ORDERS, THIS DAY, ORDER WAS MADE THEREIN AS
UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S.R.KRISHNA KUMAR
ORAL ORDER
In W.P. No.200328 of 2025, petitioner seeks the following reliefs:
"i) Issue a Writ in the nature of certiorari whereby quashing the impugned
notification dated 26-09-2024 as at Annexure-F to an extent of land Sy.No.25 measuring 1 acre 10 guntas situated at village Donagaon, Ta.Chittapur, Dist:
Kalaburagi to the writ petition in the interest of justice and equity. i(a) Issue a Writ in a nature of Certiorari whereby, quashing the impugned
notification dated 30-05-2024 as at Annexure-K published by 1strespondent, in the interest of justice equity.
ii) Issue any other writ or order or direction as this Hon'ble Court deems fit in view of the facts and circumstances of the case stated above in the interest of justice and equity.
2. In W.P. No.203560 of 2025, the petitioner seeks the following reliefs:
- 6 -
"i) Issue a Writ in the nature of certiorari whereby quashing the impugned
notification dated 22-09-2025 as at Annexure-L to an extent of land Sy.No.25 measuring 16 guntas situated at village Donagaon, Ta.Chittapur, Dist: Kalaburagi to the writ petition in the interest of justice and equity.
i(a) Issue a Writ in a nature of Certiorari whereby, quashing the impugned
notification dated 30-05-2024 as at Annexure-M published by 1strespondent, in the interest of justice equity.
iii) Issue any other writ or order or direction as this Hon'ble Court deems fit in view of the facts and circumstances of the case stated above in the interest of justice and equity.
3. The common petitioner in both the petitions is Smt. Ayyamma who claims to be the owner in possession and enjoyment of land bearing Survey No.25 situated at Donagaon village, Chittapura Taluk, Kalaburagi District. In W.P.No.200328 of 2025, the petitioner is aggrieved by the impugned acquisition proceedings in relation to 1 acre 10 guntas of land in Survey No.25 while in W.P. No.203560 of 2025, the very same petitioner is aggrieved
- 7 -
by the acquisition proceedings in respect of another extent of 16 guntas of land in the very same Survey No.25 which is the subject land in both the petitions. The petitioner also assails the impugned notification dated 30.05.2024 issued by the respondent No.1 exercising powers under Section 2 (37A) of the Railways Act, 1989 (for short 'the said Act of 1989), declaring and notifying a Special Railway Project for acquisition of land in the State of Karnataka, as a Special Railway Project for the benefit of respondent No.5- M/s Shree Cement Limited.
4. Since common questions of law and fact arise for consideration in both the petitions, they are taken up together and disposed of by this common order.
5. A perusal of the material on record will indicate that as stated supra, the petitioner contends that in pursuance of approval granted in favour of the respondent No.5 for establishing a Railway Siding/Track between Cement Manufacturing Plant and Storage and Bagging
- 8 -
Plant at Benakanahalli village, Kodla Hobli, Sedam Taluk and Chittapura village, Kasaba Hobli, Chittapura Taluk, Kalaburagi District, the respondent No.5 purchased various lands from the villagers and other co-owners of land bearing Survey No.25 referred to supra. It is contended that since the petitioner refused to give consent for either purchase of her land by the respondent No.5 nor gave consent for acquisition of the said land by the respondent No.5, the Central Government issued the impugned Notification dated 30.05.2024 invoking Section 2 (37A) of the said Act of 1989 declaring that the said project of the respondent No.5 as a Special Railway Project for acquisition of land in pursuance of which the respondent No.1 issued and published a Preliminary Notification dated 26.07.2024 under Section 20A of the said Act followed by a Final Notification/Declaration dated 26.09.2024 issued under Section 20E of the said Act of 1989, thereby acquiring the subject land of the petitioners. It is contended that the impugned Notification
- 9 -
dated 30.05.2024 issued under Section 2 (37A) of the said Act of 1989 declaring and notifying the project of the respondent No.5 as a Special Railway Project for providing National Infrastructure for public purpose is illegal, arbitrary and in contravention of the said provision as a consequence of which the acquisition proceedings pursuant to the Preliminary Notification dated 26.07.2024 and Final Notification dated 26.09.2024 are also illegal, arbitrary and the same deserves to be quashed.
6. In the first instance, the petitioner challenged only the acquisition Notification dated 26.09.2024 and subsequently got the petition amended vide order dated 15.07.2026 and assailed the Notification dated 30.05.2024 issued under Section 2 (37A) of the said Act of 1989 declaring the project of the respondent No.5 as a Special Railways Project. It is contended that the aforesaid Notification dated 30.05.2024 as well as the acquisition proceedings pursuant to the impugned Notifications dated 26.07.2024 and 26.09.2024 are not in
- 10 -
public interest and in contravention of Section 2 (37A) of the said Act of 1989 as well as Section 20A and Section 20E of the said Act, 1989 and the impugned Notification and the entire acquisition proceedings for the benefit of respondent No.5 are illegal and contrary to law and facts and the same deserves to be quashed.
7. The respondent No.1-Government of India and respondent No.2-State of Karnataka as well as respondent No.5- M/s Shree Cement Limited, the beneficiary of the acquisition proceedings have filed separate Statement of objections inter alia disputing and denying the various allegations and claim made by the petitioner and contend that the impugned Notification dated 30.05.2024 as well as the acquisition Notifications and proceedings are correct, legal and proper and that there is no merit in the petition and the same is liable to be dismissed.
- 11 -
8. Heard learned counsel for the petitioner and learned counsel for the respondents and perused the material on record.
9. In addition to reiterating the various contentions urged in the petition and referring to the material on record, learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that the very invocation of Section 2 (37A) by the respondent No.1 for the purpose of issuing the impugned Notification is contrary to the said provision, since the said Notification was issued for the personal benefit/purpose of the private respondent No.5 and not for any public purpose as required under Section 2 (37A) of the said Act of 1989 and the impugned acquisition proceedings at the instance of respondent No.5 and for its benefit are vitiated by malafides and malice by paying meager compensation in favour of the petitioner who had not given consent to the said acquisition which is a colourable exercise of power for the respondent No.5 which is a private company. It is contended that except
- 12 -
the sole benefit of the respondent No.5, there is no public purpose involved in the impugned Notification and acquisition proceedings and consequently the same deserves to be quashed.
