Citation Codes Equivalent Citations citation codes Docket Number 15146 Attorney(S) Messrs. John M. Daniel, Attorney General, Hubert E. Yarborough, Jr., and William H. Smith, for appellant, cite: As to unlawful discrimination: 123 N.W., 504; 42 L.R.A. (N.S.), 804; 226 U.S. 157; 57 L.Ed., 164; 291 U.S. 304; 78 L.Ed., 814; 291 U.S. 67; 78 L.Ed., 655; 291 U.S. 502; 78 L.Ed., 941; 212 U.S. 86; 53 L.Ed., 417. Right of State to legislate against combines in restraint of trade: 197 U.S. 115; 49 L.Ed., 689; 196 U.S. 447; 49 L.Ed., 546; 52 F., 917; 1 L.R.A., 744; 35 F., 866; 33 L.R.A., 209; 59 A.S.R., 457; 35 S.W. 129; 156 U.S. 1; 39 L.Ed., 325; 174 U.S. 237; 44 L.Ed., 146; 193 U.S. 197; 48 L.Ed., 679; 196 U.S. 375; 49 L.Ed., 518; 59 N.E., 55; 229 U.S. 373; 57 L.Ed., 1232; 221 U.S. 1; 55 L.Ed., 619; 34 L.R.A. (N.S.), 834; Ann. Cas., 1912-D, 734; 221 U.S. 106; 55 L.Ed., 663; 75 A.S.R., 306; 54 N.E., 551; 196 U.S. 589; 49 L.Ed., 610; 212 U.S. 86; 53 L.Ed., 417; 280 U.S. 396; 226 U.S. 157; 57 L.Ed., 164; 274 U.S. 1; 71 L.Ed., 893; 52 A.L.R., 163; 42 L.R.A. (N.S.), 804; 123 N.W., 504; 220 U.S. 81; 55 L.Ed., 369; Ann. Cas., 1912-C, 160; 127 U.S. 205; 32 L.Ed., 107; 216 U.S. 400; 54 L.Ed., 536; 19 Ann. Cas., 1247; 170 U.S. 283; 42 L.Ed., 1037; 172 U.S. 557; 43 L.Ed., 552; 223 U.S. 59; 56 L.Ed., 350; 199 U.S. 401; 50 L.Ed., 246; 23 L.R.A. (N.S.), 1287; 130 A.S.R., 671; 117 N.W., 768; 126 N.W., 527; 133 N.W., 895; 134 N.W., 496; 219 U.S. 549; 55 L.Ed., 328; 217 U.S. 433; 54 L.Ed., 826; 211 U.S. 489; 53 L.Ed., 295; 187 U.S. 609; 47 L.Ed., 323; 121 N.W., 395; 23 L.R.A. (N.S.), 1260; 71 S.C. 544; 51 S.E., 455; 193 U.S. 197; 48 L.Ed., 679; 69 S.C. 434; 48 S.E., 460; 67 L.R.A., 111; 75 S.C. 378; 55 S.E., 973; 9 Ann. Cas., 902; 234 U.S. 199; 58 L.Ed., 1276; 52 L.R.A. (N.S.), 525; 141 S.W., 672. Construction of statutes: 187 U.S. 606; 47 L.Ed., 323; 67 S.C. 312; 45 S.E., 211; 169 S.C. 198; 168 S.E., 554; 294 U.S. 87; 79 L.Ed., 780; 292 U.S. 44. Messrs. Royall Wright, Cyrus S. Gentry and Charles L. Harding, for respondent, Shell Oil Co., and Willcox, Hardee Wallace, George W. Ray, Jr., and Albert E. Van Dusen, for respondent, The Texas Co., and Henry E. Davis, for respondent, Sinclair Refining Co., cite: Right of Legislature to regulate commerce and trade: 71 S.C. 544; 51 S.E., 455; 212 U.S. 86; 53 L.Ed., 417; 285 U.S. 262; 76 L.Ed., 747; 229 U.S. 26; 57 L.Ed., 1050; 262 U.S. 522; 67 L.Ed., 1103. Constitutionality of penal statute repugnant to due process clause: 269 U.S. 385; 70 L.Ed., 323; 19 Ann. Cas., 68; 83 L.Ed., 590; 92 U.S. 214; 23 L.Ed., 563; 283 U.S. 359; 75 L.Ed., 1117; 73 A.L.R., 1484; 303 U.S. 444; 82 L.Ed., 949; 269 U.S. 385; 70 L.Ed., 322; 274 U.S. 445; 71 L.Ed., 1146; 210 P., 841; 213 P., 331; 234 U.S. 232; 58 L.Ed., 1284; 255 U.S. 81; 65 L.Ed., 516. Language of statute: 234 U.S. 26; 267 U.S. 233; 283 U.S. 553; 286 U.S. 210; 