Per contra, the Learned Counsel for the Respondent/Plaintiff argued that law of primogeniture was a tradition under Mankiary tradition and also under Choto
6
Nagpur Tenancy Act, 1908. According to him, the Learned First Appellate Court rightly considered this law of primogeniture and allowed the suit. The order of the First Appellate Court should not be interfered into.
I have heard rival submissions.
Firstly, the Trial Court came to the conclusion that some of the lands were in occupation of subsequent purchasers who were not made party to the suit. According to the Trial Court, the suit is bad for defect of parties. One of the prayers in the plaint is partition. It goes without saying that all the co-owners are necessary parties in absence of any of whom no effective decree can be passed. Non-joining of any of the co-owner is, therefore, made the suit bad for non-joinder of the necessary party which was fatal qua the suit. The conclusion of the Trial Court was, therefore, correct. The First Appellate Court committed error in fact as well as in law in ignoring the conclusion of the Trial Court. Secondly, the Trial Court considered the law of primogeniture in the Mankiary. The First Appellate Court possibly was more enthused to compose a social history than to write a judgment and explored to wriggle out a history of Mankiary Estate, in complete oblivion of Section 4 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956. The First Appellate Court upheld the right of Plaintiff/Respondent on the basis of law of primogeniture.
Section 4 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 provides that the Act has an overriding effect over any custom or usage in any part of India. After coming into force of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 and by virtue of this Section 4 of the Act prevalence of law of primogeniture stood abrogated and law of succession in accordance with Hindu Succession Act, 1956 became prevalent. Therefore, instead of Mankiary Estate or Mankiary Tradition, Hindu Secession Act, 1956 would govern the relationship and law of succession. Plaintiff/Respondent's right to property on the basis of Mankiary Estate or Mankiary Tradition cannot be allowed. The observation
7
and findings of the First Appellate Court in this regard in contrary to codified law and provisions as stated above hence perverse. The Plaintiff has no right, title and interest under this Mankiary Law. The First Appellate Court failed miserably to consider all these legal provisions and principals of law. Therefore, the Judgment and Order passed by the First Appellate Court suffers from serious infirmity and demands interference.
In nutshell, the instant appeal is allowed. It is ordered that the impugned Judgment and Decree passed by the Additional District Judge, 1stCourt, Purulia in Title Appeal No. 118 of 2001 stands overruled and set aside. The Judgment passed by the Trial Court stands affirmed.
The instant appeal is stands disposed along with all pending applications, if any. The Respondent shall also liable to pay cost of litigation of Rs.50,000/- to the Appellant.
Let T.C.R be returned.
(Sugato Majumdar, J.)
8