Citation Codes Equivalent Citations citation codes Docket Number No. 303, Docket 25410. Attorney(S) Abraham Lebenkoff, Stuart Wadler Jules E. Coven, New York City, of counsel, for Arthur H. Christy, U.S. , New York City, Roy Babitt, Sp. U.S. , New York City, of counsel, for Judges Thomas Walter Swan Carroll Clark Hincks Leonard Page Moore See more information ... Smart Summary Please sign up to generate summary. UNITED STATES of America ex rel. TIE SING ENG, Relator-Appellant, v. P.A. ESPERDY, as District Director of the Immigration Ser PER CURIAM. The judgment is affirmed on the opinion below, United States ex rel. Tie Sing Eng v. Murff, D.C., 165 F. Supp. 633.