We affirmed in an unpublished opinion, In re L.M. (Oct. 30, 2023, B320963/B322275).
III. Period of Review
As of July 2022, father stated he was working on enrolling in his court- ordered counseling and parenting classes and was participating in domestic violence classes, but had not yet provided proof to DCFS. Father was having monitored visits, but had missed several weeks of visitation because of his new work schedule.
In November 2022, maternal aunt reported that she could no longer care for the twins and they were placed with foster caregivers (the caregivers). In a December 2022 report, DCFS stated that father had completed his parenting program and was scheduled to start his domestic violence program the following month. He had not attended any individual counseling sessions or conjoint counseling with mother. He visited the twins together with mother twice per week. The visit monitors reported that the
3
parents were appropriate during the visits and the twins were sad when the visits ended. However, DCFS noted that it had not liberalized visits because father had not attended any domestic violence or conjoint counseling sessions. Father stated that because of his work schedule he could only complete one class at a time.
At a review hearing in January 2023, the court found father had not made substantial progress with his case plan. The court continued reunification services.
In February 2023, DCFS liberalized the parents' visits to unmonitored, but recommended that the twins remain placed with the caregivers, because the parents had not yet fully participated in their case plans and did not have suitable housing. Father stated that he was homeless and staying with friends and relatives. As of March 2023, father had enrolled in a domestic violence program but had not started counseling. In April, DCFS reported that mother and father continued to visit the twins together, although they stated they were not a couple and had not started conjoint counseling. DCFS reverted mother's visits to monitored for lack of compliance with court orders. The CSW told father that he could not have mother or any other individuals at his unmonitored visits. Father stated he would only participate in monitored visits with mother. On April 11, the court ordered the parents to visit separately.
In a family assessment, DCFS noted it was concerned with a "lack of parent-to-child bonding and/or involvement." It reported that the safety risks to the twins continued to exist, as neither parent had participated in counseling and they did not appear to have gained any insight into the harm to the twins from their domestic violence or substance abuse. DCFS also noted that the children were receiving services for developmental delays and that the caregivers ensured that the twins were actively engaged in those services. The parents "were afforded the opportunity to participate in the children's therapy sessions, but have increasingly reduced their participation." DCFS also noted that father's attendance at visits had been decreasing.
In May 2023, DCFS reported that the twins were thriving in their placement with the caregivers and were making good progress with their
4
developmental delays. Mother admitted to DCFS that after the twins were removed she began drinking alcohol excessively. After she was involved in an altercation while intoxicated in January 2023, mother called father from jail to pick her up.
DCFS also reported a new charge for father for driving under the influence of alcohol in December 2022. Father tested positive for marijuana and ethanol in December 2022, and failed to show for two of five drug and alcohol tests in January and February 2023. Both parents told DCFS that their reunification plan was for each parent to have primary custody of one twin while supporting the other parent to raise the other child. The caregivers reported to DCFS that father had cut short or cancelled multiple visits between March and June. By June 2023, father was continuing with his domestic violence program and was engaged in conjoint counseling with mother. He had not yet started individual counseling. At a review hearing that month, the court found father had made partial progress with his case plan and continued reunification services. The court also ordered both parents to attend individual counseling with a licensed therapist and father to submit to random and on-demand substance testing. In October 2023, DCFS reported that the twins continued to do well with their caregivers and were making good progress with their developmental delays. Father stated that sometimes his work schedule made it difficult to attend visits. DCFS noted that father's visits remained unmonitored, but there were "growing concerns about safety as father is not submitting to drug testing and he is not in compliance with counseling."
DCFS reported that father had not participated in substance testing since June. He had not started individual counseling and had stopped conjoint counseling with mother, stating that they were no longer a couple. Father was scheduled for visitation twice per week, but attended only four visits between August 1 and September 9. DCFS noted that visits by the parents had decreased after they were ordered to visit separately. The caregivers observed that father "is not as present as he was. He doesn't seem quite as involved."
