Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Docket Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Docket Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This interlocutory appeal and cross appeal arise from a partial summary judgment in a class action challenging the validity of a rent escalation clause in a condominium recreation lease. The plaintiffs, Sam Kaufman and Fifth Moorings Condominium, Inc., are unit owners and the condominium association of Fifth Moorings Condominium. The defendants, Ralph and Inez Shere, were officers and directors of the corporation that developed Fifth Moorings and lessors of the recreational facilities serving the condominium complex. The lease containing the rent escalation clause was a mandatory condition for purchasing condominium units.

In May 1974, defendants demanded a rent increase pursuant to the escalation clause tied to the Consumer Price Index. Plaintiffs filed suit on July 1, 1975, seeking declaratory relief under Florida Statutes § 711.236, enacted June 5, 1975, which voids escalation clauses in condominium recreation leases and prohibits their enforcement on public policy grounds.

The trial court ruled that the statute applied only prospectively and upheld the May 1974 rent increase but prohibited rent escalations after June 4, 1975. Plaintiffs appealed the allowance of the May 1974 increase, arguing for retroactive application of the statute. Defendants cross appealed, challenging the constitutionality of the statute and the interpretation of the condominium declaration as incorporating the statute.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Florida Statutes § 711.236 applies retroactively to invalidate rent escalation increases demanded before its enactment.
  2. Whether the Declaration of Condominium for Fifth Moorings incorporated by reference the provisions of Florida Statutes § 711.236, thereby applying the statute prospectively to prohibit future rent escalations.
  3. Whether the statute is unconstitutional and whether the Declaration should be interpreted as incorporating it.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiffs' Arguments

  • Section 711.236 should be applied retroactively to invalidate the May 1974 rent increase.
  • The language in the Declaration of Condominium clearly incorporates Section 711.236 as part of the governing documents.

Defendants' Arguments

  • Section 711.236 is unconstitutional.
  • The Declaration of Condominium incorporates only those provisions of the Condominium Act existing at the time of filing, not subsequent amendments like Section 711.236.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Fleeman v. Case, 342 So.2d 815 (Fla. 1977) Section 711.236 is inapplicable retroactively to contracts predating its enactment. The court relied on this ruling to uphold the May 1974 rent increase as valid and to reject plaintiffs' retroactivity argument.
Bouden v. Walker, 266 So.2d 353 (2d DCA 1972) Ambiguities in condominium declarations are construed against the drafter, especially a developer/lessor. The court applied this principle to reject defendants' argument and interpret the Declaration as incorporating future amendments like Section 711.236.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by addressing the retroactivity issue, relying on the Florida Supreme Court's decision in Fleeman v. Case, which held that Section 711.236 does not apply to contracts made before its enactment. Thus, the May 1974 rent increase was valid and properly upheld by the trial court.

Regarding the incorporation of Section 711.236 into the condominium's governing documents, the court examined the Declaration's clause adopting the Condominium Act "as it may be amended from time to time." The court found this language unambiguous and indicative of an intent to incorporate future legislative amendments, including Section 711.236, prospectively.

Defendants' argument that the incorporation applied only to provisions existing at the time of filing was rejected. Even if ambiguity existed, the court stated it would construe the language against the developer/lessors as the drafters, consistent with established legal principles.

Accordingly, the court affirmed the trial court's ruling that Section 711.236 was incorporated into the Declaration and that the prohibition on rent escalations after the statute's effective date was proper.

Holding and Implications

Affirmed.

The court affirmed the partial summary judgment: the May 1974 rent increase pursuant to the escalation clause was valid because Section 711.236 does not apply retroactively, but all rent escalations after June 4, 1975, are prohibited as the statute was incorporated prospectively into the condominium's governing documents. This decision directly affects the parties by validating the earlier rent increase and barring subsequent increases under the statute, but it does not establish new precedent beyond confirming the prospective application of the statute and the interpretation of incorporation clauses in condominium declarations.

SAM KAUFMAN ET AL., APPELLANTS, v. RALPH H. SHERE AND INEZ SHERE, HIS WIFE, APPELLEES.

NATHAN, Judge.

