Michigan Supreme Court Lansing, Michigan
Megan K. Cavanagh, Chief Justice Brian K. Zahra Richard H. Bernstein Elizabeth M. Welch Kyra H. Bolden Kimberly A. Thomas Noah P. Hood,
Justices
Order
July 2, 2025
166182
CODY BONTER and KAYTLIN JACKMAN, Plaintiffs/Counterdefendants- Appellants,
v SC: 166182
COA: 360411
Genesee CC: 21-115568-CK
PROGRESSIVE MARATHON INSURANCE
COMPANY,
Defendant/Counterplaintiff/ Cross-Plaintiff-Appellee, and
TAYLON WILLIAMS,
Defendant/Cross-Defendant. _________________________________________/ On May 7, 2025, the Court heard oral argument on the application for leave to appeal the August 17, 2023 judgment of the Court of Appeals. On order of the Court, the application is again considered. MCR 7.305(I)(1). In lieu of granting leave to appeal, we REVERSE the judgment of the Court of Appeals holding that the increased minimum bodily injury or death liability limits for no-fault insurance policies enacted in 2019 PA 21 and 2019 PA 22 do not apply to policies delivered or issued for delivery before July 2, 2020, and we REMAND this case to that court for further consideration not inconsistent with this order.
MCL 500.3009 sets the minimum liability limits for property damage and bodily injury or death coverage in automobile liability policies. Effective June 11, 2019, MCL 500.3009(1) provides that, "[s]ubject to subsections (5) to (8), an automobile liability or motor vehicle liability policy . . . must not be delivered or issued for delivery . . . unless the liability coverage is subject to all of" the minimum liability limits provided in Subsections (1)(a) through (1)(c). This case concerns only the limits provided in
1
2
Subsections (1)(a) and (1)(b).1As amended by 2019 PA 21 and 2019 PA 22, Subsections (1)(a) and (1)(b) identify the applicable minimum liability limits for bodily injury or death coverage before July 2, 2020, as $20,000 for one person in any one accident and $40,000 for two or more persons in any one accident, and, after July 1, 2020, as $250,000 for one person in any one accident and $500,000 for two or more persons in any one accident. Here, defendant Progressive issued the present policy on June 19, 2020,2which is after the June 11, 2019 effective date of 2019 PA 21 and 2019 PA 22. Accordingly, Subsection (1) required the policy to include "all" the minimum liability limits set forth in Subsections (1)(a) and (1)(b). MCL 500.3009(1). Yet the policy, which was in effect from June 20 to December 20, 2020, included only the $20,000/$40,000 liability limits for bodily injury or death. These terms did not satisfy the requirements of Subsections (1)(a) and (1)(b) because they did not incorporate liability limits of at least $250,000/$500,000 for the coverage period beginning July 2, 2020, through the policy's end date of December 20, 2020. By delivering a policy that did not comply with the minimum liability limits specified in Subsections (1)(a) and (1)(b), Progressive issued a policy that failed to comply with the minimum requirements of the no-fault act.
In so concluding, we reject the Court of Appeals' conclusion that the date ranges in Subsections (1)(a) and (1)(b) instead modify the verb phrase "must not be delivered or issued for delivery" in Subsection (1).3This reading is contrary to the statute's plain
2
3
language and organization. Subsection (1) requires that the "liability coverage" of automobile policies must fulfill "all of the following limits," expressing that the entirety of what follows in Subsections (1)(a) and (1)(b) are the required "limits" on "the liability coverage" in an insurance policy, rather than a further condition on the statement in Subsection (1) that a policy "must not be delivered or issued for delivery." Had the Legislature intended to require the coverage levels in Subsections (1)(a) and (1)(b) to apply only in policies delivered or issued for delivery after July 1, 2020, it would have used different language to express that intention. Indeed, the Legislature explicitly limited other contemporaneously enacted no-fault amendments to policies issued or renewed after July 1, 2020. See, e.g., MCL 500.3107c(1); MCL 500.3107d(1). Instead, Subsection (1) of MCL 500.3009 requires that a policy may not be delivered or issued for delivery unless it provides all of the minimum liability coverage prescribed in Subsections (1)(a) and (1)(b), while Subsections (1)(a) and (1)(b) specify what coverage level is to be provided and differentiate between the required coverage level before July 2, 2020, and after July 1, 2020. "Courts cannot assume that the Legislature inadvertently omitted from one statute the language that it placed in another statute, and then, on the basis of that assumption, apply what is not there." Farrington v Total Petroleum, Inc, 442 Mich 201, 210 (1993). Thus, the general effective date of 2019 PA 21 and 2019 PA 22—June 11, 2019—governs, such that policies delivered or issued for delivery after that date must comply with "all"
