Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes

SAMUEL VANCE v. CALEB GRANGER'S EX'RS. — Conf., 71.

An injunction or order of the court of equity, directing a promissory note to be deposited with the clerk and master, by which the plaintiff was delayed in bringing his suit, will not prevent the commencement or stay the operation of the statute of limitations.

The jury find the note was executed by Caleb Granger on the 13th July, 1785, for the sum of one hundred and thirty pounds 4s.3d. They also find that by an injunction issued 7th July, 1787, by order of the Honorable Samuel Ashe, Judge in the Court of Equity, and an order of the said Court, that the note aforesaid was lodged in the hands of the clerk and master in equity, and that it appears to them that thereby the plaintiff was hindered from bringing suit on said note; that he afterwards brought suit on the 14th February, 1791; we further find that there is due to the plaintiff on a note the sum of £ 150 (292) 10s. 1d.

The question arising on this special verdict was, whether the plaintiff's demand was barred by the act of limitation.

By the Court.

Whatever hardship there may be in this case, there is no legal ground or principle to warrant the Court to render judgment for the plaintiff. The act of limitation would amount to a general and positive bar, were not certain exceptions contained in the proviso; we cannot add to these others, which the Legislature has omitted, nor construe cases to be within the saving, which is plain were not meant to be included. A Court of Equity has, under circumstances similar to the present, interposed its authority to restrain a defendant from pleading the act; but as a question of law, the decision must be for the defendant.

Cited: Broadfoot v. Fayetteville, 124 N.C. 494.

Use AI to get other relevant cases.

Comments

VANCE v. GRANGER
(Jan 1, 1800)