Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Docket Number
Attorney(S)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Docket Number
Attorney(S)
Smart Summary

BROWN v. LEDGER-ENQUIRER COMPANY; GRIMES v. LEDGER-ENQUIRER COMPANY — Court of Appeals of Georgia (Apr. 16, 1958; rehearing denied May 8, 1958)

Factual and Procedural Background

Two separate libel actions were brought by Carlton Brown and Al Grimes against the Ledger-Enquirer Company based on a newspaper article published December 6, 1956. The article carried the headline "TWO MEN BOUND TO HIGHER COURT IN AUTO THEFT" and, in the body, reported that Brown and Grimes were injured in an automobile wreck and described their injuries. The defendant filed general demurrers to both petitions. The trial court sustained the demurrers and dismissed both petitions, reasoning that (1) the alleged libelous words appeared only in the headline, which did not identify the plaintiffs, and (2) reading the article showed that the headline and the body had no relationship and that the only reasonable construction was an innocent one. Each plaintiff excepted to the ruling sustaining the demurrer.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the whole article, including the headline, would, to the average reader, be construed as charging the plaintiffs with being bound over to a higher court for auto theft.

Arguments of the Parties

Defendant's Arguments

  • The allegedly libelous words appeared only in the headline, which did not identify the plaintiffs in any manner.
  • When the article is read in its entirety, the headline and the body have no relationship; the body concerns an automobile wreck and does not refer to bound-over charges for auto theft, so the only reasonable construction is an innocent one.
  • Based on the above, the general demurrers to the petitions should be sustained.

Plaintiffs' Positions

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the plaintiffs' legal arguments beyond the fact that each sued for libel and excepted to the trial court's sustaining of the general demurrer.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Pavesich v. New England Life Ins. Co., 122 Ga. 190 (50 S.E. 68, 69 L.R.A. 101, 106 Am. St. R. 104, 2 Ann. C. 561) Courts should apply recognized principles to new instances where the case is new only in instance and grant relief when appropriate. The court invoked this principle to justify applying established libel law to the present factual situation even though no directly analogous Georgia decision was located.
Davis v. Macon Telegraph Pub. Co., 93 Ga. App. 633 (92 S.E.2d 619) It is well settled that it is libel per se in a newspaper to charge a person falsely with a crime. Used to support the proposition that false criminal charges in a publication constitute libel per se and are actionable.
Witham v. Atlanta Journal, 124 Ga. 688 (53 S.E. 105, 4 L.R.A. (NS) 977) "To publish falsely of another that there are criminal cases pending against him is libelous per se." Reinforced the rule that imputations of pending criminal cases are libelous per se and relevant to evaluating the headline's effect.
Southeastern Newspapers Inc. v. Walker, 76 Ga. App. 57 (44 S.E.2d 697) Where a publication is ambiguous and capable of both criminal and innocent interpretations, it is a jury question whether it is susceptible to the criminal interpretation. The court applied this precedent to hold that ambiguity between headline and body creates a jury question as to whether the article accused the plaintiffs of crime.
Annotation to McAllister v. Detroit Free Press Co., 76 Mich. 338 (15 Am. St. R. 347) Headlines may be considered part of a publication and may justify regarding the publication as libelous when the body is not necessarily so. Used to support the rule that a conspicuous headline can inflict injury and be considered in assessing libel, even where the body is harmless.
Hayes v. Press Co., 127 Pa. St. 642 (18 A. 331, 5 L.R.A. 643, 14 Am. St. R. 874) A headline, when considered with the article's contents, can present a jury question as to whether the publication is libelous. The court cited Hayes as an example where a headline plus truthful body allegations nevertheless presented a jury question — supporting the conclusion that the headline in the present case could render the article libelous.
Wiley v. Oklahoma Press Publishing Co., 106 Okla. 52 (233 Pac. 224, 40 A.L.R. 573) A headline may be libelous even though the article body, read carefully, shows the headline to be false; the protection of a careful reader does not necessarily protect the publisher. The court used Wiley to emphasize that a false or misleading headline can be independently libelous because casual readers may rely on it.
33 Am. Jur. 101, Libel and Slander, § 88 Headlines directing attention to publications may be considered part of the publication and may justify regarding it as libelous. Cited as authority for treating headlines as part of the publication that may convey a defamatory meaning to readers and thus create a jury question.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court identified the single controlling inquiry: whether an average reader would conclude that the two named men in the article's body were the "two men bound to higher court in auto theft" mentioned in the headline. The court reasoned as follows:

  • The headline is conspicuous and may attract casual readers who do not read the entire article; headlines can therefore inflict serious injury and must be considered part of the publication.
  • Established authorities support that false imputations of criminality are libel per se and that ambiguous publications capable of both innocent and criminal meanings present a jury question.
  • Even if a careful reader would see the inconsistency between headline and body, the controlling standard is the average reader, not the careful reader; the careful reader's understanding does not necessarily protect the publisher.
  • Applying these principles, the court concluded it could not determine as a matter of law that the article was not libelous nor could it direct a verdict for the plaintiffs in the absence of proof that they had been bound over for auto theft.
  • Consequently, the petitions raised jury questions as to whether the publication reasonably could be construed to impute the crime to the plaintiffs, and the sustaining of the general demurrers was erroneous.

Holding and Implications

Judgments reversed.

Direct effect: The Court of Appeals reversed the trial court's judgments sustaining the defendant's general demurrers, holding that the petitions presented issues for the jury on whether the headline, together with the body of the article, could be construed by the average reader as charging the plaintiffs with auto theft. The opinion does not announce the entry of a final verdict for either party nor set out further procedural directions beyond reversal; it establishes that the factual interplay between headline and article can create a jury question rather than being resolved as a matter of law.

BROWN v. LEDGER-ENQUIRER COMPANY. GRIMES

In a libel action against a newspaper, where the headline of the alleged publication charges two unnamed persons with being charged with a crime and the body of the alleged libelous publication relates to an event involving two named persons, a jury question is presented as to whether the persons named in the body of the article were libelously charged with the crime mentioned in the headline.

DECIDED APRIL 16, 1958 — REHEARING DENIED MAY 8, 1958.

In separate actions Carlton Brown and Al Grimes sued the Ledger-Enquirer Company for alleged libel. The actions were based on the following article allegedly published in the defendant's paper on December 6, 1956:

"TWO MEN BOUND TO HIGHER COURT IN AUTO THEFT.

"LUMPKIN, GA., Dec. 5 — Carlton Brown, a Lumpkin lawyer, and Al Grimes, employed at the Singer Co., were injured when the car in which they were riding overturned near the Stewart-Quitman county line on State Highway 27 Sunday.

"Both men were taken to the Barbour County Hospital in Eufaula. Brown suffered a deep jagged cut on his right leg above the knee, 3 broken ribs, collar bone broken and other cuts and bruises. Grimes had his right leg broken."

The defendant filed general demurrers to both actions, which the trial court sustained, and identical judgments were rendered in both cases. They were in part as follows: "The words alleged to be libelous appear only in the headline to the article. The headline does not identify the plaintiff in any manner whatever. The article itself must be read in order to identify the plaintiff, and upon reading the article it is obvious that the headline and the remainder of the article have no relationship one with the other. In its entirety, the article conveyed to the mind of the reader the fact that the auto theft referred to in the headline was not imputed to the plaintiff, and since this is the `only construction by the reader, of which the article was reasonably susceptible,' it follows that the general demurrer to the petition should be, and it hereby is, sustained, and the petition dismissed." The plaintiff, in each case, excepts to the judgment sustaining the defendant's general demurrer to his petition.

NICHOLS, Judge.

No Georgia decision directly in point has been located; however, as was said in Pavesich v. New England Life Ins. Co., 122 Ga. 190 (1) ( 50 S.E. 68, 69 L.R.A. 101, 106 Am. St. R. 104, 2 Ann. C. 561): "The absence, for a long period of time, of a precedent for an asserted right is not conclusive evidence that the right does not exist. Where the case is new in principle, the courts can not give a remedy; but where the case is new only in instance, it is the duty of the courts to give relief by the application of recognized principles." It is well settled that it is libel per se in a newspaper to charge a person falsely with a crime. See Davis v. Macon Telegraph Pub. Co., 93 Ga. App. 633 ( 92 S.E.2d 619), and citations. "To publish falsely of another that there are criminal cases pending against him is libelous per se." Witham v. Atlanta Journal, 124 Ga. 688 (2) ( 53 S.E. 105, 4 L.R.A. (NS) 977). "Where in an action for libel the publication sued on is ambiguous and capable of being understood in a double a sense, the one criminal and the other innocent, it is a question for the jury to determine whether or not the publication is susceptible to the criminal or the innocent interpretation under all the facts and attendant circumstances of the publication." Southeastern Newspapers Inc. v. Walker, 76 Ga. App. 57 (1) ( 44 S.E.2d 697).

