AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Docket Number
Motions
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Docket Number
Motions
Judges

NATIONAL AUDUBON SOCIETY; DEFENDERS OF WILDLIFE; SEATTLE AUDUBON SOCIETY; and AMERICAN BIRD CONSERVANCY, Plaintiffs, v. COLONEL RANDALL J. BUTLER; BRIGADIER GENERAL C.A. STROCK; and UNITED STATES ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS, Defendants.

ORDER DENYING DEFENDANTS' MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION OF ISSUANCE OF TEMPORARY RESTRAINING ORDER

BARBARA JOCOBS ROTHSTEIN, United States District Judge

I. BACKGROUND

THIS MATTER comes before the court on plaintiffs National Audubon Society, Defenders of Wildlife, Seattle Audubon Society, and American Bird Conservancy's (hereinafter "NAS") complaint and motion for temporary restraining order. NAS seeks to prevent defendants Colonel Randall Butler, Brigadier General C. A. Strock, and the United States Army Corps of Engineers (hereinafter "COE") from pursuing their plan to relocate the Caspian tern colony that nests in the Columbia River estuary on Rice Island down river to East Sand Island. Caspian terns are a natural predator of Columbia River salmonid species. The COE intends its tern relocation program to reduce consumption of salmonid species protected by the Endangered Species Act (hereinafter "ESA"), and thereby increase the outmigration and overall abundance of these species.

NAS claims that the year 2000 relocation program lacks scientific support as to its its potential effectiveness, does not provide the terns with sufficient alternative nesting habitat, and rests on the faulty assumption that tern predation is a key limiting factor on the vitality of Columbia River salmonid stocks. By contrast, NAS claims, the relocation program is certain to disrupt the reproductive pattern of the Rice Island terns and further diminish the numbers of a species already suffering from depressed reproductive success. At the very least, NAS asserts that the COE must prepare an Environmental Impact Statement (hereinafter "EIS") prior to taking any action on tern relocation.

The COE claims that the terns will not be adversely affected by a single season of relocation efforts. They claim this action is absolutely necessary to protect ESA—listed salmonid species, because each fish eaten irretrievably reduces the overall population. In this scenario, the COE claims that the interests of the ESA—listed fish must prevail over that of the non-listed Caspian terns.

On April 10, 2000, this court granted NAS's motion for temporary restraining order. The court directed the COE to prepare a response to NAS's motion, and convened a hearing on April 13, 2000, in order to revisit the merits of the temporary restraining order.

II. DISCUSSION

A. Test for Temporary Restraining Order

The traditional test for a temporary restraining order requires the moving party to show either 1) a combination of likely success on the merits and the possibility of irreparable injury; or 2) that serious questions as to the merits are raised and that the balance of hardships tips sharply in the moving party's favor. Sierra Club v. Marsh, 816 P.2d 1376 (9th Cir. 1987). The COE argues that this traditional test for a temporary restraining order is not the test to be applied under the ESA because the ESA evidences Congress' determination that the balance of hardships and the public interest always tip sharply in favor of the endangered species. See National Wildlife Federation v. Burlington Northern R.R., Inc., 23 F.3d 1508, 1510-11 (9th Cir. 1994).

Contrary to the COE's arguments, these cases do not stand for the proposition that the court is constrained to side with the party invoking endangered species' interests in every instance. Moreover, these cases are not helpful authority given the present circumstances where protecting an ESA—listed species puts another species at risk. The court, therefore, may exercise its discretion to balance in the more traditional manner.

III. FINDINGS

Having considered the arguments of counsel, the pleadings and attachments thereto, and the complete files and records herein, the court finds and rules as follows:

1. Likelihood of success on the merits

The court finds on the pleadings before it that there is a substantial controversy regarding the wisdom of the proposed relocation project. The plaintiffs' declarations raise serious questions as to the scientific basis for finding that relocating the tern population will contribute to the replenishing of the salmonid stocks. The record contains scientific opinions finding that:

The Corps' EA fails to acknowledge that data are lacking to support the presumed relationship between increasing numbers of terns and cormorants and decreasing numbers of returning adult salmon. In fact, the EA recognizes that information on smolt outmigration, Caspian tern numbers, and numbers of adult spawner returns in Grays Harbor suggest that tern predation was not a factor limiting numbers of adult returns there. There is little scientific evidence that control of avian predation has ever yielded increases in the number of returning adult salmon.

U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service February 18, 2000 Letter to COE at 2, Smith Decl. Exh. H. "[T]here is no scientific evidence to support the statement that piscivorus birds `may be one of the factors that currently limit salmonid stock recovery.'" Review of Management of Avian Predation on Salmon and Steelhead Smolts in the Columbia River in 2000 by Dr. Cynthia Tynan at ¶ 2, Smith Decl. Exh. B.

The court further finds that there is a likelihood that NAS will establish that an Environmental Impact Statement on the project should have been prepared.

2. Likelihood of irreparable harm

The court finds that the tern population would be irreparably harmed by the project due to the failure of the COE to provide adequate alternative nesting habitat to replace the Rice Island habitat despite the fact that both Fish and Wildlife and National Marine Fisheries Service scientists advised the COE about this need. The East Sand Island area being prepared for the terns is only half the size of that on Rice Island, which discrepancy the COE admits is part of its intentional design to force some portion of the tern colony out of the Columbia River estuary altogether. Apparently the COE could have? and indeed, might still be able to, set aside an area on East Sand Island that would be large enough to encompass the entire tern population.

IV. CONCLUSION

For the reason stated above, the court denies defendants' motion to reconsider issuance of the temporary restraining order. The restraining order will remain in place. The court expects the parties to consult on a briefing schedule and hearing date for the preliminary injunction and to determine if witnesses will be called at the hearing.

Use AI to get other relevant cases.

Comments

NATIONAL AUDUBON SOCIETY v. BUTLER, (W.D.Wash. 2000)
(Apr 13, 2000)