Citation Codes Equivalent Citations citation codes Docket Number No. 3912. Attorney(S) Richard M. Davis, Jr., of Burgess, Kennedy Davis, Sheridan, for William J. Kirven Robert A. Hill, Buffalo, for Judges PER CURIAM. See more information ... Smart Summary Please sign up to generate summary. CHAPMAN COMPANY, INC., APPELLANT (PLAINTIFF BELOW), v. KBBS, INC., AND JEANNETTE MAXWELL, APPELLEES (DEFENDANTS BELOW). PER CURIAM. The judgment below is affirmed by an equally divided court. PARKER, J., believes that opinions should be filed expressing the divergent views of the justices.