THE DISTRICT COURT'S FIRST COMPETENCY ORDER AND ITS ORDER
DENYING REEVALUATION
¶18 The State first asks us to review our jurisdiction to consider Menzies's appeals of the first competency order and the order denying reevaluation. It argues Menzies does not have a right to appeal the competency orders because his original sentence,
6
Cite as: 2025 UT 38 Opinion of the Court
7
entered in 1988, constituted the final judgment, and no statute grants him the express authority to appeal the orders.8We disagree. ¶19 Here, Utah Code subsection 77-18a-1(1)(b) grants Menzies express authority to appeal the district court's competency orders. That provision states, "A defendant may, as a matter of right, appeal from . . . an order made after judgment that affects the substantial rights of the defendant."9An order deeming a defendant competent to be executed or denying a reevaluation of competency undoubtedly "affects the substantial rights of the defendant." The Eighth Amendment prohibits a state from executing "one whose mental illness prevents him from comprehending the reasons for the penalty or its implications."10 An order rejecting a claim of incompetency to be executed thus implicates the defendant's constitutional right to be free from cruel and unusual punishments.11
¶20 The State argues that, in the same statute, the legislature expressly gave the State the right to "appeal an order finding a defendant incompetent to be executed,"12but the statute grants a defendant "no corresponding right to appeal an order finding him competent to be executed." That "precise exclusion," the State argues, "should control over any broad reading of 'substantial __________________________________________________________
7
STATE v. MENZIES Opinion of the Court
8
rights'" that would grant a defendant an appeal of a competency order as of right. Again, we disagree.
¶21 This is not a situation where the specific controls over the general, as the State contends.13In that situation, "when two statutory provisions conflict in their operation, the provision more specific in application governs over the more general provision."14 But the two provisions the State points to here are not in conflict. We may not read the legislature's explicit and narrow grant of the State's right to appeal as overriding the legislature's explicit and broad grant of a right to appeal to a criminal defendant. As we have previously recognized, the State's right to appeal is limited relative to the broad appeal rights granted to defendants.15We thus conclude that we have jurisdiction to hear Menzies's appeals from the district court's competency order and order denying reevaluation.
II. THE EIGHTH AMENDMENT BARS EXECUTION OF A PETITIONER WHO
LACKS A RATIONAL UNDERSTANDING OF THE STATE'S REASON FOR
EXECUTING HIM
¶22 Having confirmed our jurisdiction, we turn to the merits of Menzies's appeals. We start by reviewing the rational understanding test laid out by the United States Supreme Court for evaluating competency in this context.
¶23 Over the last forty years, the Supreme Court has explained that the Eighth Amendment protects incompetent individuals from execution. In Ford v. Wainwright, the Supreme Court established that "the Eighth Amendment prohibits a State from carrying out a sentence of death upon a prisoner who is insane."16Competency- __________________________________________________________
8
Cite as: 2025 UT 38 Opinion of the Court
9
to-be-executed challenges ripen when execution is "imminent"
because a petitioner must be competent at the time of the execution.17
¶24 Building on its holding in Ford, the Supreme Court articulated in Panetti v. Quarterman and Madison v. Alabama that competency turns on "whether a prisoner can reach a rational understanding of the reason for his execution."18Stated differently, The critical question is whether a prisoner's mental state is so distorted by a mental illness that he lacks a rational understanding of the State's rationale for his execution. Or similarly put, the issue is whether a prisoner's concept of reality is so impaired that he cannot grasp the execution's meaning and purpose or the link between his crime and its punishment.19 Incompetency can arise from a variety of mental illnesses, including conditions like vascular dementia.20What matters most in evaluating competency to be executed is not the specific diagnosis at issue, but its "downstream consequence[s]"—the ultimate effect it has on a petitioner's ability to rationally understand the State's reasons for his or her execution.21 __________________________________________________________
9
STATE v. MENZIES Opinion of the Court
10
¶25 The Supreme Court has repeatedly acknowledged that the rational understanding standard is somewhat vague and requires a fact-intensive test.22Given the test is a fact-specific inquiry, "[t]he conclusions of physicians, psychiatrists, and other experts in the field will bear upon the proper analysis."23Here, all parties agree that Menzies suffers from vascular dementia. At issue in the competency proceedings is only whether Menzies's vascular dementia prevents him from having a rational understanding of the State's reasons for executing him.24We next turn to his competency proceedings.