In a November 2023 last-minute information, DCFS explained that it had not liberalized father's visitation due to his noncompliance with court-
5
ordered individual counseling, his inconsistent drug testing, and unstable housing. Father was not able to drive the children because his driver's license had been suspended as a result of his 2022 DUI conviction. DCFS reported that father had postponed efforts to assess his home for overnight visits in September and October due to his unstable housing. At the 18-month review hearing on November 13, 2023, DCFS noted that father had been given 20 months of reunification services—far longer than the six months provided pursuant to section 361.5, subdivision (a)(1)(B)—but he had not completed his case plan. DCFS therefore recommended terminating services. Counsel for the twins agreed. Finding that father had not made substantial progress with his case plan, the court terminated his reunification services and set the matter for a permanency planning hearing. The court allowed DCFS discretion to allow for additional unmonitored visitation with the children.
IV. Section 388 Petition
DCFS filed a section 366.26 report in February 2024. DCFS reported that father had attended all of his visits since November 2023, although he sometimes left the visit early without explanation. The caregivers were loving to the twins and committed to adopting them, and the children appeared happy and well-bonded to the caregivers.
In May 2024, the caregivers reported that father was participating in some therapy sessions with the twins and afterward father and his girlfriend would take the children to the mall for their visit. The caregivers expressed concerns regarding the twins' diapers not being changed and also noted that at times father missed visits.
The following month, the caregivers again reported that father was feeding the twins unhealthy food during visits, resulting in the children having diarrhea following a visit. The caregivers had spoken to father about it, but the issue persisted. Father agreed to give the children healthier food and monitor their intake more closely. Father also sometimes failed to show up for visits.
Mother and father separately filed section 388 petitions in July 2024, seeking to change the order terminating reunification services, granting further reunification services or returning the children to their care. Father
6
stated that he had demonstrated changed circumstances because he had completed most elements of his case plan, including his domestic violence program. He also started individual counseling in July 2024.2Father also contended that his requested change would benefit the children because he had maintained consistent, unmonitored visitation and had a strong bond with them.
DCFS filed a response to the section 388 petitions in August 2024. During monthly visits, the CSW observed that the twins had a loving relationship with the caregivers and called both caregivers "Papa." As for father's case plan, DCFS reported that he had completed his domestic violence and parenting programs and had recently begun individual counseling.3DCFS noted the concerns regarding father's visits as to diet and diapering, as the caregivers reported the twins often returned from father's visits wearing the same diapers they had on when they left, and frequently had diarrhea for a few days after the visit. The caregivers also noted that at times one child asked to "go home" as they were about to drop the twins off for a visit with father. Father sometimes missed visits or asked to reschedule to times that were inconvenient to the children's daily schedule. Father reported that he had a good job and it was hard to balance work and visits, but he felt that he and the children "have a really good time" during visits. DCFS acknowledged father's efforts toward completing his case plan, but expressed concern that father did not care for the children independently. DCFS noted that father's girlfriend had "encouraged and guided" him to
"complete classes, confirm and attend visits, and communicate with the CSW," and that sometimes the CSW could hear the girlfriend over the phone
"feeding the father the appropriate questions and answers." DCFS noted that father was provided with far longer than average reunification services
7
but failed to reunify and had never had overnight unmonitored contact with the twins. DCFS acknowledged that the visits were going well, but took place in public locations in a "fun environment," and thus DCFS had not observed a strong parent-child relationship where father might need to discipline a child, assist with academics, or accompany the children to services and appointments. By contrast, the caregivers had been with the twins for more than half of their lives, had shown the ability to meet their needs, and the children were strongly bonded to them. DCFS recommended denying both parents' petitions and proceeding with adoption.
In a last-minute information on August 30, 2024, the caregivers reported that the children would become clingy and quiet before visits and require coaxing to go. In between visits, father did not have any phone or video calls with the twins and they never asked for him. DCFS also expressed concern with father's ability to meet the twins' needs, including their hours of speech and occupational therapy. Father worked two jobs and his only identified support was his partner, who was also pregnant and had an older son.