the coverage requirements in Subsections (1)(a) and (1)(b) unless the insured selects a different coverage level under Subsection (5).4
We also reject Progressive's argument that this interpretation is inconsistent with Subsection (1)'s provision that it is subject to Subsections (5) to (8). Subsections (5) through (8) generally provide the option to purchase bodily injury liability coverage that is less than the minimums provided in Subsections (1)(a) and (1)(b). Subsections (5), (6), and (8) begin with the phrase "[a]fter July 1, 2020," and therefore were not applicable when policies, like the present one, were issued or renewed before July 2, 2020. Subsection (5) gives "an applicant" or a "named insured" the option to purchase bodily injury or death liability coverage that is less than the $250,000/$500,000 minimums provided in Subsections (1)(a) and (1)(b),5and Subsections (6) and (7) require insurers to advise
4 As the dissent notes, the Department of Insurance and Financial Services (DIFS) website issued guidance that conflicts with our holding today. Although this Court grants respectful consideration to an administrative agency's interpretation of a statute, guidance posted on an administrative agency's website—like any agency interpretation—cannot rewrite the plain language of a statute. See In re Complaint of Rovas Against SBC Mich,
3
4
insureds of this option and provide a form for them to select their preferred coverage. Finally, Subsection (8) provides that, if the insured "has not made an effective choice under subsection (5)," the insurer must issue a policy containing the $250,000/$500,000 minimum coverages provided in Subsections (1)(a) and (1)(b). Read together, Subsection
(1) requires any policy delivered or issued for delivery after the statute's effective date of June 11, 2019, to provide the statutory minimum liability coverage—which is $250,000/$500,000 after July 1, 2020—and Subsections (5) through (7) allow an insured to opt for lower coverage beginning July 2, 2020.6
Having concluded that Subsection (1) required insurers issuing policies after June 11, 2019, to provide for minimum liability limits of $250,000/$500,000 after July 1, 2020, and that Progressive failed to do so in the present policy, we now reverse the judgment of the Court of Appeals and remand this case to that court for consideration of Progressive's remaining arguments.
We do not retain jurisdiction.
Z AHRA, J. (dissenting).
I respectfully dissent. I would affirm the judgment of the Court of Appeals, because I agree with the panel that the Court of Appeals' decision in Progressive Marathon Ins Co who received a policy before July 2, 2020—and whose policy should have provided for $250,000/$500,000 liability limits after July 1, 2020—may purchase lower limits after that date. Thus, contrary to the dissent's suggestion, a policy issued before July 2, 2020, could still be "subject to" Subsection (5).
4
5
v Pena7is dispositive.8In Pena, the Court of Appeals correctly concluded that the increased bodily injury minimum liability limits for no-fault insurance policies enacted in 2019 PA 22 do not apply to insurance policies issued or delivered before July 2, 2020. In concluding to the contrary, a majority of this Court fails to consider MCL 500.3009 in its entirety and in its proper context in light of contemporaneous amendments of the no-fault act, MCL 500.3101 et seq.
Effective June 11, 2019, legislative amendments of MCL 500.3009 raised the minimum liability limits on auto policies, identifying July 2, 2020, as the date on which those limits changed.9Defendant Progressive Marathon Insurance Company issued a six- month policy to defendant Taylon Williams on June 19, 2020,10which would expire on December 20, 2020. Williams was involved in an accident on July 25, 2020, which injured plaintiffs Cody Bonter and Kaytlin Jackman. In addition to unlimited personal protection insurance (PIP) benefits, the applicable no-fault policy provided for limited bodily injury coverage up to $20,000 for any one person and $40,000 for any one accident, regardless of the number of covered automobiles or insured persons involved. At issue is whether the amendment of MCL 500.3009 required the June 19, 2020, policy to include the heightened limits of $250,000 for any one person and $500,000 for any one accident, where the accident occurred after July 1, 2020.
