Citation Codes Equivalent Citations citation codes Docket Number 15048 Attorney(S) Messrs. John M. Daniel, Attorney General, Claude K. Wingate and Henry R. Sims, for appellants, cite: Defining of terms by Legislature: 294 U.S. 87; 79 L.Ed., 780; 114 S.W.2d 796; 14 F.2d 564; 248 P., 1017; 141 N.E., 551; 112 A., 385; 232 P., 569; 239 P., 1022; 133 N.E., 399; 136 A., 223; 242 P., 49. As to avoidance of an evasion: 281 U.S. 497; 278 U.S. 470; 283 U.S. 15; 218 U.S. 57; 247 U.S. 138; 201 U.S. 633; 19 F.2d 260; 272 U.S. 365; 248 U.S. 297; 248 U.S. 498; 226 U.S. 192; 127 U.S. 678; 187 U.S. 606; 211 U.S. 31; 251 U.S. 264; 253 U.S. 350; 265 U.S. 545; 272 U.S. 581; 259 U.S. 503. Classification: 63 S.C. 425; 41 S.E., 521; 113 U.S. 27; 63 S.C. 169; 41 S.E., 108; 141 S.C. 407; 139 S.E., 834; 156 S.C. 299; 152 S.E., 865; 177 S.C. 427; 181 S.E., 481; 25 R.C.L., 297; 178 S.C. 57; 182 S.E., 96; 240 U.S. 342; 60 L.Ed., 679; L.R.A., 1917-A, 421; Ann. Cas., 1917-B, 455; 68 S.C. 339; 47 S.E., 695; 165 U.S. 1; 169 U.S. 366; 187 U.S. 606; 92 S.C. 14; 75 S.E., 374; 220 U.S. 61; 55 L.Ed., 369; 168 S.C. 440; 167 S.E., 674; 290 U.S. 169; 78 L.Ed., 247; 233 U.S. 389; 58 L.Ed., 1011; L.R.A., 1916-C, 1189; 147 S.C. 116; 144 S.E., 846; 37 C.J., 201; 17 R.C.L., 518; 92 S.C. 81; 75 S.E., 392; 62 S.C. 524; 40 S.E., 970; 74 S.C. 207; 54 S.E., 362; 86 S.C. 94; 67 S.E., 1070. Taxation: 134 U.S. 232; 33 L.Ed., 892; 286 U.S. 276; 76 L.Ed., 1102; 87 A.L.R., 374. Liability of principal employer: 141 A., 705; 173 S.E., 741; 139 S.E., 365; 3 S.E., 2d 290; 168 U.S. 85. Messrs. Edens Weinberg, for respondent, cite: Doubtful tax statutes to be construed against taxing power: 174 S.C. 359; 177 S.E., 653; 182 S.C. 72; 188 S.E., 508; 183 S.C. 38; 190 S.E., 249; 139 S.C. 107; 137 S.E., 211; 171 S.C. 441; 172 S.E., 432; 133 S.C. 383; 131 S.E., 37; 127 S.C. 473; 121 S.E., 377; 187 So., 880; 301 U.S. 584; 81 L.Ed., 1279; 109 A.L.R., 1293; 301 U.S. 619; 81 L.Ed., 1307; 109 A.L.R., 1319. Construction of statutes: 173 S.C. 149; 175 S.E., 213; 102 S.C. 483; 86 S.E., 1057; 154 S.C. 55; 151 S.E., 218; 166 S.C. 117; 164 S.E., 588; 286 U.S. 472; 76 L.Ed., 1232; 83 S.C. 481; 65 S.E., 725; 135 S.C. 348; 132 S.E., 673. See more information ... Smart Summary Please sign up to generate summary. OPINION JACK ULMER, INC., v. DANIEL, ATTORNEY GENERAL, ET AL. March 28, 1940. The opinion of the Court was delivered by MR. CHIEF JUSTICE BONHAM. The facts in this case are not in dispute and are succinctly and clearly stated by Judge Gaston in his order on Circuit, from which this appeal comes. His exposition of the statute, and conclusions of law therefrom, meet the approval of this Court and are adopted by it. Let it be reported. The judgment of the Court below is affirmed. MESSRS. JUSTICES CARTER and FISHBURNE and MESSRS. ACTING ASSOCIATE JUSTICES J. HENRY JOHNSON and E. H. HENDERSON concur.