PATRICIA L. DODGE UNITED STATES MAGISTRATE JUDGE
REPORT AND RECOMMENDATION
PATRICIA L. DODGE UNITED STATES MAGISTRATE JUDGE
I. Recommendation
It is respectfully recommended that Defendant's Partial Motion to Dismiss (ECF No. 23) be granted.
II. Report
A. Relevant Procedural History
Plaintiff Best Medical International, Inc., d/b/a Best Nomos (“Best Medical”) commenced this lawsuit by filing a redacted Complaint in which it sought a declaratory judgment against its former counsel, Defendant Buchanan Ingersoll & Rooney PC (“Buchanan”), with respect to an agreement between the parties. (ECF No. 1.) In an Order dated July 21, 2020, the Court directed Best Medical to either file an unreacted version of the Complaint or move to file it under seal. (ECF No. 2.) Best Medical chose the latter option. (ECF No. 5.) After the parties briefed this issue (ECF Nos. 6, 12, 15), the Court denied the motion to seal and ordered Best Medical to file an unredacted version of the Complaint, after which it did so. (ECF Nos. 16, 21.)
Best Medical then filed an Amended Complaint against Buchanan with claims of breach of contract, misrepresentation, breach of fiduciary duty, and declaratory relief. (ECF No. 20 (“Am. Compl.”).) Buchanan responded with the pending partial motion to dismiss (ECF No. 23), and also filed an Answer and Counterclaim against Best Medical (ECF No. 25), which it later amended. (ECF No. 41.) Buchanan's motion is fully briefed. (ECF Nos. 24, 34, 35, 40.)
B. Factual Background
All facts set forth in this Section are from the Amended Complaint.
In August 2018 Best Medical entered into an agreement with Buchanan to enforce its intellectual property (“IP”) rights against two alleged infringers, namely Varian and Elekta. (Am. Compl. ¶ 10.) Buchanan also agreed to represent Best Medical in the USPTO post-grant proceedings involving the patents at issue in the litigation against Varian and Elekta (“IP Litigation”). (Id. ¶ 11.) Under the parties' agreement, Buchanan agreed to provide Best Medical with monthly estimates of fees and costs for each upcoming two-month period. (Id. ¶ 12.) The parties' agreement also required Buchanan to issue monthly billing statements “with a brief description of each entry for time worked and each Cost item incurred.” (Id. ¶ 18.)
At the end of September 2018, Buchanan provided Best Medical with the first monthly estimate for the months of October and November. (Id. ¶ 13.) Buchanan did not furnish the next monthly estimate to Best Medical until July 2019 and it was only for the months of July and August. (Id.) Even though Buchanan continued to represent Best Medical in the IP Litigation until April 2020, the last and final monthly estimate that it provided to Best Medical was in October 2019 for the months of October and November. (Id. ¶ 16.) Despite being reminded that it was not providing the agreed upon monthly estimates, Buchanan continued to represent Best Medical in the IP Litigation and the USPTO proceedings without furnishing those estimates. (Id. ¶ 17.)
Additionally, Best Medical claims that the monthly billing statements reflect that Buchanan billed identical or similar issues related to Varian and Elekta “as though the work had begun anew” (id. ¶ 19), even though it was “unnecessary to bill the same amount for work that was merely copied and pasted . . .” (Id. ¶ 20.) Best Medical alleges that Buchanan's billing practices resulted in duplicative charges and significantly increased the total legal costs which Buchanan now claims “to be at least $2, 700, 000.00 despite Best Medical having already paid Buchanan over $900, 000.00.” (Id. ¶¶ 21, 22.)
