CITATION CODES

DOCKET NO.

No. 92SA141, No. 92SA263

ATTORNEY(S)

Hill Robbins, P.C., David W. Robbins, Robert F. Hill, Karen A. Tomb, and Anne K. LaPorta, of Denver, Colorado, Attorneys for Rio Grande Water Conservation District; San Luis Valley Water Conservancy District; San Luis Valley Irrigation Well Owners, Inc.; the City of Alamosa; the Town of Monte Vista; the Town of LaJara; the Town of Crestone; the County of Saguache; Alamosa County; Rio Grande County; and Rio Grande County Commissioners. Gale A. Norton, Attorney General, Raymond T. Slaughter, Chief Deputy Attorney General, Timothy M. Tymkovich, Solicitor General, Patricia S. Bangert, Deputy Attorney General, Jennifer L. Gimbel, First Assistant Attorney General, Christine A. Klein, Assistant Attorney General, Bradley W. Cameron, Assistant Attorney General, and Thomas W. Gibb, Assistant Attorney General, Natural Resources Section, of Denver, Colorado, Attorneys for the State of Colorado, the Colorado Division of Wildlife, the Colorado Water Conservation Board, and the State and Division Engineers for Water Division 3. Bruce McMillen of Saguache, Colorado, Attorney for Richard Blumenhein; Bonanza Road Water Users, Owners and Objectors; David P. Collins; Barbara J. Collins; Ernest Lamar Goodwin; Lazy KV Estates Homeowners Association, Inc.; Marold Ranches; R. G. Marold; Loren Santistevan; Julie Santistevan; and Villa Grove Area Water Users, Owners and Opposers. Janet Reno, United States Attorney General and Robert L. Klarquist, Attorney, Appellate Section, U.S. Department of Justice, Environment and Natural Resources Division, of Washington, D.C., Michael J. Norton, United States Attorney and James J. Dubois, Attorney, General Litigation Section, U.S. Department of Justice, Environment and Natural Resources Division, Denver, for U.S. Fred Bauder of Crestone, Colorado, Pro se. Moses, Wittemyer, Harrison and Woodruff, P.C., David L. Harrison, Raphael J. Moses, and Steven P. Jeffers, of Boulder, for Conejos Water Conservancy District; Oliver Powell Roemer, III, Successor of Trustee under the trusts under the will of Avis Neal Roemer; and Howard R. Platz, Oasis Land and Cattle Corp. No appearance for the following Objectors-Appellees: Alexander Ranch; Darell Keith Alexander; Richard Angell; Baca Grande Water Sanitation District; Harold L. Bennett; Lena C. Chiles; Floyd D. Chiles; Terry R. Chiles; Cyril Clayton; Dave Collins; Columbine Telephone Company; Concerned Citizens of Crestone, Colorado and Vicinity; Richard E. Conour; Elizabeth A. Conour; Cotton Creek Ranch; Fred J. Davie; Douglas M. Davie; Michael R. Dennet; Tom Enos; Dennis L. Felmlee; First Pegasus Corporation; Freel Ranch; Eugene W. Freel; Beverly Freel; Harold L. Freel; Terry Lee Freel; Fullenwider Ranch, Inc.; Haidakhandi Universal Ashram; Ernest T. Harer; Grace Harer; Richard W. Hanby; Pamyla Hill; D. Robin Hood; Town of Hooper; J. Richard Johnston; Mary A. Johnston; L.D. Ranch; Henry R. Lamm; Mable A. Lamm; John N. Lawrence; KSD, Ltd.; Timothy N. Lovato; Lori S. Lovato; Barbara Mertian; AM Farms; Pamela Bertin; Phillip Briscoe; Debra Briscoe; Eddie Clayton; Wayne C. Davis; Maggi Dessain; Margarita Diaz; Melvin E. Getz; Julie Goodnight; Greg Gosar; Margaret N. Herzfield; Maggie Houston-Smith; Pamela L. Lunt; Phil Martinez; Messick Farms; Richard A. Messick; Douglas G. Messick; Richard L. Messick; Sandra J. Murray; Curtis W. Nelson; Gayle Nichols; Anne Silver Philleo; Robert S. Philleo; Marlene L. Pruitt; Robert A. Ress; Toni G. Romero; Marianne Sandstrom; Robert W. Simpson; W.E. Sisemote; C. Kimberly Snider; Francis E. Snider; M. Catherine Snider; Shella Snider; Katherine Steichen; Harvey V. Sullivan; Liz Washburn; John R. Wright; George Whitten, Jr.; Donald E. Whitten; Karen Whitten; Betty L. Worley; Town of Moffat; Jimmy R. Moore; Mary Moore; Morfitt Brothers Farm, Inc.; Darrel Neese; Harold Neese; Gayle A. Nichols; Edward R. Oliver; Otaka International; Robert A. Owens; Edwin Pace; Rio Grande County Farm Bureau; Rito Alto and San Luis Ranches, Inc.; Rito Alto Ranch, Inc.; Rito Alto Ranchers; Arthur L. Rivale; Ileen J. Rivale; Rocky Mountain Bison, Inc.; Thomas C. Sanderson; Town of Saguache; Neil F. Seitz; Valley View Hot Springs; Martin T. Shellabarger; Patricia Shellabarger; Kenneth L. Skoglund; Mary F. Skoglund; Spiritual Life Institute of America, Inc.; David G. Stagner; Travelers Insurance Company; Thomas F. Trim; Annabelle R. Trim; Wagner Ranch, Ltd.; John H. Wagner; Weiss Ranches, Inc.; A.L. Wood; John M. Woodard; Erwin Young; and Lynne Young. No appearance for Objector-Respondent Gayle Nichols.

