Citation Codes Equivalent Citations citation codes Attorney(S) Samuel D. Smoleff for William C. Chanler, Corporation Counsel ( Robert H. Schaffer Paxton Blair of counsel), for See more information ... Smart Summary Please sign up to generate summary. In the Matter of BEN FORMAN et al., Appellants, against PAUL J. KERN et al., Constituting the Municipal Civil Service Commission of the City of New York, et al., Respondents. Order affirmed, with costs; no opinion. Concur: CRANE, Ch. J., LEHMAN, HUBBS, LOUGHRAN, FINCH and RIPPEY, JJ. Taking no part: O'BRIEN, J.