Best Medical maintains that the charges reflected in the monthly billing statements are unreasonable and not consistent with the amount of work required or performed by Buchanan in the IP Litigation and the related USPTO proceedings. (Id. ¶ 23.) When Buchanan threatened to withdraw as counsel and bring a lawsuit against Best Medical for the full balance due on the monthly billing statements, Best Medical recognized that these actions “would have significantly undermined Best Medical's bargaining position which would have seriously prejudiced Best Medical's ability to settle and/or successfully prosecute” the IP Litigation. (Id. ¶ 25.) Therefore, Best Medical commenced this lawsuit seeking a declaratory judgment that reduced the unpaid fees to a reasonable amount consistent with the work that Buchanan actually performed. (Id. ¶ 26.)
Best Medical asserts that it moved to file the original Complaint under seal to prevent itself from being prejudiced in the IP Litigation. (Id.) According to Best Medical, by disclosing certain information related to the parties' fee dispute in response to Best Medical's motion to seal, Buchanan violated its ethical duties to Best Medical, prejudiced Best Medical in the IP Litigation, and caused Best Medical embarrassment, distress, and lost opportunity to favorably settle that litigation. (Id. ¶¶ 27, 64.) Among other things, Best Medical faults Buchanan for divulging the approximate dollar amount of parties' fee dispute, disclosing the parties' settlement efforts leading up to the filing of this lawsuit, and asserting that Best Medical filed this lawsuit in a strategic attempt to misuse the Court's power to seal records. (Id. ¶ 64.)
Based on the foregoing, Best Medical alleges four claims against Buchanan in its Amended Complaint. In Count I, Best Medical asserts a breach of contract claim and alleges that Buchanan's failure to furnish the monthly estimates constituted a material breach of the parties' agreement. (Id. ¶ 31.) Best Medical also claims that Buchanan further breached the parties' agreement by charging Best Medical for more hours than it actually worked as reflected in the monthly billing statements. (Id. ¶ 37.)
In Count II, which asserts a claim for misrepresentation, Best Medical alleges that Buchanan intentionally or negligently misrepresented the hours actually worked as reflected in the monthly billing statements and overbilled Best Medical by charging for the same work more than once. (Id. ¶¶ 44, 45.) In Count III, Best Medical asserts a breach of fiduciary duty claim premised on (1) the alleged overbilling by Buchanan in the monthly billing statements and (2) Buchanan's disclosure of certain allegedly prejudicial information related to the parties' fee dispute in a brief that Buchanan filed in this lawsuit. (Id. ¶¶ 57, 61, 64.) Finally, in Count IV, Best Medical seeks declaratory judgment against Buchanan on all the claims alleged in this lawsuit. (Id. at 22.)
C. Standard of Review
Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(b)(6) requires the dismissal of a complaint, in whole or in part, when it fails to state a claim upon which can be granted. In deciding a Rule 12(b)(6) motion, the court must “accept all factual allegations as true, construe the complaint in the light most favorable to the plaintiff, and determine whether, under any reasonable reading of the complaint, the plaintiff may be entitled to relief.” Fowler v. UPMC Shadyside, 578 F.3d 203, 210 (3d Cir. 2009) (quoting Phillips v. Cnty. of Allegheny, 515 F.3d 224, 233 (3d Cir. 2008). While “accepting] all of the complaint's well-pleaded facts as true, ” the court “may disregard any legal conclusions.” Id. at 210-11.
To survive the motion, the plaintiff must plead “enough facts to state a claim to relief that is plausible on its face.” BellAtl. Corp. v. Twombly, 550 U.S. 544, 570 (2007). “A claim has facial plausibility when the plaintiff pleads factual content that allows the court to draw the reasonable inference that the defendant is liable for the misconduct alleged.” Ashcroft v. Iqbal, 556 U.S. 662, 678 (2009). “Though ‘detailed factual allegations' are not required, a complaint must do more than simply provide ‘labels and conclusions' or ‘a formulaic recitation of the elements of a cause of action.'” Davis v. Abington Mem'l Hosp., 765 F.3d 236, 241 (3d Cir. 2014) (quoting Twombly, 550 U.S. at 555). In sum, the plaintiff “must plead facts sufficient to show that her claim has substantive plausibility.” Johnson v. City of Shelby, Miss., 574 U.S. 10 (2014).
