Citation Codes Equivalent Citations citation codes Docket Number 160. Judges Carmen Beauchamp Ciparick See more information ... Smart Summary Please sign up to generate summary. ESTELLE GILSON, ET AL., Appellants, v. METROPOLITAN OPERA, Respondent, et al., Defendants. Order affirmed, with costs. Opinion by Judge CIPARICK. Chief Judge Kaye and Judges Rosenblatt, Graffeo, Read and R.S. Smith concur. Judge G.B. Smith dissents and votes to reverse in an opinion.