AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Attorney(S)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Attorney(S)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This case arises from a medical malpractice action brought by appellants Muriel Winegrad et al. against defendant Joseph Jacobs and other medical professionals affiliated with New York University Medical Center. Plaintiffs alleged that defendant Jacobs failed to review Mrs. Winegrad's medical history before performing surgery near her eyes and allowed anesthesia administration without such review. During the surgery, Mrs. Winegrad suffered shock and cardiac arrhythmia. Defendants Ross and Pasternack were accused of administering unnecessary and harmful drugs. Additionally, Jacobs allegedly left the surgery incomplete after representing it had been completed.

Plaintiffs moved to strike defendants' answers due to their failure to appear for depositions. In response, defendants filed a cross motion for summary judgment, supported only by brief affidavits asserting adherence to accepted medical practices and denying causation of injury. The Special Term granted plaintiffs' motion and denied defendants' cross motion. The Appellate Division reversed, dismissing the complaint. This appeal followed.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether defendants made a prima facie showing entitling them to summary judgment by eliminating material issues of fact concerning medical malpractice.
  2. Whether plaintiffs' verified pleadings and defendant Jacobs' acknowledgment of injury preclude summary judgment for defendants.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • Plaintiffs contended that defendants failed to appear for depositions, warranting striking of their answers.
  • They alleged specific acts of negligence causing injury, supported by verified pleadings and a bill of particulars.

Respondents' Arguments

  • Defendants argued for summary judgment, submitting affidavits asserting they adhered to accepted medical practices and did not cause the plaintiff's injuries.
  • Defendant Jacobs acknowledged attempting surgery but denied deviation from standards or causation of harm.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Zuckerman v City of New York, 49 N.Y.2d 557, 562 Requirement that the movant in a summary judgment motion must make a prima facie showing eliminating material issues of fact. Cited to emphasize defendants' burden to provide sufficient evidence to entitle them to summary judgment.
Sillman v Twentieth Century-Fox Film Corp., 3 N.Y.2d 395, 404 Standard for granting summary judgment requiring elimination of material factual disputes. Used to reinforce the standard defendants failed to meet.
Matter of Redemption Church of Christ v Williams, 84 A.D.2d 648, 649 Failure to meet prima facie burden requires denial of summary judgment regardless of opposing papers. Supported the denial of defendants’ motion due to insufficient showing.
Greenberg v Manlon Realty, 43 A.D.2d 968, 969 Similar to above: movant must establish entitlement as a matter of law. Reinforced that defendants did not satisfy this standard.
Neuman v Greenstein, 99 A.D.2d 1018 Contextual reference on summary judgment in medical malpractice cases. Compared to show defendants’ conclusory affidavits were insufficient.
Pan v Coburn, 95 A.D.2d 670 Similar application to medical malpractice and summary judgment standards. Used to illustrate that mere conclusory statements do not warrant dismissal.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the defendants' cross motion for summary judgment under the established standard that the movant must make a prima facie showing eliminating material factual issues. It found that the defendants' affidavits were conclusory and lacked factual detail connecting their conduct to the alleged injuries. Notably, defendant Jacobs admitted to attempting the surgery, which resulted in cardiac arrhythmia, acknowledging some injury occurred. The court held that such bare assertions do not suffice to demonstrate entitlement to summary judgment. Plaintiffs’ verified pleadings further established factual claims that required resolution at trial. Thus, the court concluded that defendants failed to meet their burden and the cross motion should have been denied. The order of the Appellate Division dismissing the complaint was reversed, and the case was remitted for further consideration of unresolved issues.

Holding and Implications

The order of the Appellate Division dismissing the complaint is REVERSED. The individual defendants' cross motion for summary judgment is DENIED. The case is REMITTED to the Appellate Division for consideration of issues not previously addressed.

The direct effect of this decision is to allow the medical malpractice lawsuit to proceed, ensuring that factual disputes regarding defendants' alleged negligence are resolved through further judicial proceedings. The court did not establish new precedent but applied existing summary judgment standards to the facts at hand.

MURIEL WINEGRAD et al., Appellants, v. NEW YORK UNIVERSITY MEDICAL CENTER, Defendant, and JOSEPH JACOBS et al., Respondents.

MEMORANDUM.

The order of the Appellate Division should be reversed, with costs, the individual defendants' cross motion for summary judgment denied, and the case remitted to the Appellate Division for consideration of issues not reached on the appeal to that court.

In this action to recover damages for medical malpractice, plaintiffs in a verified complaint and bill of particulars alleged that defendant Jacobs failed to check Mrs. Winegrad's medical history before undertaking to perform surgery on the tissues surrounding her eyes, and allowed administration of anesthesia without checking this history; that during the course of this minor surgery she went into shock and developed cardiac arrhythmia; that defendants Ross and Pasternack treated her and administered drugs for a blood clot and heart condition which were unnecessary and actually were incompatible with her condition; and that defendant Jacobs wrongfully left the surgery incomplete after representing to her that it had been completed.

In response to plaintiffs' motion to direct that defendants' answers be stricken on account of their failure to appear for depositions, defendants sought summary judgment, tendering in support of their cross motion only the brief affidavit of each asserting that the pertinent medical records had been reviewed. Each affidavit further contained the following identical paragraph: "I now state with a reasonable degree of medical certainty that I did not deviate from good and accepted medical practices in my treatment of plaintiff, nor did anything I do [ sic] or allegedly failed to do proximately cause the plaintiff's alleged injuries. Therefore, I should not have been named as a defendant in the above-entitled action." Defendant Jacobs, in addition, acknowledged that he had attempted to perform a blepharoplasty on plaintiff, which was not completed since she developed cardiac arrhythmia. In opposition to the cross motion, plaintiffs submitted only their counsel's affidavit complaining of defendants' failure to appear for depositions. Special Term granted plaintiffs' requested relief and denied the cross motion for summary judgment; the Appellate Division reversed and dismissed the complaint.

The proponent of a summary judgment motion must make a prima facie showing of entitlement to judgment as a matter of law, tendering sufficient evidence to eliminate any material issues of fact from the case ( see, Zuckerman v City of New York, 49 N.Y.2d 557, 562; Sillman v Twentieth Century-Fox Film Corp., 3 N.Y.2d 395, 404). Failure to make such showing requires denial of the motion, regardless of the sufficiency of the opposing papers ( Matter of Redemption Church of Christ v Williams, 84 A.D.2d 648, 649; Greenberg v Manlon Realty, 43 A.D.2d 968, 969).

In the appeal before us, plaintiffs have in verified pleadings described certain injuries purportedly caused by the negligence of defendants, and defendant Jacobs has acknowledged that at least in some part the alleged injury actually occurred. On this record, the bare conclusory assertions echoed by all three defendants that they did not deviate from good and accepted medical practices, with no factual relationship to the alleged injury, do not establish that the cause of action has no merit so as to entitle defendants to summary judgment (CPLR 3212 [b]; cf. Neuman v Greenstein, 99 A.D.2d 1018, and Pan v Coburn, 95 A.D.2d 670). Defendants' cross motion for summary judgment should therefore have been denied.

Chief Judge WACHTLER and Judges JASEN, SIMONS, KAYE and ALEXANDER concur in memorandum; Judge MEYER taking no part.

On review of submissions pursuant to section 500.4 of the Rules of the Court of Appeals (22 N.Y.CRR 500.4), order reversed, etc.

Use AI to get other relevant cases.

Comments

WINEGRAD v. N.Y. UNIV. MEDICAL CENTER
(Feb 12, 1985)