D. Discussion
Buchanan seeks dismissal of Best Medical's misrepresentation, breach of fiduciary duty, and declaratory judgment claims along with certain relief requested in the Amended Complaint.
1. Applicability of gist of the action doctrine
Buchanan contends that Best Medical's misrepresentation and breach of fiduciary duty claims that are based on alleged overbilling in its monthly billing statements are barred by Pennsylvania's gist of the action doctrine. (ECF No. 24 at 3-5.) Under this doctrine, “an alleged tort claim against a party to a contract, based on the party's actions undertaken in the course of carrying out a contractual agreement, is barred when the gist or gravamen of the cause of action stated in the complaint, although sounding in tort, is, in actuality, a claim against the party for breach of its contractual obligations.” Earl v. NVR, Inc., No. 20-2109, 2021 WL 833990, at *4 (3d Cir. Mar. 5, 2021) (quoting Dixon v. Nw. Mut., 146 A.3d 780, 788 (Pa. Super. Ct. 2016)). The Pennsylvania Supreme Court has explained that:
If the facts of a particular claim establish that the duty breached is one created by the parties by the terms of their contract-
i.e., a specific promise to do something that a party would not ordinarily have been obligated to do but for the existence of the contract-then the claim is to be viewed as one for breach of contract. If, however, the facts establish that the claim involves the defendant's violation of a broader social duty owed to all individuals, which is imposed by the law of torts and, hence, exists regardless of the contract, then it must be regarded as a tort.
Id. (quoting
Bruno v. Erie Ins. Co., 106 A.3d 48, 68 (Pa. 2014)).
As alleged in the Amended Complaint, under the terms of parties' agreement, Buchanan was required to issue monthly billing statements “with a brief description of each entry for time worked and each Cost item incurred.” (Am. Compl. ¶ 18.) Best Medical alleges that Buchanan breached this provision by charging Best Medical for more hours than it actually worked. (Id. ¶ 37.) Best Medical's misrepresentation claim and part of its breach of fiduciary duty claim is based on precisely the same conduct: alleged overbilling in monthly billing statements. (Id. ¶¶ 44, 58.)
Best Medical argues that the gist of the action doctrine is not applicable because by allegedly misrepresenting the hours actually worked, Buchanan also breached a societal “duty of honesty, owed to all individuals, especially clients.” (ECF No. 35 at 7.) It is evident, however, that the duty allegedly breached is the requirement in the parties' agreement to provide a brief description of each entry for time worked and each cost item incurred. But for the parties' agreement, Buchanan would not have been obligated to furnish any monthly billing statements.
Because the gravamen of Best Medical's misrepresentation and breach of fiduciary duty claims sounds in contract, not in tort, these claims are barred by the gist of the action doctrine and should be dismissed.
2. Breach of fiduciary duty claim based on Buchanan's statements
Buchanan also seeks dismissal of Best Medical's fiduciary duty claim to the extent it is premised on the disclosure of certain statements related to the parties' fee dispute that Buchanan referenced in a brief filed in this lawsuit. (ECF No. 24 at 5.) Buchanan does not dispute that an attorney client relationship, and therefore a fiduciary duty, generally exists between the parties. (ECF No. 40 at 5.) Buchanan argues, however, that because Best Medical elected to file this lawsuit, Pennsylvania Rule of Professional Conduct 1.6 permits it to disclose confidential information that it believes is necessary to establish or defend against a claim in this lawsuit. (ECF No. 24 at 6.) Best Medical counters that it has alleged a viable breach of fiduciary duty claim because the amount of information that Buchanan disclosed went well beyond that which was necessary. (ECF No. 35 at 8-9.) Buchanan asserts that in any event, Pennsylvania's doctrine of absolute judicial privilege bars Best Medical's claim for breach of fiduciary duty. (ECF No. 40 at 5-6.)