III. THE DISTRICT COURT ERRED IN DENYING MENZIES'S PETITION FOR
REEVALUATION
¶26 Having outlined the constitutional standard for evaluating competency to be executed, we turn now to the threshold requirements for a petition to reevaluate competency. Menzies argues that the district court misinterpreted what legal standard applies to a successive competency petition and that it erred in concluding that Menzies failed to meet his burden to reopen his competency proceedings. We agree on both counts. ¶27 We begin by reviewing the statutory framework for competency-to-be-executed proceedings. We then apply that framework to Menzies's case and hold that the district court erred in denying Menzies's petition for reevaluation. We review the district court's interpretation of statutes for correctness.25We also review prima facie determinations for correctness.26 __________________________________________________________
10
Cite as: 2025 UT 38 Opinion of the Court
11
A. Utah Code Subsection 77-19-203(5) Requires a Petitioner to Make a Prima Facie Showing to Reopen Competency Proceedings
¶28 Utah Code sections 77-19-201 through -205 lay out the statutory procedures for evaluating a petitioner's competency to be executed. Most relevant here, section 77-19-203 outlines the requirements for a petition to initiate competency proceedings and section 205 adds additional requirements for successive petitions made after the petitioner has previously been found competent. Menzies argues the district court erred by misinterpreting its role under the statute. When we interpret statutory text, our goal "is to ascertain the intent of the legislature, the best evidence of which is the plain language of the statute itself."27
¶29 Subsection 77-19-203(1) provides, "If an inmate who has been sentenced to death is or becomes incompetent to be executed, a petition . . . may be filed in the district court of the county where the inmate is confined."28Subsection (2)(a) requires that the petition must be filed "in good faith" and based "on reasonable grounds to believe the inmate is incompetent to be executed."29 And subsection (2)(b) states the petition must "contain a specific recital of the facts, observations, and conversations with the inmate that form the basis for the petition."30Under subsection (3), the petition "may be based upon knowledge or information and belief and may be filed by the inmate . . . , legal counsel for the inmate, or by an attorney representing the state."31Subsection (4) instructs that, after receiving a petition, "the court shall give the state and the Department of Corrections an opportunity to respond to the allegations of incompetency."32
¶30 Subsection (5) provides a path for reopening competency proceedings after a district court has found an inmate competent to be executed. Under that provision, "no further hearing on competency may be granted" based on a successive petition unless __________________________________________________________
11
STATE v. MENZIES Opinion of the Court
12
that petition "(a) alleges with specificity a substantial change of circumstances subsequent to the previous determination of competency; and (b) is sufficient to raise a significant question about the inmate's competency to be executed."33 ¶31 The statutory language of section 77-19-203 suggests that the general requirements laid out in subsections (1) through
(4) apply to both an initial competency petition and a successive petition. Subsection (1) states that if a petitioner facing the death penalty becomes incompetent, "a petition . . . may be filed."34 Subsections (2) through (4) mirror that language, speaking in terms of "the petition" or "a petition."35The statute then discusses successive competency petitions: "If a petition is filed after" an initial finding of competency, "no further hearing on competency may be granted unless the successive petition" "alleges with specificity a substantial change of circumstances" and "is sufficient to raise a significant question about the inmate's competency to be executed."36A successive petition is referred to as "a petition,"
echoing the language of subsection 77-19-203(1). We read that to mean that a successive petition is a subset of the competency petitions discussed in subsection (1) and is thus subject to the statutory requirements in subsections (2) through (4), in addition to those in subsection (5).
