Citation Codes Equivalent Citations citation codes Attorney(S) John S. Davenport for F.R. Minrath Henry Siegrist for See more information ... Smart Summary Please sign up to generate summary. WILLIAM W. RUTHERFURD, Respondent, v. J. HERBERT CARPENTER, Appellant. Judgment reversed and new trial granted, costs to abide event, on dissenting opinion of INGRAHAM, J., below. Concur: GRAY, WERNER, WILLARD BARTLETT and CHASE, JJ. Dissenting: CULLEN, Ch. J., HISCOCK and COLLIN, JJ.