Citation Codes Equivalent Citations citation codes Docket Number Civil Action No. 95-4017. Attorney(S) Robert J. Young, Jr., Timothy J. Young, Young, Richaud, Theard Myers, New Orleans, LA, for Barbara Sherman. William Bryon Schwartz, William Daniel Wellons, Burke Mayer, New Orleans, LA, for Gulf Pride Marine Services, Inc. John M. Futrell, Richard Marshall Perles, Kops, Lee, Futrell Perles L.L.P., New Orleans, LA, for Lloyds, London Ilu Companies. Gerard T. Gelpi, G. Beauregard Gelpi, Gelpi, Sullivan, Carroll Gibbons, P.L.C., New Orleans, LA, for Fireman's Fund. Judges Morey Leonard Sear Acts Judiciary And Judicial Procedure — District Courts; Jurisdiction — Jurisdiction And Venue — Bankruptcy Cases And Proceedings Judiciary And Judicial Procedure — District Courts; Removal Of Cases From State Courts — Jurisdiction And Venue — Removal Of Claims Related To Bankruptcy Cases See more information ... Smart Summary Please sign up to generate summary. Barbara SHERMAN v. GULF PRIDE MARINE SERVICES, INC. ORDER SEAR, Chief Judge. Considering plaintiff Barbara Sherman's "Motion for Remand, and Alternatively Motion for Abstention under 28 USCA 1334(c)" and the opposition filed by defendant Gulf Pride Marine Services, Inc. I find that the Fifth Circuit has not decided whether the prohibition against removal of Jones Act cases applies when there exists an independent basis for removal under the bankruptcy "related to" statute. See 28 U.S.C. § 1334; 28 U.S.C. § 1452. However, I find the reasoning in Kinder v. Wisconsin Barge Line, Inc., 69 B.R. 11 (E.D.Mo. 1986), to be correct and, therefore, conclude that the general prohibition against removal of Jones Act cases does apply in this case. Although the parties expend considerable effort discussing the doctrine of abstention, my disposition of the plaintiff's motion obviates the need to reach this issue. Accordingly, IT IS ORDERED that plaintiff's motion is GRANTED and that the case is hereby REMANDED to state court for further proceedings.