U
Supreme Court of Colorado.EN BANC. , 27 Sep 1993
U
Supreme Court of Colorado. EN BANC , 29 Mar 1993
U
Supreme Court of Colorado. EN BANC , 16 Feb 1993
U
Supreme Court of Colorado. EN BANC , 01 Feb 1993
U
Colorado Court of Appeals. Division II. , 31 Dec 1992
U
Supreme Court of Colorado. EN BANC , 19 Oct 1992
U
Colorado Court of Appeals. Division II. , 13 Aug 1992
U
Supreme Court of Colorado. EN BANC , 08 Jun 1992
U
Colorado Court of Appeals. Division IV. , 07 May 1992
U
Colorado Court of Appeals. Division V. , 12 Sep 1991
U
Colorado Court of Appeals. Division V. , 20 Jun 1991
U
Supreme Court of Colorado. EN BANC , 25 Feb 1991
U
Colorado Court of Appeals. Division III. , 11 Oct 1990
U
United States Court of Appeals, Fifth Circuit. , 28 Jun 1990
U
United States District Court, D. Maine. , 22 May 1990
U
United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit. , 21 Nov 1989
U
U.S. Supreme Court , 19 Jun 1989
U
Supreme Court of Colorado. EN BANC , 30 May 1989
U
Supreme Court of Colorado. EN BANC , 30 May 1989
U
Supreme Court of Colorado. EN BANC , 23 Jan 1989
U
Colorado Court of Appeals. Division IV. , 29 Dec 1988
U
Colorado Court of Appeals. Division III. , 20 Oct 1988
U
Supreme Court of Colorado. EN BANC , 05 Jul 1988
U
United States Court of Appeals, Tenth Circuit. , 13 Jun 1988
U
Supreme Court of Colorado. EN BANC , 30 Nov 1987
U
Supreme Court of Colorado. EN BANC , 02 Nov 1987
U
U.S. Supreme Court , 05 Oct 1987
U
Supreme Court of Colorado. EN BANC , 27 Jul 1987
U
Colorado Court of Appeals. Division III. , 09 Apr 1987
U
Supreme Court of Colorado. EN BANC , 23 Mar 1987
U
Supreme Court of Colorado. EN BANC , 23 Feb 1987
U
United States District Court, W.D. Michigan, S.D. , 29 Jan 1987
U
Colorado Court of Appeals. Division III. , 23 Oct 1986
U
United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit. , 15 Oct 1986
U
United States Court of Appeals, Tenth Circuit. , 08 Sep 1986
U
Supreme Court of Colorado. EN BANC , 25 Aug 1986
U
United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit. , 24 Jun 1986
U
U.S. Supreme Court , 21 Apr 1986
U
United States Court of Appeals, Eleventh Circuit. , 03 Feb 1986
U
United States Court of Appeals, Seventh Circuit. , 18 Nov 1985
U
United States Court of Appeals, Seventh Circuit. , 20 Sep 1985
U
Court of Appeals of Kansas , 27 Jun 1985
U
United States Court of Appeals, Seventh Circuit. , 13 Feb 1985
U
Supreme Court of Colorado. , 17 Dec 1984
U
Colorado Court of Appeals. , 06 Dec 1984
U
Supreme Court of Colorado. , 22 Oct 1984
U
U.S. Supreme Court , 16 Apr 1984
U
U.S. Supreme Court , 21 Mar 1984
U
Supreme Court of Colorado. , 16 Jan 1984
U
U.S. Supreme Court , 09 Jan 1984
U
Supreme Court of Colorado. , 05 Dec 1983
U
U.S. Supreme Court , 28 Nov 1983
U
Colorado Court of Appeals. , 29 Sep 1983
U
