WHETHER PURA'S RATE ORDER
WAS CONFISCATORY
Lastly, Aquarion claims that PURA's rate order resulted in a confiscatory taking of its property because
(1) the denial of some of Aquarion's requested capital expenditures and operating costs effectively reduced the allowed ROE from 8.70 percent to almost 5 percent, and (2) PURA's factual finding that the approved ROE would be sufficient to maintain Aquarion's credit rating and to attract capital was premised on an incorrect assumption that Aquarion would recover all of its requested capital expenditures and operating costs. We disagree.
In its rate application, Aquarion requested a ROE of 10.35 percent. Other parties objected and provided evidence in support of a lower ROE. In particular, the EOE recommended a ROE between 7.65 and 8.91 per- cent, the OCC recommended a ROE of 9 percent, and the OAG recommended a ROE between 8.33 and 9 per- cent. To ascertain a ROE that was sufficient, but no more than sufficient, to allow Aquarion to cover its capital expenditures and operating costs in accordance with § 16-19e (a) (4), PURA considered the respective effects that this range of ROEs would have on Aquari- on's credit rating. PURA noted that Aquarion had main- tained an ''A3 [s]table [r]ating'' from Moody's Investors Service (Moody's) since 2018. After evaluating the fac- tors that Moody's uses to calculate credit ratings, PURA determined that, ''[u]nder all the recommendations offered by [Aquarion], [the] OCC, and [the] EOE . . . the metrics remain in the range of the core metrics followed by Moody's to maintain its A3 rating.'' PURA therefore concluded that ''an ROE set within the ranges presented by [the] EOE, [the] OCC, and [Aquarion] (i.e.,
35
Page 34 CONNECTICUT LAW JOURNAL 0, 0 , 036 0 Conn. 1
Aquarion Water Co. of Connecticut v. Public Utilities Regulatory Authority
7.765 [percent] to 10.35 [percent]) would not adversely affect [Aquarion's] credit rating.''
To arrive at a precise ROE, PURA examined ''several factors . . . including current economic and market conditions, analytical models and cost of equity capital methodologies . . . ROEs of similar companies in other jurisdictions, and [Aquarion's] financial risk and credit rating.'' With respect to comparable allowed ROEs, PURA noted that, ''[o]ver the period [of] 2021 through July 26, 2022, water company allowed ROEs ranged from 7.46 [percent] to [10 percent], with an average of 9.37 [percent].'' PURA also calculated vari- ous ROEs under two different analytical models, the discounted cash flow model and the capital asset pric- ing model, which yielded ''a reasonable ROE for [Aquar- ion] . . . in the range of [8 percent] to [9.5 percent].'' As for Aquarion's financial risk, PURA concluded that it was comparable to other similarly situated utility companies and that ''the regulatory framework in Con- necticut, by design, also provides certain risk mitigation mechanisms that should be accounted for in setting a reasonable ROE.'' See, e.g., General Statutes § 16-262w (authorizing use of water infrastructure and conserva- tion adjustments); General Statutes § 16-262y (revenue adjustment mechanism); see also footnote 8 of this opinion. After a thorough analysis of Aquarion's ''capital structure, its financial condition, ROEs from other juris- dictions, analytical models, testimony from the [p]arties and [i]ntervenors, prevailing and anticipated market conditions, and the regulatory environment,'' PURA found that ''an ROE of [8.7 percent] is reasonable and provides the proper balance between shareholders and ratepayers.''
The trial court upheld PURA's determination, reason- ing that a ROE of 8.7 percent was within the range recommended by the parties and was reflective of the fact that Aquarion operates in a highly regulated,
36
Page 35CONNECTICUT LAW JOURNAL0, 0 , 0 370 Conn. 1
Aquarion Water Co. of Connecticut v. Public Utilities Regulatory Authority monopolistic environment involving little practical eco- nomic risk. The court rejected Aquarion's claim that the ''actual ROE will be closer to 5 percent because Aquarion will be forced to use revenue it has otherwise designated to return to investors in order to make up for the revenue shortfalls caused by PURA's denial of Aquarion's revenue requests in other areas'' on the basis of GenConn Energy, LLC v. Public Utilities Regulatory Authority, 348 Conn. 532, 548-50, 308 A.3d 1018 (2024) (GenConn), which held that a reduction in overall
recoverable capital costs does not alter a utility com- pany's allowed ROE. The court also was not persuaded by Aquarion's claim that the combined effect of disal- lowing certain capital expenditures and operating costs, and adopting a ROE of 8.7 percent would undermine
Aquarion's financial integrity or ability to attract capital, pointing out that ''PURA specifically made the factual determination that [its] decision would not harm Aquar- ion's credit rating'' and that, even if this factual finding was clearly erroneous, ''a credit rating is only one factor in a company's ability to attract capital.'' Because there was no evidence that a downgrade in Aquarion's credit rating ''would wholly prevent Aquarion from raising
capital or . . . [would] jeopardize its financial integ- rity,'' the court determined that PURA's rate order was not confiscatory.