10. In support of his submissions, he placed reliance upon the following judgments:
1) Gaukaran Singh V/s State of C.G and others -2008 SCC Online Chh 216.
2) Kolkata Municipal Corporation and another V/s Bhimal Kumar Shah and others (2024) 10
SCC 533.
11. Per contra, learned counsel for the respondent would reiterate the various contentions urged in the Statement of objections and submitted that there is no merit in the petition and the same is liable to be dismissed.
- 13 -
12. I have given anxious consideration to the rival contentions and perused the material on record.
13. A perusal of the material on record will indicate that on 13.10.2021, the Government of India launched the PM Gati Shakti National Master Plan with the objective of providing multimodal connectivity infrastructure to various economic zones across the country. The plan aims to bring together all the relevant Ministries and Departments of the Government of India on a unified digital platform to facilitate holistic, integrated and co- ordinated planning and implementation of infrastructure projects. It seeks to ensure seamless connectivity among various modes of transport, including roadways, railways and waterways, thereby enabling efficient movement of goods and promoting economic development. The details of the said PM Gati Shakti Master Plan (Annexure-R12) is as hereunder:
- 14 -
Annexure R12. About PM Gati Shakti PM GatiShakti National Master Plan (PMGS-NMP) was launched on 13th October 2021 for providing multimodal connectivity infrastructure to various economic zones. Cabinet Committee on Economic Affairs (CCEA) accorded approval for the implementation of PM GatiShakti National Master Plan on 21st October 2021. PM GatiShakti is a transformative approach for economic growth and sustainable development. The approach is driven by 7 engines, namely:
1. Railways
2. Roads
3. Ports
4. Waterways
5. Airports
6. Mass Transport
7. Logistics Infrastructure All 7 engines will pull forward the economy in unison. These engines are supported by the complementary roles of Energy Transmission, IT Communication, Bulk Water & Sewerage, and Social Infrastructure. The approach is powered by Clean Energy and Sabka Prayas the efforts of the Central Government, the state governments. and the private sector together- leading to huge job and entrepreneurial opportunities for all, especially the youth.
- 15 -
The scope of PM GatiShakti National Master Plan will encompass the 7 engines for economic transformation, seamless multimodal connectivity and logistics efficiency. It will also include the infrastructure developed by the State Governments, as per the GatiShakti Master Plan. The focus will be on planning, financing including through innovative ways, use of technology and speedier implementation.
The projects pertaining to these 7 engines in the
"National Infrastructure Pipeline" will be aligned with PM GatiShakti framework. The touchstone of the Master Plan will be world-class modern infrastructure and logistics synergy among different modes of movement-both of people and goods and location of projects. This will help raise productivity and accelerate economic growth and development.
The plan has been developed as a Digital Master Planning tool by BISAG-N (Bhaskaracharya National Institute for Space Applications and Geoinformatics) and has been prepared in dynamic Geographic Information System (GIS) platform wherein data on specific action plan of all the Ministries/Departments have been incorporated within a comprehensive database. Dynamic mapping of all infrastructure projects with real-time updation will be provided by way of a map developed by BISAG-N. The map will be built on open-source technologies and hosted securely on MEGHRAJ Le cloud of Govt. of India. It will use satellite imagery available from ISRO and base maps from Survey of India. The
- 16 -
comprehensive database of the ongoing & future projects of various Ministries has been integrated with 200+ GIS layers thereby facilitating planning, designing and execution of the infrastructure projects with a common vision.
The digital system is a software where Individual Ministries will be given separate user identification (login ids) to update their data on a periodic basis. The dala of all the individual Ministries will be integrated in one platform which will be available for planning, review and monitoring. The Logistics Division, Ministry of Commerce & Industry (MOCI) will further assist all the stakeholders through BISAG-N for creating and updating their required layers in the system and update their database through Application Programming Interface (APIs)."
14. In pursuance of aforesaid Master Plan, the Ministry of Railways incorporated the Gati Shakti Multi- Modal Cargo Terminal (GCT policy) on 15.12.2021 by issuing a Master Circular which was applicable to all new cargo terminals as well as cargo terminals that are under construction or under approval under the erstwhile Private Sidings Policy or Private Freight Terminal (PFT) policy and the said policy was introduced to facilitate development of modern cargo terminal infrastructure and to promote
- 17 -
seamless multimodal logistics connectivity as can be seen from the Master Circular produced as Annexure-R13 dated 15.12.2021 issued by the Railway Board as hereunder:
Annexure-R13
Master Circular on 'Gati Shakti Multi-Modal Cargo Terminal (GCT)-2021
भारत सरकार
GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
रेल मंालय MINISTRY OF RAILWAYS (रेलवे बोड RAILWAY BOARD)
No. 2021/TC(FM)/18/23
Rail Bhavan,
New Delhi-110 001, Dated 15.12.2021 The General Managers.
1. Central Railway, Mumbai
2. Eastern Railway, Kolkata
3. East Central Railway, Hajipur
4. East Coast Railway, Bhubaneshwar
5. Northern Railway, New Delhi
6. North Central Railway, Prayagraj
7. North Eastern Railway, Gorakhpur
8. Northeast Frontier Railway, Maligaon
9. North Western Railway, Jaipur
10. Southern Railway, Chennai
11. South Central Railway, Secunderabad
12. South Eastern Railway, Kolkata
13. South East Central Railway, Bilaspur
14. South Western Railway, Hubli
15. Western Railway, Mumbai
16. West Central Railway, Jabalpur Sub: Master Circular on 'Gati Shakti Multi-modal Cargo Terminal (GCT)'.
- 18 -
Ref:(1) Private Siding Policy issued vide Freight Marketing Circular no. 11 of 2016 under Board's letter No. 99/TC(FM)/26/1/Pt. II dated 22.08.2016 and amendments thereof.
