Citation Codes Equivalent Citations citation codes Docket Number 54. Judges Opinion by Judge Pigott. See more information ... Smart Summary Factual and Procedural Background This opinion addresses an appellate review by the Court of Appeals of the State of New York concerning a dispute between the City of Long Beach (Respondent) and the Civil Service Employees Association, Inc. — Long Beach Unit (Appellant). The procedural posture culminates in an order that was subject to affirmation by the court. Specific factual details and the underlying procedural history leading to the appeal are not provided in the text. Legal Issues Presented The opinion addresses a procedural matter and does not frame distinct legal issues. Arguments of the Parties The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments. Table of Precedents Cited No precedents were cited in the provided opinion. Court's Reasoning and Analysis The court issued a brief ruling affirming the order below, with costs. The opinion does not elaborate on the legal reasoning or analysis underpinning this decision. The concurrence and partial dissent by various judges are noted but not explained in the text. Holding and Implications Order affirmed, with costs. The court's decision upholds the lower court's ruling, resulting in a final resolution of the matter in favor of the respondent. No new legal precedent or broader implications are discussed in the opinion. Show full summary ... In the Matter of City of Long Beach, Respondent, v. Ci Opinion by Judge Pigott. Order affirmed, with costs.