Citation Codes Equivalent Citations citation codes Attorney(S) David B. Coxe, Jr., for Plaintiff. C. Edward Duffy (James L. Latchum of Counsel) for Defendants. See more information ... Smart Summary Please sign up to generate summary. THE STATE OF DELAWARE, on the relation of Edward Carpenter, Plaintiff, v. WILLARD D. BOYCE, being Treasurer of the State of Delaware, and EDWARD W. COOCH, J. GORDON SMITH and FREDERIC K. LAMB, being the Members of and Constituting the State Pension Board, Defendants. Superior Court for New Castle County, No. 588, Civil Action, 1949.