United States Court of Appeals, Tenth Circuit. , 23 Aug 1983
U
United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit. , 29 Jul 1983
U
Supreme Court of Colorado. , 18 Jul 1983
U
United States Court of Appeals, Second Circuit. , 15 Jun 1983
U
United States Court of Appeals, Eleventh Circuit. , 10 Jun 1983
U
U.S. Supreme Court , 06 Jun 1983
U
U.S. Supreme Court , 16 May 1983
U
United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit. , 05 May 1983
U
Supreme Court of Colorado. En Banc. , 06 Dec 1982
U
Supreme Court of Colorado. En Banc. , 29 Nov 1982
U
Supreme Court of Colorado. En Banc. , 16 Aug 1982
U
United States Court of Appeals, District of Columbia Circuit. , 30 Apr 1982
U
Supreme Court of Colorado. , 11 Jan 1982
U
Supreme Court of Colorado. , 28 Dec 1981
U
United States Court of Appeals, District of Columbia Circuit. , 03 Sep 1981
U
United States District Court, S.D. New York. , 25 Aug 1981
U
Supreme Court of Colorado. , 30 Mar 1981
U
United States Court of Appeals, District of Columbia Circuit. , 02 Sep 1980
U
United States Court of Appeals, Sixth Circuit. , 25 Oct 1979
U
Supreme Court of Colorado. En Banc. , 23 Apr 1979
U
Supreme Court of Colorado. En Banc. , 19 Mar 1979
U
United States Court of Appeals, Fifth Circuit. , 27 Oct 1978
U
Colorado Court of Appeals. Division I. , 03 Aug 1978
U
U.S. Supreme Court , 31 May 1978
U
United States District Court, S.D. New York. , 27 Sep 1977
U
Supreme Court of Colorado. En Banc. , 06 Jun 1977
U
Supreme Court of Colorado. En Banc. , 22 Nov 1976
U
United States Court of Appeals, Fifth Circuit. , 15 Mar 1976
U
Supreme Court of Colorado. En Banc. , 02 Sep 1975
U
Supreme Court of Colorado. En Banc. , 17 Dec 1973
U
Colorado Court of Appeals. , 01 May 1973
U
Supreme Court of Colorado. En Banc. , 10 Jul 1972
U
United States Court of Appeals, Fifth Circuit. , 16 Sep 1971
U
Supreme Court of Colorado. En Banc. , 18 Dec 1967
U
United States Court of Appeals, Tenth Circuit. , 23 Jun 1967
U
Supreme Court of Colorado. En Banc. , 21 Nov 1966
U
United States Court of Appeals, Sixth Circuit. , 22 Feb 1964
U
Supreme Court of Colorado. En Banc. , 09 Sep 1963
U
Supreme Court of Colorado. En Banc. , 03 Sep 1963
U
United States Court of Appeals, Fifth Circuit. , 08 May 1963
U
Supreme Court of Colorado. En Banc. , 03 Dec 1962
U
Supreme Court of Colorado. En Banc. , 27 Nov 1961
U
Supreme Court of Colorado. En Banc. , 21 Apr 1961
U
U.S. Supreme Court , 08 Apr 1957
U
United States Court of Appeals, Tenth Circuit. , 07 Aug 1952
U
Supreme Court of Colorado. En Banc. , 08 Jan 1940
U
Circuit Court of Appeals, Fourth Circuit. , 09 Nov 1936
U
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLORADO , 26 Sep 2018
U
v.
Supreme Court of the State of Colorado , 02 Oct 2017
U
COLORADO COURT OF APPEALS , 10 Aug 2017
U
v.