(ii) Master Circular on Private Freight Terminal (PFT)/2020/0. Dated 23.06.2020 and amendments thereof.
In order to boost investment from industry in development of additional terminals for handling rail cargos, a new 'Gati-Shakti Multi-modal Cargo Terminal (GCT)' policy has been framed
All new as well as under-construction/under-approval Cargo Terminals (approved /proposed under 'Private Siding' or Private Freight Terminal policies) shall be covered by this "Gati-Shakti Multi-Modal Cargo Terminal (GCT)' policy. Existing Siding/Terminals can also migrate to this new GCT policy by submitting request to Division. Private Siding/Terminal which opt to migrate in GCT policy will need to sign a supplementary Agreement for this purpose. Private Siding / Terminal which do not opt to migrate in new GCT Policy, will continue to be governed by their existing Agreement.
The policy is in supersession of existing Private Siding Policy 2016 (FMC 11 of 2016) and Master Circular on Private Freight Terminal/2020 mentioned under references above.
This issues in consultation with Civil Engineering, Land and Amenities, Traffic Transportation, Mechanical Engineering and Signal Directorates, and with the concurrence of Finance Directorate of Ministry of Railways.
Enclosure/As Above
Sd/-
Anshoo Pandey
Director Freight Marketing
No. 2021/TC(FM)/18/23
New Delhi, Dated 512.2021
- 19 -
Copy forwarded for information to:
1. The PFAs, All Indian Railways.
2. The Deputy Comptroller & Auditor General of India (Railways), Rail Bhawan
Sd/-
For Member (Finance)
No 2021/TC(FM)/18/23
New Delhi, Dated 15.12.2021
1. The Principal Chief Operations Managers, All Indian Railways
2. The Principal Chief Commercial Managers. All Indian Railways.
3. The Chief Traffic Planning Manager, All Indian Railways.
4. The Principal Chief Engineers, All Indian Railways.
5. The Chief Commercial Managers (FM), All Indian Railways.
6. Director General, RDSO, Manak Nagar, Lucknow.
7. Director, Indian Railways Institute of Transport Management (IRITM), Manak Nagar, Lucknow.
8. Director General, National Academy of Indian Railways. Vadodara
9. The Managing Director/Chief Commercial Manager, Konkan Railway Corporation Lad Belapur Bhawan, Plot No. 6, Sector-11, CBD Belapur, Navi Mumbai-400014
10. Managing Director, CRIS, Chanakyapuri, Near National Rail Museum, New Deilti.
11. Managing Director, DFCCIL, Pragati Maidan, New Delhi Anshoo Pandey
Sd/-
Director Freight Marketing
New Delhi, Dated 15.12.2021
No. 2021/TC(FM)/18/23
1. Copy for kind information to:
2. Chairman & CEO, Member (O&BD), Member (Finance), Member (Infira), Member (T&RS), DG(RPF), and Secretary Railway Board, New Delhi.
- 20 -
3. AM(Traffic), AM(C). Adv (Infra), Adv. (Vig), EDTC(Rates), EDTT(M), EDITTIS) EDTT(F), ED(Pig) EDT (PPP), EDV(T), EDF(C), DTT (Coord), 050/Chairman & CEO OSD/Member (O&BD). Co-Chairman/TMIR, Chairman and Covener/AGE and DTC(R)/Railway Board, New Delhi. Sub: Policy for 'Gati Shakti Multi-Modal Cargo Terminal'
1. Introduction
1.1 This policy seeks to promote proliferation of new Cargo Terminals and improve existing Cargo Terminals to accelerate the growth in Railways' cargo traffic. All new as well as under-construction/ under-approval Cargo Terminals shall be covered by this Gati Shakti Multi-Modal Cargo Terminal (GCT)' policy
1.2 Existing Cargo Terminals governed by Private Siding or Private Freight Terminal policies shall have the option to continue with their existing Agreements, or to migrate to the GCT policy.
1.2.1 Existing Cargo Terminals can migrate to GCT policy by submitting a request to the Divisional Railway Manager (DRM) of the
concerned Division of Railway, after clearing pending Railway dues and withdrawing all
pending arbitration cases/court cases, if any. The provisions of this Policy shall be applicable on such Cargo Terminals from the date the request is approved by the DRM.
1.2.2 Existing Cargo Terminal owners shall be allowed to migrate to this new GCT policy only when all pending Railway dues of all Cargo Terminals belonging to the same
owner/ its subsidiaries/ parent company/
sister concerns over Indian Railways are
cleared and all pending arbitration cases/ court cases over Indian Railways are
withdrawn.
- 21 -
1.2.2.1 The management of existing terminals desirous of migrating to the GCT policy shall provide a list of all terminals belonging to their company/its subsidiaries/ parent company/ sister concern over Indian Railways, along with an Undertaking stating that 'there are no Railway dues pending as well as no court cases/ arbitration cases pending over Indian Railways in respect of these terminals. The concerned Division shall inform all the other Divisions/Railways where such terminals (if any) are located within fifteen days of the receipt of application, and other Divisions/ Railways shall inform within fifteen days if there is any discrepancy/ omission in the Undertaking submitted by the applicant. If no discrepancy/ omission is reported within the prescribed time, the concerned Division shall permit migration to GCT However, if it is revealed at any later stage that the applicant had omitted any fact or had given any false declaration/ submission, Railway may take suitable legal action including reversion of the migration of Terminal to GCT policy.
1.2.2.2 If the terminal owner is not satisfied with the claims made/ charges levied by Railway, a representation to this effect may be submitted to the concerned DRM after clearing such dues. The DRM will decide on the representation within two months, after examining the facts of the case and in consultation with the associate
- 22 -
finance. If the DRM decides that the claims made/ charges levied by the Railway were not as per policy guidelines, the excess amount paid by the terminal owner will be refunded within fifteen days of such decision. The terminal owner may also preter an appeal against the decision of DRM to the General Manager, whose decision will be final.
