Citation Codes Equivalent Citations citation codes Attorney(S) Clarence L. Barber, Peter A. Hendrick James A. Deering for Theodore De Witt for See more information ... Smart Summary Please sign up to generate summary. GRENVILLE A. SMITH, Appellant, v. JOHN E. MARSH et al., Respondents. Judgment affirmed, with costs, on authority of Van Winkle v. Van Winkle ( 184 N.Y. 193). Concur: CULLEN, Ch. J., EDWARD T. BARTLETT, HAIGHT, VANN, WILLARD BARTLETT and CHASE, JJ. Absent: O'BRIEN, J.