Citation Codes Equivalent Citations citation codes Docket Number Civil Action No. H-05-1606. Judges Melinda Harmon See more information ... Smart Summary Please sign up to generate summary. EASTERN CARPET HOUSE, INC., MOHAMMAD Z. TIPU, HOUMAIRA ZUBAIR, TALHA ZUBAIR, and HAFSA ZUBAIR, Plaintiffs v. DEPARTMENT OF HOMELAND SECURITY through its secretary, MICHAEL CHERTOFF, EDUARDO AGUIRRE, DIRECTOR, UNITED STATES CITIZENSHIP and IMMIGRATION SERVICES and EVELYN UPCHURCH, DIRECTOR, TEXAS SERVICES CENTER, Defendants. FINAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT MELINDA HARMON, District Judge On this day, May 5, 2006, in the action pending between Plaintiffs, Eastern Carpet House Inc., Mohammad Z. Tipu, Houmaira Zubair, Talha Zubair, and Hafsa Zubair, and Defendants, Michael Chertoff as Secretary of Homeland Security, Eduardo Aguirre as Director of Citizenship and Immigration Services, and Evelyn Upchurch as Director of the Texas Service Center, the court issued its Memorandum Opinion and Order that Plaintiffs' Freedom of Information Act claim must be dismissed as a matter of law, and the court hereby ORDERS that Plaintiff take nothing and that Defendants are awarded their costs.