STEWART v. COLLIER

Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Report a problem

Citation Codes

Equivalent Citations

citation codes

Docket Number

10232

Attorney(S)

Mr. J. Harry Foster, for appellant, submits: The automobile attached, and advertised for sale, is admittedly a part of the owner's homestead and personalty, and cannot be sold under judgment lien recovered against it under the automobile statute of 1912. Homestead is not subject to levy and sale: 99 S.C. 410; 28 S.C. 71; 32 S.C. 264; 73 S.C. 329; 26 S.C. 1; 24 S.C. 424; 37 S.C. 118; 107 S.C. 366; Code 1912, sec. 348, subdiv. 4; Const. 1895, art III, sec. 28; Code 1912, vol. I, sections 3711-3722; 106 S.C. 362; 69 S.C. 326; 14 Rich. 251; 2 S.C. 557; 84 S.C. 563; 13 Rich. 277; Cooley on Constitutional Lim. (7th Ed.), p. 127; 26 Enc. of L., 2d Ed. 280; 11 S.C. 333; 15 S.C. 593; 21 S.C. 375, 381. The Automobile Act of 1912, the homestead exemption statutes appearing in Code of 1912, and the Constitution of 1895, article III, sec. 28, must be construed together. Messrs. Dunlap Dunlap, for respondent, submit: The Automobile Act of 1912 was enacted by the legislature in the exercise of its police power, and is constitutional: 8 Cyc 863; 103 U.S. 344; 26 L.Ed. 505; 106 S.C. 366; 92 S.E. 508 (N.C.); 106 S.C. 333.

Are you a practicing lawyer?

Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.

Upload pleading to use the new AI search

Click here to upload

Cites

Citation Codes

Equivalent Citations

citation codes

Docket Number

10232

Attorney(S)

Mr. J. Harry Foster, for appellant, submits: The automobile attached, and advertised for sale, is admittedly a part of the owner's homestead and personalty, and cannot be sold under judgment lien recovered against it under the automobile statute of 1912. Homestead is not subject to levy and sale: 99 S.C. 410; 28 S.C. 71; 32 S.C. 264; 73 S.C. 329; 26 S.C. 1; 24 S.C. 424; 37 S.C. 118; 107 S.C. 366; Code 1912, sec. 348, subdiv. 4; Const. 1895, art III, sec. 28; Code 1912, vol. I, sections 3711-3722; 106 S.C. 362; 69 S.C. 326; 14 Rich. 251; 2 S.C. 557; 84 S.C. 563; 13 Rich. 277; Cooley on Constitutional Lim. (7th Ed.), p. 127; 26 Enc. of L., 2d Ed. 280; 11 S.C. 333; 15 S.C. 593; 21 S.C. 375, 381. The Automobile Act of 1912, the homestead exemption statutes appearing in Code of 1912, and the Constitution of 1895, article III, sec. 28, must be construed together. Messrs. Dunlap Dunlap, for respondent, submit: The Automobile Act of 1912 was enacted by the legislature in the exercise of its police power, and is constitutional: 8 Cyc 863; 103 U.S. 344; 26 L.Ed. 505; 106 S.C. 366; 92 S.E. 508 (N.C.); 106 S.C. 333.

See more information ...

Smart Summary

IN RE McFADDEN, STEWART v. COLLIER, ET AL.

July 14, 1919. The opinion of the Court was delivered by

MR. CHIEF JUSTICE GARY.

For the reasons stated by his Honor, the Circuit Judge the order of the Circuit Court is affirmed.

MESSRS. JUSTICES HYDRICK, WATTS and GAGE concur

MR. JUSTICE FRASER did not sit.

Use AI to get other relevant cases.