Citation Codes Equivalent Citations citation codes Docket Number 11370 Attorney(S) Mr. W.G. Sirrine, for plaintiff-appellant, cites: Act 1923 is unconstitutional, Const. 1895, Art. 3, Sec. 31. Mr. Oscar K. Mauldin, for Greenville County, appellant, cites: Dedication: 7 A. E Enc L., 43; 5 Strob., 217; 8 R.C.L., 834; 27 L.R.A. (N.S.), 875. Greenville County chartered: 7 Stat., 245. Court House authorized: 5 Stat., 230. City of Greenville incorporated: 6 Stat., 434. Land must be used for purpose for which it was dedicated: 8 R.C.L., 910, 911; 48 N.E., 927; 61 Pac., 237; 2 S.W. 130; 22 Pac., 528; 23 Am. Dec., 207; 97 Am. Dec., 696; 35 L.R.A. (N.S.), 603. Chamber of Commerce is a private corporation: 7 A. E Enc. L., 637, 638. Unlawful for city to go into hotel business: 42 S.C. 427; 41 S.C. 220; 57 N.W., 331 Messrs. L.O. Patterson and Stephen Nettles, for Greenville Chamber of Commerce, respondent, cite: No limit on power of city to vacate portion of street: 3 Dillon Mun. Corp., 5th Ed., 1122, 1128, 1138, 1160, 1197; Ell. Roads Streets, 3d Ed., 609, 543, 1177, 1182, 1183; 13 R.C.L., 67. Vacation is authorized by Legislature in this case: 33 Stat., 688. Test is whether use serves public good and advantage: 115 S.E., 596; 115 S.C. 108. See more information ... Smart Summary Please sign up to generate summary. CHAPMAN v. GREENVILLE CHAMBER OF COMMERCE ET AL. December 10, 1923. The opinion of the Court was delivered by MR. JUSTICE WATTS. For the reasons assigned by his Honor, Judge Mauldin, in his Circuit decree, it is the judgment of this Court that the judgment of the Circuit Court be affirmed.