¶32 The parties debate how much evidence, if any, must accompany the allegations in a successive petition. Subsections (2), (3), and (5) answer this question. A successive petition must
"allege[] with specificity a substantial change of circumstances"
and must be "sufficient to raise a significant question about the inmate's competency to be executed."37The petition must "contain a specific recital of the facts, observations, and conversations with the inmate that form the basis for the petition."38And statements in the petition "may be based upon knowledge or information and __________________________________________________________
12
Cite as: 2025 UT 38 Opinion of the Court
13
belief."39Taken together, we interpret these provisions to require a successive petition to include specific factual allegations. The provisions nowhere require that the petition contain supporting evidence, though a petitioner may opt to enclose supporting exhibits to support his prima facie showing.
¶33 The parties also dispute the State's role in responding to a successive petition. Subsection (4) requires a court to "give the state and the Department of Corrections an opportunity to respond to the allegations of incompetency" before it rules on a petition.40Like the other subsections, that provision does not mention evidence— only the opportunity to respond. Thus the State may present argument that a successive petition does not meet the statutory threshold, but the statute does not permit the State to introduce evidence to rebut the petitioner's initial showing.41That reading is bolstered by the fact that a court may not grant a competency hearing on a successive petition "unless the successive petition . . . alleges with specificity a substantial change of circumstances" and
"is sufficient to raise a significant question about the inmate's competency to be executed."42The plain language suggests that the court must rule on the basis of the showing in the petition, not on the basis of any weighing of contrary evidence. ¶34 A district court reviewing a successive competency petition is performing a gatekeeping function—determining whether a petitioner has made a prima facie showing that the court should hold another competency hearing. It is not deciding on the __________________________________________________________
13
STATE v. MENZIES Opinion of the Court
14
merits whether the petitioner is actually competent.43So long as the petition—including specific allegations and any supporting materials—shows a substantial change in circumstances and raises a significant question about competency, the district court must grant a "further hearing on competency."44The district court must accept the specific allegations in the petition as true in making that threshold determination. Here, rather than look to the petition alone, the court reevaluated competency by weighing the allegations and supporting materials against a number of recorded phone calls submitted by the State. To do so at this prima facie stage was error.
B. The District Court Erred in Concluding That Menzies Failed to Meet His Burden to Make a Prima Facie Showing ¶35 Reviewing the district court's order denying reevaluation under this framework, we hold that the court erred in concluding that Menzies failed to meet his burden to reopen competency proceedings. Because we evaluate prima facie determinations for correctness, we determine whether Menzies made a prima facie showing without deference to the district court's conclusions.45 ¶36 Under Utah Code subsection 77-19-203(5), a petitioner makes a prima facie showing if "the successive petition: (a) alleges with specificity a substantial change of circumstances subsequent to the previous determination of competency; and (b) is sufficient to raise a significant question about the inmate's competency to be executed."
¶37 We first consider whether Menzies's allegations established a substantial change of circumstances. The district court's order highlighted a timing issue that we address briefly __________________________________________________________
14
Cite as: 2025 UT 38 Opinion of the Court
15
before getting to the core of the court's ruling. The court noted that subsection 77-19-203(5)(a) "explicitly requires the change of circumstances to have occurred subsequent to the previous determination of competency." And the court was concerned that
"almost all of Menzies's decline alleged in the successive petition occurred prior to the Court's initial determination of competency"
in an order issued on June 6, 2025.
¶38 Regardless of when Menzies's most significant decline occurred—which may be impossible to pinpoint or prove with respect to his progressive condition—it is undisputed that the petition alleges specific facts that arose after the court's first competency order. Most relevant to our analysis, Menzies's petition to reevaluate competency relied on two expert reports: one from Dr. Lynette M. Abrams-Silva, based on a new evaluation on June 27, 2025 and one from Dr. Thomas M. Hyde, based on a new evaluation on June 30, 2025. The petition alleges that, during those evaluations, Menzies exhibited signs of decline that provided ample support for his claimed post-competency-order change of circumstances, even without considering the alleged pre- competency-order decline. Because we conclude that Menzies makes a prima facie case of incompetency based solely on changes in circumstances allegedly observed at the post-competency-order evaluations, we consider only those factual allegations here. We reserve for another day the statutory interpretation question of whether a change of circumstance that arose prior to an initial competency order could sustain a subsequent petition. ¶39 Looking to Menzies's petition and proffered evidence, we conclude that he "allege[d] with specificity a substantial change of circumstances."46In their June 2025 reports, Dr. Hyde and Dr. Abrams-Silva stated they no longer believed that Menzies had an awareness of the connection between his execution and his murder of Maurine Hunsaker. Experts had previously testified that Menzies had an awareness of this causal link between his conviction and his impending punishment. These new allegations establish a "substantial change."