Supreme Court of the State of Colorado , 19 Jun 2017
U
COLORADO COURT OF APPEALS , 17 Nov 2016
U
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLORADO , 26 Jun 2015
U
Colorado Court of Appeals, Div. II. , 18 Jun 2015
U
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLORADO , 27 Mar 2015
U
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLORADO , 26 Mar 2015
U
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLORADO , 25 Nov 2014
U
United States District Court, D. Colorado. , 25 Nov 2014
U
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLORADO , 16 Sep 2014
U
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLORADO , 26 Feb 2014
U
Colorado Court of Appeals, Div. I. , 02 Jan 2014
U
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLORADO , 28 Aug 2013
U
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLORADO , 13 Aug 2013
U
Supreme Court of Colorado. , 01 Jul 2013
U
Supreme Court of Colorado, En Banc. , 03 Dec 2012
U
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF UTAH, CENTRAL DIVISION , 27 Sep 2012
U
Office of the Presiding Disciplinary Judge of the Supreme Court of Colorado. , 21 Sep 2012
U
Colorado Court of Appeals, Div. I. , 21 Jun 2012
U
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLORADO , 21 Mar 2012
U
Division I Colorado Court of Appeals , 15 Dec 2011
U
Colorado Court of Appeals, Div. I. , 27 Oct 2011
U
Supreme Court of Colorado. , 11 Apr 2011
U
Supreme Court of Colorado. , 10 Jan 2011
U
Colorado Court of Appeals. , 06 Jan 2011
U
Supreme Court of Colorado. , 13 Sep 2010
U
Colorado Court of Appeals. , 23 Jul 2009
U
Supreme Court of Hawaii. , 13 May 2009
U
Supreme Court of Colorado. , 20 Apr 2009
U
Colorado Court of Appeals. , 05 Feb 2009
U
Colorado Court of Appeals. , 05 Feb 2009
U
Colorado Court of Appeals. , 22 Sep 2008
U
United States District Court, D. Colorado. , 18 Aug 2008
U
Colorado Court of Appeals. , 03 Apr 2008
U
Colorado Court of Appeals. , 09 Oct 2007
U
Colorado Court of Appeals. , 12 Jul 2007
U
Colorado Court of Appeals. , 09 Apr 2007
U
Colorado Court of Appeals. Division III. , 23 Feb 2007
U
United States District Court, D. Colorado. , 02 Mar 2006
U
Supreme Court of Colorado. EN BANC. , 13 Jun 2005
U
Supreme Court of Colorado. , 18 Apr 2005
U
Supreme Court of Colorado. En Banc. , 14 Feb 2005
U
Supreme Court of Colorado, En Banc. , 18 Jan 2005
U
Colorado Court of Appeals. , 17 Jun 2004
U
Colorado Court of Appeals. , 17 Jun 2004
U
Supreme Court of Colorado.EN BANC. , 23 Feb 2004
U
United States Court of Appeals, Tenth Circuit. , 12 Nov 2003
U
Supreme Court of Colorado. EN BANC. , 20 Oct 2003
U
Supreme Court of Colorado. En Banc. , 30 Jun 2003
U
Colorado Court of Appeals.Division III Jones and Dailey, JJ., concur , 03 Sep 2002
U
United States District Court, D. Colorado. , 01 Jul 2002
U
Colorado Court of Appeals.Division I Ruland and Vogt, JJ., concur , 15 Mar 2001
U
Colorado Court of Appeals.Division II Jones and Davidson, JJ., concur , 12 Oct 2000
U
Colorado Court of Appeals.Division II Ney and Taubman, JJ., concur , 20 Jul 2000
U
Supreme Court of Colorado. , 17 Jul 2000
U
Colorado Court of Appeals.Division IV Marquez and Roy, JJ., concur , 11 May 2000
U
Colorado Court of Appeals.Division III Jones and Taubman, JJ., concur , 11 May 2000
U
Supreme Court of Colorado. , 10 Apr 2000
U
Colorado Court of Appeals. Division I , 12 Nov 1999
U
Colorado Court of Appeals.Division V Hume, C.J., and Briggs, J., concur , 01 Nov 1999
U
Colorado Court of Appeals.Division V Davidson and Kapelke, JJ., concur , 28 Oct 1999
U
Supreme Court of Colorado.EN BANC , 04 Oct 1999
U
Colorado Court of Appeals.Division IV Kapelke, J., concurs Ruland, J., concurs in part and dissents in part , 30 Sep 1999
U
Colorado Court of Appeals.Division III , 13 Sep 1999
U
United States District Court, D. Colorado. , 06 Aug 1999
U
Court of Appeals of New Mexico. , 12 Feb 1999
U
Supreme Court of Colorado.EN BANC , 06 Jul 1998
U
Supreme Court of Colorado.EN BANC , 20 Apr 1998
U
Supreme Court of Colorado.EN BANC JUSTICE HOBBS does not participate. , 09 Dec 1996
U
Supreme Court of Colorado.EN BANC JUSTICE KOURLIS concurs in part and dissents in part, and JUSTICE MULLARKEY joins in the concurrence and dissent. JUSTICE HOBBS does not participate. JUSTICE LOHR , 15 Oct 1996
U
Supreme Court of Colorado.EN BANC. , 23 Sep 1996
U
Supreme Court of Colorado.EN BANC , 01 Jul 1996
U
Supreme Court of Colorado.EN BANC , 19 Dec 1994
AMERICAN WATER DEV. v. CITY OF ALAMOSA
Supreme Court of Colorado. EN BANC. JUSTICE SCOTT does not participate. (9 May, 1994)