1.3 Sidings/PFTs that have been partially commissioned (Le partially operational, with next phase under construction or under planning/ approval) before 15.12.2021, and whose next phase is planned for commissioning/ becoming operational after 15.12.2021 shall continue to be governed by the policy guidelines under which their 1stphase was commissioned. However, as per para 12 such Sidings/PFTs will also have the option to migrate in the GCT Policy
2. Definition The key terms used in these policy guidelines have been defined below for correct interpretation and elimination of ambiguities.
i. Act: The Railways Act, 1989, as amended from time to time.
ii. Agreement: Document exeruted ny a fati Shakti Multi-Modal Cargo Terminal Operator (GOTO) and Railway Administration (RA) setting forth the terms and conditions for operation of a Gati Shakti Multi-Modal Cargo Terminal (GCT).
iii. Authorized Users: Rail users authorized by the GCTO to make use of the Facilities at a GCT.
- 23 -
iv. Cargo Terminal: Terminal where goods are loaded in wagons/coaching vehicles for transportation over Indian Railway network, and/or unloaded from wagons/coaching vehicles after being transported over Indian Railway Network.
v. Charging on Through Distance Basis: The system of charging freight up to the buffer end of the siding, instead of levying Siding Charges.
vi. Common User Facility: A facility available for common use of all Rail users without any discrimination including yards/ additional lines/ loop lines/signaling and interlocking arrangement/ OLIE at the serving station, crossing station, patch doubling, etc.
vii. Consignee: The person named as consignee in Railway Receipt.
viii. Consignor: The person named in Railway Receipt as consignor, by whom or on whose behalf goods covered by the Railway Receipt are entrusted to a Railway Administration for carriage.
ix. EIMWB: Electronic In motion Weighbridge.
x. FOIS: Freight Operations Information System.
xi. Gati Shakti Multi Modal Cargo Terminal Operator (GCTO): The entity constructing and/or managing a Gati Shakti Multi-Modal Cargo Terminal (GCT)
xii. Good Industry Practices: The practices, methods, techniques, designs. standards, skills, diligence, efficiency, reliability, and prudence
- 24 -
which are generally and reasonably expected from a reasonably skilled and experienced operator engaged in the same type of undertaking as envisaged under this Polity, following applicable laws and applicable permits in reliable, safe, economical and efficient manner, and which are expected to result in fulfillment of obligations of operator under the Agreement.
xiii. Over Head Equipment (OHE): Infrastructure and equipment installed to provide electric traction.
xiv. Private Freight Terminal (PFT): A terminal notified under Private Freight Terminal (PFT) policy of Indian Railways, to deal with rail-based cargo.
xv. Private Siding: Privately owned siding constructed by a 'customer at its own cost for railway cargo services at the premises of its plant, or manufacturing unit, or production unit, or mine, etc, connecting the customer's works with the Railway system connectivity, telephone, etc) for installing FOIS terminal to the GCT, for issuing of BR and/or taking delivery of consignment.
17. General Conditions
17.1 Applicant/ GOTO will be solely responsible for (a) arranging/ acquiring ownership/lease/licensing of con Hallway land for the development of GCT; (b) all statutory and non statutory clearances from other government departments and statutory bodies: and (e) payment of all charges, taxes/ GST, surcharges, cess,
- 25 -
levies, etc, related to transportation and handling of cargo.
17.2 For GCTs being developed entirely on non-Railway land, the portion of land required for linear connectivity of GCT with the serving Railway station may be acquired by Railway Administration on the specific request of applicant/ GCTO and at the cost of the applicant/OCTO, under the 'Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013'/ 'The Railway Act, 1989.
17.2.1 An estimate of the cost of the land, prepared by Railway Administration in
consultation with the Land Acquisition Officer, will be presented to the applicant, who shall deposit the amount before any further action is initiated for the acquisition of land. The applicant shall also agree to pay on demand such excess cost, if any, as may be incurred for the acquisition of this land.
17.2.1.1 The applicant shall also agree to compensate Railway if any extra cost is
incurred by Railway arising out of such
acquisition, even after commissioning of the Terminal.
17.2.2 Ownership of the land so acquired will vest with Railway, and the applicant for the Terminal shall have no right or claim thereto
- 26 -
17.2.3 The entire cost of Railway infrastructure to be developed on such portion of acquired land will be borne by the GCTO, however the ownership of assets so created on such land will rest with Railway. Railway will reserve the right to grant connectivity to other Gati Shakti Cargo Terminal(s) taking off from the track passing over this land.
17.3 Unless otherwise mentioned in this policy, all 'Commercial and Operating rules as applicable for a goods-shed for booking, supply and delivery of goods shall be applicable at GCT's
17.3.1 All GCTs are required to function round the clock on all days, including Sundays and other holidays.
17.4 The GCTO shall be responsible for clearance of all Railway dues, including demurrage charges, accrued within the GCT.
17. 4(A)
(i) Each case of stabling of a rake on IR network exclusively for want of acceptance by a GCT will be recorded as on instance of non- acceptance. When any rake is stabled on IR network for want of acceptance by a GCT or for reasons attributed to GETO Stabling Charges will be levied.
(ii) The quantum of Stabling Charges shall be as per Para 6.0 (Chapter 1) of Bates Master Circular/Demurrage-Wharfage Waiver/2016 (as modified from time to me)
- 27 -
(iii) Further, in situation of congestion involving stabling of rakes for acceptance by a GCT. Railway Administration will be authorized to impose loading restriction or quota for an appropriate duration for such a GCT.
17.5 The cost of electricity/diesel consumed by Railway locomotives shit be borne by Railway.
17.6 The GCTO shall provide at his own cost the level crossings and ROB/RUB/L115s for sale passage of trains as well as road vehicles, as per requirement and prescribed norms.
17.6.1 All level-crossings have to be provided with requisite infrastructure (gate-post, gate-lodge, etc) and have to be manned by GCTO at its own cost.