The determination of “[w]hether a particular statement is absolutely privileged is a question of law for the court.” Richmond v. McHale, 35 A.3d 779, 785 (Pa. Super. 2012). Under Pennsylvania law, judicial privilege “extends to ‘communications which are issued in the regular course of judicial proceedings and which are pertinent and material to the redress or relief sought.'” Gen. Refractories Co. v. Fireman's Fund Ins. Co., 337 F.3d 297, 311 (3d Cir. 2003) (quoting Post v. Mendel, 507 A.2d 351, 353 (Pa. 1986)). The Third Circuit has explained that “[t]he privilege exists because there is a realm of communication essential to the exploration of legal claims that would be hindered were there not the protection afforded by the privilege.” Id. (quoting Silver v. Mendel, 894 F.2d 598, 603 (3d Cir.1990)). In Pennsylvania, “[t]he privilege covers statements by a party, a witness, an attorney, or a judge, ” Schanne v. Addis, 121 A.3d 942, 947 (Pa. 2015) (citing Binder v. Triangle Publications, Inc., 275 A.2d 53, 56 (Pa. 1971)), and “is not limited to statements made in open court, but encompasses pleadings as well.” Id. (citing Greenberg v. Aetna Ins. Co., 235 A.2d 576, 577 (Pa. 1967)). In fact, Pennsylvania Courts have “extended the privilege further to ‘even less formal communications such as preliminary conferences and correspondence between counsel in furtherance of the client's interest . . .'” Id. (quoting Pawlowski v. Smorto, 588 A.2d 36, 41 (Pa. Super. 1991)).
Here, after filing a redacted Complaint, Best Medical asked the Court to seal not only the unredacted version of its original Complaint and the parties' agreement, but also any future pleadings and documents that revealed information that was sensitive or confidential to Best Medical. (ECF No. 5; see ECF No. 5-2.) Best Medical's breach of fiduciary duty claim is based on certain statements Buchanan made in the brief it filed in opposition to Best Medical's efforts to seal these documents. (ECF No. 12.) In arguing that there was no basis for granting Best Medical's motion, Buchanan approximated the dollar amount that Best Medical allegedly owed to Buchanan in legal fees and also outlined the efforts that Buchanan had undertaken to recover those fees. Given the broad scope of the relief Best Medical sought, which would result in essentially sealing the entire judicial record in this lawsuit, Buchanan contended that Best Medical filed this lawsuit in a strategic attempt to misuse the Court's power to seal records.
The statements and arguments advanced in Buchanan's brief were both pertinent and material to the relief it sought, which was an order of the Court denying Best Medical's motion to seal. Thus, to the extent Best Medical's breach of fiduciary duty claim is based on the statements Buchanan made in opposing a motion in this lawsuit, those statements are shielded by judicial privilege. See Church Mut. Ins. Co. v. All. Adjustment Grp., 708 Fed.Appx. 64, 70 (3d Cir. 2017) (affirming the dismissal of certain tort claims premised entirely on filings and pleadings during the course of litigation as barred by Pennsylvania's judicial privilege). Therefore, Best Medical's breach of fiduciary duty claim based on those statements must be dismissed.
3. Claim for declaratory relief
Under the Declaratory Judgment Act, the Court “may, ” but is not required to, “declare the rights and other legal relations of any interested party seeking such declaration, whether or not further relief is or could be sought.” 28 U.S.C. § 2201(a). The Third Circuit has explained that “[declaratory judgments are meant to define the legal rights and obligations of the parties in the anticipation of some future conduct.” Andela v. Admin. Off. of U.S.Cts., 569 Fed.Appx. 80, 83 (3d Cir. 2014) (citing Terra Nova Ins. Co. v. 900 Bar, Inc., 887 F.2d 1213, 1224 (3d Cir. 1989)), as opposed to merely “proclaiming] that one party is liable to another.” Id. (citing Love ladies Harbor, Inc. v. United States, 27 F.3d 1545, 1553 (Fed. Cir. 1994)). Additionally, “[c]ourts generally decline granting declaratory relief when the claim for declaratory judgment is entirely duplicative of another claim in the cause of action.” Butta v. GEICO Cas. Co., 400 F.Supp.3d 225, 233 (E.D. Pa. 2019).