52 F., 917; 23 Fed. Supp., 70; 4 P.2d 117; 237 N.W., 711; 209 P., 896; 218 S.W. 493; 46 F.2d 354; 13 S.C. 56; 99 S.C. 218; 5 L.Ed., 37; 8 L.Ed., 745; 10 L.Ed., 543; 18 L.Ed., 830. Demurrer: 71 S.C. 544; 51 S.E., 455; 255 U.S. 81; 65 L.Ed., 516; 303 U.S. 444; 82 L.Ed., 949; 11 A.J., 774; 71 A.L. R., 1190; 181 N.W., 106; 127 N.W., 397; 140 A.S.R., 460; 72 Am. Dec., 97; 74 N.E., 1035; 1 L.R.A. (N.S.), 215; 108 A.S.R., 196; 3 Ann. Cas., 487; 55 N.E., 550; 77 S.E., 264; 80 S.E., 367; 18 R.C.L., 108; 304 U.S. 144; 293 U.S. 194; 164 U.S. 543; 295 U.S. 330; 274 U.S. 357; 71 L.Ed., 1095; 298 U.S. 407; 80 L.Ed., 1245; 301 U.S. 495; 81 L.Ed., 1245; 109 A.L.R., 1327; 238 U.S. 446; 59 L.Ed., 1400; 248 U.S. 303; 279 U.S. 582. Messrs. McEachin Townsend, Benet, Shand McGowan, Luke W. Finlay, Clarence J. Shearn and Charles C. Smith, for respondent, Standard Oil Company of New Jersey, cite: As to construction of penal statute creating new offense: 269 U.S. 385; 70 L.Ed., 322; 274 U.S. 445; 71 L.Ed., 1146; 210 P., 843; 234 U.S. 216; 255 U.S. 81; 236 U.S. 660. Where statute indefinite and uncertain: 234 U.S. 639; 83 L.Ed., 590; 19 Ann. Cas., 68; 267 U.S. 233; 69 L.Ed., 589; 283 U.S. 553; 75 L.Ed., 1264; 286 U.S. 210; 76 L.Ed., 1062; 22 F. Supp. 249; 23 F. Supp. 70; 209 P., 896; 109 S.W.2d 106; 193 S.W., 675; 46 F.2d 354; 99 S.C. 218; 5 L.Ed., 37; 287 U.S. 86; 77 L.Ed., 180; 279 U.S. 639; 73 L.Ed., 884. Due process clause: 291 U.S. 502; 23 F. Supp. 70; 50 F., 749; 152 U.S. 436; 295 F., 84; 82 P.2d 1; 102 S.W. 710; 77 P.2d 464; 131 N.W., 836; 25 R. C.L., 1050; 84 A., 567; 207 N.W., 210; 185 S.W. 487; 199 S.W. 811; 55 S.W. 117; 219 U.S. 467; 55 L.Ed., 297; 176 S.C. 41; 165 S.E., 724; 288 F., 774. Demurrer: 71 A.L.R., 1190; 181 N.W., 106; 127 N.W., 379; 140 A.S.R., 460; 74 N.E., 1035; 1 L.R.A. (N.S.), 215; 108 A.S.R., 196; 3 Ann. Cas., 487; 46 N.E., 720; 55 N.E., 550; 77 S.E., 264; 80 S.E., 367; 44 L.R.A. (N.S.), 83; 18 R.C.L., 108; 11 A.J., 825; 82 L.Ed., 1235; 304 U.S. 144; 293 U.S. 194; 79 L.Ed., 281; 264 U.S. 543; 68 L.Ed., 841; 295 U.S. 330; 274 U.S. 357; 298 U.S. 407; 301 U.S. 495; 81 L.Ed., 1245; 109 A.L.R., 1327; 238 U.S. 446; 59 L.Ed., 1400; 302 U.S. 392. See more information ... Smart Summary Please sign up to generate summary. STATE v. STANDARD OIL CO. OF NEW JERSEY.STATE September 25, 1940. The opinion of the Court was delivered by MR. JUSTICE FISHBURNE. The decree of Judge Lide, from which this appeal is taken, includes a thorough discussion of the issues raised by the exceptions. We think that the questions before us have been soundly decided by the lower Court, and that the exceptions are without merit. Let the decree of the Circuit Court be reported as the judgment of this Court. Judgment affirmed. MR. CHIEF JUSTICE BONHAM, MR. JUSTICE CARTER and MESSRS. ACTING ASSOCIATE JUSTICES J. HENRY JOHNSON and E.H. HENDERSON concur.