17.6.1.1 If the level-crossing becomes due for interlocking the cost of interlocking shall be borne by the GCTO
17.6.1.2 Maintenance of level-crossings falling on the track being maintained by Railway shall be done by Railway at its own cost, while maintenance of level-crossings falling on the track being maintained by the GCTO shall be done by GCTU (as illustrated in Section III of Schedule '3').
17.7 Railway shall reserve the right to grant connectivity to another GCT(s) from the connectivity portion of track,
- 28 -
either on Railway land or on non-Railway land, subject to operational feasibility and consideration that the traffic to/from the Initial GCT is not disrupted. Cost of the capacity enhancement works/traffic facilities up- gradation, it required to support the traffic of both terminals (as decided by the DRM), shall be borne by the GCT to whom connectivity is being subsequently granted. However, in case traffic facilities up-gradation/ capacities enhancement work is required in future, capital cost of the same shall be shared by both GCT's according to the increase/ expected increase in traffic handled by them, as decided by DRM.
18. Agreement
18.1 An Agreement for GCT shall be signed before the issue of commercial notification and operation of the GCT by Railway. Sr.DCM of the concerned Division shall be the signatory of the Agreement.
18.2 For existing Terminals migrating to this Policy, the period of Supplementary Agreement (to be signed as per the provisions of this Policy) shall be co-terminus with the existing Agreement.
19. Dispute Resolution
19.1 In case of any dispute arising in the interpretation of the Policy, the decision of DRM will be final and binding.
19.2 Conciliation: All disputes and differences of any kind whatsoever arising out of or in connection with the
- 29 -
construction and operations of GCT shall be referred by the GCTO to Railway Administration through 'Notice of Dispute. RA shall, within 30 days after receipt of the 'Notice of Dispute, notify the name of conciliator(s) to the GCTO. The Conciliator(s) shall assist the parties to reach an amicable settlement in an independent and impartial manner within the terms of Agreement. If the parties reach agreement on a settlement of the dispute, they shall draw up and sign a written Settlement Agreement duly signed by Railway's representative (Sr.DCM), GCTO and conciliator(s). When the settlement agreement is signed, it shall be final and binding on the parties. The conciliators shall be paid fee as fixed by Ministry of Railways time to time, which shall be shared equally by the parties.
19.2.1 The parties shall not initiate, during the conciliation proceedings, any reference to arbitral or judicial proceedings in respect of a dispute that is the subject matter of the conciliation proceedings.
19.2.2 The conciliation shall be carried out as per "The Arbitration and Conciliation Act. 1996' and the proceedings shall be terminated as per Section 76 of the above Act."
15. Subsequently on 06.06.2022 the State Level Single Window Clearance Committee (SLSWCC),
- 30 -
Government of Karnataka accorded approval in favour of the respondent no.5 for establishment of railway siding/track connecting Kodla Cement Plant and Storage Unit and Bagging Plant situated at Kodla Hobli, Sedam and Chittapur Taluk, Kalaburagi District which has been produced by the petitioner herself at Annexure-B in W.P.No.203560 of 2025 which reads as under:
Annexure-B
PROCEEDINGS OF THE GOVERNMENT OF
KARNATAKA
Sub : Approval to the proposal of M/s Shree Cement Limited to establish a unit for "Railway Siding/Track between Cement manufacturing plant and storage & bagging plant at Benakanahalli Village, Kodla Hobli, Sedam Taluk and Chittapura Village, Kasaba Hobli, Chittapur Taluk, Kalaburagi District.
Read: 1. Proceedings of the 94% Land Audit Committee (LAC) meeting held on 26.04.2022.
2. Proceedings of the 131 State Level Single Window Clearance Committee (SLSWCC) meeting held on 30.04.2022.
Preamble:
M/s Shree Cement Limited has proposed to establish a unit for "Railway Siding/Track between Cement
- 31 -
manufacturing plant and storage & bagging plant", with an investment of Rs/156.17 crore, generating employment to about 54 persons at Benakanahalli Village, Kodla Hobli, Sedam Taluk and Chittapura Village, Kasaba Hobli, Chittapur Taluk, Kalaburagi District. In the 94th Land Audit Committee meeting held on 26.04.2022, the representative of the company appeared before the committee through V.C and highlighted the project proposal.
The representative of the company also informed that the company is an Indian Cement manufacturer founded in Beawar, Ajmer District, Rajasthan. Company is one of the major cement manufacturers in India. The company manufacturing operations are spread over North, South and East India with presence across approximately 10 States. It has cement production capacity of apprx. 43.4 МΤΡΑ.
The Committee noted the request of the company, land utilization details and after detailed discussions, resolved to recommend to SLSWCC for approval of the project of M/s Shree Cement Limited to set up "Railway Siding/Track between Cement manufacturing plant and storage & bagging plant" in 183.29 acres of land to be purchased by the company at Sy No.361, 362,363, 420
421, 429, 430, 437, 438, 439, 448, 451, 337, 265,
364/1, 365, 452 of Benakanahalli Village, Kodla Hobli, Sedam Taluk, Sy No. 223, 226, 231, 232, 233, 258, 259,
- 32 -
456, 461, 462, 469, 470, 480, 481, 482 Chittapura Village, Kasaba Hobli, Chittapur Taluk, Kalaburagi District, subject to non violation of non alienation clauses like PTCL, Inam land, Iluvari land, Govt. land, Nala land, Bandidari land etc. under KLR Act.
In the 131 State Level Single Window Clearance Committee (SLSWCC) meeting held on 30.04.2022, the proposal of the Company was discussed and approved. Government has examined the recommendations made by the SLSWCC its 131 Meeting, in all aspects. Hence the following order.
GOVERNMENT ORDER No. CI 148 SPL 2022.