Buchanan seeks dismissal of Best Medical's declaratory judgment claim because it is duplicative of the breach of contract claim and also because it concerns past, not future, conduct.
In disputing these arguments, Best Medical first contends that there is no duplication of claims because while its breach of contract claim arises out of Buchanan's failure to provide the monthly estimates, its declaratory judgment claim seeks a declaration that the fees sets forth in those statements are both inaccurate and include duplicate entries, and thus, are unreasonable. (Id.) The problem with this contention is twofold. First, it is contradicted by the allegations of the Amended Complaint, which predicate Best Medical's breach of contract claim on two alleged breaches: Buchanan's failure to furnish the monthly “estimates” under the parties' agreement (Am. Compl. ¶¶ 12, 29, 31), and the alleged overbilling in monthly “billing” statements in violation of separate provisions of the parties' agreement. (Id. ¶¶ 18, 33, 34, 37.)
In addition, the relief sought by Best Medical is a declaration that Buchanan breached the parties' agreement and that Best Medical suffered damages as a result. (Id. at 22.) Thus, Best Medical's declaratory judgment claim is not only duplicative of its breach of contract claim, but it also improperly seeks a proclamation “that one party is liable to another.” Andela, 569 Fed.Appx. at 83.
Finally, although Best Medical alleges that it seeks declaratory relief “as to unpaid fees and a threat of a lawsuit” by Buchanan (Am. Compl. ¶ 67), this claim only addresses past conduct. Specifically, Best Medical seeks a declaration with respect to all claims that were asserted in this lawsuit, i.e., that Buchanan breached the parties' agreement and that its actions constituted misrepresentation and breach of its fiduciary duty. (Id. at 22.) To the extent Best Medical argues that its seeks a declaration of its rights and obligations under the parties' agreement to safeguard itself from the threat of a future lawsuit by Buchanan for unpaid legal fees, Buchanan has already asserted a counterclaim against Best Medical with respect to those fees. (ECF No. 41.) Therefore, there is no threat of any future conduct on behalf of Buchanan that would support Best Medical's declaratory judgment claim. Additionally, resolution of Best Medical's breach of contract claim and Buchanan's counterclaim will necessarily resolve the parties' rights and obligations under the parties' agreement.
In sum, Best Medical's declaratory judgment claim should be dismissed because it is duplicative, addresses past conduct, and improperly seeks a declaration that Buchanan is liable to pay damages to Best Medical for claims asserted in this lawsuit.
4. Certain damages sought in breach of contract claim
Having determined that Best Medical's misrepresentation, breach of fiduciary duty and declaratory judgment claims should be dismissed, the Court's analysis is limited to the relief that Best Medical seeks with respect to its breach of contract claim.
With respect to Best Medical's breach of contract claim, Buchanan asserts that Best Medical cannot recover money damages for the lost opportunity to timely and fairly settle the IP Litigation (“lost opportunity damages”) and for disgorgement of all fees charged or paid by Best Medical to Buchanan (“disgorgement”). (ECF No. 24 at 9; see Am. Compl. at 10-11.) Additionally, Buchanan asserts that Best Medical is not entitled to costs and attorneys' fees. (ECF No. 24 at 12; Am. Compl. at 23)
As Best Medical has failed to respond to Buchanan's arguments regarding this issue, the Court could grant Buchanan's motion to dismiss solely on the basis of waiver. See Dreibelbis v. Scholton, 274 Fed.Appx. 183, 185 (3d Cir. 2008) (by failing to make an argument in response to a motion to dismiss, plaintiff waived that argument). However, an independent review of the allegations and applicable law compels the conclusion that Best Medical is not entitled to the relief it seeks.