As amended, MCL 500.3009 states, in pertinent part:
5
6
(1) Subject to subsections (5) to (8), an automobile liability or motor vehicle liability policy that insures against loss resulting from liability imposed by law for property damage, bodily injury, or death suffered by any person arising out of the ownership, maintenance, or use of a motor vehicle must not be delivered or issued for delivery in this state with respect to any motor vehicle registered or principally garaged in this state unless the liability coverage is subject to all of the following limits:
(a) Before July 2, 2020, a limit, exclusive of interest and costs, of not less than $20,000.00 because of bodily injury to or death of 1 person in any 1 accident, and after July 1, 2020, a limit, exclusive of interest and costs, of not less than $250,000.00 because of bodily injury to or death of 1 person in any 1 accident.
(b) Before July 2, 2020 and subject to the limit for 1 person in subdivision (a), a limit of not less than $40,000.00 because of bodily injury to or death of 2 or more persons in any 1 accident, and after July 1, 2020, and subject to the limit for 1 person in subdivision (a), a limit of not less than $500,000.00 because of bodily injury to or death of 2 or more persons in any 1 accident.
* * *
(5) After July 1, 2020, an applicant for or named insured in the automobile liability or motor vehicle liability policy described in subsection
(1) may choose to purchase lower limits than required under subsection (1)(a) and (b), but not lower than $50,000.00 under subsection (1)(a) and $100,000.00 under subsection (1)(b). To exercise an option under this subsection, the person shall complete a form issued by the director and provided as required by section 3107e, that meets the requirements of subsection (7).
(6) After July 1, 2020, on application for the issuance of a new policy or renewal of an existing policy, an insurer shall do all of the following:
(a) Provide the applicant or named insured the liability options available under this section.
(b) Provide the applicant or named insured a price for each option available under this section.
(c) Offer the applicant or named insured the option and form under this subsection.
6
7
(7) The form required under subsection (5) must do all of the following:
(a) State, in a conspicuous manner, the risks of choosing liability limits lower than those required by subsection (1)(a) and (b).
(b) Provide a way for the person to mark the form to acknowledge that he or she has received a list of the liability options available under this section and the price for each option.
(c) Provide a way for the person to mark the form to acknowledge that he or she has read the form and understands the risks of choosing the lower liability limits.
(d) Allow the person to sign the form.
(8) After July 1, 2020, if an insurance policy is issued or renewed as described in subsection (1) and the person named in the policy has not made an effective choice under subsection (5), the limits under subsection (1)(a) and (b) apply to the policy.
This case presents the exact same legal issue as that presented in Pena. In that case, the Court of Appeals rejected the argument that the 2019 amendments of MCL 500.3009 automatically increased liability coverage for preexisting policies whose terms extended beyond July 1, 2020. Instead, the panel analyzed the plain language of MCL 500.3009 to conclude that the Legislature intended for the heightened liability limits to apply only to policies delivered or issued after July 1, 2020. I agree with the Court of Appeals' holding in Pena and with the Court of Appeals' application of that holding in this case. MCL 500.3009(1) is poorly drafted; the Legislature could have more clearly specified which language in the body of Subsection (1) it intended the July 2, 2020, date set forth in MCL 500.3009(1)(a) and (b) to modify. In reversing the Court of Appeals, a majority of this Court concludes that the July 2, 2020, date found in Subdivisions (a) and
(b) refers to the "unless the liability coverage is subject to all of the following limits"
language in Subsection (1).11According to the majority, this means that because
7
8
Progressive issued the applicable policy after the effective date of 2019 PA 22, Subsection
(1) of MCL 500.3009 required the policy's liability coverage to meet all of the minimum liability limits set forth in both Subdivisions (a) and (b) by providing a $20,000/$40,000 bodily injury limit through July 1, 2020, and then a $250,000/$500,000 bodily injury limit thereafter. While this interpretation makes some sense when reading Subsection (1) in isolation, when considered in its proper context, the Court of Appeals in Pena more reasonably concluded that the July 2, 2020, date set forth in MCL 500.3009(1)(a) and (b) should be read in reference to the "delivered or issued for delivery" language in Subsection (1). That is, MCL 500.3009(1)(a) and (b) are conditioned on when a policy was "delivered or issued for delivery" under Subsection (1). Accordingly, policies "delivered or issued for delivery" before July 2, 2020, were subject to coverage limits of $20,000/$40,000 under Subsection (1)(a), and only those "delivered or issued for delivery" after July 1, 2020, are subject to the heightened limits of $250,000/$500,000 under Subsection (1)(b). To the extent that MCL 500.3009(1) is difficult to decipher, any confusion is resolved when reading MCL 500.3009 in its entirety and in context with related provisions of the no-fault act, which this Court is required to do. Starting with MCL 500.3009, Subsection (1) states that its provisions are "[s]ubject to" Subsections (5) through (8), all of which incorporate a July 1, 2020, date. MCL 500.3009(5) includes an option for an insured to purchase lower liability limits after July 1, 2020, providing that "[a]fter July 1, 2020, an applicant for or named insured in the automobile liability or motor vehicle liability policy described in subsection (1) may choose to purchase lower limits than required under subsection (1)(a) and (b), but not lower than $50,000.00 under subsection (1)(a) and $100,000.00 under subsection (1)(b)."12The Legislature seemingly would not have made the coverage provided for in Subsection (1) "[s]ubject to" the election referred to in Subsection (5) before that election was contemplated—"after July 1, 2020."