BENGALURU, DATED 06.06.2022
Government is pleased to accord in-principle approval to the investment proposal of M/s Shree Cement Limited to establish a unit for "Railway Siding/Track between Cement manufacturing plant and Storage & bagging plant", with an investment of Rs.156.17 crore, generating employment to about 54 persons at Benakanahalli Village, Kodla Hobli, Sedam Taluk and Chittapura Village Kasaba Hobli, Chittapur Taluk, Kalaburagi District with the following infrastructure assistances, incentives and concessions:
Land 183.29 acres of land to be purchased by the company at Sy.No.361, 362,363, 420, 421,
429, 430, 437, 430, 438, 448, 451, 337, 365,
- 33 -
|
364/1, 365, 452 of Benakanahalli Village, Kodia Hobli, Sedam Taluk, Sy.No 223, 226, 231, 232, 233, 258, 259, 456, 461, 462, 469, 470, 430, 431, 482 Chittapura Village, Kasaba Hobil, Chittapur Taluk Kalaburagi District, subject to non vielation of nom alienation clauses like PTCL, Inam land, levari land, Cove land, Nala land, Bandidari land etc. under KLR Act and also NOC/approval from competent authority |
| Water |
30 KLPD from Local Authority |
| Power |
15000 KVA from GESCOM |
| Incentives & concessio ns |
As per applicable Policy of the State |
Sanction of the above infrastructure assistances,
incentives and concessions is subject to the
following terms and conditions:
1. Environment: The company to obtain Consent for Establishment and Consent for Operation from KSPCB and environmental clearance from MoEF, Govt. of India or the Dept of Forest, Biology & Environment, Govt. of Karnataka, if applicable.
2. Employment: The Company shall comply with the provisions of applicable Policy of the State of Govt. of Karnataka with respect to local employment on the project Prepare a plan for development of Human Resources required for the prelect train local people. A copy of Human Resources Development plan shall be sent to the
- 34 -
Commissioner for Industrial Development & Director of Industries and Commerce for monitoring.
3. Vendor Development: Wherever there is scope for vendor development for the project, the company shall prepare a vendor development plan, develop local vendors and procure the required inputs, components and sub-assemblies from these local vender units. A copy of the vendor development plan shall be sent to the Commissioner for Industrial Development & Director of Industries and Commerce for monitoring.
4. Social Infrastructure Development: The Company is advised to take up social infrastructure development projects in the vicinity of the proposed location of the unit and comply with the stipulation of Company Act 2013. A copy of such projects shall be sent to the Commissioner for Industrial Development & Director of Industries and Commerce for monitoring.
5. Others a. The company shall adopt rainwater harvesting, waste water recycling and water conservation techniques. Zero discharge facility should be adopted wherever applicable.
- 35 -
b. The company shall take all statutory and other necessary clearances from the competent authorities including Govt. of India.
c. As part of "Ease of Doing Business" Government vide order No. CI 89 SPI 2013, Dated: 20.12.2014 has accorded approval to operationalise e-Udyami Phase 11 for obtaining various clearances / approvals/licenses etc. through common e-platform for the projects approved through District Level Single Window Clearance Committee (DLSWCC) or State Level Single Window Clearance Committee (SLSWCC) or State High Level Clearance Committee (SHLCC) w.e.f. 01.01.2015.
d. The approvals/NOCs of following Departments have been covered under Phase II of e-Udyami. e.
i. Karnataka Industrial Areas Development Board.
ii. Karnataka Small Scale Industries Development Corporation
iii. Karnataka State Pollution Control Board.
iv. Factories, Boilers, Industrial Safety and Health Department
v. Industries and Commerce Department
vi. Town Planning Department and Local Planning Authorities
vii. Municipal Administration Department
viii. BESCOM/GESCOM/HESCOM/CESCOM/
MESCOM
ix. Karnataka State Fire and Emergency Services Department
x. Water Resources Department
- 36 -
e. The login and passwords which are used for filing application through e-Udyami Phase I are also applicable for filing application through e-Udyami Phase II. E-Udyami Phase II web application may be accessed through www.ebizkarnataka.gov.in and online application along with necessary documents may please be filed for any of above Departments' approval/NOCS.
f. Karnataka Udyog Mitra (KUM) would provide the necessary escort services for the speedy implementation of your project. You are requested to inform the progress made in the implementation of the project every quarter in the proforma. This approval is valid for a period of two years from the date of issue of this Government Order. By Order and in the name of the
Governor of Karnataka,
Sd/-
(NAGARATHNAMMA.
G) 06/06/2022 Desk Officer (Technical Cell), Commerce & Industries Department.
1. Principal Accountant General (G&SSA), Karnataka, New Building Audit Bhawan', Post Box No. 5398, Bengaluru-01.
2. Principal Accountant General (E&RSA), Karnataka, New Building, Audit Bhawan', Post Box No. 5398, Bengaluru-01
.
3. Principal Accountant General (A&E), Karnataka, Park House Road,, Post Box No. 5329, Bengaluru-01
- 37 -
4. Additional Chief Secretary to Government, Finance Department, Vidhana Soudha, Bengaluru.
5. Additional Chief Secretary to Government, Energy Department, Vikasa Soudha, Bengaluru.
6. Additional Chief Secretary to Government, Forest, Ecology & Environment Department, M.S. Building, Bengaluru,
7. Additional Chief Secretary to Government, Water Resource Department Vikasa Soudha, Bengaluru.
8. Principal Secretary to Government, Revenue Department, M.S. Building Bengaluru.
9. Secretary to Government (Mines & SSI), Commerce & Industries Department, Vikasa Soudha, Bengaluru.
10. Commissioner for Industrial Development and Director of Industries and Commerce, Khanija Bhavan, Race Course Road, Bengaluru.
11. Commissioner of Commercial Taxes, Vanijya Therige Karyalaya, Gandhi Nagar, Bengaluru-09.
12. Managing Director, Gulbarga Electricity Supply Company Limited (GESCOM), Kalaburagi.
13. Member Secretary, Karnataka State Pollution Control Board (KSPCS), No 49, Church Street, Parisara Bhavan, Bengaluru-01.
