Citation Codes Equivalent Citations citation codes Docket Number No. 62518. Judges [3] TATE, J., dissents. See more information ... Smart Summary Please sign up to generate summary. BERTHA J. McPHERSON ET AL. v. CATAHOULA PARISH POLICE JURY. Writ denied. SANDERS, C. J., and SUMMERS and TATE, JJ., would grant the writ. [3] TATE, J., dissents. Hornsby v. Department of Highways, 241 La. 989, 132 So.2d 871 (1961), was incorrectly decided and should be overruled. See Hebert v. T. L. James, 224 La. 498, 70 So.2d 102 (1954). See also Louisiana Constitution of 1974, Article 1, Section 4.