Citation Codes Equivalent Citations citation codes Docket Number Gen. Nos. 47,640, 47,641, 47,642, consolidated. (Abstract of Decision.) Attorney(S) Herman Jacobs, for appellant John C. Melaniphy, Corporation Counsel of the City of Chicago (Sydney R. Drebin, Rita Ivy Epstein, Assistant Corporation Counsel, of counsel) for Judges Opinion by JUSTICE SCHWARTZ. See more information ... Smart Summary Please sign up to generate summary. City of Chicago, a Municipal Corporation, Appellee, v. Hyman Goldstein, Appellant. Opinion by JUSTICE SCHWARTZ. Not to be published in full.