CHRISTENSEN JAMES &MARTIN, CHTD. BY KEVIN B. ARCHIBALD, ESQ. COUNSEL FOR PLAINTIFFS
SIERRA CREST BUSINESS LAW GROUP BY: ALISON R. KERTIS, ESQ. COUNSEL FOR THE DEFENDANTS
JOINT STATUS REPORT AND STIPULATION TO STAY PROCEEDINGS (Third Request)
The above-captioned Parties, each acting by and through their undersigned counsel, state the following:
A. BACKGROUND
1. Plaintiffs filed their original Complaint on March 27, 2024 [ECF. No. 1].
2. Plaintiffs filed their First Amended Complaint on April 11, 2024 [ECF No. 5].
3. Plaintiffs completed service of process of Defendant American Contractors Indemnity Company on April 19, 2024. See ECF No. 9.
4. Plaintiffs completed service of process of Defendant Karen Beth Fleischmann on April 23, 2024. Id.
5. Plaintiffs completed service of process of Defendants J. E. Simas Floors, Inc. d/b/a JE Simas Floors (“JE Simas”), James Edward Simas and Taylor Simas Samms on May 20, 2024. Id.
6. Plaintiffs filed the Affidavits of Service for the Defendants on June 14, 2024. Id.
7. None of the Defendants have filed responsive pleadings. See Docket, generally.
8. The Parties have not yet exchanged Initial Disclosures or participated in a 26(f) Conference; however, the Parties have begun initial discussions of the facts underlying the case and the claims and defenses asserted herein and have developed a preliminary plan for moving this case forward, as set forth below.
9. This case centers on alleged fringe benefit payment obligations arising from the Northern Nevada Floor Covering Master Agreement (“CBA”) between the International Union of Painters and Allied Trades District Council 16 (“Union”) and Defendant JE Simas.
10. The Plaintiffs allege that the Defendants owe fringe benefit contributions, interest, liquidated damages and other amounts discovered through a payroll compliance review of JE Simas's payroll and related records (“Audit”) for the period April 1, 2017 to December 31, 2020 (“First Audit Period”).
11. JE Simas disputes the Auditor's findings for the First Audit Period.
12. The Plaintiffs have been advised that JE Simas closed its business on or about September 30, 2023.
13. The Plaintiffs claim the right to a second audit (the “Second Audit”) for the period of January 1, 2021 through September 30, 2023 (“Second Audit Period”).
14. The Parties filed a Stipulation to Stay Proceedings on May 24, 2024 [ECF No. 7].
15. The Court issued its Order granting the Stipulation to Stay Proceedings on May 28, 2024, in which the Court ordered, inter alia, that all discovery dates and deadlines would be stayed through August 24, 2024, to allow: (a) JE Simas to provide to the Plaintiffs certain documents to conduct the Second Audit; (b) the Audit of the Second Audit Period to commence; (c) the Parties to discuss further JE Simas's objection to, and availability of additional Audit documents that the Plaintiffs have requested; and (d) the Parties the opportunity to negotiate a global resolution of the Parties' claims and defenses.
16. On or around June 6, 2024, JE Simas provided initial documents for the Second Audit, and the Plaintiffs' Auditor commenced the Second Audit thereafter.
17. The Plaintiffs' Auditor has determined, after due diligence and reasonably commencing the Second Audit with the documents provided, that the Second Audit cannot be reasonably completed without additional documents from JE Simas.
18. The Plaintiffs provided a list of the necessary additional documents for the Second Audit to JE Simas (“Additional Second Audit Documents”).
19. On August 12, 2024, counsel for the Parties met and conferred to discuss and resolve in good faith the issues regarding the Second Audit.
20. JE Simas agreed to request from third parties the Additional Second Audit Documents and believed additional time would be required to obtain such documents.
21. On August 13, 2024, the Parties filed a Stipulation to Stay Proceedings (Second Request) [ECF No. 10].
22. The Court issued its Order granting the Stipulation to Stay Proceedings (Second Request) on August 14, 2024, in which the Court ordered, inter alia, the following:
a. All discovery dates and deadlines would be stayed through November 12, 2024 to allow: (i) JE Simas to request from third parties certain additional documents to conduct the Second Audit on or before August 19, 2024 (“Second Audit Documents Request Deadline”); (ii) the Audit of the Second Audit Period to continue; (iii) the Parties to discuss further JE Simas's objection to, and availability of additional Audit documents that the Plaintiffs have requested; and (iv) the Parties the opportunity to negotiate a global resolution of the Parties' claims and defenses; and
b. No later than October 29, 2024
, the Parties will meet and confer and file a Joint Status Report to update the Court on the status of the Audit and how the Parties intend the case to proceed.
B. STATUS
1. On October 30, 2024, counsel for the Parties met and conferred to discuss the possibility of global resolution of the Case and the status of the Additional Second Audit Documents. The Parties were unable to reach a resolution agreement.
2. JE Simas provided the Additional Second Audit Documents that were available to it on October 31, 2024.
3. The Trusts believe that additional time is required to conduct the Second Audit and the Parties have agreed to extend the stay of this Case.
C. STAY OF PROCEEDINGS
1. The Parties agree to stay this Case, including all discovery dates and deadlines through January 15, 2024, for the Trusts to conduct the Second Audit and for the Parties to negotiate a global resolution of the Parties' claims and defenses.
2. The Parties have discussed requesting the Court order a pre-discovery early settlement conference with a Magistrate Judge pursuant to LR 16-5; counsel will readdress a potential settlement conference at a meet and confer by no later than December 13, 2024.
3. This is the third request to stay these proceedings.
4. A stay of these proceedings will not prejudice any party and is not sought for any improper purpose; rather this Stipulation is sought for the purposes of judicial economy and to promote settlement.
5. The Parties agree that all case deadlines shall be stayed through January 15, 2024.
6. The Parties shall conduct two meet and confers: one no later than December 13, 2024, to reassess the possibility of a judicial settlement conference; and one no later than January 8, 2024, to discuss and file a Joint Status Report to update the Court on the status of the Second Audit and any request for an Order to participate in a settlement conference with a Magistrate Judge pursuant to LR 16-5.
IT IS SO ORDERED: