Loading..
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts

    YASMEEN WD/O NADIRBHAI DEVANI D/O BAHADURALI HASAMBHAI JIVANI v. RAJKOT MUNICIPAL CORPORATION

    C/SCA/465/2026 JUDGMENT DATED: 04/08/2026

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD

    R/SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 465 of 2026

    FOR APPROVAL AND SIGNATURE:

    HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE NIRAL R. MEHTA

    ========================================================== Approved for Reporting Yes No

    √

    ========================================================== YASMEEN WD/O NADIRBHAI DEVANI D/O BAHADURALI HASAMBHAI

    JIVANI

    Versus

    RAJKOT MUNICIPAL CORPORATION

    ========================================================== Appearance:

    MR. GAURAV A. GOGIA(14128) for the Petitioner(s) No. 1 MS KAJAL L KALWANI(6623) for the Petitioner(s) No. 1 MR. MN MARFATIA(6930) for the Respondent(s) No. 1 ==========================================================

    CORAM:HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE NIRAL R. MEHTA

    Date : 04/08/2026

    ORAL JUDGMENT

    1. By way of the present petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, the petitioner, who is the widow of the deceased employee, has approached this Court seeking a direction to the respondents to fix and release the family pension payable on account of the death of her husband with effect from 27.08.2025, together with the consequential arrears and interest thereon.

    Page 1 of 10

    2. Heard learned advocate Mr. Gaurav A. Gogia for the petitioner and learned advocate Mr. M. N. Marfatia for the respondent. Since the controversy involved in the present petition lies within a narrow compass and the issue is no longer res integra, with the consent of the learned advocates appearing for the respective parties, the petition is taken up for final hearing at the admission stage.

    3. Rule. Learned advocate Mr. M. N. Marfatia waives service of notice of Rule for and on behalf of the respondent.

    4. The following undisputed facts emerge from the record:

    4.1 The petitioner is the legally wedded wife of late Shri Devani Nadirbhai Mahamadali, who was serving as a Line Man in the Electrical Department of the Rajkot Municipal Corporation.

    Page 2 of 10

    4.2 The petitioner's husband retired from service on 30.04.2024 upon attaining the age of superannuation, after rendering 30 years, 7 months and 16 days of qualifying service for the purpose of pension. It is an admitted position that, at the relevant point of time, there were certain matrimonial differences between the petitioner and her husband. However, the marriage between them continued to subsist and was never dissolved by a decree of divorce.

    5. It is the case of the petitioner that the respondent has failed to process and sanction the family pension in her favour on the ground that, during his lifetime, the petitioner's husband had submitted an affidavit requesting the respondent-authority not to release any retiral dues to the petitioner. It is further the case of the respondent that the petitioner's name was not mentioned in the nomination form and, instead, the names of the couple's two sons were recorded as nominees. Aggrieved by the aforesaid action of the

    Page 3 of 10

    respondent, the petitioner has approached this Court by filing the present petition seeking the following reliefs:

    "8(A) YOUR LORDSHIP may be pleased to admit andallow this petition.

    (B) YOUR LORDSHIP may be pleased to hold,declare and direct that the Petitioner is entitled tofamily pension on account of death of her husbandfrom the date of his death i.e., 27.08.2025. And theRespondent Authorities be directed to grant the familypension to the Petitioner with interest @9%.

    (C) Pending admission, hearing and final disposal ofthis matter, Your Lordship be pleased to passappropriate orders to not withheld the payment offamily pension, payable to the Petitioner in Para-4 ofPPO issued in relation to the deceased husband ofthe Petitioner.

    (D) YOUR LORDSHIP may be pleased to grant suchother and further reliefs as the nature andcircumstances of the case require in the interest ofjustice."

    6. Since the aforesaid facts are not in dispute, the short question that falls for consideration before this Court is whether the petitioner, being the legally wedded wife of the deceased employee, is entitled to the benefit of family pension, notwithstanding the fact that, during his lifetime, the deceased had informed the respondent- authorities that he did not intend to confer any retiral

    Page 4 of 10

    benefits upon his wife and had nominated his two sons in the nomination form.

    7. The aforesaid question in my view has no longer res integra. The Division Bench of this Court in case between Abedakhatun Y. Malek V/s. Director of Pension and Provident Funds and Others reported in 2011 LawSuit(Guj) 1442 has in identical facts and circumstances held as under:-

    "7. We have carefully perused the record andproceedings along with the order dated 14-10-2010passed by learned Single Judge as well page Nos. 20(21A, 21B and 21C) and page Nos. 22 (Page Nos. 23A,23B and 23C), referred in the said order. It appearsthat though the disputes were surfaced of routebetween the pensioner and the appellant, the marriagehad subsisted and after completion of 27 years ofmarried life, it appears that both had started livingseparately. The appellant had started living with hereight children and also the appellant had brought themup with love and concern. It further appears that thenomination given by the pensioner, i.e. late Mr.Yashinmiya Malek, to his nephew and niece does nothave an bearing on the fixation of the family pensionfor which primarily, the wife is only entitled for. Sofar as the Rules are concerned, the learned Counsel forthe appellant has drawn our attention to Rule 88(a)(i)of the Gujarat Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 2002,which describes family means -

    "88(a)(i) Wife in the case of a male Governmentemployee or husband in the case of a femaleGovernment employee, even if the marriage took

    Page 5 of 10

    place before or after retirement of the Governmentemployee."

    The learned Assistant Government Pleader has notdenied the above legal position.

    8. The learned Counsel has also put reliance onvarious citations, which are as under :-

    (1) Jodh Singh Vs. Union of India (UOI) and Another,1980 4 SCC 306, in which, it has been held that,"benefit of special family pension admissible underRegulation 74 of the Pension Regulations for IndianAir Force admissible to wife of the officer only in theevent of the death of the officer and such benefitwould be the exclusive property of his widow and theofficer is not entitled to make testamentary dispositionof the same during his lifetime."

    (2) Rampyari Bai v. Municipal Corporation andAnother, 1987 (Supp) SCC 263, where in it was foundthat, ''there was no valid marriage and therefore,there could be no valid nomination in favour of thepetitioner by the deceased for payment of familypension'' and so the Hon'ble Apex Court had notinterfered with. By citing the said decision, thelearned Counsel for the appellant has submitted thatwhether the marriage was valid one and it wassubsistence at the time of death of the pensioner, isthe main criteria to be considered while deciding thequestion of family pension and there appears force init.

    (3) Smt Violet Issaac and Others Vs. Union of India(UOI) and Others, 1991 1 SCC 725, wherein it hasbeen held that:

    "....The Family Pension Scheme under the Rules isdesigned to provide relief to the widow and childrenby way of compensation for the untimely death of thedeceased employee. The Rules do not provide for anynomination with regard to family pension, instead theRules designate the persons who are entitled toreceive the family pension. Thus, no other personexcept those designated under the Rules are entitledto receive family pension. The Family Pension Scheme

    Page 6 of 10

    confers monetary benefit on the wife and children ofthe deceased Railway employee, but the employee hasno title to it. The employee has no control over thefamily pension as he is not required to make ancontribution to it. The family pension scheme is inthe nature of a welfare scheme framed by theRailway administration to provide relief to the widowand minor children of the deceased employee...."

    (4) G.L. Bhatia vs. Union of India and Another, 19995 SCC 237. Relevant Paragraphs 3, 4 and 5reproduced hereunder :

    "3. Under Rule 54 sub-rule (14)(b)(i) the expression"family"' has been defined thus :

    "54. (14)(b)(i) Wife in the case of a male Governmentservant, or husband in the case of a femaleGovernment servant..."

    4. Sub-rule (8)(ii) of Rule 54 states that :

    "54 (8)(ii) If a deceased Government servant orpensioner leaves behind a widow or widower, thefamily pension shall become payable to the widow orwidower, failing which to the eligible child."

    5. In the light of the aforesaid provisions and therebeing no divorce between the husband and wife eventhough they might be staying separately, theappellant-husband would be entitled to the familypension in terms of the rules as noted aforesaid andthe authorities, therefore, committed error in notgranting family pension to the appellant relying uponthe nomination made by the deceased wife of theappellant. The impugned order is, accordingly, setaside and this appeal stands allowed."

    9. We have considered the above-referred legalposition and we are agreeable to the submissionsmade by the learned counsel for the appellant, and inour view, the same are squarely applicable to thepresent case on hand. It appears that during the life-time of deceased pensioner Mr. Yashinmiya U. Malek,his marriage was subsisted and till he expired, nodivorce has taken place between the deceasedpensioner and the appellant. It is important to notethat family pension is provided by statutory provisions

    Page 7 of 10

    and notifications and circulars issued by thecompetent authority from time to time and theconcerned officials are supposed to follow the same. Inthe computation for the claim of family pension, itwould not be open to decide the issue of desertionand to attribute the cause of desertion because theissue of desertion is never a criteria for granting anddenying the family pension. For grant of familypension, the only consideration would be that theclaimant ought to be legally wedded wife or husbandof the pensioner and he/she be alive on the date ofdeath of the pensioner. Even if the pensioner hasnominated third person excluding his wife, then also,the right of the legitimate wife/widow to claim familypension cannot be brushed aside.

    10. Considering the overall aspect of the case andconsidering the entire welfare scheme to providefamily pension, the present appeal deserves to beallowed, and hence, it is allowed. Order passed by thelearned Single Judge in Special Civil ApplicationNo.12800 of 2010 dated 14-10-2010 is hereby setaside. Respondent No. 3 as well as respondent No. 2are hereby directed to retransmit the family pensioncase papers, related to present appellant, if at all thesame are lying with them, to respondent No. 1 andon receiving the same, the respondent No. 1 isdirected to fix the family pension of the appellantfrom the date of death of her husband within aperiod of two months following all due procedure forthe same."

    8. Upon perusal of the aforesaid enunciation of law, it emerges that the Division Bench of this Court has categorically held that family pension is governed by statutory provisions. It has further been held that, for the purpose of grant of family pension, the only relevant

    Page 8 of 10

    consideration is whether the claimant is the legally wedded wife or husband of the pensioner and was alive on the date of the death of the pensioner. Even if the pensioner has nominated a third person, excluding his wife, the right of the legally wedded wife or widow to claim family pension cannot be defeated or brushed aside. Keeping in view the aforesaid proposition of law and the admitted facts of the present case, it is evident that the marriage between the petitioner and the deceased continued to subsist till the death of the petitioner's husband. Admittedly, during his lifetime, no divorce proceedings were instituted, nor was any decree of divorce obtained. In view of the aforesaid facts and circumstances, the ratio laid down by the Division Bench squarely applies to the facts of the present case, there being no distinguishable feature pointed out by the respondent so as to warrant a different view.

    9. Mr. Marfatia, learned advocate appearing for the respondent, fairly conceded that the ratio laid down by

    Page 9 of 10

    the Division Bench of this Court in Abedakhatun Y. Malek v. Director of Pension and Provident Funds and Others (supra) governs the controversy involved in the present case and was unable to dispute its applicability.

    10. In view of the foregoing discussion, the present petition deserves to be allowed and is accordingly allowed. The respondent-authorities are directed to fix and release the family pension payable to the petitioner as expeditiously as possible and, in any event, not later than three months from the date of receipt of this order. Upon fixation of the family pension, the consequential arrears shall also be paid to the petitioner within a further period of three months. Rule is made absolute.

    (NIRAL R. MEHTA,J)

    MAYA

    Page 10 of 10

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    YASMEEN WD/O NADIRBHAI DEVANI D/O BAHADURALI HASAMBHAI JIVANI v. RAJKOT MUNICIPAL CORPORATION
    (Aug 4, 2026)