¶40 Previously, even though Menzies maintained his innocence, he could articulate that he was in prison for the murder of Maurine Hunsaker. When Dr. Abrams-Silva asked about the charges associated with Menzies's death sentence in her initial __________________________________________________________
15
STATE v. MENZIES Opinion of the Court
16
evaluations, Menzies reportedly responded that he was "charged with capital homicide that I didn't do." In her new report, Dr. Abrams-Silva reported that Menzies responded to similar questioning by stating, "They don't tell me all the details."
¶41 Dr. Hyde similarly reported that on June 30, 2025, when asked why he had been sentenced to death, Menzies answered, "I don't know." When queried about the State's official reason for executing him, he replied, "Because they want to. I don't think there is an official explanation." These statements, accepted as true, mark a substantial change in circumstances for Menzies and establish the first prong of Menzies's prima facie case. ¶42 To make a prima facie showing, Menzies also needed to
"raise a significant question about [his] competency to be executed,"47and the allegations he made through the submission of expert reports meet that threshold showing. In his report, Dr. Hyde explained that he asked Menzies "a series of questions to assess Mr. Menzies's understanding of the connection between his crime and punishment, but at no point, even with questions intending to cue correct answers, was he able to articulate a basic awareness that his impending execution was linked to the facts of his offense." Based on their interactions, Dr. Hyde concluded that
"Mr. Menzies no longer possesses an awareness of why he is to be executed."
¶43 Dr. Abrams-Silva had a similar experience. When she asked Menzies about the outcome of his most recent court visit, he stated, "It means they tell me bye-bye." She explained that when
"asked multiple times, rephrased in different ways, to elaborate on this, he could not, and only repeated that the next step was to be told 'bye-bye.'" Based on the whole of her interview, Dr. Abrams- Silva ultimately concluded that Menzies's newly progressed
"cognitive deficits have rendered him incapable of forming a rational understanding or maintaining a factual understanding of the link between his crime and its punishment."
¶44 The district court minimized these expert reports, deeming their statements "conclusory." The court took issue with the fact that "[t]he examiners did not include which questions were asked of Menzies and what his answers, if any, were. Dr. Hyde explained __________________________________________________________
16
Cite as: 2025 UT 38 Opinion of the Court
17
that he cued correct answers in his questioning, but did not provide what cues he used." We disagree.
¶45 Both expert reports provided specific allegations, including "a specific recital of the facts, observations, and conversations with the inmate that form the basis for the petition."48Dr. Abrams-Silva's report included a table listing at least three questions she had asked over the course of four examinations and included Menzies's verbatim answers. And Dr. Hyde included several paraphrased questions he asked, along with several verbatim answers to the questions most relevant to Menzies's competency. That is enough detail at this stage to meet Menzies's burden. As long as the petition, inclusive of its attached reports and any other materials provided with the petition, met both of the criteria of Utah Code subsection 77-19-203(5)—which it did here—the district court should have set another competency proceeding. Then, at an evidentiary hearing, both parties could present their full evidence, as was done in the first competency proceeding.
¶46 Under the "rational understanding" standard we articulated above,49both expert reports raise serious and significant questions about whether Menzies is competent to be executed. Madison dictates that a petitioner must be able to understand "the link between his crime and its punishment."50 The statements by both Dr. Hyde and Dr. Abrams-Silva, taken as true, suggest that Menzies can no longer understand that causal connection. For the district court to weigh the evidence and conclude otherwise at this stage was error.