14. Chief Executive Officer & Executive Member, Karnataka Industrial Area Development Board, Khanija Bhavan, Race Course Road, Bengaluru-Q2
15. Director (Technical Cell), Commerce & Industries Department, Vikasa Soudha, Bengaluru.
16. Additional Director (P&P), Directorate of Industries & Commerce, Khanija Bhavan, Race Course Road, Bengaluru.
17. Managing Director, Karnataka Udyog Mitra (KUM), Khanija Bhasan, Race Course Road, Bengaluru.
18. PS to Hon'ble Minister for Large and Medium Industries, Vidhana Soudha Bengaluru.
- 38 -
19. PS to Additional Chief Secretary to Government, Commerce & Industries Department, Vikasa Soudha, Bengaluru.
21. M/s Shree Coment Limited, Post Box No.33, Bangor Nagar, Beawar, Ajmer, Rajasthan 305901
22. Guard File/Spare Coples
16. Thereafter, the remaining co-owners/joint owners of the subject land bearing Survey No.25 executed registered Sale Agreement (Annexure-R10 dated 29.12.2022) in favour of respondent no.5 and handed over possession to the respondent no.5 after receiving valuable consideration towards the said project. In addition thereto upto 12.03.2024, the respondent no.5 had purchased about 103.8 acres out of the total required area of 106.37 acres from various landowners whose names are enumerated in the list at Annexure-R1 produced by the respondent no.5 along with its statement of objections. The material on record discloses that on 18.03.2024, the respondent no.5 addressed a requisition to the Divisional Railway Manager, South Central Railways, Secunderabad seeking declaration of the proposed connectivity as a
- 39 -
special railway project under Clause 17.2 of the GCT policy 2022. In pursuance of the aforesaid acquisition, the South Central Railway approved the proposal vide Annexure-R3 dated 28.05.2024 and directed the construction department to proceed with acquisition which is extracted hereunder:
Annexure R3
SOUTH CENTRAL RAILWAY
Office of the DRM/WORKS/SC 2-Floor, Sanchalan Bhasan Secunderabad 500071 NCW.277/DB/Land/SCL-KODLA/SUH Dt: 28.05.2024 CAO/C/SC
Sub Proposed construction of Private siding under Gati Shakti Multi-Modal Carga Terminal (GCT) by M/s Shree Cement Limited taking off From Sulehalh station in SC WADI section-Proposal for declaration of Special Railway Project Reg.
Ref. M/s Shree Cement Lad's Lr. No. SCL/Kodia GCT SP RLY PROJ SCR/2024/01 dt. 18/03/2024 & 20.03.2024 * * *
Railway Board has issued Master Circular on "Gati Shakti Multi-model Cargo Terminal (GCT) on 06.12.2022 to promote proliferation of new Cargo Terminals and improve existing Cargo Terminals to accelerate the growth in Railways cargo traffic All new as well as under construction/ under approval cargo terminals shall
- 40 -
covered under Gati Shakti Multi-modal Cargo Terminal (GCT) policy
M/s Shree Cement Limited vide Letter No. SCL/KODLA GCT SP RLY PROJ/SCR/2024/02 dated 20.03.2024 has informed that land of approximate extent 48.00 Hectares over 6 villages of Chittapur Mandal, Gulbarga District in required for linear connectivity portion taking off from Sulehalli Railway Station as per approved ESP and requested to acquire the land by Railway by declaring the project of SCL- Kodla Lane as Special Railway Project as per Clause 17.2 of GCT Policy dated 06.12.2022.
Accordingly, the proposal for declaration of SCL- Kodla line of M/s Shree Cements Ltd. as Special Railway Project has been processed by Secunderabad Division as per Railway Board latest guidelines and initial approval has been obtained by competent authority DRM/SC. Further, the proposal has been forwarded to Headquarters to obtain final approval of GM/SCR for declaring the Project of SCL-Kodla line as Special Railway Project. Vide Note 37 dated 22.05.2024, GM/SCR has approved the proposal and instructed that the Process of Acquisition of Land is to be dealt by Construction Department.
In this regard, as per the instruction of GM/SCR, all the relevant documents along with the E-office noting are herewith forwarded for necessary action by Construction Organization Please
Sd/-
Sr.DEN/Co-ord/St
Copy to:
1) CGE/SCR for Kind information
2) DRM/SC for kand information
3) Sr.DOM/SC & Sr.DCM/SC for information
4) M/s. Shree Cement Ltd for your information.
- 41 -
17. In pursuance of the aforesaid events, documents etc., the Ministry of Railways, Government of India issued the impugned Gazette Notification dated 30.05.2024 and in the exercise of powers conferred by Clause 37A of Section 2 of the Railways Act, 1989, the Central Government notified the proposed siding connectivity to Kodla Cement Plant of M/s Shree Cement Ltd (respondent no.5) with extension from dead end of their existing Gati Shakti Multimodal Cargo Terminal (GCT) served by Sulehalli station on SC-Wadi section as a special railway project for acquisition of land in the State Of Karnataka in Kalaburagi District.
Annexure-R4
MINISTRY OF RAILWAYS
(South Central Railway)
NOTIFICATION
Secunderabad, the 30th May, 2024
50. 2147 (E)- In exercise of the powers conferred by clause (37A) of Section 1 of the Railways Act, 1989 the Central Government hereby notifies "Proposed siding connectivity to Kodla Cement Plant of M/s. Shree Cement
- 42 -
Ltd., with extension from dead end of their existing Gati Shakti Multi-Modal Cargo Terminal (GCT) served by Sulehalli station on SC-Wadi section" as a Special Railway Project for acquisition of land in the State of Karnataka in the District of Kalaburagi with effect from the date of publication of this notification in the Official Gazette [F. No. W.Con. 182/SRP-14/SCL-KODLA/24-25/262/37A Mothilal Bhookya, Chief Engineer/Con-II.