Our review of the constitutionality of PURA's rate
order is governed by the standards articulated by the United States Supreme Court in Federal Power Com-
mission v. Hope Natural Gas Co., 320 U.S. 591, 64 S. Ct. 281, 88 L. Ed. 333 (1944). See Woodbury Water Co.
v. Public Utilities Commission, supra, 174 Conn. 264. When a rate order is challenged as confiscatory, the appellant ''carries the heavy burden of making a con- vincing showing that it is invalid because it is unjust and unreasonable in its consequences.'' Federal Power Commission v. Hope Natural Gas Co., supra, 602. A
37
Page 36 CONNECTICUT LAW JOURNAL 0, 0 , 038 0 Conn. 1
Aquarion Water Co. of Connecticut v. Public Utilities Regulatory Authority regulatory agency is ''not bound to the use of any single formula or combination of formulae in determining
rates,'' and may exercise its rate-making authority to make ''pragmatic adjustments.'' (Internal quotation
marks omitted.) Id. ''[I]t is the result reached not the method employed [that] is controlling. . . . It is not theory but the impact of the rate order [that] counts. If the total effect of the rate order cannot be said to be unjust and unreasonable, judicial inquiry . . . is at an end. The fact that the method employed to reach that result may contain infirmities is not then important.'' (Citations omitted.) Id. A rate order is not unjust and unreasonable if the utility company's return on invest- ment is enough ''not only for operating expenses but also for the capital costs of the business,'' ''commensu- rate with returns on investments in other enterprises having corresponding risks,'' and ''sufficient to [ensure] confidence in the financial integrity of the enterprise, so as to maintain its credit and to attract capital.'' Id., 603. We first address whether our holding in GenConn
Energy, LLC v. Public Utilities Regulatory Authority, supra, 348 Conn. 548-50, applies to Aquarion's claim that disallowance of some requested capital expendi- tures and operating costs effectively lowered Aquari- on's approved ROE below 8.7 percent and resulted in a confiscatory taking. In GenConn, the plaintiff, GenConn Energy, LLC (GenConn), claimed that, by disallowing
recovery of certain prudently incurred operating costs to prevent an over recovery, PURA effectively pre-
vented GenConn from earning a reasonable ROE in
violation of General Statutes §§ 16-19e (a) and 16-243u. Id. We rejected GenConn's claim that the denial of costs effectively reduced the allowed rate of ROE from 9.85 percent to 7.59 percent on the ground that ''[t]he rate of [ROE] was not lowered by PURA. It is true that
GenConn's recoverable capital is lower than what it
requested . . . but this is a result of a reduction in the
38
Page 37CONNECTICUT LAW JOURNAL0, 0 , 0 390 Conn. 1
Aquarion Water Co. of Connecticut v. Public Utilities Regulatory Authority debt rate. The rate of [ROE] remains 9.85 percent . . . . Simply because GenConn's overall recoverable capital was lowered as a result of the reduction in the debt rate does not mean that the [ROE] has been altered.'' Id.,
548. Thus, despite the reduction in recoverable capital costs, GenConn was ''allowed a reasonable rate of [ROE] pursuant to the same rate of return'' authorized by PURA. Id., 549.