This is an interlocutory appeal and cross appeal from a partial summary judgment in a class action challenging the validity of a Rent Adjustment or "escalation" clause in a condominium recreation lease. The plaintiff Kaufmans are unit owners in Fifth Moorings Condominium and plaintiff Fifth Moorings Condominium, Inc., is the condominium association. Defendants Ralph Shere and the late Inez Shere, his wife, were officers and directors of the corporation which developed the Fifth Moorings Condominium, which is part of a complex that includes seven other condominiums. Defendants were also the lessors of the recreational facilities, which serve the entire Moorings complex.

The lease was assumed by all unit owners as a mandatory condition for purchasing their condominiums. In May of 1974, defendants demanded an increase in rent pursuant to the escalation clause, which calls for periodic rent adjustments in accordance with the Consumer Price Index. Plaintiffs initiated this action on July 1, 1975, seeking, inter alia, declaratory relief with respect to their rights and obligations under Florida Statutes § 711.236, which became law on June 5, 1975. Essentially, that section of the Condominium Act declares escalation clauses in condominium recreation leases void for public policy and prohibits their enforcement.

The trial judge did not pass on the constitutionality of retroactive application of Section 711.236, since he found that the legislature had declared escalation clauses to be unenforceable prospectively only. He also ruled that the Declaration of Condominium by which Fifth Moorings Condominium was created and governed had provided for the adoption of future legislative acts as amendments to the Declaration and that Section 711.236 should therefore be given prospective operation and effect with respect to the Fifth Moorings Condominium.

In accordance with these findings, the trial court granted a partial summary judgment allowing the rent increase of May 21, 1974, but prohibiting any further rent escalations after June 4, 1975. Plaintiffs appealed the upholding of the May, 1974 increase, arguing that Section 711.236 should be applied retroactively. Defendants have cross appealed, asserting that Section 711.236 is unconstitutional and that the Declaration of Condominium should not be interpreted as incorporating the provisions of Section 711.236.

With regard to plaintiffs' argument that Section 711.236 should be applied retroactively, we find that the Florida Supreme Court's recent ruling in Fleeman v. Case, 342 So.2d 815 (Fla. 1977), is completely dispositive of this question. The Court there ruled that Section 711.236 is inapplicable to contracts which antedate its enactment. Thus, the trial judge properly refused to invalidate the rent increase of May 21, 1974, which occurred before the effective date of the statute.

The only remaining question is whether the Declaration of Condominium of Fifth Moorings was properly interpreted as including the prospective invalidation of escalation clauses mandated by Section 711.236.

The critical contested provision of the Declaration reads as follows:

"1. Except where variances permitted by law appear in this Declaration or in the annexed By-Laws or in the annexed Charter of FIFTH MOORINGS CONDOMINIUM, INC., or in lawful amendments thereto, the provisions of the Condominium Act as presently existing, or as it may be amended from time to time, including the definitions therein contained, are adopted and included herein by express reference."

Plaintiffs argue that this language clearly provides for the incorporation of Section 711.236 as part of the Declaration of Condominium, while defendants contend that the quoted provision was applicable only where the Declaration was at variance with the Condominium Act at the time that the Declaration was filed. We do not find this latter argument persuasive.

Section 711.236 comes within Chapter 711, Florida Statutes (1975); Chapter 711 was known as the Condominium Act. Section 711.236 was created by Ch. 75-61, Laws of Florida and codified as § 711.231, Fla. Stat.

The contested clause unequivocally states that provisions of the Condominium Act are adopted " as it may be amended from time to time." (Emphasis added.) We perceive no ambiguity in this language, and thus find that it was the express intention of all parties concerned that the provisions of the Condominium Act were to become a part of the controlling document of Fifth Moorings whenever they were enacted. Even if we were to find an ambiguity, we would be forced to construe it against the defendant developer/lessors as authors of the Declaration of Condominium. See Bouden v. Walker, 266 So.2d 353 (2d DCA 1972); see generally 49 Am.Jur.2d, Landlord and Tenant, § 143.

Of course, such provisions would only be incorporated to the extent that they were valid, and thus Section 711.236 could only be adopted prospectively.

We hold that the trial judge properly ruled as a matter of law that Florida Statutes § 711.236 was incorporated into the Fifth Moorings Declaration of Condominium by virtue of the express wording of the Declaration itself. In light of this holding, the prohibition against further rent increases subsequent to the effective date of Section 711.236 was also proper.

Affirmed.

Use AI to get other relevant cases.

Comments

KAUFMAN v. SHERE
(Jul 27, 1977)