¶47 Menzies's petition adequately alleged a substantial change of circumstances and raised a significant question as to his competency to be executed. It thus made the prima facie showing required under Utah Code subsection 77-19-203(5). We reverse the district court's order denying reevaluation and remand for further competency proceedings.
__________________________________________________________
17
STATE v. MENZIES Opinion of the Court
18
IV. ONE APPEAL AND ONE PETITION FOR EXTRAORDINARY RELIEF ARE
NOW MOOT AND WE DO NOT CONSIDER THE MOTION TO
DISQUALIFY THE STATE'S COUNSEL IN THE FIRST COMPETENCY
PROCEEDING
¶48 Our decision to reverse the order denying reevaluation and to remand this matter for a new competency evaluation leaves one of Menzies's pending appeals and one of his petitions for extraordinary relief moot. An appeal is moot if "during the pendency of the appeal circumstances change so that the controversy is eliminated, thereby rendering the relief requested impossible or of no legal effect."51
¶49 First, Menzies's appeal of the first competency order is moot. Having ordered that Menzies's competency must be reevaluated, a decision to affirm or reverse the order issued after his first competency proceeding would have no legal effect. ¶50 Second, one of Menzies's petitions for extraordinary relief asked that we stay his execution until the district court ruled on his then-pending petition to reevaluate his competency. He also asked us to continue that stay pending the outcome of any appeal of that order. The district court subsequently issued the order denying reevaluation, and we resolve today the merits of Menzies's appeal of that order. That petition for extraordinary relief is now also moot.
¶51 We also decline Menzies's request that we consider the district court's order denying his motion to disqualify the Attorney General's Office, which was decided during the first competency proceeding.52Menzies briefed this issue with his appeal of the first competency order. Even assuming Menzies had a right to appeal the disqualification order as part of his appeal of the first competency order, his notice of appeal specifically identified only the first competency order as the order being appealed. It did not include the order denying the motion to disqualify. Rule 3 of the Utah Rules of Appellate Procedure requires all orders being __________________________________________________________
18
Cite as: 2025 UT 38 Opinion of the Court
19
appealed to be included in the notice of appeal.53And that requirement is jurisdictional.54
¶52 Further, assuming Menzies did not have the right to appeal the disqualification order as part of his appeal of the first competency order, to consider the disqualification issue we would need to exercise our discretionary authority to grant extraordinary relief.55Under those circumstances, we would decline to exercise that discretion because of the delay in seeking review of the interlocutory disqualification order.56
V. WE VACATE THE WARRANT OF EXECUTION
¶53 Our final task is to address the petition for extraordinary relief that asks us to vacate the execution warrant issued on July 9, 2025. When reviewing extraordinary writ requests, we limit our review "to determining whether the trial court has regularly pursued its authority and has not abused its discretion."57A district court can abuse its discretion in various ways, including when it applies the wrong legal standard or misapplies the law.58 ¶54 The requirements for a district court to enter an execution warrant are prescribed in Utah Code subsection 77-19-9(2): "When the defendant is brought before the court, it shall inquire into the facts and, if no legal reason exists against the execution of judgment, the court shall make an order requiring . . . that the judgment is executed on a specified day . . . ."
¶55 Menzies asserts that two legal reasons existed that should have precluded issuance of the warrant of execution: (1) an appeal was pending (his appeal of the first competency order) and (2) a petition for other relief was pending (his petition to reevaluate his __________________________________________________________
19
STATE v. MENZIES Opinion of the Court
20
competency). In support of his position, he argues that these pending proceedings should have resulted in an automatic stay of any execution proceedings.59We decline to consider whether Menzies was entitled to an automatic stay and instead decide this petition based only on an analysis of whether "legal reason[s] exist[ed] against the execution of judgment" on July 9, 2025.60 ¶56 We conclude that legal reasons did exist on that date that should have stopped the court from issuing a warrant of execution. Menzies had a pending appeal and a pending petition for reevaluation contending that he was incompetent and could not be executed under the Eighth Amendment. On July 9, the district court held a hearing on the State's request for a warrant of execution. At that hearing, the State agreed with the district court that Menzies had a right to directly appeal the court's competency order and that his appeal was pending.