Aquarion claims that GenConn is distinguishable because, in that case, the court ''did not confront, or express any view about, the federal constitutional rule against confiscatory rates.'' Aquarion's claim lacks merit because the statutory standard for establishing just and reasonable rates under § 16-19e (a) (4) tracks, almost verbatim, the constitutional standard articulated in Federal Power Commission v. Hope Natural Gas Co., supra, 320 U.S. 602-603. As we explained in Connecticut Light & Power Co. v. Dept. of Public Utility Control, supra, 219 Conn. 55-56, the statutory requirement that rates be sufficient to enable utility companies ''to cover their operating costs including, but not limited to, appropriate staffing levels, and capital costs, to attract needed capital and to maintain their financial integrity''; General Statutes § 16-19e (a) (4); is not materially differ- ent from the constitutional requirement that rates be ''sufficient to [ensure] confidence in the financial integ- rity of the enterprise, so as to maintain its credit and to attract capital.'' Federal Power Commission v. Hope Natural Gas Co., supra, 603; see Connecticut Light & Power Co. v. Dept. of Public Utility Control, supra, 56 (''§ 16-19e (a) (4) embodies the 'just and reasonable' provision of Hope [Natural Gas Co.]''). Our decision in GenConn applies equally to statutory and constitutional claims, and compels the conclusion that Aquarion's approved ROE of 8.7 percent was not altered, for pur- poses of our constitutional analysis, by the disallow- ance of certain capital expenditures and operating costs
39
Page 38 CONNECTICUT LAW JOURNAL 0, 0 , 040 0 Conn. 1
Aquarion Water Co. of Connecticut v. Public Utilities Regulatory Authority consistent with the general rate-making principles codi- fied in § 16-19e (a) (4) and (5). See Fitchburg Gas & Electric Light Co. v. Dept. of Public Utilities, 375 Mass. 571, 575, 380 N.E.2d 1304 (1978) (''A confiscation claim is not made out by showing that the effective rate of return will be less than the allowed rate of return'' because inherent in policy of disallowing certain costs ''is the possibility that a company's effective rate of return will be less than its allowed rate of return. Such a result is not a constitutional violation.''); Toledo Edi- son Co. v. Public Utilities Commission, 12 Ohio St.
3d 143, 146, 465 N.E.2d 886 (1984) (utility's claim that disallowance of requested costs resulted in confiscatory taking because ''the 'effective' rate of return [fell] out- side of the range approved by the commission'' was
''without merit,'' insofar as ''[t]he 'effective' rate of return . . . was computed outside Ohio's [rate-mak-
ing] formula'').
Alternatively, Aquarion contends that PURA improp-
erly found that a ROE of 8.7 percent would not adversely affect Aquarion's credit rating and ability to attract capi- tal because this finding was premised on the incorrect assumption that Aquarion would recover all of its
requested capital expenditures and operating costs.
According to Aquarion, if PURA had evaluated its credit outlook using the approved revenue requirement of
$195,561,690, instead of the requested revenue require- ment of $236 million, PURA necessarily would have
found that a ROE of 8.7 percent was insufficient to
maintain Aquarion's credit rating and its ability to attract capital. This claim fails because it is unsupported by legal analysis or citation to evidence in the adminis- trative record. Notably, Aquarion has not examined the financial metrics that Moody's uses to calculate credit ratings,22
applied those metrics to the evidence in the
40
Page 39CONNECTICUT LAW JOURNAL0, 0 , 0 410 Conn. 1
Aquarion Water Co. of Connecticut v. Public Utilities Regulatory Authority administrative record,23
or explained how a ROE of 8.7 percent is insufficient to permit Aquarion to maintain its credit rating or ability to attract capital. ''[I]t is the result reached not the method employed [that] is con- trolling,'' and, in the absence of any concrete analysis demonstrating that the result reached by PURA was unjust and unreasonable, Aquarion has failed to fulfill its ''heavy burden'' of establishing a confiscatory taking. Federal Power Commission v. Hope Natural Gas Co., supra, 320 U.S. 602; see Trunkline Gas Co. v. Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, 880 F.2d 546, 552 (D.C. Cir. 1989) (utility could not prevail on claim that rate order undermined its creditworthiness and deprived investors of reasonable financial safeguards because ''much more concrete information [was] required . . . [to] hold these consequences to be unjust and unreasonable'').
asset ownership model (5 percent), cost and investment recovery (15 per- cent), revenue risk (5 percent), and the scale and complexity of the capital program and asset condition risk (10 percent). Forty percent of Moody's credit rating is based on leverage and coverage, which includes adjusted interest coverage or FFO (funds from operations) interest coverage (12.5 percent), net debt/regulated asset base, or debt/capitalization (10 percent), FFO/net debt (12.5 percent), and retained cash flow/net debt (5 percent). The remaining 10 percent depends on financial policy.
41
Page 40 CONNECTICUT LAW JOURNAL 0, 0 , 042 0 Conn. 1
Aquarion Water Co. of Connecticut v. Public Utilities Regulatory Authority The judgment is reversed only with respect to the
trial court's decision to uphold PURA's assessment as to the prudence of Aquarion's deferred conservation
expenses and the case is remanded with direction to
remand to PURA for further proceedings concerning
those expenses; the judgment is affirmed in all other respects.
In this opinion the other justices concurred.
42