DCFS also reported that it had not been able to assess father's home for safety to enable home visits. A CSW was only able to complete a visual assessment of the exterior of his home and noted several structures and vehicles "in different stages of disarray that pose a physical safety risk" to the young children. In October 2024, the caregivers expressed a concern that some visits were taking place at father's home, which had not been approved and continued to have physical hazards for the children.
In a November 2024 status review report, DCFS observed that based on home visits and reports from the twins' therapist, the children continued to be happy, healthy, and thriving with their caregivers and were bonded to them. The twins were continuing to receive developmental and physical therapy and had made marked progress in meeting developmental milestones.
Father had improved in the consistency of his visits and
communicating when he needed to reschedule. However, DCFS expressed continued concern with the twins' diet and the consistency of diaper changing during visits, and suspected some visits were taking place at father's home,
8
which was not approved. This suspicion arose after the twins returned home with hay in their shoes and mentioned words like "chicken," "pig," and
"ducks." DCFS noted that father's residence had farm animals and included a barn with hay. Father told DCFS he felt that visits were going well and they no longer conflicted with his work schedule.
The CSW also spoke with the twins' social group therapist, who reported that father was often on his phone during sessions and was affectionate but not attentive. Father was also resistant to following rules he did not like and the therapist had to alert him several times that a diaper change was needed. The therapist observed the strong attachment between the twins and the caregivers, while with father, she stated, "I don't see the connection there." The twins' speech therapist also observed that the children "appear to be overstimulated" when with father and that father would not engage with the therapy unless she required him to do so. She noted that the children called their caregivers "Papa" and "Daddy" and were excited to see them, while they were calm when they saw father. The CSW observed a social group therapy session on October 21, 2024 and noted that father was attentive and enthusiastic and the children were happy and engaged. Afterward, the therapist noted that father was much more engaged than he usually was during a session. Father told DCFS that he wanted the children back. The caregivers remained committed to adopting the twins. DCFS recommended terminating parental rights and continuing adoptive planning.
The court held the hearing on father's section 388 petition on October 9 and November 12, 2024.4The CSW who prepared the most recent report testified that he had attended two recent visits with father, his partner, and the children. The CSW stated that the visits went well, the children were affectionate and father's interactions were appropriate. He also testified to observing a strong attachment between the children and the caregivers. He noted that the twins would turn to the caregivers for comfort and that the caregivers would go "above and beyond" making sure the twins had the support they needed.
9
Father testified about what he had learned from his domestic violence and parenting classes. He also explained that he had trouble finding a therapist but now was attending once a week. He denied failing to change diapers during visits and spending time on his phone during the children's therapy sessions. He complained about the children's relationship with the caregivers, including that they called the caregivers "dad," that the caregivers were also present during the twins' group therapy and did not "let me do my own thing and let me be the father," and claimed that when they arrived for visits, one of the caregivers would often "try to like make [child S.] cry or something for her not to go." Father testified that sometimes at the end of a visit, the children would say they wanted to stay and play more with him.
Father had been with his partner for about 14 months. They lived together with her son and their new baby, he had stable employment, and their home could accommodate the twins. Father claimed he began asking for overnight visits around October 2023 once he had stable housing, but DCFS kept putting it off.