Notably, Subsection (6) provides:
After July 1, 2020, on application for the issuance of a new policy or renewal of an existing policy, an insurer shall do all of the following:
(a) Provide the applicant or named insured the liability options available under this section.
"all of the following limits" in the statute was seemingly intended to convey that all three types of minimum coverage are required to be included in no-fault policies. I question the majority's reliance on this language to support its conclusion that policies must contain not only the three types of coverage referred to in the statute, but both the pre- and post-July 2, 2020, monetary limits set forth in MCL 500.3009(1)(a) and (b).
8
9
(b) Provide the applicant or named insured a price for each option available under this section.
(c) Offer the applicant or named insured the option and form under this subsection.
This subsection does not require insurers to provide such information when issuing a policy that takes effect before July 2, 2020, and lasts beyond July 1, 2020. If the increased limits automatically applied to that group of insureds, as the majority concludes, then those insureds would also need to be apprised of the change in limits and the ability to purchase lower limits under Subsection (5). Because the insureds are not statutorily entitled to such information, it is unlikely that the Legislature intended the heightened limits to apply to policies that were issued before July 2, 2020. Rather, the increased limits apply only when an application is made after July 1, 2020.
Finally, Subsection (8) states that "[a]fter July 1, 2020, if an insurance policy is issued or renewed as described in subsection (1) and the person named in the policy has not made an effective choice under subsection (5), the limits under subsection (1)(a) and
(b) apply to the policy."13This language indicates that the insured may make a choice as to coverage, and that the default under Subsection (8) is automatically invoked absent a contrary choice only where a policy is issued or renewed after July 1, 2020.14If the majority's interpretation is correct, this language would also apply to policies issued or renewed prior to July 2, 2020, with terms that extended beyond July 1, 2020. In short, consideration of the statute in its entirety supports the Court of Appeals' interpretation in Pena. The Legislature easily could have included a subsection making clear that all existing policies must be adjusted before July 2, 2020. It also could have included a different deadline for making an election under MCL 500.3009(5) so that insurers and insureds could mutually agree on a policy that would go into effect on July 2, 2020. Instead, the Legislature enacted a statute that repeatedly refers to events occurring after July 1, 2020, with Subsection (6) specifically providing instruction as to what needs to occur for "the issuance of a new policy or renewal of an existing policy" "[a]fter July 1, 2020." The statute simply does not contemplate that the heightened limits set forth in MCL 500.3009(1) apply to policies issued before July 2, 2020.
9
10
Just as other subsections of MCL 500.3009 support the interpretation of the Court of Appeals in Pena, so too do related provisions of the no-fault act. This is because at the same time that the Legislature modified MCL 500.3009, it added or modified provisions of the no-fault act to apply when a policy is issued or renewed after July 1, 2020. The Legislature added MCL 500.3107c, which allows insurance applicants to purchase limited PIP coverage—with a corresponding reduction in the premium—for policies "issued or renewed after July 1, 2020."15MCL 500.3109a(2) instructs that "[f]or an insurance policy issued or renewed after July 1, 2020, the insurer shall offer to an applicant or named insured that selects a personal protection benefit limit under section 3107c(1)(b) an exclusion related to qualified health coverage."16And MCL 500.3107d allows applicants who are qualified persons to decline PIP coverage altogether for a policy that "is issued or renewed after July 1, 2020."17I seriously doubt that the Legislature intended for these statutes to apply only to policies issued or renewed after July 1, 2020, yet also intended the increase in minimum liability limits of MCL 500.3009 to apply to policies that were issued before July 2, 2020.