The sole question here for consideration is whether the whole article, including the headline, quoted in the above statement of fact, would, to the average reader, be construed as charging the plaintiffs with being bound over to a higher court for auto theft.

"The headline of an article or paragraph, being so conspicuous as to attract the attention of persons who look casually over a paper without carefully reading all its contents, may in itself inflict very serious injury upon a person, both because it may be the only part of the article which is read, and because it may cast a graver imputation than all the other words following it. There is no doubt that in publications concerning private persons, as well as in all other publications which are claimed to be libelous, the headlines directing attention to the publication may be considered as a part of it, and may even justify a court or jury in regarding the publication as libelous when the body of the article is not necessarily so: Lewis v. Clement, 2 Barn. Adol. 702; Clement v. Lewis, 7 Moore, 200; 3 Brod. B. 279; Harvey v. French, 2 Tyrw. 585; 1 Car. M. 11; 2 Moore S. 519; Hayes v. Press Co., 127 Pa. St. 642; 14 Am. St. Rep. 874." 15 Am. St. R. 347 (Annotation to McAllister v. Detroit Free Press Co., 76 Mich. 338). See also, 33 Am. Jur. 101, Libel and Slander, § 88.

In Hayes v. Press Co., 127 Pa. St. 642 (18 A. 331, 5 L.R.A. 643, 14 Am. St. R. 874), it was held that the headline "Hotel Proprietors Embarrassed," followed by a brief truthful statement that two named persons, who were hotel proprietors, had confessed judgment on a note, when taken into consideration with other allegations of the petition to the effect that the language implied that they were financially embarrassed, presented a jury question as to whether the article, including the headline, constituted libel.

In Southeastern Newspapers Inc. v. Walker, 76 Ga. App. 57, supra, this court held that a jury question was presented where an otherwise innocent announcement of the forthcoming marriage of an unmarried young lady was published by a newspaper under a picture of a young lady with a baby on her lap.

The body of the article in the case sub judice is not libelous unless the headline or caption thereof makes it so. The headline referred to two men being bound over to a higher court in connection with an auto theft, while the body of the article referred to two named men, the plaintiffs, being involved in an automobile wreck. Would the average reader conclude that these two named men mentioned in the article were the two men mentioned in the headline as being bound over to a higher court because of auto theft? or, on the contrary, would the average reader believe that there was no connection between the headline and the body of the article?

As shown above, the purpose of headlines in a newspaper should be to draw attention to the main body of the article, but not by making untruthful statements therein. In the case of Wiley v. Oklahoma Press Publishing Co., 106 Okla. 52 (233 pac. 224, 40 A.L.R. 573), it was held that a headline was libelous which, in effect, charged a father with commending a police officer for killing his son, although in the article itself it showed that the father stated, in effect, to the police officer that he realized the officer was merely doing his duty at the time and that he, the father, could not blame him. These cases illustrate the rule that although the body of the article itself is harmless and absolutely truthful, if the headline used in connection therewith is libelous the fact that a careful reader would realize that the headline was false does not protect the party or parties responsible.

In the body of the article under consideration in the present case there is no reference to the named men being bound over to a higher court for auto theft, and this would be readily apparent to the careful reader, but whether this would be apparent to a careful reader is not the question for decision for the average reader is not necessarily a careful reader.

While this court cannot hold that, upon proof of the publication and in the absence of proof that the plaintiffs had been bound over to a higher court for auto theft, a finding for the plaintiffs would be demanded, neither can it hold that the article was not, as a matter of law, libelous. The petitions presented jury questions and the judgments of the trial court sustaining the defendant's general demurrers to both petitions must be reversed.

Judgments reversed. Felton, C.J., and Quillian, J., concur.

Use AI to get other relevant cases.

Comments

BROWN v. LEDGER-ENQUIRER CO
(Apr 16, 1958)