The court denied father's petition. The court noted that its focus after termination of reunification services was on the children's need for permanency and stability and that father had a particularly difficult burden given the near finalization of adoption as the permanent plan. The court commended father for completing the majority of his case plan, but found that he lacked motivation and had not enrolled in individual therapy until after the permanency planning hearing was set. In light of his progress, the court found that father had shown changed circumstances in support of his petition. However, father had not established that it was in the twins' best interest to grant the petition. The court found that "the best interests of the children here is to provide them with permanency and stability." The court pointed out that the twins had not lived with father since they were three months old and were now "extremely bonded" to the caregivers. In addition, the court found that father's relationship with the twins was "a positive relationship, affectionate and good visits [sic], but it is not the type of significant bond that would cause the court to conclude that it would be in the best interests to give father more reunification services." The court
10
credited the observations of the children's therapists as consistently indicating "some deficiencies in father's visits," as well as the difference in the relationship between father and the twins versus the caregivers. Turning to permanency planning, the court found by clear and convincing evidence that the children were adoptable. With respect to father's request to apply the parental benefit exception, the court found that father had met the first element by maintaining regular visitation and having positive visits.5However, the court found father had not met the second element, which required him to prove a substantial positive attachment with the twins. The court noted that the children were only in father's care until they were three months old and had been with the caregivers for the past two years. The court also cited evidence that the children would not ask for father when not with him, would look to the caregivers for comfort, and would at times express not wanting to go to visits, as well as the statements by the children's therapists observing that father did not have a significant bond with the children. Based on all of the evidence, the court found that father's visits were "pleasant visits with some emotional connection," but had not shown the requisite significant attachment.
The court also found that father failed to meet the third element of detriment, as the twins were "very clearly extremely bonded to the caregivers." The court found no evidence of potential long-term harm from severing the relationship with father, such as behavioral or emotional issues. The court concluded that the benefits of adoption, particularly given the
"excellent care" provided by the caregivers, greatly outweighed any potential harm from losing the relationship with father. Having found no applicable exceptions to adoption, the court terminated mother's and father's parental
11
rights and designated the foster caregivers as the prospective adoptive parents.
Father timely appealed from the court's November 12, 2024 orders.
DISCUSSION
Father contends that the juvenile court erred in denying his section 388 petition. He argues that he established changed circumstances and that it would be in the children's best interests to grant the petition. In addition, father asserts that he met the requirements of the parental benefit exception and the court thus erred in terminating his parental rights. We find no error.
I. Section 388 Petition A. Legal Principles
Pursuant to section 388, a parent may petition the juvenile court to modify a previous order based "upon grounds of change of circumstance or new evidence." (§ 388, subd. (a)(1); see also In re Alayah J. (2017) 9 Cal.App.5th 469, 478.) A parent may seek relief under section 388 even after the juvenile court has terminated family reunification services. "After reunification services have been terminated, it is presumed that continued out-of-home care is in the child's best interests. Section 388 allows a parent to rebut that presumption by demonstrating changed circumstances that would warrant modification of a prior court order." ( In re Alayah J., supra, 9 Cal.App.5th at p. 478.) "Even after the focus has shifted from reunification, the scheme provides a means for the court to address a legitimate change of circumstances while protecting the child's need for prompt resolution of his custody status." (In re Marilyn H. (1993) 5 Cal.4th 295, 309.) To obtain modification of an order under section 388, the parent must demonstrate, by a preponderance of the evidence, both a change of circumstances or new evidence, and that the proposed change is in the best interests of the child. (In re Alayah J., supra, 9 Cal.App.5th at p. 478; In re Mickel O. (2011) 197 Cal.App.4th 586, 615.) In evaluating a section 388 petition, the juvenile court may consider factors such as "the seriousness of the reason leading to the child's removal, the reason the problem was not resolved, the passage of time since the child's removal, the relative strength of the bonds with the child, the nature of the change of circumstance, and the reason the change was not made sooner." (In re Mickel O., supra, 197
12
Cal.App.4th at p. 616; see also In re Kimberly F. (1997) 56 Cal.App.4th 519, 530-532.) The analysis is a searching one; the court may consider the entire factual and procedural history of the case. (In re Mickel O., supra, 197 Cal.App.4th at p. 616.) "In assessing the best interests of the child, 'a primary consideration . . . is the goal of assuring stability and continuity.'"
(Ibid.)
We review the juvenile court's denial of a section 388 petition for abuse of discretion. (In re C.J.W. (2007) 157 Cal.App.4th 1075, 1081; see also In re Jasmon O. (1994) 8 Cal.4th 398, 415 (Jasmon O.) ["The petition is addressed to the sound discretion of the juvenile court and its decision will not be disturbed on appeal in the absence of a clear abuse of discretion."].)
