CORRIGAN, J. (concurring.)
I concur in the Court's order denying leave to appeal. I write separately to express my agreement with a majority of other states that territorial jurisdiction presents an issue of subject-matter, rather than personal, jurisdiction, which cannot be waived. See People v Betts, 34 Cal 4th 1039, 1049 (2005); State v Willoughby, 181 Ariz 530, 538, n 7 (1995); People v McLaughlin, 80 NY2d 466, 471 (1992); see also LaFave, Criminal Procedure (3d ed), § 16.4(a), n 2, p 830 ("Since territorial jurisdictional limits operate to restrict the subject matter over which the court can exercise authority, they are treated procedurally as presenting issues of subject matter jurisdiction."). Further, I emphasize that the record in this case clearly established that the state of Michigan had territorial jurisdiction to prosecute defendant pursuant to MCL 762.2. After a six-day trial, a jury convicted defendant of both first-degree premeditated murder, MCL 750.316(1)(a), and first-degree felony murder, MCL 750.316(1)(b). The record reveals that the prosecutor presented ample evidence that defendant committed at least one element of each charged offense in Michigan. This evidence, which the jury found persuasive, was more than sufficient to establish territorial jurisdiction under MCL 762.2(1)(a) and (2)(a). Accordingly, I agree with the Court of Appeals that "even though the evidence suggested that the fatal blows were struck in Indiana, and despite the discovery of the victim's body in Indiana, the trial court had territorial jurisdiction to try defendant for murder under the laws of Michigan." People v Gayheart, 285 Mich App 202, 220 (2009).
KELLY, C.J., would grant leave to appeal.
O'BRIEN v PUBLIC SCHOOL EMPLOYEES RETIREMENT BOARD, No. 140484; Court of Appeals No. 294388.
CORRIGAN, J. (concurring).
I concur in the Court's decision to deny the application for leave to appeal. I write to express my shock and disbelief at the salary of petitioner Robert M. O'Brien as a school superintendent, to urge legislative attention to the statutory scheme that gave rise to this expenditure, and to alert the public to this use of its tax dollars.
Petitioner was a Huron Valley School District superintendent from 1998 until his retirement in 2006. Petitioner made regular contributions to the Public Employees Retirement Fund during that time. This case concerns petitioner's dispute with respondent Public School Employees' Retirement Board over the amount of his remuneration that may be considered "compensation" under the public school employees retirement act of 1979, MCL 38.1301, et seq., for purposes of determining his monthly pension benefit. An employee's retirement benefit is calculated based on his "final average compensation," which is an average of the employee's reportable "compensation" for the 36 consecutive months during which the employee had the highest compensation. MCL 38.1304(12). Petitioner contests the final average compensation calculated by the Office of Retirement Services. Petitioner appealed to the Michigan Public Schools Retirement Board (Board), which denied his request that his retirement allowance be increased from $8,346.92 per month to $15,601.95 per month. The circuit court affirmed. The Court of Appeals denied leave, to appeal. O'Brien v Pub School Employees' Retirement Bd, unpublished order of the Court of Appeals issued December 21, 2009 (Docket No. 294388).
Petitioner now seeks leave to appeal to this Court, claiming that respondent erred in several respects in calculating the final average compensation used to determine his retirement benefits and that certain terms used in the retirement act are unconstitutionally vague. I agree with the Court's decision to deny leave to appeal. I write separately to express my amazement at the amount petitioner was compensated for serving as a public employee and to draw legislative and public attention to these alarming facts. Given the considerable concern-over public expenditures in the current economic climate, I believe the facts of this case signal a need for legislative scrutiny.
For the year ending June 30, 2001, petitioner earned a total of $158,911.00. For the year ending June 30, 2006, petitioner earned a total of $418,965.00. The chart below shows petitioner's compensation from 2001 to 2006:
Year Ending June 30 Total Remuneration 2001 158,911.00 2001 244,726.00 2003 328,902.00 2004 356,662.00 2005 388,121.00 2006 418,965.00 According to the Board's Decision and Order, December 11, 2008 (Docket No. 2008-221 PSRS) at 15-16, the $418,965.00 petitioner received in 2006 included:
• $154,181.00 as a gross salary;
• $24,500.00 as deferred compensation;
• $17,369.07 for days worked beyond allotted vacation and personal days;
• $20,101.00 for reimbursement for contributions to the Member Investment Plan;
• $114,111.86 for the purchase of two years service credit by Huron Valley School District or the equal cost of an investment by petitioner;
• $30,836.20 for merit pay;
• $57,839.04 for longevity.
These amounts are eye-popping. I question which individuals and bodies are responsible for this use of tax dollars and whether the legislature and the public are aware that this is happening.