18. The material on record also discloses that in pursuance of aforesaid notification dated 30.05.2024, the respondents proceeded to issue the preliminary notification dated 26.07.2024 which was published in the newspapers on 02.08.2024 and upon the competent Authority submitting a report dated 18.09.2024 under Section 20E of the said Act of 1989 recommending acquisition, the Government of India issued Final Declaration/Notification dated 26.09.2024 under Section 20E of the said Act of 1989 and published the same in newspapers on 16.10.2024 as a result of which all notified lands stood acquired and vested absolutely all lands including the subject land of the petitioner in
- 43 -
W.P. No.20328 of 25 in the Central Government, free from all encumbrances. So also, by virtue of Preliminary Notification dated 29.07.2025 and followed by Final Notification dated 22.09.2025, the additional 16 guntas in Survey No.25, which is the subject matter of W.P.No.203560 of 25 also stood acquired and vested absolutely in the Central Government free from all encumbrances.
19. A perusal of the material on record will also indicate that though the respondent no.5 had acquired about 103.8 acres out of the total extent of 106.37 acres prior to March 2024 itself and the entire project was given sufficient publicity and the acquisition proceedings were duly notified and published in all newspapers, the petitioner did not choose to file objections to the Preliminary Notification and it was only on only in February 2025 that the petitioner chose to prefer W.P.No.20328 of 2025 and W.P.No.203560 of 2025 on 06.11.2025 without raising any objection as regards the notification and
- 44 -
acquisition proceedings. The aforesaid facts and circumstances clearly establish that the impugned notification dated 30.05.2024 issued under Section 2(37A) of the said Act Of 1989 declaring the project of the respondent no.5 as a Special Railway Project was notified by the Central Government for providing national infrastructure for public purpose and the same is perfectly legal, proper and valid apart from being in accordance with law and the provisions contained in the said Act of 1989; so also the acquisition proceedings have been conducted and the impugned acquisition notifications have been issued by following the prescribed procedure and after giving sufficient and reasonable opportunity to all land owners/losers including the petitioner as can be seen from the material on record. Under these circumstances, I am of the considered opinion that the various contentions urged by the petitioner in the present petition are clearly contrary to law and facts and the same are baseless,
- 45 -
untenable and devoid of merit and cannot be countenanced by this Court in the present petition.
20. As noticed earlier, the main/primary contention of the petitioner is that the impugned acquisition pursuant to the impugned Notification was for the purpose of the respondent no.5 which is a private entity and not for providing national infrastructure for a public purpose as required under Section 2(37A) and Section 20A of the said Act of 1989; the said contention of the petitioner is wholly misconceived and untenable in the light of the various events, notifications, recommendations, policy decisions commencing from the P.M. Gathi Shakti National Master Plan referred to supra, the cumulative effect of which is sufficient to come to the conclusion that there has been sufficient and substantial compliance of not only the aforesaid provisions but also the procedure prescribed for acquisition of the subject land from the petitioner. Further the respondent no.5 has produced several other notifications at Annexure-R14 (colly.) to establish that
- 46 -
identical projects had been declared as Special Railway Projects throughout India which is yet another circumstance that would militate against the claim of the petitioner.
21. Further it is well settled that challenge to large extents of acquisition is impermissible in law by a minority land owner as held by the Hon'ble Apex Court and this Court in various judgments including the judgment of the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of M.S.P.L. Vs State of Karnataka (2022) 20 SCC 58, wherein it is held as under:
H. Challenge to acquisition by a minority
(10%) of landowners
94. It is admitted position that the challenge to the acquisition of more than a thousand acres was made by a small fraction of landowners having land less than 10% of the total acquisition. Compensation for rest of the 90% land acquired had been accepted by their respective landowners. The Division Bench has quashed the entire acquisition of more than a thousand acres of the instance of such a small fraction. This aspect has been dealt with by this
- 47 -
Court in Amarjit Singh v. State of Punjab [Amarjit Singh v. State of Punjab, (2010) 10 SCC 43 (2010)
4 SCC (Civ) 29) and Om Prakash v. State of U.P. (Om Prakash v. State of U.P. (1998) 6 SCC 1) The learned Single Judge had placed reliance on the judgment of Om Prakash (Om Prakash v. State of
U.P. (1998) 6 SCC 1)
95. It is also worthwhile to mention that out of approximately 110 acres of land acquired for MSPL, only one landowner possessing only 4.34 acres of land, had filed the writ appeal before the Division Bench. Quashing the entire acquisition at the instance of one landowner having 4.34 acres of land out of total acquisition for MSPL of 110 acres, would be against the public policy and public interest. MSPL alone provides employment to 292 persons with a substantial investment of Rs. 200 crores. The employment to approximately 300 persons by MSPL is also alleged to be double of the number of employees as projected in the proposal. Further, in the case of AISL acquisition of 914 acres is challenged by a fraction of less than 10% landowners. The estimated project of AISL is approximately Rs 2092 crores and would provide employment to at least one thousand persons.
96. In view of the above analysis, we are of the view that the Division Bench committed an error in quashing the acquisition proceedings. Accordingly,
- 48 -
the appeals filed by MSPL, AISL, Kiadb and the State of Karnataka are allowed.
97. The judgment of the Division Bench dated 22-3- 2012 [Kakaral Ravikumar v. State Of Karnataka, 2012 SCC OnLine Kar 8976] is set aside and the writ petitions stand dismissed as ordered by the learned Single Judge vide judgment dated 17-3-2009 [Eerappa Gejji v. State of Karnataka, 2009 SCC OnLine Kar 989].
22. In the instant case, it is a matter of record and undisputed fact that the subject land of the petitioner in both the petitions is 1 acre 10 guntas and 16 guntas respectively and having regard to the total extent of land acquired by the respondent no.5 which comes to about
103.8 acres coupled with the acquisition proceedings involving more than 500 acres even this contention urged by the petitioner cannot be accepted. In view of the aforesaid facts and circumstances, I am of the considered opinion that the various contentions urged by the petitioner in the present petitions cannot be accepted and
- 49 -
the petitions are devoid of merit and the same are liable to be dismissed.
23. In the result, I pass the following:
O R D E R
W.P.No.200328 of 2025 and W.P. No.203560 of 2025 are hereby dismissed.
Sd/-
(S.R.KRISHNA KUMAR)
JUDGE
MBB
LIST NO.: 1 SL NO.: 119
CT:SI