Citation Codes Equivalent Citations citation codes Attorney(S) Attorney General Leroy F. Youmans, for appellant, adopts as his argument that filed by his predecessor, Hon. U.X. Gunter, who cites: 70 S.C. 446; 132 U.S. 185; 114 U.S. 185. Mr. B.L. Abney, contra, cites: 6 Stat., 91, 124; 67 Fed.R., 291; 6 Stat., 213, 267; 11 Stat., 304; 13 Stat., 293, 378; 14 Stat., 368; 16 Stat., 360, 444; 17 Stat., 87; 18 Stat., 139, 538; 19 Stat., 1090; 20 Stat., 967; 8 Fla., 46; 9 Ohio St., 627; Fed. Cas. No. 16763; 15 Fed., 790; 24 Atl., 725; 67 Fed., 292; 51 Am. R., 669; 1 Swan, 269; 81 Wis. 554; 9 A. E. Corp. Cas., 431; 43 S.C. 557; 179 U.S. 250; 11 Pet., 607; 115 U.S. 650; 85 Fed., 364; 43 S.C. 170; 13 Wall., 273; 191 U.S. 379; 166 U.S. 147; 201 U.S. 559; 17 S.C. 279; 8 Wall., 430; 15 Rich., 190; 6 Gill, 288; 37 Fed., 27; 6 McLean, 386; 39 S.C. 13; 3 S.C. 379; McM. Eq., 145; 85 Fed., 368; 36 Ia., 405; 27 S.C. 107; 2 McC., 219; 70 S.C. 446; 71 S.C. 485; 45 L.R.A., 308; 34 L.R.A., 820; 159 U.S. 628; 25 S.C. 262; 1 Rob., 782; 47 Pa. St., 468; 16 Fla., 147; 7 Cranch, 164; 17 Tenn., 486; 171 U.S. 186; 114 U.S. 185; 172 U.S. 181. See more information ... Smart Summary Please sign up to generate summary. COLUMBIA WATER POWER CO. v. CAMPBELL, COUNTY TREASURER. July 28, 1906. The opinion of the Court was delivered by MR. JUSTICE GARY. This Court is satisfied with the reasons clearly and ably stated by his Honor, the Circuit Judge, in overruling the demurrer, and the appeal is, therefore, dismissed.