Under Pennsylvania law, “a plaintiff seeking to proceed with a breach of contract action must establish ‘(1) the existence of a contract, including its essential terms, (2) a breach of a duty imposed by the contract and (3) resultant damages.” Ware v. Rodale Press, Inc., 322 F.3d 218, 225 (3d Cir. 2003) (quoting CoreStates Bank, N.A. v. Cutillo, 723 A.2d 1053, 1058 (Pa. Super. Ct. 1999)). With respect to the third element, it is well-established that “damages for breach of contract are not recoverable unless there is a ‘causal relationship between the breach and the loss.'” Brader v. Allegheny Gen. Hosp., 64 F.3d 869, 878 (3d Cir. 1995) (quoting Robinson Protective Alarm Co. v. Bolger & Picker, 516 A.2d 299, 303 n.9 (Pa. 1986)). Additionally, while “Pennsylvania law of contracts allows for some uncertainty in calculating damages, ” Ware, 322 F.3d at 226 (quoting ATACS Corp. v. Trans World Communications, Inc., 155 F.3d 659, 670 (3d Cir.1998)), the relief sought on a breach of contract claim cannot be “‘too speculative, vague or contingent' upon some unknown factor.” Id. (quoting ATACS Corp., 155 F.3d at 669).
Here, even if Best Medical was to prevail on its breach of contract claim, it would not be entitled to recover lost opportunity damages because there is no causal relationship between Buchanan's breach of the parties' agreement, that is, failure to provide the monthly estimates and overbilling, and Best Medical's ability to timely and fairly settle the IP Litigation. Additionally, Best Medical has not even alleged that a settlement opportunity existed or was lost, making any lost opportunity damages entirely speculative. Similarly, with respect to disgorgement, there is no causal relationship between Buchanan's breach of the parties' agreement and Best Medical's demand that Buchanan be ordered to forfeit all monies Buchanan claims to be owed as well as disgorge all of the legal fees Best Medical has paid Buchanan for services already rendered. Significantly, Best Medical does not argue that it received no benefit whatsoever from Buchanan's representation. Simply put, if Best Medical prevails at trial, it is entitled to recover damages that directly flow from Buchanan's breach of contract, including damages for overbilling. The facts alleged in the Amended Complaint provide no basis for lost opportunity damages, forfeiture of all fees currently owed or disgorgement of all fees already paid.
Finally, as to costs and attorneys' fees, “in the absence of an agreement or statute providing for attorneys' fees, the American rule is that ‘the prevailing litigant is ordinarily not entitled to collect a reasonable attorneys' fee from the loser.'” O'Brien v. Travelers Prop. & Cas. Ins. Co., 65 Fed.Appx. 853, 856 (3d Cir. 2003) (quoting Alyeska Pipeline Serv. Co. v. Wilderness Soc'y, 421 U.S. 240, 247 (1975)). This rule holds true in Pennsylvania “unless there is express statutory authorization, a clear agreement of the parties or some other established exception.” McMullen v. Kutz, 603985 A.2d 769, 775 (Pa. 2009) (quoting Mosaica Academy Charter School v. Com. Dept. of Educ., 813 A.2d 813, 822 (2002)). Because Best Medical has not identified any statutory or contractual fee shifting provisions, it cannot seek recovery of costs and attorneys' fees with respect to its breach of contract claim.
Therefore, Best Medical is not entitled to lost opportunity damages, disgorgement, or costs and attorneys' fees.
E. Conclusion
For all of the reasons set forth herein, it is recommended that Defendant's Partial Motion to Dismiss (ECF No. 23) be granted. Plaintiff's misrepresentation (Count II), breach of fiduciary duty (Count III), and declaratory judgment (Count IV) claims, as well as Plaintiff's demands for lost opportunity damages, disgorgement, and costs and attorneys' fees with respect to its breach of contract (Count I) claim should be dismissed.
Any party who seeks to challenge this Report and Recommendation must seek review by the district judge by filing objections by March 29, 2021. Any party opposing the objections shall file a response by April 12, 2021. Failure to file timely objections will waive the right of appeal.