B. Analysis
The juvenile court concluded that father met his burden to establish a change of circumstances, based on the evidence that since termination of reunification services, he had completed most of his case plan and consistently visited the twins. But the court found father had not established that it would be in the twins' best interest to reinstate reunification services or return the twins to his care. Father contends this was error. We find no abuse of discretion in the juvenile court's determination that father did not meet his burden on his section 388 petition. In determining the best interest of the twins, the court cited the evidence that they had been out of father's care since they were three months old and had been ably and lovingly cared for by the caregivers for the past two years, or two-thirds of their young lives. Father had failed to reunify with the twins even after 20 months of reunification services and for much of that time made minimal effort to complete his case plan or consistently visit the twins. The court also considered the testimony by two therapists observing the strong bond between the twins and the caregivers, contrasted with a warm but much weaker bond between the twins and father. Although father cites his testimony that he and the twins had a loving bond, it is the trial court's role to assess the credibility of the witnesses and to weigh the evidence. We will not revisit these determinations on appeal. (See, e.g., In re I.B. (2020) 53 Cal.App.5th 133, 156.)
13
Father relies on a parent's fundamental interest in the care and custody of his or her children. He ignores, however, that this interest is no longer paramount after termination of reunification services.
"Although family preservation is the primary objective during the reunification period . . . , upon cessation of reunification efforts, the scale tips away from the parents' interest in maintaining family ties and towards the child's interest in permanence and stability." (Andrea L. v. Superior Court (1998) 64 Cal.App.4th 1377, 1386; see also Jasmon O., supra, 8 Cal.4th at p. 421 [after termination of reunification services, "'[t]he overriding concern . . . is to provide a stable, permanent home in which a child can develop a lasting emotional attachment to his or her caretakers.'" ].) As the Jasmon O. court explained, "after a child has spent a substantial period in foster care and attempts at reunification have proved fruitless, the child's interest in stability outweighs the parent's interest in asserting the right to the custody and companionship of the child." (Id. at pp. 419-420, citing In re Marilyn H., supra, 5 Cal.4th at pp. 307-309.)
Thus, although father presented evidence that he had made efforts to complete his case plan and had improved the consistency of his visits, the juvenile court was entitled to weigh that evidence against the twins' need for stability. Here, it was undisputed that the caregivers had provided a loving, stable home, were committed to adopting the children, and ensured the children's special needs were met. The court did not abuse its discretion in denying father's section 388 petition based on the best interests of the children.
III. Termination of Parental Rights A. Legal Principles
1. Parental benefit exception The express purpose of section 366.26 is "to provide stable, permanent homes" for dependent children. (§ 366.26, subd. (b).) After reunification services are terminated, adoption is the legislative preference. (§ 366.26, subd. (b)(1); see also In re Celine R. (2003) 31 Cal.4th 45, 53 ["'Adoption is the Legislature's first choice because it gives the child the best chance at [a full] emotional commitment from a responsible caretaker.'"]) Thus, once the juvenile court finds the child is adoptable, "the court must order adoption and
14
its necessary consequence, termination of parental rights," unless a parent can establish one of the exceptions set forth in section 366.26, subdivision (c). (In re Celine R., supra, 31 Cal.4th at p. 53; see also § 366.26, subd. (c)(1); Caden C., supra, 11 Cal.5th at p. 625.) These statutory exceptions "merely permit the court, in exceptional circumstances, to choose an option other than the norm, which remains adoption." (In re Celine R., supra, 31 Cal.4th at p. 53; see also In re A.L. (2022) 73 Cal.App.5th 1131, 1150.) Father sought to apply the parental benefit exception, which permits the selection of another permanent plan if a parent has "maintained regular visitation and contact with the child and the child would benefit from continuing the relationship." (§ 366.26, subd. (c)(1)(B)(i).) In Caden C., supra, 11 Cal.5th at p. 631, our Supreme Court set forth three elements the parent must prove to establish the parental benefit exception. First, the parent asserting the exception must show "regular visitation and contact with the child, taking into account the extent of visitation permitted." (Caden C., supra, 11 Cal.5th at p. 636.) This element is
"straightforward," involving an assessment of whether the parent visits consistently. (Id. at p. 632.)
