Citation Codes Equivalent Citations citation codes Attorney(S) For the appellant there was a brief by Richmond, Jackman, Wilkie Toebaas of Madison, oral argument by Harold M. For the respondent there was a brief by O'Melia Kaye of Rhinelander, oral argument by A.J. O' Judges PER CURIAM. See more information ... Smart Summary Please sign up to generate summary. GERBING, Respondent v. McDONALD, Appellant. PER CURIAM. This case is ruled by the case of Gerbing v. McDonald, decided herewith ( ante, p. 214, 229 N.W. 860). Judgment of the circuit court is affirmed. FRITZ, J., dissents.