These amendments tie into the Legislature's simultaneous reform of tort liability under the no-fault act. MCL 500.3135(3)(c) subjects tortfeasors to liability for allowable expense damages exceeding any applicable limits selected under MCL 500.3107c, or without limit for allowable expenses for those who excluded PIP coverage entirely under MCL 500.3107d, which, again, both explicitly refer to policies issued or renewed after July 1, 2020.18As the Court of Appeals in Pena explained, "[b]ecause applicants or named
10
11
insureds were only permitted to limit or exclude PIP coverage under MCL 500.3107c and 3107d in policies issued or renewed after July 1, 2020, their direct reference in MCL 500.3135 indicates that the changes in tort liability cannot affect policies issued prior to July 2, 2020."19Consideration of all of these amendments makes clear that the Legislature intended a combination of changes to available PIP benefits, tort recovery, and liability limits for policies issued or renewed after July 1, 2020.20The increased limits set forth in MCL 500.3009(1)(a) and (b), and the ability to elect lower limits under MCL 500.3009(5), are part of a comprehensive group of changes that apply only to policies issued or renewed after July 1, 2020. MCL 500.3009 therefore did not increase liability coverage for preexisting policies whose terms extended beyond July 1, 2020. Because Progressive's respect to which the security required by section 3101(1) was in effect is abolished except as to:
* * *
(c) Damages for allowable expenses, work loss, and survivor's loss as defined in sections 3107 to 3110, including all future allowable expenses and work loss, in excess of any applicable limit under section 3107c or the daily, monthly, and 3-year limitations contained in those sections, or without limit for allowable expenses if an election to not maintain that coverage was made under section 3107d or if an exclusion under section 3109a(2) applies.
11
12
policy is consistent with the plain language of MCL 500.3009, the trial court erred by granting summary disposition in favor of plaintiffs.
It is noteworthy that the Department of Insurance and Financial Services (DIFS), the entity tasked with interpreting and applying no-fault statutes, approved of this interpretation. The DIFS stated on a website addressing frequently asked questions about 2019 PAs 21 and 22 that the "changes will apply to policies issued or renewed after July 1, 2020." The DIFS also stated the following question and answer on its website:
When does Section 3009 requiring a change in Bodily Injury limits become effective? Does it go in effect for new policies written and existing policies renewing after July 1, 2020, or does it go in effect for all policies on that date?
[Answer:] The new BI limits did not automatically apply on July 2, 2020. They become effective for policies that are issued or renewed after July 1, 2020.
Progressive complied with the DIFS's clear guidance. If insurers were required to issue a staggered policy (with different policy limits applied up to and after July 1, 2020), it was never contemplated by the DIFS, nor did the DIFS appear to contemplate that insurers would need to terminate all policies on July 1, 2020, and issue new policies after that date.
Finally, the majority's interpretation requires Progressive to provide limits more than 12 times higher than what was contracted for without an increased premium. The majority's interpretation allows Williams to receive unlimited PIP benefits under the policy because it predated July 2, 2020, but also obtain the benefit of the highest liability limit that the Legislature intended would apply only to policies issued or renewed after July 1, 2020. Williams bears no burden by adhering to the $20,000/$40,000 liability limits that he purchased.
In sum, I would affirm the judgment of the Court of Appeals because Pena correctly held that the amendments of MCL 500.3009 did not automatically increase liability coverage for preexisting policies whose terms extended beyond July 1, 2020.21This result
12
13
is consistent with the plain text of MCL 500.3009, as well as with related provisions of the no-fault act.22For these reasons, I dissent.
stated that "an auto that permanently replaces an auto shown on the declarations page . . . will have the same coverage as the auto it replaces if the replacement auto is not covered by any other insurance policy." (Emphasis added and omitted.) On July 6, 2020, Progressive, at Williams' request, changed the insured vehicle under the policy from a 2014 Jeep Grand Cherokee to a 2017 Dodge Charger.
Plaintiffs disclaimed any argument that this swap amounted to the issuance of a new policy. But even if they did not, this argument would fail. In Wells v Detroit Auto Inter- Ins Exch, 29 Mich App 235, 241 (1970), the Court of Appeals concluded that a vehicle swap conducted under a nearly identical provision did not amount to a new policy. By providing coverage for Williams' Jeep, Progressive was merely fulfilling its obligations under the original June 20, 2020 policy. Consequently, the analysis set forth in Pena is entirely applicable and dispositive here.
13
I, Larry S. Royster, Clerk of the Michigan Supreme Court, certify that the foregoing is a true and complete copy of the order entered at the direction of the Court. July 2, 2025
t0625
14
Clerk WELCH, J., joins the statement of ZAHRA, J. B ERNSTEIN and HOOD, JJ., took no part in the decision of this case.
14