Second, the parent must show that "the child has a substantial, positive, emotional attachment to the parent—the kind of attachment implying that the child would benefit from continuing the relationship."
(Caden C., supra, 11 Cal.5th at p. 636.) In assessing whether the child would benefit from continuing the relationship with the parent, "the focus is the child. And the relationship may be shaped by a slew of factors, such as '[t]he age of the child, the portion of the child's life spent in the parent's custody, the "positive" or "negative" effect of interaction between parent and child, and the child's particular needs.'" (Id. at p. 632.) Thus, "courts often consider how children feel about, interact with, look to, or talk about their parents."
(Ibid.)
Third, the parent must show that terminating the parent-child attachment "would be detrimental to the child even when balanced against the countervailing benefit of a new, adoptive home." (Caden C., supra, 11 Cal.5th at p. 636.) "Because terminating parental rights eliminates any legal basis for the parent or child to maintain the relationship, courts must assume
15
that terminating parental rights terminates the relationship. [Citations.] What courts need to determine, therefore, is how the child would be affected by losing the parental relationship—in effect, what life would be like for the child in an adoptive home without the parent in the child's life." (Id. at p. 633.) This evaluation consists of a "subtle, case-specific inquiry[,]" including consideration of whether "the benefit of placement in a new, adoptive home"
outweighs the harm the child "would experience from the loss of [a] significant, positive, emotional relationship" with the parent. (Ibid.) In making this detriment determination, the juvenile court does "not look to whether the parent can provide a home for the child," and "is not comparing the parent's attributes as custodial caregiver relative to those of any potential adoptive parent(s)." (Id. at p. 634.)
2. Standard of review We apply a mixed standard of review to a juvenile court's findings regarding the parental benefit exception. The first two elements—regular visitation and a beneficial relationship—involve determinations that are essentially factual; we therefore review those findings for substantial evidence. (Caden C., supra, 11 Cal.5th at p. 640.) The third element requires the juvenile court to determine whether any harm the child would suffer from the severance of the parental bond would outweigh the benefit to the child of adoption. (Ibid.) Like the first two elements, the juvenile court must make a series of factual determinations including determinations about the child's relationship with a parent, which we review for substantial evidence. (Id. at p. 640.) However, "the ultimate decision—whether termination of parental rights would be detrimental to the child due to the child's relationship with his [or her] parent—is discretionary and properly reviewed for abuse of discretion." (Ibid.)
In this case, the juvenile court found that father did not meet his burden of proving the exception. In such a case, where the trier of fact has
"expressly or implicitly concluded that the party with the burden of proof did not carry the burden and that party appeals, it is misleading to characterize the failure-of-proof issue as whether substantial evidence supports the judgment. This follows because such a characterization is conceptually one that allows an attack on (1) the evidence supporting the party who had no
16
burden of proof, and (2) the trier of fact's unassailable conclusion that the party with the burden did not prove one or more elements of the case." (In re I.W. (2009) 180 Cal.App.4th 1517, 1528, overruled on other grounds by Conservatorship of O.B. (2020) 9 Cal.5th 989.) Thus, to the extent father challenges the juvenile court's findings regarding his failure of proof, we determine whether the evidence compels a finding in father's favor as a matter of law, asking whether that evidence was uncontradicted and unimpeached and of such a character and weight as to leave no room for a judicial determination it was insufficient to support a finding. (In re I.W., supra, 180 Cal.App.4th at p. 1528.)6
B. Analysis
The juvenile court found that father met the first element for the parental benefit exception under Caden C.—regular visitation with the children—but failed to meet the second or third elements. Neither party challenges this finding and we therefore do not address it. The second element required father to establish that the twins had a
"substantial, positive, [and] emotional attachment" to him. (Caden C., supra,
11 Cal.5th at p. 636.) That meant demonstrating that the children's attachment was "significant" and conferred more than "some incidental benefit" to the twins. (In re Autumn H. (1994) 27 Cal.App.4th 567, 575.) Father argues that the evidence does not support the court's finding that there was no substantial attachment between him and the twins. But he cannot show, as he must, that the evidence was "uncontradicted and unimpeached and of such a character and weight as to leave no room for a judicial determination it was insufficient to support a finding." (In re I.W., supra, 180 Cal.App.4th at p. 1528.) Father had not cared for the twins for most of their lives, and for most of the period of dependency supervision, he missed or cut short many of his visits. Although he was able to gain unmonitored supervision, he never progressed further. Father complains that DCFS rebuffed his requests for overnight visits, but there was evidence in the record that much, if not most, of the delay was attributable to father's issues, as he lacked stable housing, rebuffed DCFS attempts to schedule a
17
review of his home, and then failed to address safety issues at the home that DCFS had identified.