¶57 As we concluded above,61Menzies had a direct right to appeal the first competency order as a post-judgment order "that affects [his] substantial rights."62His constitutional right not to be executed if he is incompetent is unquestionably a "substantial right."63The petition to reevaluate his competency—also pending on July 9, 2025—involved the same substantial right: his right to avoid execution if he is incompetent. While Menzies had pending proceedings that affected his substantial rights, it was legal error for the district court to issue the warrant of execution. ¶58 The State argues that our opinion in State v. Gardner prohibits this conclusion.64In Gardner, we also reviewed an extraordinary writ petition challenging the issuance of an execution warrant.65We interpreted Utah Code subsection 77-19-9(2) to mean __________________________________________________________
20
Cite as: 2025 UT 38 Opinion of the Court
21
that the trial court was required to "review only the procedural status of the case and to determine that no direct or collateral attacks on the judgment are pending, that no stays are in effect, and that there are no procedural defects in the warrant application process" before issuing an execution warrant.66We rejected Gardner's argument that "the trial court erred in declining to consider claims going to the validity of his death sentence as 'legal reasons'" not to issue the warrant.67And though we did not articulate explicitly what type of claims Gardner raised, we held that the statute does not permit review of substantive claims that the underlying sentence is invalid "such as those raised . . . by Mr. Gardner."68Unlike Gardner, Menzies does not raise claims going to the validity of his death sentence.
¶59 A competency-to-be-executed challenge is not a direct or collateral attack on the underlying judgment, sentence, or conviction.69Rather, a competency-to-be-executed challenge brought under Ford and its progeny questions whether a petitioner can constitutionally be executed, based on the petitioner's alleged incompetency at a particular point in time, when execution is imminent.70Other types of mental incompetency claims involve permanent incompetency and may result in vacating a death sentence.71A Ford challenge may result in a long-lasting stay, but it __________________________________________________________
21
STATE v. MENZIES Opinion of the Court
22
does not result in vacatur.72This is a fine and narrow distinction but a significant one.
¶60 The district court recognized the same in its order: "If a defendant is found to be incompetent, either by a lower court or an appellate court, the death sentence is not vacated. . . . [T]he judgment of death remains in force. This is so even if a defendant never regains competency." Unlike the claims raised in Gardner, we conclude that a pending competency proceeding, including an appeal of a competency determination, is a legal reason that should prevent issuance of an execution warrant.73
¶61 In sum, when the district court issued the July 9, 2025 warrant of execution, Menzies had a pending petition asserting his incompetency to be executed under the Eighth Amendment and a pending appeal of an order declaring him to be competent. Those pending proceedings affected Menzies's substantial rights and constituted a legal reason not to issue the execution warrant.74The __________________________________________________________ constitutionally ineligible for the death penalty. By contrast, intellectual disability is by definition a permanent condition . . . . A person who is found to be intellectually disabled is permanently ineligible to be executed, and the sentence of death is vacated."
(footnote omitted)). We do not consider whether Menzies's vascular dementia is permanent incompetency in this appeal since his competency proceedings were brought only under Ford, Panetti, and Madison.
22
Cite as: 2025 UT 38 Opinion of the Court
23
petition for extraordinary relief is granted, and we vacate the July 9, 2025 warrant of execution.
CONCLUSION
¶62 Menzies's vascular dementia and its progressive effects call into question whether he remains competent to be executed. We acknowledge that this uncertainty has caused the family of Maurine Hunsaker immense suffering, and it is not our desire to prolong that suffering. But we are bound by the rule of law, and the law dictates that if Menzies makes a prima facie showing of a substantial change of circumstances that raises a significant question about his competency to be executed, a district court must reevaluate his competency, even though it may cause additional delay.75
¶63 We hold that Menzies's petition for reevaluation made a prima facie showing of that requires the district court to reevaluate his competency. We reverse the district court's order denying Menzies's petition for reevaluation, vacate the warrant of execution and remand to the district court for further proceedings. __________________________________________________________
23