Although the court found that father and the twins enjoyed playing together during visits, there was significant evidence in the record that father and the twins lacked the strong bond required to support application of the exception. "A positive attachment between parent and child is . . . nurturing and provides the child with a sense of security and stability. . . . [A]n emotional attachment is one where the child views the parent as more than a mere friend or playmate and who's interactions with the parent were not ambivalent, detached, or indifferent." (In re B.D. (2021) 66 Cal.App.5th 1218, 1230; see also In re Katherine J. (2022) 75 Cal.App.5th 303, 318 ["the beneficial relationship exception demands something more than the incidental benefit a child gains from any amount of positive contact with her natural parent"].)
Father cites to testimony that the CSW considered that there likely would be continued contact between the parents and the children following termination of parental rights. He notes that the court cannot consider this possibility in determining whether terminating parental rights would be detrimental to the children. (See Caden C., supra, 11 Cal.5th at p. 633 ["Because terminating parental rights eliminates any legal basis for the child to maintain the relationship, courts must assume that terminating parental rights terminates the relationship."].) There is no suggestion in this record that the juvenile court relied on this evidence. Indeed, counsel for both mother and father repeatedly reminded the court during the section 366.26 hearing that it could not consider any post-adoption contact with the parents. During counsel's examination of the social worker, the court responded to an objection on this issue by agreeing, "I know, legally, the court can't consider it." As such, father has not demonstrated any error by the court. We similarly find no error in the juvenile court's conclusion that father failed to establish the third element, that it would be "harmful to the child[ren] to sever the relationship and choose adoption." (Caden C., supra,
11 Cal.5th at p. 633.) As discussed above, the twins had developed a deep bond with their caregivers and were thriving in their care. The caregivers had provided a stable, loving home for the twins for two years and made sure
18
all of their needs were met, resulting in marked improvements in their developmental delays. The twins referred to the caregivers as "papa" and
"daddy," turned to them for comfort, and were excited to see them. By contrast, the court was entitled to consider the evidence that father and the twins lacked a strong bond, that father was not always focused or involved in their therapy, and that the children did not always want to attend visitation. The court could also consider the length of time father was given reunification services and his failure to complete many elements of the services, including many months of missed visits, father's initial refusal to visit the twins without mother, and his failure to complete his court-ordered programs. Here, the evidence supports the court's findings that there was not a significant emotional relationship between father and the children and additionally, that the children had "security and the sense of belonging" with their caregivers. (Caden C., supra, 11 Cal.5th at p. 633.) As such, the court was well within its discretion to conclude that the benefits of allowing the twins' adoption by their long-time caregivers, to whom they were deeply bonded, outweighed any detriment from terminating father's parental rights.
19
DISPOSITION
The orders denying father's section 388 petition and terminating his parental rights are affirmed.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
COLLINS, ACTING P. J.
We concur:
MORI, J.
TAMZARIAN, J.
20